Vayri7X
Members-
Posts
126 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Vayri7X
-
Ins't this the guy quoted by turkish denialists>?
-
David Barsamian David Barsamian is founder and director of Alternative Radio, the independent award-winning weekly series based in Boulder, Colorado. He is a radio producer, journalist, author and lecturer. He has been working in radio since 1978. His interviews and articles appear regularly in The Progressive and Z Magazine. He is the author of several books, including Propaganda and the Public Mind: Conversations with Noam Chomsky; Eqbal Ahmad: Confronting Empire and The Decline and Fall of Public Broadcasting. His latest books are The Checkbook and the Cruise Missile: Conversations with Arundhati Roy, and Louder Than Bombs: Interviews from The Progressive Magazine. The Institute for Alternative Journalism named him one of its "Top Ten Media Heroes." Barsamian lectures on U.S. foreign policy, the media, propaganda, and corporate power in the U.S., Canada, Brazil, India and Europe. He is the winner of the ACLU's Upton Sinclair Award for independent journalism and of a Democracy Media Award. from : http://www.alternativeradio.org/barsamian.shtml Lists of his books. He is a prolific writer, who employs excellent journalistic skills in the art of interview.
-
Err.. how about " Ro-manian"? Living in the us " bible belt" , people ask about my background and here's what follows: me: i'm Armenian. them: Ro-MAnian??? me: no , Armenian, as in Armenia.. them: Ro=mannian? So yer a gypsy, huh? read my palm , blah blah blah me: (sigh) A-ight. You are gonna die and you are gonna pay taxes. No fork up 15 dollars , ya whack otar. There's an "armenian fortune" for ya. them: what's a Romanian fortune ? me : AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAKKKKKKHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
-
hetanos here, sans the racism and xenophobia and over-adulation of notions of authority . It simply seems more viable with notions of science. I.e. , most folks with polytheistic religion do nto see the incompatibility with science, and are intelligent enough to accept that the goddesses/gods/spirits are archetypical representations ( albeit, with real meaning and response) of the forces of nature, biology and so forth. Kind of like a long poetic version of James Lovelocks "Gaia Hypothesis". then again, I was raised in " Indian Country" ( native american- not south asian indian) , so being exposed to nature-based, polytheistic practices that were not hostile to science was not unusual or even solely the domain of new age tree-huggers. Most of my friends (native) and their families went both to protestant christian churches to maintain face, and also practiced traditional spirituality /religion . So I questioned monotheism quite early. My dad ( 100% hye) did too. I still go to Armenian Apostolic church, and am not " out" with other armenians, save my dad- about my views. BTW, it seems like every major christian practice, one can find Pagan roots. Too many to name here. It seems to me, that us being one of the earliest christian peoples, that the church no doubt holds more veiled pagan practices than others. What do you think?
-
-
I want a copy so BAD!! I have been listening to Galas' works since I was 12. To say that her voice is powerful , potent and shaking is not giving it justice. Speaking of justice, her use of her voice and musical projects has largely been shaped by her notions of justice , and rememberance in the face of forgetfulness and oblivion. I have her earlier works, Plague Mass, where she constructed a project around the marginalized, forgotten and outcaste victims of AIDS. She challenges though jolting the listener out of complacence , especially in regards to their preconceived ideas regarding compassion , social hypocrisy and religion. Too bad the authorities in Armenia prevented her performance. Sidenote: Once I went to a smarmy corporate bookstore in an azzbackwards state in the southern us ( Borders *ahem) asking around for her Divine Litanies/ Plague Mass double cd. It turned out that the guy working there had a copy. He told me that I could have it for free ( usually quite rare and expensive ) . Why? This big man leaned down to me, looked furtively around and said in a quivering whisper ..." IT scares me"..
-
A little history on Armenians in Jerusalem and Palestine from G. Hintlian: Excerpts: "In 1922, when Armenians were evacuated from the towns of Southern Turkey (Cilicia) as a result of Mustapha Kemal’s offensive, some ships of evacuees reached the Palestinian coast, especially Haifa. The British authorities barred their entry. But when Arab notables of Palestine protested, they were allowed to disembark. The Arab village chief of Sheikh Breik offered free land to the Armenian refugees, who established the village of Athlit near Haifa. By 1925, there were 15,000 Armenians in Palestine, residing mainly in Haifa, Jaffa, and Jerusalem."}} The War in 1948, however, caused major dislocations. Overnight the Armenian communities of Jaffa and Haifa, numbering 10,000, were reduced to a mere 1,000 people. In West Jerusalem, several hundred Armenian families also lost their homes and businesses. They all flocked to the Armenian Quarter. Suddenly, the monastic authorities had to provide for the needs of 4,000 refugees. Before 1948, the Armenian Community in Palestine numbered 15,000. Far from emigrating, many Armenians were moving to Palestine from neighbouring countries like Lebanon and Syria. After 1948, the pattern was reversed. Some Armenians from Haifa and Jaffa took refuge in Beirut and Amman, hoping to return in a short time, while others came to stay with their relatives in Jerusalem. Subsequently, many moved to Amman, Beirut, and Kuwait for employment. Then, in the early 1960’s, emigration shifted to Canada, the United States, and Australia. After 1967, emigration accelerated, this time to Los Angeles. The Israeli occupation thwarted the natural increase of the community in Palestine by blocking migration from Arab countries.}} "During 1948, out of a total of 10,000 residents left in the Old City, 6,000 were Armenians. Equipped only with makeshift weapons, the Armenian civil guards made a valiant defense. The Armenian Quarter suffered considerable damage from the Hagana shelling of the Old City. Forty civilians lost their lives and another 250 were wounded. Since 1967, the Armenian Patriarchate has lost several plots of land in Jerusalem through confiscation. All the land below the western side of the ramparts from outside the walls to the old Fast Hotel was confiscated for so-called public purposes. In 1982, the Israeli Interior Ministry refused to renew the visa of Archbishop Karekin Kazandjian, the Gra.nd Sacristan of the Patriarchate (equivalent to deputy Patriarch), and issued a deportation order. All the Churches and other public bodies stood behind the Armenian Patriarchate in an act of solidarity. This tension lasted for eight years, ending only when Kazandjian was elected Armenian Patriarch of Istanbul. The Armenian Patriarchate, like other institutions, has great difficulty obtaining building permits. Work on the Armenian Church on Mt. Zion has been delayed for 20 years due to denial of building permits. In the Armenian Quarter settlers have tried several times to buy property, without success. " The Armenian Patriarchate during the intifada and today takes firm positions on human rights and justice issues affecting the Palestinian people. Along with the Greek and Latin Patriarchs, it has been a signatory to over twenty petitions of protest during the intifada and today. Before and during the intifada there were scores of Armenian youth arrested in Bethlehem, Ramallah, and Jerusalem. Haroutune Gulezian, an Armenian youth, was martyred while leading a demonstration in August 1991 in Ramallah. He is buried in the Armenian cemetery in Jerusalem. }}
-
Anyone know anything of the Loma of Armenia? Also known as the Boshas or Bosa. In Europe , their Diaspora is called Roma, with the common exonym ( and an erroneous one) calling them " Gypsies" or "Tziganskii". Armenia Now" published some info on them , although it was a little on the paternalizing side. I did some research under the Roma-American scholar Dr. Hancock in the US on the language, Lomavren, which is the central variant of Romani. Apparently, this language is dying out, although I know first-hand some people who still can functionally speak it. It is quite a shame in that of the three major routes that these people took out of India a thousand years ago, a point of major signficance was Armenia. Vlax Romani , a widespread dialect of Romanes, indicates great influence from Armenian. Moreover, most all dialects, including Domari , show a great amount of Armenian influence as well. There is very, very little written focusing centrally on them. For hayastanci s , is it true that there is a good deal of prejudice towards Bosha?However, from what I have heard , Armenia is one of the few places where the prejudice is quite low in comparison to Turkey, Iran, Georgia and Azerbaijan. If so, that's a good track record considering that Roma all over Europe are having to engage in a massive collective move towards basic civil rights (such as the recent uprising in Slovakia).
-
Don't *just* vote! http://www.dontjustvote.com/ " Because our dreams will never fit in thier ballot boxes" Excerpt : We are calling for a national campaign to take advantage of this election year to emphasize the power of direct action and to present direct democracy as a viable alternative to representation. This campaign will include literature distribution, postering and stickering, demonstrations, educational events, and other forms of community outreach, both in our own communities and around the Democratic and Republican National Conventions. It will culminate in a nationwide day of direct action on November 2, election day. On this day, people across the country will come together in groups both large and small to demonstrate the effectiveness of direct democracy as a way to make decisions without mediation or hierarchy, and of direct action as means to implement those decisions and create the kind of communities we desire. Those who wish to take an hour out of this day to cast a vote are welcome to do so; but we urge you to spend the remainder of the election day in creative experiments in self-determination and cooperation. At the end of the day or in the weeks that follow, people can reconvene and compare which approach was more rewarding and empowering: ballot-box voting or direct engagement without representatives.
-
Wow.. I suppose it's the Mozilla browser or something. I hope it is up. Thx for the replies...*
-
I've been trying to reach the Birthright Armenia site for a couple of weeks. Did the organization fold or fail? Does it still exist? Does anyone have an alternate method of contacting BA other than the website ( re; phone, mailing address, alternate e-mail) ? Also , has anyone done any work with this org? What did you think?
-
Just got back from Vardavar here in South Texas. Why is it that the most you don't want to get wet is in equal...nay eerily in mathematically balanced porportion ---- to the desire of other sunbaked, crazy armos to douse you? I am still trying to wring out my tee.. At least I didn't get thrown in the creek this year ;-) Anybody else grab the cans and buckets and have a Vardavar picnic this weekend? Or did you instead represent for the armos and and douse an unsuspecting odar ( i did both heheheh)
-
shnrklm,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,, It would be great to have another queer hye poet of the female variant here. - the Tribe too
-
Yeah...unfortunately, I took on the task of covering them for the local independant paper here. I hope I can get out of the DNC in the summer, as the paper doesn't cover travel expensese. Such is the case for independant media, though well worth it.
-
Speaking of the World Bank/IMF, check out "whirled bank" www.whirledbank.org site "Our father who art in Washington Whirled Bank be thy name. Thy kingdom come, thy will be done, or else, there'll be no more lending. Give us this day our triple A credit rating, and forgive us our past loans, as we remove all barriers to investment. Our economy is your economy, your economy is our economy, we are all one, globally integrated, forever and ever. Amen."
-
I am curious if any of you living in the great lil empire of the US of A are going to either the (DNC) Democratic National Convention this summer or the(RNC) Republican National Convention at the beginning of the fall. Despite finances, I am certainly going to attempt to go and demonstrate at these for whatever it is worth. As an anarchosynicalist and anti-authoritarian, I am committed to the idea of "direct action" i.e. ; unmediated democracy and taking action where I know that my "representatives" will not do it for me or my communities in question . Well put by the RNC unwelcoming committee is the sentiment ; " When the vote does not place in power those who represent the will of the people, democracy must be taken to the streets" If any wants any more info and logistics, try http://www.rncnotwelcome.org/ for RNC and http://blackteasociety.org/index.php for the DNC . Also, I know there's alot of hyes in Boston ( I'm in Tejas- akh,,amot che !! !) What do ya'll think about having your city all whacked up to accomodate a bunch of rich @%s? And, .. do you have any suggestions on where a surly but self-controlled Hye anarchist girlie like myself could find a (cheap) place to crash in Boston that is accessible during the shudown?
-
Ted Rall: Reagan's Shameful Legacy REAGAN'S SHAMEFUL LEGACY Mourn for Us, Not the Proto-Bush NEW YORK--For a few weeks, it became routine. I heard them dragging luggage down the hall. They paused in a little lounge near the dormitory elevator to bid farewell to people they'd met during their single semester. Those I knew knocked on my door. "What are you going to do?" I asked. "Where are you going to go?" A shrug. They were eighteen years old and their bright futures had evaporated. They had worked hard in junior and senior high school, harder than most, but none of that mattered now. President Reagan, explained the form letters from the Office of Financial Aid, had slashed the federal education budget. Which is why the same grim tableau of shattered hopes and dreams was playing itself out across the country. Colleges and universities were evicting their best and brightest, straight A students, stripping them of scholarships. Some transferred to less-expensive community colleges; others dropped into the low-wage workforce. Now, nearly a quarter century later, they are still less financially secure and less educated than they should have been. Our nation is poorer for having denied them their potential. They were by no means the hardest-hit victims of Reaganism. Reagan's quack economists trashed scholarships and turned welfare recipients into homeless people and refused to do anything about the AIDS epidemic, all so they could fund extravagant tax cuts for a tiny sliver of the ultra rich. Their supply-side sales pitch, that the rich would buy so much stuff from everybody else that the economy would boom and government coffers would fill up, never panned out. The Reagan boom lasted just three years and created only low-wage jobs. When the '80s were over, we were buried in the depths of recession and a trillion bucks in debt. Poverty grew, cities decayed, crime rose. It took over a decade to dig out. Reagan's defenders, people who don't know the facts or choose to ignore them, claim that "everybody" admired Reagan's ebullient personality even if some disagreed with his politics. That, like the Gipper's tall tales about welfare queens and "homeless by choice" urban campers, is a lie. Millions of Americans cringed at Reagan's simplistic rhetoric, were terrified that his anti-Soviet "evil empire" posturing would provoke World War III, and thought that his appeal to selfishness and greed--a bastardized blend of Adam Smith and Ayn Rand--brought out the worst in us. We rolled our eyes when Reagan quipped "There you go again"; what the hell did that mean? Given that he made flying a living hell (by firing the air traffic controllers and regulating the airlines), I'm not the only one who refuses to call Washington National Airport by its new name. His clown-like dyed hair and rouged cheeks disgusted us. We hated him during the dark days he made so hideous, and, with all due respect, we hate him still. Not everybody buys the myth that Reagan won the Cold War by demanding that Mikhail Gorbachev "tear down this [berlin] wall" or bankrupting the Soviet Union via the arms race--Zbigniew Brezinski's plot to "draw the Russians into the Afghan trap" by funding the mujahedeen, Chernobyl and covert U.S. schemes to destabilize the ruble had more to do with the end of the USSR. Gangsterism replaced the ossified cult of the state, millions of Russians were reduced to paupers, revived radical Islamism in Central Asia and eliminated our sole major ideological and military rival. That increased our arrogance and insularity, left us in charge of the world and to blame for everything, paving the road to 9/11. (Reagan even armed the attacks' future perpetrators.) Anyway, the Cold War isn't over. In which direction do you think those old ICBMs point today? The lionizers are correct about one thing: Reagan was one of our most influential presidents since FDR, whose New Deal safety net he carefully disassembled. He pioneered policies now being implemented by George W. Bush: trickle down economics, corporate deregulation, radicalizing the courts, slithering around inconvenient laws and international treaties. On the domestic front, he unraveled America's century-old social contract. What the poor needed was a kick in the ass, not a handout, said a president whose wealthy patrons bought him a house and put clothes on his wife Nancy. National parks were to be exploited for timber and oil, not protected. The federal tax code, originally conceived to redistribute wealth from top to bottom, was "reformed" to eradicate social justice. Bush also models his approach to foreign policy on that of the original Teflon President. Reagan elevated unjustifiable military action to an art. In 1983, anxious to look tough after cutting and running from Lebanon, Reagan sent marines to topple the Marxist government of Grenada. His pretext for invading this Caribbean island was the urgent plight of 500 medical students supposedly besieged by rampaging mobs. But when they arrived at the airport in the United States, the quizzical young men and women told reporters they were confused, never having felt endangered or seen any unrest. In a bizarre 1985 effort to free a few American hostages being held in Lebanon, Reagan authorized the sale of 107 tons of anti-tank and anti-aircraft missiles to Iran, at the time one of our staunchest enemies, with the proceeds to be used to fund rightist death squads in Nicaragua--something Congress had expressly forbidden him to do. Evidence strongly suggests that Iran-Contra was at least his second dirty deal with Islamic Iran, the first being the October Surprise, which delayed the release of the Iranian embassy hostages until after the 1980 election was over. Ronald Reagan eventually admitted to "trading arms for hostages," yet avoided prosecution for treason and the death penalty. Reagan, like Bush 43, technically served in the military yet studiously avoided combat. Both men were physically robust, intellectually inadequate, poorly traveled former governors renowned for stabbing friends on the back--Reagan when he named names during McCarthyism. Both appointed former generals as secretaries of state and enemies of the environment to head the Department of the Interior. Both refused to read detailed briefings, worked short hours, behaved erratically in public appearances, ducked questions about sordid pasts, and relied on Christianist (the radical right equivalent of Islamist) depictions of foes as "evil" and America, invariably as embodied by himself and the Republicans, as "good." Based on intelligence as phony as that floated to justify the war against Iraq, Reagan bombed Muslim Libya. COPYRIGHT 2004 TED RALL RALL 6/8/04
-
We can be decent human beings and give respect and be civil and even honor for the sake of good behavior and respect. But do not forget the full "legacy", and the actuality of one who visited war criminals graces. Central American atrocities , Reaganomics ( trickle-down phenomena) and so forth. To truly remember , I do not forget, and neither do the victims. May as much peace be upon his soul as he sowed in life. May he duly receive what he gave unto others. May his family receive the peace he reserved for the families of others, and may they have comfort as the comfort they made for others. -paz/peace
-
Yanar Mohammed , an active secular femnst in Iraq and the organization. Link http://www.equalityiniraq.com/
-
Armenian Quarter In Jerusalem
Vayri7X replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Question related to Armenian quarter, et al. Parev all! ( I am back again } ;-) ) I am "glad " to see that our vociferous debating has not died down yet. But I have a related question for all of you interested in the Armenian community in the Holy Lands of Palestine and isrel. Any suggestions as to what you , my fellow Armenians, would find valuable to be documented/studied/recorded in addition to our religious heritage in the Holy Lands of Palestine ? Would you suggest that I focus on oral histories? Photographic documentation? Taping the dialect and sayings to contribute to the maintenance our folklore and language? What would you all find interesting and meaningful to be documented ? I am very excited to visit the Armenian Quarter in Jerusalem next year. I hope to visit our community at St. James , visit Baron Der and also the holy sites; i.e, the ones in Beit Sahur, Beit Jala and Bethlehem and gods willing, Nazareth. Maybe even go to Deir Zor for memorial and Lebanon for pilgrimage. ( Funds and godwilling !) If all goes well , and I raise the money ( 7,000 - OUCH!!) , I plan to study for one year at Birzeit starting next February for the human rights/anthropology program & PAS . I will be studying Armenian with some community and faculty members and of course Arabic. Also, if possible, get some crash lessons in Hebrew ;-) -which I started at age 16, but couldn't finish. There is a REALLY interesting Jerusalem dialect of Armenian !!! I will post the link here. soon The professors and staff at BZE have been very helpful in locating Armenian communities holding out in Ramallah and the other adjacent towns and villages. We have some really neat people along the Via Dolorosa and we are famous for our tileworks in Jerusalem. I hope to use my anthropological and further training during my study to do some documentary work on our community there. Although my Armenian is nowadays atrocious ( thanks to yermag chrt and moving so much in the US with no continuous Armenian community to be in here in the South ) , I am hoping that I can contribute to our collective history and the maintenance of our heritage and history despite this,and especially re-learn Armenian ( I heard Western Armenian when I was partially raised by my grandfather, but they lost contact with relatives by having to move all over the US . The last time I heard it actively spoken in the family was by my Aunt Mryam Marian when I was 13 at a hantes Any productive suggestions would be helpful. And as far as what has been posted, well,,, as Amira Haas, Adam Shapiro , Ali Abunima, Hagop Hagopian , Ghassan Andoni and various peace groups of Jewish membership and mixed Palestinian and other membership , and others (in and out of the Holy Land have proved), many if not all pro-justice people ARE anti-occupation and not anti-Jewish or anti-Arab .So if you answer, please , please , please my dears - I beg you !!! - do not try to " jew-bait" or " arab-bait" me. I wanna be positive here. and BTw a late shnorhavour zadik ! -
IMO, peyote is best used with what is known as a " sitter"; someone who can be trusted and who is familiar with the effects and skilled at navigating extrememly intense mindscapes. Being raised in areas in N. america with high Native populations , I always saw it as no different than communion for Catholics. Intresting note: there is a substance called Ibogaine out of W. Africa that is one of the strongest hallucinogens known ( ayahuasca and DMT being similarly strong). In Europe and elsewhere, psychologists specializing in treating drug addiction and phobias have used Ibogaine to successfully treat the strongest of addictions - and phobias. Heroin and opium users have been treated with Ibogaine and psychotherapy- very, very successfully. it is commonly said that Ibogaine is like having 10 yersof therapy in around 2 hours. I think the word comes from a Dahomean word fro god =" Ibo"
-
Trying to find Eastern and Western teach yourself software and/or books w/ tape for my friends ( a slew of them *seriously * wanna learn this year -yay!) I hear the discover armenian- it's western, i think. I am now looking ofr EAstern . Any suggestions?
-
No problems w/ the governments turning to the past. Makes sense. And I agree w/ what you said about the French, Germans and so on. I am right now in the middle of writing about how nationalism in pre-WWI 'germany' helped create a "civic religion" . The historian Mosse - FAllen Soldiers: Reshaping the Memory of the World Wars argues the exact same thing about the roots being in Napoleonic France, as well as affecting Italian nationalism.
-
THOTH : :yes:Thanks for the close reading of what I wrote, and for understanding why I wrote it. Also for not assuming how I "read" in ra/ethn. terms in everyday society. I appreciate your attention to the issues at hand, which in addition to racism/natl'sm mostly were based on ; privilege, power, resistance, historical and cultural "appropriation", how power and social facts are constructed via our individual & collective identities and the globalization of certain ideologies. I hope that some of the things I quoted ( Fanon, Bourdieu, Scott) provide constructive contributions. Also , I hope that the process that I detailed on how one could come to identify with the ideologies at hand ( The Superman Fantasy) serve useful in your future dealings, or just to think on. I may have @#$ed up in that the terminology I used in my writing it was dense. But these terminologies carry histories of meaning ( in progressive and anti-racist communities and sciences) and each was carefully chosen to imply those meanings. Yeznig: I am grateful for your contributions. I think you definitely read my positions closely, and gleaned the implications as to what I was saying. I liked your Fanon reference and the beautiful words you dropped lifted my spirits during the frustrations ( and helped my other writings along as well). I find your position on identification interesting and valied. Yes, there are many armos about who have those solidarities in spirit and practice. I won't detail my doings, but needless to say I am active in a number of areas, so my expressions are not limited to discourse alone. Due to my mobility, I haven't been able as I had as a teenager to spend -uninterrupted- , realtime in hye communities where these values abound on the same footing as say the religious values here in southern communities. I'm not dissing religion at all, just giving it as an example of the normative value structures that abound in Armenian communities. Note: To maintain constructiveness past this post, I will soon post progressive links for others who wish to inform themselves further on issues of anti-racism, cultural issues, history, class and so forth. I'd also be interested to see our "take" on these subjects. I think that alot applies to in unique ways. For lost brevity, I will stop here.
-
For a good book on how history serves to forge or undo links of unity or solidarity, how "communities" are formed , and ideas of nationalism and its cultural roots I suggest: Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism by Benedit Anderson Anderson supplies some interesting theoretical backgrounds for discussion 'nations' and the like. I think how he qualifies 'imagined', ' limited' , ' sovereign' and 'community' form a good basis for discussing things such as historical processes of Armenian nationalisms.At the same time, I limit it to an informative theory where our Armenian case in particular deserves _and has_ our own demarcations of meaning. A section of five small paragraphs from it: "In an anthropological spirit, then, I propose the following definition of the nation: it is an imagined political community - - and imagined as both inherently limited and sovereign. "It is [I]imagined[/i] because the members of even the smallest nation will never know most of their fellow-members, meet them, or even hear of them, yet in the minds of each lives the image of their communion. Renan referred to this imagining in his suavely back-handed way when he wrote that 'Or l’essence d'une nation est que tons les individus aient beaucoup de choses en commun, et aussi que tous aient oublié bien des choses.” With a certain ferocity Gellner makes a comparable point when he rules that 'Nationalism is not the awakening of nations to self-consciousness: it invents nations where they do not exist.' The drawback to this formulation, however, is that Gellner is so anxious to show that nationalism masquerades under false pretences that he assimilates 'invention' to 'fabrication' and 'falsity', rather than to 'imagining' and 'creation'. In this way he implies that 'true' communities exist which can be advantageously juxtaposed to nations. In fact, all communities larger than primordial villages of face-to-face contact (and perhaps even these) are imagined. Communities are to be distinguished, not by their falsity/genuineness, but by the style in which they are imagined. Javanese villagers have always known that they are connected to people they have never seen, but these ties were once imagined particularistically-as indefinitely stretchable nets of kinship and clientship. Until quite recently, the Javanese language had no word meaning the abstraction 'society.' We may today think of the French aristocracy of the ancien régime as a class; but surely it was imagined this way only very late. To the question 'Who is the ‘Comte de X?’ the normal answer would have been, not 'a member of the aristocracy,' but 'the lord of X, 'the uncle of the Baronne de Y,'or 'a client of the Duc de Z.' "The nation is imagined as limited because even the largest of them encompassing perhaps a billion living human beings, has finite, if elastic boundaries, beyond which lie other nations. No nation imagines itself coterminous with mankind. The most messianic nationalists do not dream of a day when all the members of the human race will join their nation in the way that it was possible, in certain epochs, for, say, Christians to dream of a wholly Christian planet. "It is imagined as sovereign because the concept was born in an age in which Enlightenment and Revolution were destorying the legitamcy of the devinely-ordained, hierarchical dynastic realm. Coming to maturity at a stage of human history when even the most devout adherents of any universal religion were inescapably confronted with the living pluralism of such religions, and the allomorphism between each faith's ontological claims and territorial stretch, nations dream of being free, and, if under God, directly so. The gage and emblem of this freedom is the sovereign state. "Finally, it is imagined as a community, because, regardless of the actual inequality and exploitation that may prevail in each, the nation is always conceived as a deep, horizontal comradeship. Ultimately it is this fraternity that makes it possible, over the past two centuries, for so many millions of people, not so much to kill, as willingly to die for such limited imaginings. "These deaths bring us abruptly face to face with the central problem posed by nationalism: what makes the shrunken imaginings of recent history (scarcely more than two centuries) generate such colossal sacrifices? I believe that the beginnings of an answer lie in the cultural roots of nationalism." Anderson, Benedict. Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. Revised Edition ed. London and New York: Verso, 1991, pp. 5-7.
