Jump to content

Siamanto

Members
  • Posts

    668
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Siamanto

  1. Not that easy! In the above, you are expressing yourself as if the "class of unclassified convictions" is a well defined class i.e. the class of all convictions that cannot be classified. It can be that in my case, I can't determine whether my "conviction" can or cannot be classified! I can't even tell whether "it" is a conviction or not! Also, you are free to classify my "conviction," but I will still refuse to do so! Not that easy! (Too repetitious! ) What are "objective limits?" Unfortunately, I have to finish two documents before Friday evening and have to go! In the meantime, I suggest that you consider Quine's concept of "intersubjectivity" (as a form/illusion of "objectivity.")
  2. gamavor, Thanks for the link! Anything particular about Catholic Armenians? Just cirious!
  3. I just watched an enchanting 90 minute conversation between two individuals I genuinely admire and respect: Bernard Pivot - undoubtedly The symbol of Culture of the last decades, in France - and late Franois Mitterand. When discussing a chapter of Mitterand's biography - written by Elie Wiesel - discussing his faith, he - Mitterand - said: "I regret and feel sorrow that it is not at easy at it was during my childhood." (He defined himself as a "mystic agnostic.") At the end of each "interview" - "entretien" in French - Pivot asks his guest a certain number of well know questions. To the question: If Heaven exists, what would you like to hear God say when you arrive at the Pearly Gates? Mitterand answered: "At last, you know." (Enfin, tu sais.) I believe he meant: "At last, you know that I exist!"
  4. armjan, I hear you and you make sense! I will only speak for myself when I say that my intention was neither to convince nor to disrespect anybody! I apologize if anything I have said was perceived as such. Personally, I'm neither religious nor atheist or agnostic! I just refuse to classify myself. Faith is a private matter and I would never have a "rational" discussion about its significance/legitimity and/or how it should be practiced. Personally, I believe that Christianity is not about miracles and supernatural imagery - what I earlier called "mise en scène" - it is about the Philosophy of Redemption and forgiveness! I think that Solaris was rather complimenting Jesus and the Christian Philosophy. For many, being married in a church has more than religious connotations: it's more complex!
  5. I wish I could say: "It goes without saying!" Public opinion indicates otherwise. However, that is how I understand it! I view the supernatural "mise en scène" as an "infomercial!" Maybe one should blame those who initiated the rumors, instead of the victim!
  6. Siamanto

    New York Photos

    For the sake of clarity, I will add that it was my first visit of the US my "distorted" and naive perception of the "American" was based on Rock Musicians and exported movies i.e. mainly Whites/WASPs.
  7. Russian-Azeri transport cooperation against Armenian "interests" - agency Mediamax news agency, Yerevan 21 Feb 05 Armenia's attempts to achieve changes in Russia's regional transport policy have failed, the Armenian news agency Mediamax has suggested. In its weekly analytical review, the news agency cast doubt on Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov's promises during his recent visit to Yerevan "to take into account Armenia's interests" as Moscow will unlikely quit the "promising" railway project linking Russia to Iran via Azerbaijan. Indifference to Armenian transport "interests" in the region does not mean that Russia will give up an idea of purchasing Armenian energy facilities "to form a chain", Mediamax added. The following is an excerpt from report in English by Armenian news agency Mediamax; subheadings have been inserted editorially: The visit of Russian Foreign Minister Sergey Lavrov to Yerevan last week left double impression. If we speak about the political component of the visit, the participants of the talks did not say anything new having described the Armenian-Russian relations as "partnership and alliance". As to the settlement of the Nagornyy Artsax conflict, in this case Sergey Lavrov also did not go beyond stating official Moscow's position: "The solution of the problem should be found by Armenia and Azerbaijan, Russia is ready to become a guarantor for the fulfillment of the agreements." The Russian and Armenian foreign ministers also spoke about "practically full coincidence of positions" on the issues of reforming the UN and the OSCE. This could form an impression that the visit of the Russian foreign minister to Armenia went off rather smoothly, especially in the light of the scandal which burst out in Tbilisi in connection with Lavrov's refusal to visit in Tbilisi the memorial of the victims who died for the restoration of Georgia's territorial integrity during the conflicts in Abkhazia and South Ossetia. Lavrov's diplomatic gestures By the way, in this concern a question arose among several Armenia media as to what prevented Lavrov from showing such "delicacy" and refusing to visit the "Martyrs Avenue" in Azerbaijan where the people, who have taken part in the anti-Armenian pogroms in Baku in 1990 and killed as a result of the belated interference of the Soviet troops into the conflict, were buried? When Lavrov was directly asked about his attitude to those events in Baku, he behaved as a true diplomat and not only avoided the answer but also used it to once more indirectly mention about a complication in Russia's relations with the Baltic countries on the eve of celebrating the 60th anniversary of the victory over Fascism. This is Lavrov's answer: "This question has long ago been answered partly by the historians, though historical research and discussions still continue. The emotions should not overshadow the necessity to live together, to solve urgent problems. Any attempt to heat up emotions around the historical facts, which has long ago been defined in the relations between the states, only take us away from this. It is not by accident that today talks are proceeding on the necessity for the states to once more review their history, including the history of the World War II. I regard such attempts to rewrite the history as a desire not to allow the normal mutually beneficial development of cooperation, partnership, which would be open for all the European states. I prefer concentrating on topical problems. There are a lot of them, I repeat. Life is actively going on: globalization, mutual dependence. We have concrete affairs. Let's leave all this to the historians." However, today the point is not why the Russian leaders consider it possible to honour the memory of the participants of anti-Armenian pogroms and fear to visit the memorial of the Georgian victims in Tbilisi. We would like to attach special attention to the report on Sergey Lavrov's meeting with Armenian Prime Minister Andranik Markaryan, during which the latter did not hesitate to be a fly in the ointment. Lavrov pledges to take Armenian transport interests into account The Armenian prime minister openly stated Yerevan's concern about the planned construction of the Qazvin-Rasht [iran]-Astara [Azerbaijan] railway bypassing Armenia within the framework of the North-South international transport corridor. [Passage omitted: background details] In reply, Sergey Lavrov said that during the implementation of regional transport projects Russia would take into account Armenia's interests and would not take steps that could harm them. He also promised to inform Russian Transport Minister Igor Levitin and the head of the Russian Railways company, Gennadiy Fadeyev, about the Armenian prime minister's concern. Most likely, this can be understood as follows: Russia takes Armenia's concern with understanding but it will not refuse taking part in the promising project. [Passage omitted: reported details] During his recent visit to Tehran, Armenian National Security Council Secretary [and Defence Minister] Serzh Sarkisyan discussed the prospects for the construction of the Iran-Armenia railway. Last December, having met the Iranian ambassador in Yerevan, Serzh Sarkisyan described the idea of the construction of the railway as "brilliant" and noted that if the implementation of the project became possible, it would have major importance for Armenia. To all appearances, Russia does not share the optimism of the Armenian side...[ellipsis as published] Armenia unsuccessful to change situation in its favour The fact that the Armenian side decided to make the media aware of its discontent with Russia's regional transport policy may testify to the fact that the attempts to achieve changes in the situation by diplomatic methods were not successful, and this, of course, cannot make Yerevan happy. Nevertheless, without showing desire to ease Armenia's transport problems, Russia does not hide its appetite for Armenian energy. Last week, the Russian RAO UES company [unified Energy System of Russia] confirmed that it was holding talks with the Midland Group offshore company on the purchase of the Armenian power grid. [Passage omitted: background details] We should assume that the head of the Russian RAO UES company, Anatoliy Chubays, who put forward a scandalous idea of building a "liberal empire" in 2003, wants to begin its implementation precisely in Armenia. The interest towards the power grids, besides political implication, has evident economic implication as well. Chubays has repeatedly stated that Armenia was a leader among CIS countries for the level of collection of payments for the consumed electricity. Taking into account the fact that Armenia's main power facilities are already controlled by the RAO UES company, the possible purchase of the power grids will allow to "form a chain" providing maximum business efficiency. The Midland Group company cannot sell the shares it possesses without the Armenian government's consent. If the RAO UES Company is really interested in the purchase, it is very unlikely that Yerevan will refuse. If this happens amid Russia's indifference to Armenia's interests in the region, future protests by Armenia will be at least strange as official Yerevan's decision will formally be considered voluntary. http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg103524.html
  8. http://www.archives.gov/research_room/fede...nnel_rg024.html National Archives of the United States Records of the Bureau of Naval Personnel (RECORD GROUP 24) 1798-1991 (bulk 1798-1956) 24.10 MOTION PICTURES (GENERAL) 1917-27 World War I naval operations and activities, including anti- submarine patrols, minelaying, convoy and escort duty, submarine maneuvers, and training; ship launching and maintenance; torpedo production and firing; Liberty Loan promotions and patriotic celebrations; Armistice celebrations; captured German equipment; U.S. and foreign political and military leaders; foreign naval vessels; President Woodrow Wilson's second inauguration; the airship Los Angeles (ZRS-3) over New York; and lighter-than-air craft rescuing fishermen, 1917-18 (44 reels). Naval activities after World War I, including aerial mapping techniques, rescue of Armenian refugees from Turkey, evacuation of personnel from grounded and burning ships, escort duty, and training, 1918-27 (57 reels). http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg103515.html
  9. Siamanto

    New York Photos

    My first impression of LA was (coming from Paris:) where everybody did go? Honestly, that was my first reaction! The next day, I've been to downtown LA and I was a little relieved. Then I asked myself: where did the Americans go? I 'm a big wanderer and I don't like to drive, but I prefer LA to New Jersey! I enjoy walking around SoHo, but I wouldn't live there: it's still not a real "neighborhood" - with the exception of West of West Broadway. They are not annoying! They do not discomfort me. Their number has increased since the Bush Administration and the recession.
  10. Siamanto

    New York Photos

    style_images/master/snapback.png anoushik, If you're planning to take full advantage of NYC and live in city, then secure a high paying job! The rent in Manhattan is excessive - close to absurd - by LA standards! On the bright side, it did go slightly down the last couple of years. Also, keep in mind that in New York, you can get stuck in either the subway or traffic: the choice is yours! Armat, I have noticed that you often - almost always - talk about LA with such animosity! I relate to what you say and maybe I did not stay long enough in LA to hate it! Personally, I need to feel the energy and the "density" of the crowd!
  11. Armen, It is noteworthy that as soon as you were asked to go one step beyond counting fairy tales, you started looking for the closest exit. You probably thought that it would be a "piece of cake" to convince your challengers! When things got "tough," you first started "distorting" what it was said and, when unsuccessful, looked for an exit! Honestly, I seriously doubt that you have anything meaningful to say about the views/theories of those who you claim to be the "first" to have understood and contemplated Individualism. You kept on mentioning their "pioneering" and "unique" work, yet not a single idea, not a single line that would present their views/theories. Isn't that curious? Honestly, based on your replies, I seriously doubt that you are capable of distinguishing Scientific Fundamental Discoveries from Technological Innovations. Even less capable of assessing their relevance in the History of Sciences. Yet you allow yourself - with ease and obstination - to insist on highly controversial statements. Honestly, and sadly enough, you seem to lack the Intellectual Courage and Honesty to admit it! Would you care to prove me wrong?
  12. I see that you managed to "cut and paste" from the link that I have provided! Congratulations! Unfortunately, you have chosen to selectively "cat and paste!" I have already replied to this "Anecdote & Fairy Tale." It's a shame that you lack the courage to take the challenge to understand the impact of the three Scientific Discoveries that I have mentioned! Again, can't take the challenge to elicit the views/theories of those who were the "first" to understand Individualism?
  13. Armen, with all due respect, "you are slowly but constantly moving towards becoming" either emotional or juvenile! and failing to understand what is meant. It was about your "masterpiece" - or what you probably thought it was: You could and should have noticed that my reply about the compass came later! Read more carefully! style_images/master/snapback.png What!!!! No comments! Trying to save face? Nice try! Did you read my post? What are you talking about? The context was your "masterpiece" - that miserably failed you - about Microsoft! Allow me to quote myself: You're not thinking clear! Please get hold of your emotions! Thanks! By the way, how did you manage to put together Arabs and Russell and... Wow! What a mess! Also, what makes you think that they are my "favourite scientists?" I don't know if I would call Wittgenstein a scientist! Do you know who they are? Wht only these three? What a fruitless converstaion! What's your point? What a fruitless conversation! Of course, we would have been lost without the Arabs and the compass! I've already answered this question. Read again! Why? What's your point? Is your memory that short? With all due respect, you are becoming a little "juvenile!" I know what I have provided and your obstination to focus on the Greek-Egyptian exchanges is a bit....Can you go on step beyond that? I don't want to quote myself for a third time! The point was clear. Also, I gave you examples of Fundamental Scientific Discoveries. Honestly, I seriously doubt that you are capable of understanding their importance and impact on Science! You probably have no clue of what they are or how fundamental they are! This is a challenge!
  14. OK! Thank you! And??? That is a bit confusing! In fact, according to your previous post, only few did have and understanding and/or were "consciously talking about it." As far as I know, most - if not all - Cultures had the equivalent of warrior/aristocrat. Most - if not all - Cultures were aware in the dialectics of Individual/Group! In any case, I'm glad we agree! Did I say that? I'm sorry if you got that impression! No, it's not arrogance; it's called "preference." I have very close friends that I highly respect who have read - and had a lot of interest - in such readings/theories. I don't see your reasoning! Sorry! "First to understand!!!!" So what was their understanding? You have been constantly mentioning them, yet none of their views/theories have been elicited so far! Would you care to enlighten us? Thanks! What is the point? Thanks! Why are you assuming I don't know what/where are the origins of Zarathustra? When did I say that "there was no influence whatsoever?" Let's try to a bit more reasonable and fair! Thanks! I'm afraid that the conversation is degenerating! Of course it did! Please read my previous replies!
  15. No, I was not making fun of you! However, I should thank you for a great example of - addition to - what I called "Anecdote and Fairy Tales." First of all, it is hard to understand what you perceive as unique in MS Windows? 1- A better designed, architected and implemented Operating System existed before MS Windows (For the record, when first released MS Windows was only a Windowing System. The OS was DOS.) 2- A better designed, architected and implemented Windowing System existed before MS Windows. In fact, MS Windows remains a poor version of what X was in 1984! Most of all, it is so obvious that others would have marketed - and did - a comparable OS that I would consider it a mere platitude. Furthermore, many think that the contribution of Microsoft to Computer Science has been rather negative. Personally, I believe that Computer Science would have advanced with or without Microsoft in a comparable manner. Last but not least, the work of Logicians such as Russell, Wittgenstein and Frege. The "Ontological Methodologies" conceived and developed by philosophers - including Aristotle - had a more significant contribution than Microsoft in the advancement of Software Development and Computer Science, in the form of 1- Object Oriented Design 2- ER (Entity/Relationship) Data Modeling 3- Relational Databases You seem to be confusing a- Advancements in Fundamental Sciences b- Technological Innovations c- Mass Production of Technologies. The difference is "ler ou tsor!" Microsoft contributed in the Mass Production of a Technological Innovation! Again, I sincerely thank you for an excellent example of what I call "Anecdote & Fairy Tale!" I have entertained myself on many occasions about the impact of Technological Innovations and their Mass production on Fundamental Scientific Discoveries. My previous statements were based on the result of such activities. The work of epistemologists of early/mid 20th Century may help you! Engineering - not Sciences - is such that they would have found another solution! As simple as that! Please "entertain yourself" contemplating the impact of the following examples of Fundamental Scientific Discoveries/contributions: 1- The discovery of irrational numbers that resulted in the foundation of Axiomatic Geometry (Thales/Phytagoras.) 2- The "Galois Theory." 3- The work of Godel style_images/master/snapback.png It's hard to tell what "this" refers to in your reply. In any case, the point was that 1- You seem to be confusing between Advancement in Fundamental Sciences and Technological Innovations. 2- In your assessment, the impact of the few Technological Innovations are over-rated 3- There is a fundametal difference between European Philosophy/Science and Arab/Muslim/Oriental/... Engineering - not Sciences - is such that they would have found another solution! As simple as that!
  16. style_images/master/snapback.png style_images/master/snapback.png Armen, If you read carefully, you should realize that I did not deny the existence of Arab - and non-Arab - scientists within the territories of the Empire that they have founded and ruled. Neither, I have denied interactions between the two Civilizations. (By the way, interactions often involve bilateral exchanges.) What I have questioned is: 1- The relevance of "Arab Scientists" on the European Renaissance and Sciences in general. I maintain that the European Renaissance and Sciences would have developed the way they did with or without the interactions with the Arabs and Muslims. The impact of these few inventions would be comparable to the impact of a successful start-up on the US Economy! In other words, negligible! Western Philosophy and Science has been founded in "Greece" and occasional interactions with Arabs - or any other Civilization - has been of little relevance for its achievements! If you think otherwise, you need to 1- Provide examples 2- Assess their impact i.e. relevance on the path/History of Western Philosophy and Science All the "anecdotal evidence" mentioned in this thread is old news i.e. already integrated! I'm simply questioning their relevance and believe that they are far too over-rated! Most of all, you seem to be confusing the Fundamental Essence of a given Civilization - the equivalent of a Genetic Code - and the occasional interactions with other Civilizations - of accidental nature. The Spanish Culture would have been close enough to what it is to day. Close enough that the difference would have been imperceptible! Again, one should not make a confusion between the Essence of a Culture - the equivalent of a Genetic Code - and interactions that are of accidental nature. PS. I may or may not like Algerians, Maghrebins or Arabs in general; shall I assume that you have a fascination for Arabs?
  17. You're even far less perceptive - to use a euphemism - than I thought! I'll draw a picture, just for you! style_images/master/snapback.png style_images/master/snapback.png style_images/master/snapback.png style_images/master/snapback.png I hope the picture helped! Don't worry we all have our handicaps! Thank you for posting Chapter 4 of "Anecdotes & Fairy Tales." I enjoyed reading it! As perceptive as ever! Let me repeat myself: Thank you for the advice and the words of wisdom! Tomorrow is a holiday, I'll shop for a barometer - or an instrument to check pressure - and deflate as necessary!
  18. Armen, We seem to have very different - not even opposite - understandings of Individualism. Your understanding of Individualism is new to me. It is apparently based on the works and thinking of Hermetics, mine - closer to the Nietzsche - is based on 1- The concepts of "Aristocrat," "Warrior" and/or "Samurai" i.e. aiming for individual virtues and excellence 2- The dialectics of Individuals vs Groups and the awareness of the irreducibility of the former to the latter My nature is such that I never had an interest in those - somehow "obscure/occultist" - alchemist/spiritualist systems such as the Hermetics, the Kabbalists etc. Also, I have a quite different interpretation of historical "facts." 1- Of course, it may be the case that in the Hellenic city of Alexandria, Greeks have been exposed to Egyptian Philosophy and integrated some of its elements into their thinking, but I don't think the exchange was unilateral. I agree with Anonymouse, that Greek and Western Philosophy/Science have little to do with Egyptian Philosophy/Science. For instance, Egyptian Geometry and Arithmetic were empirical in essence; while Greek Geometry was axiomatic and based on the awareness that it transcends the empirical world. (Consider the discovery of irrational numbers.) The same applies to Plato's Ontology, the same is true of Aristotle's Logic: it is more deductive than inductive. Western Science and Philosophy could not have developed as it did, if based solely on empirical principles. 2- I consider the relevance of "Arab Scientists" on the European Renaissance as anecdotal and mainly a speculation. The Crusades gave an impetus because it crystallized and channeled the energies. Note: I am aware that some of what is known as "Greek" originated in Anatolia, Persia or Hellenic Cities of the Mediterranean.
  19. Azat, Another question: are "fairy tales" necessarily "negative?"
  20. Azat, Aren't you taking it a bit too literally? "Fairy tales" are necessary to "package" and "market" a Philosphy, a Thought System or a Software Product. But, shouldn't we distinguish the package/ad from the product? Would Managers and Salesmen understand a highly technical Design Document? No! Of course, I'm not justifying or criticizing those "fairy tales." But, let's not confuse the ads and the product! I'm not religious, but I find that Christianity offers much more than the "fairy tales" we learn as a child!
  21. How criminal. When will barbarians learn to leave others' property alone? style_images/master/snapback.png Your next Armenian lesson: "Kogh sird@ togh!" Integrating elements of another Culture into one's own is a universal phenomena: some do it in an ethical manner others prefer dishonesty. In both cases, the credit should go to the original! You should have in mind what your Nation has done for centuries: stealing and appropriating other Cultures and destroying and/or stealing the artifacts created by those Cultures. Briefly said, stealing their Identity! Don't feel so unfortunate, after all you *urks were far "more developed" than any other Nation in the art of destruction and looting. How many *urks does it take to figure out that a comparison - "A more developed than B" - involves two distinct entities i.e. has two operands? Apparently, more than one! What happened to all the "inverses, converses" and all that "charmingly" subversive "Logic?" that you have so proudly displayed, only two weeks ago? Yes! You have googled that day to show us how conversed you are in Logic; but, could not tell that what you've found belonged to the Middle Ages! (How appropriate to our conversation! ) Later, you have reversed back to your own flavor of naive provincialism! Note: I have chosen to auto censor the word "*urk" because it is commonly perceived as unpleasant and offending, with immoral and evil connotations!
  22. Is it really possible to locate the "sole" "roots" of Individualism? Is it possible that the idea has been developed "simultaneously" and/or independently in different cultures? Egypt is not the only country the British - or some Europeans countries - have looted! Does that indicate an interest in - or an attraction to - the victim? Interesting! Would you care to elaborate? Thanks! Do we have written records? For some reason, it reminds me of the "proven" "fact" that Jesus has studied - was influenced by - Indian Philosophy/Religion!
  23. There indeed existed a thick layer of culture on which Renaissance was essentially based – I'd even say wouldn't be possible without it. But with a few exceptions, the "dark ages" culture lacked the true greatness of the Classical and Renaissance art, at least in my perception of greatness. style_images/master/snapback.png No comments! Maybe "patent law and intellectual property rights were unknown," but the "Magic" of documenting and building artifacts that would survive time and testify was already known!
  24. No, you won't be able to prove much with anecdotes! Sorry! As for your time-machine, is it the model that Abdul El Hamadi engineered in 1029 AC? I've heard they are miraculous! How about Magic? Did you consider it? Honestly, your reply amazes me! Either 1- You believe in the magical powers of your arguments that should have necessarily convinced me 2- I'm a total moron who would fall for any anecdotal "evidence" 3- You fail to see the highly controversial nature of your statement that Muslims were more developed than Europeans. I believe that I've already replied to the above. Let's please avoid circular discussions. Thanks! that may be, but as far as I know by the time of the Crusades allready the Church had very much become a pillar of the State or rather a means of keeping the commoners passive and obedient to their earthly masters. And yet it was after this period that Europe began to to assert its power. style_images/master/snapback.png Did I say that?
  25. Also, Arabic or Muslim Architecture integrated many elements of ancient Persian and Assyrian Architecture. I'll try to find links!
×
×
  • Create New...