Jump to content

Anonymouse

Members
  • Posts

    2,222
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Anonymouse

  1. If they made a movie showing the harmful effects of fastfood hamburgers, I'd be touched. I would stop eating.
  2. I personally think this depends on how one views a human. Do you just see a human as a physical entity, or more than that, a spiritual being? There is this saying that says if I poke you in the arm with my finger and I ask a question, "Is this your body?" and you answer"Yes." I then ask, "Well, if that's your body, what are you?" The answer of course is a spiritual being.
  3. I may look like a mouse, but I attack like a tiger.
  4. Yea! You see, I live in this really god-awful place called Los Angeles, the "entertainment capital", and the "yeres arats" faction is perhaps the worst. Over the years I've personally witnessed this metamorphosis. I saw this in high school, and I still see it now. These parents open up nice businesses, make lots of dough, forget about their kids, they get em nice cars, spoil them to the brim, and this becomes the norm. I support castration so these people don't breed.
  5. The Music Never Stopped Recordings depend on music, not vice versa. Brian Doherty When I was young, I thought the music I heard on the radio was coming from live bands performing in the studios as I listened. I imagined pop groups frantically packing up to make room for the next one, then dashing across town to perform their new hit on another station. I can’t explain why I held this weird belief, especially since I knew that records existed. What I didn’t know is that my delusional world was the dream of a tough union leader in the first half of the 20th century, James Caesar Petrillo of the American Federation of Musicians (AFM). He saw that recorded music, and the broadcasting of that music on radio and jukeboxes, was a threat to his boys’ jobs (and his). AFM strikes brought the recording of new music to a halt in 1943 and 1948, but when the union tried again in 1958 it just didn’t work. Live musicians’ cultural and political influence had waned too much, even as the average Joe had more access to more songs than anyone in history. (That statement only gets more and more true every year, with every technological advance.) And nowadays -- well, one Los Angeles session drummer told me his AFM rep blithely advised him to cross his own union’s picket line to avoid inconveniencing himself. As music journalist Mark Coleman notes in his new book Playback: From the Victrola to MP3, 100 Years of Music, Machines, and Money (Da Capo), "It’s a pity [Petrillo] didn’t live to hear the record industry unload on Napster and file sharing in much the same way he denounced canned music. The echoes are pitch-perfect." Coleman’s book documents how new technologies -- from the player piano to the iPod -- have always rattled to their core the powers that dominate the business of making, distributing, and selling music. Those powers are right to be disturbed. They tend to become entrenched in selling music in particular manners and styles and systems. New technologies inevitably shake all those things up. Coleman tells us about many such technologies and shakeups: home phonographs and radios that sealed the fate of player pianos and sheet music in the 1920s, ’30s, and ’40s; the invention of the long-playing record in the late ’40s and multitracking in the ’50s, which created space for unified 40-to-50-minute works of musical recording art; the late ’70s introduction of portable cassette/earphone devices that elevated the cassette to the best-selling recorded-music format in just six years; the electronic synthesizer of the ’80s that drove out of business many of Petrillo’s boys who somehow had managed to survive the onslaught of canned music in the first half of the 20th century. Now we face file sharing, and the music-selling industry is shaking and suing and wondering what to do. We don’t know how this will all play out. Even where people can steal music conveniently, a new enterprise that sells the same songs we could steal can still move 25 million downloads in eight months, as iTunes has. Don’t count out selling recordings over the Internet yet. As we listen these days to the cries of music-selling middlemen that those sweet songs of yesteryear will disappear in a world of unbridled file sharing, we need to remember that the interests of music professionals don’t necessarily coincide with the interests of music listeners. Sure, new technologies and ways of doing business have hurt many trades related to the music industry. There are many fewer people making a living as song pluggers, sheet music publishers, and the like. There are probably fewer professional live musicians than there would be if we had never enjoyed radios, jukeboxes, transistorized stereos, or computerized file sharing. Yet with every change, people’s access to better reproduced, more portable, more personalized music grows. I come from the indie rock scene and ran my own label. Despite record-mogul fear mongering about the sounds of silence that will descend if they can’t sell you $18 CDs, you can’t tell me people won’t still perform music -- and even reproduce it in forms that people might be able to pirate -- merely because they won’t be able to make a healthy living at it. There are no more AFM bosses like Petrillo, who in the ’30s had enough clout to make all the radio stations in Chicago hire union musicians to flip records. But as the moribund music site MP3.com proved in its heyday, there are tens of thousands of people making their own music and yearning for an audience, though not necessarily a paying one. Music was a vital part of human culture long before anyone was able to mass reproduce and sell recordings of it. And music will survive any number of upheavals in the systems for selling recordings that developed in the last century. Brian Doherty is a senior editor at Reason. http://www.reason.com/0403/cr.bd.the.shtml
  6. What it means to be human Roger Scruton tracks down the soul — the divine spark that distinguishes us from the rest of creation. Human beings are animals, composed of nerves and sinews, cardiovascular systems and digestive tracts. We hang from the tree of evolution on the same branch as the chimpanzee and the bonobo and not far from those of the elephant, the zebra and the mouse. We are governed by the laws of biology, and even our thoughts and emotions are the result of electrochemical processes in the brain. Such, at any rate, is the conception fostered by popular science and tub-thumped into us by Richard Dawkins. What room is there in this picture for the soul — the divine spark that supposedly distinguishes humanity from the rest of creation and which bears within itself the meaning of our life on earth? Can we not give a complete account of the human condition in biological terms, without referring to the elusive soul-stuff within? And if that is possible, what grounds have we for thinking that the soul exists, still less that it is the inner essence, the originating cause and the final end of our existence? Suppose you were to look at a painting — say Manet’s ‘Bar at the Folies Bergère’ in the Courtauld Gallery — and ask yourself how it is composed. From the point of view of chemical science, it is a canvas on which pigments are distributed. From the point of view of the art-lover, it is an image of a woman on whose face the last pale twilight of innocence is fading. You could draw a graph across the picture, and indicate exactly what pigment is to be found at every pair of co-ordinates. This description would not mention the woman, still less her fading innocence or her blank but haunting gaze. Yet it could be a complete description. Somebody who daubed a canvas in the way mapped by the graph would produce an exact copy of Manet’s picture. He would do this even if he had not noticed the woman and even if he was entirely blind to pictorial images. From the scientific point of view, therefore, the woman is nothing over and above the pigments in which she is seen. But this woman exists in a space of her own. We see the back of her head, reflected in the mirror, some ten feet behind her. Of course, there is no part of this canvas that is ten feet behind any other part. The space within the picture is not mapped by our imaginary graph, even if it will be automatically reconstituted when we follow the graph’s instructions. Moreover, no smear of chrome white can possibly have a fading innocence, nor can patches of cerulean and Prussian blue look at us inquiringly or await our interest. But all those things can be seen in the painting, and someone who doesn’t see them doesn’t understand what he is looking at. In short, the picture can be described in two contrasting ways, and the descriptions are incommensurable. This resembles the case of the human soul. We can imagine a complete account of the human being as a biological organism from which nothing observable has been left out. Any creature with just this biological constitution will behave as I do, and lead the life that is distinctive of our kind. So why add a further story about the soul? Why not draw the obvious conclusion, that because nothing needs to be added to the biology, the biology is all that there is? That would be like saying that since no woman is mentioned in the scientific description of Manet’s canvas, there is no woman in the picture. We can tell two stories about Manet’s canvas, both complete. One explains it, the other tells us what it means. Likewise we can tell two stories about the human organism, one that explains its physical appearance and behaviour, the other which tells us what it means to us. Many concepts that feature in this second story have no application in the first. For example, we describe people as responsible and free. We praise them, blame them and see worth and meaning in the things that they do. We criticise, argue, persuade. A complex language has emerged through which we relate to each other, and this language bypasses reference to the organism in something like the way our description of the woman in Manet’s picture bypasses the physical constitution of the canvas. As in the case of the picture, the two descriptions that we give of the human being are incommensurable. There is no place in the language of biology for the concepts of freedom and responsibility. Biology can describe grimaces and facial contortions, but it lacks the concept of a smile — ‘for smiles from Reason flow ... and are of love the food’, as Milton finely put it. The concepts that we spontaneously use to describe the human being do not explain; they interpret. And the interpretation that we favour describes a reasonable creature, accountable to his kind. Crucial to this interpretation is the concept of self. Other animals are conscious, have thoughts, desires and emotions. But only we are self-conscious, able to address each other from ‘I’ to ‘I’ and to know ourselves in the first person, as subjects in a world of objects. As Kant plausibly argued, self-consciousness and freedom are two sides of a coin. It is I, not my body, who choose, and it is I who am praised or blamed, not my limbs, my feelings or my movements. There is a mystery here: how can I be both a free subject and a determined object, both the ‘I’ that decides and the body that carries the decision through? Kant argued that the understanding stops at the threshold of this mystery, and I suspect that he was right. It is precisely this mystery that religions try to normalise with the story of the soul. The story varies from epoch to epoch and creed to creed. But it is never more simply put than in the language of the Koran, in which one word — nafs — means both ‘self’ and ‘soul’. This soul is raised in me: only by learning the ways of accountability do I rise to the condition of a free being, who realises his freedom in his deeds. Hence the soul can be corrupted. There is such a thing as the Devil’s work, which consists in undermining the self, tempting people to see themselves as objects, leading them to identify completely with their biological condition, to squander their selfhood in orgies of concupiscence and to refuse all accountability for what they are and do. The moral truth is conveyed with admirable simplicity in the great Sura of the Sun, Koran 91, which invokes the wonders of creation: sun and moon, day and night, heaven and earth, and finally ‘a soul, and what formed her, to which He revealed both right and wrong’. The Sura goes on to tell us that the one who safeguards the soul’s purity will prosper, while he who corrupts it is destroyed. It requires no metaphysics to understand the words ‘wa nafsin...’ — ‘and a soul...’. They are spoken in me and to me. The verse refers to the self that harbours knowledge of right and wrong, and it is just this that is the source of meaning in me. Christians, Jews, Hindus and Buddhists have other ways of capturing this simple thought, but the fundamental observation is shared. Human beings stand out from the rest of creation. They are subjects in a world of objects, and as a result they judge and are judged. Hence they can be redeemed and corrupted. This work of redemption and corruption is neverending. We do not need a metaphysical doctrine of the soul to make sense of this; as we learn from the Koran, the reflexive pronoun is enough. Faith adds just one crucial detail: namely, that the reflexive pronoun is used also by God. Of course, seeing the matter in this way, we do nothing to justify the belief in immortality. Nevertheless, we can go some way towards making that belief intelligible. Although the woman in Manet’s picture is nothing over and above the pigments in which we see her, you do not destroy her by destroying the pigments. If Manet’s work were perfectly copied and then burned, we would confront a new canvas, but the same woman. The person seen in the new painting would be identical with the person seen in the old. This is a strange kind of identity, and not without paradox. But it provides a model for theologians, should they wish to explain the identity between the person that I encounter in encountering you and the person who exists eternally in God’s perception. Immortality, seen in that way, is not a prospect to look forward to but a light in which we stand. © 2004 The Spectator.co.uk
  7. That horrible spelling is indicative of frustration. Alas, I'm having an effect.
  8. How do you know it's gravity? Don't appeal to your version of what the world should be. Despite labeling that process as "gravity", we don't know what "gravity" is. For example. the Hollow Earth theory, or the Theory of Concentric Spheres states that we are held fast to the ground not by gravity, but by centrifugal force as the earth rotates. Theoretically gravity must exist for Einstein's theory to be correct. What if they are all wrong? It is a theory, and all measurements based off of this theory are therefore also assumptions. Theories are theories treat them all the same. Appealing to belief doesn't determine them to be any more truthful than they already are. Either we have to be really "scientificial" and discard things that we simply don't know, or we admit that science is and does carry a religious aura, of belief. This is why many scientists, and pseudo scientists like Domino, resort to name calling when their intellectual matrix cracks, because it is as much faith as it is science.
  9. Wow, you have all the answers to everything. So profound.
  10. There's nothing wrong if he has nothing to say, unless he insists on saying it.
  11. I think the solution to the Armenian problem is to just leave Armenia, give it to Muslims. Sounds like a good deal.
  12. I think it's about time the world ended. I'm tired of reading about this conflict.
  13. While Mustafa Kamal may be in prison now, it would have done him great service to gain linguistics knowledge by reading your post.
  14. Anonymouse

    Neocons

    Of course they haven't won any championships, they've taken it all by force. Thus it's a one-sided game.
  15. Gee, maybe you're solution would have us turn into a theocracy or socialism?
  16. I would like to meet my significant other while purchasing a 2 for 1 bananas at the produce section of Jons market.
  17. When confronted with a superior mind, it is best to resort to ad homenim attacks.
  18. Fair enough. Now if we could have taught Armenians, Kurds and Turks to double-space from each other, none of this would have happened.
  19. Apparently you haven't visited that forum. Either that or you do not know how to navigate the intraweb.
  20. That's funny I could have swore that you had no clue what you were talking about. But instead of resorting to childish name calling because I threaten your "intellectual" matrix, why not stick to the issues and not ad homenims? I care what "years" are based on, because it only shows how our measurement of time is arbitrary and for you to base a theory on this and call it "Fact" and name call me for daring to question it, is the last refuge of the pointless. Since humanity is finite and imperfect and its perception flawed, therefore any attempt by humans to measure time is going to be flawed, even for scientists. I an not contending the fact that the earth is measured in those numbers those simply stem from theoretical calculations and if you can't deal with that on its face value, you are trying too hard to believe. I am declaring that our measurement of time is arbitrary, hence it could be misconstrued and misunderstood, and in fact wrong, when trying to compare our measurement of time to the ancients. I am aware what Sitchin does and what standards he uses, the same as others. I find his theory appealing, far more appealing than evolution, but then again I will point out that which is unknown. Just because I read the book, and unlike you, don't blindly subscribe to everything, doesn't mean I haven't read it. I have maintained that I am more inclinded to believe the theory Sitchin presents, over that of evolution. For example gravity is just another theory, it is believed. We don't know what gravity is, but we believe in it, as it is a good explanation. In other words, 'science' often times behaves like a religion, but you will never hear the 'scientifical' minds admit to this. The same is applied to our measurement of time, which is an intangible thing. We find it complex to think of unlimited space, yet theology and religion offer us the idea of unlimited space of the universe. We have become accustomed to thinking of space as having some beginning and consequently some ending amnd think that since we have rules and tape measures by which people can measure the space around them, there cannot be space taht is immeasurable, or going to such an extent as to have no limit and be beyond any measurement. Unconsciously, we also associate the duration of time with the extent of space. Through his objective consciosness of a 3 dimensional world we believe that time extends itself and that space extends itself. We think that these extensions are much similar and coincidental or related to each other. Hence, we think that it must require a certain number of minutes to move ourselves or something a certain number of meters. We believe that if we roll a ball along the ground the extent of space it covers is related to the extent of time it will take to cover that space. And we have learned that we can cut down or reduce the extent in that same direction of space by faster motion and therefore by being rolle dfaster the ball will go the same distance in a shorter time. This is simply off topic, since this thread was obviously created not to deal with evolution. Suffice to say, a theory is a theory, treat them all the same. Ultimately it's that which is appealing to us, wouldn't you agree? I find evolution far more doubtful, than intelligent intervention, simply for its persistence on being nothing but chance and haphazard by nature, and that from some random mutations we can get ordered and structured organisms. The further lack of evidence ) fossils ) for establishing it as a fact, itself doesn't bode too well for evolution. Ultimately the conclusion does not follow the premise.
  21. I'd like to be handcuffed to her for the rest of my life.
×
×
  • Create New...