-
Posts
1,900 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Armat
-
Ed Could you send me the book?If you are done reading? you see bro, first we have to free our selfs from the slave mentality and look at us as the masters of our lands, i don't expect Turkey to hand out historical Armenia in a silver plater but history has shown they all come and go, The land we already have people are busy leaving Armenia.Real population number of RA could be as little as 2million now.If we truly exercise healthy nationalism then we should be investing and helping Armenia prosper.There are reports mostly by Turks that up to 100k illigal Armenians are working in Turkey.That's reality that needs to be focused. I can argue that we have plenty of land but not enough people on them.How can we even think about what we lost when what we have at present is needing urgent attention. Anyway good to hear your thoughts.By the way what about the Jews and Hitler...
-
Title: General Andranik and the Armenian Revolutionary Movement Author: Antranig Chalabian Goes in great detail about that whole period and pathetic way we lost Kars basically without even firing a shot.Lot of Armenians refused to fight even though we had better equipment and we had more soldiers.We often brag about our military victories but at Kars we simply did not fight.Turks were better organized and were motivationed. Its a great book.True eye opener.
-
Dear Arpa I simply what to know the truth as close to the truth as possible.It's not the numbers but the context which interest me.We are brainwashed to think of the Turks as barbarians, savages etc and yet we did prosper better under Ottomans then under fellow christens Byzantines who were too eager to kill,tax and subdue our identity. To understand the Turks in some measure is to understand ourselves and our shortfalls.Like I said its just a private desire to know what really happened and I can stop posting on this topic here.Its no problem.
-
100-200k Armenians joining the Russians were a formidable reason considering Ottomans were at war on multiple fronts.Armenians were deserting and fighting against the Turks so in reality Ottomans reacted more "lets get rid of these Armenians before all start to join the Russians" Lets be honest we would have done exactly that.
-
Maybe you are right but Armenians joining the Russians as much as 200k soldiers or even 100k posed a greater threat.Combined Russian and Armenian forces were a serious threat if you were the Ottomans. I believe Armenian Genocide was directly relating to Russian/Armenian campaign and frankly I have difficulty pan Turanism being the reason as often sited by our historians. Thanks for taking your time bro
-
it was a repeat
-
When Lewis says Armenian conscripts deserted the Ottoman army and joined the fight against "their own" army, he is not lying, what he is doing is he is leaving out the part where the conscripts were disarmed and put into labour batallions then systematically killed in groups"managable" I believe Lewis as much as I hate to admit is telling the truth.Check the chronology of events.There were already rebel bands of Armenians including Andranik,Njdey,Sepuh,Dro operating against the Ottomans and lot of Turkish Armenians deserted to Russian and rebel forces.Killings of labor battalions happened sept 1915 and events or fighting already started.I read the Andranic bio and in this bio it covers in greater detail how involved the rebels were. When they say Armenian archives are closed i) they are parroting propaganda lines just like the Azeris keep parroting that 20% of Azeri territory has been occupied and 1million refugees created. ii) What Armenian archives do they want to study, Armenia was not even a political entity at that time to have kept "damning" archives, one would ask: what documents issued from whom to whom? The idea of sitting down and studying the archives is a red herring, what they want to do is professionally obfuscate and muddy-up the issues, with the blessing of the West (let's not forget that). They are looking for immediate blocking of the latest Armenain drive of parliamentary genocide resolutions in the world, they WILL succeed if Armenians take the bate. At this point this issue is not historical but political, and as such in the political arena Armenians will loose. If we got nothing to hide then it should be open if it isn't already.How can it be a lie if its closed.I suspect present dashnak government will not want to reveal its organizations past. I say: If the international community, along with Turkey to some degree, regard the crimes committed against the Armenians were perpetrated by the pre-republic and now-defunked Ottoman Empire, and that no living war-criminals is alive today then why are the Turks afraid of even discussing this issue publically in Turkey, why does the mention of Ottoman criminal thugs of yesterday is concidered "an insult" for today's Turks? Great point and I raised this many times myself as well The mention of Nazi criminals does not insult the Germans today, so could it be that the Ittihadist criminals are regarded with reverence today in Turkey, and that the hatred agaisnt the Armenian "infidel" has never left theTurkish psyche? Unfortunately, if we look at the declarations of the head of the Turksih Historical Society, Yusuf Halacoglu, the answer could only be a very firm Yes! Do you mean what he said about the Armenian converting to Kurds?or simple denying of AG Thanks for the answrs Zareh
-
Guys Is there a way to verify that our archives for what its worth open? If Yes then why do the Turks keep saying our archives are closed. Armenian revolutionary movement started way before 1915 if I am correct around 1878-90's. The fact is events did take place to swing the Turkish overall opinions of Armenians to severe distrust and more easily to dispose and kill.Its not a justification but AG did not materialize from out of blue. We lived together for 600 years without much problems even prospered and all of sudden "few" rebel forces caused the AG?Something does not make sense. I am being totally objective. Dadrian says Hamidian massacres were result of dble taxation.Is this totally true?This does not make sense.
-
I've been battling deniers for almost a year and frequently asked question why Armenia refused historical discussions.At 1st I said that since we know what happened its pointless to seat down and discuss with bunch of fanatic nationalistic turks about our history.However I never totally felt comfortable with that for several reasons. 1.If we know that AG is a undisputed fact then why should be afraid to discuss the issue with anyone 2.Better case to be made if could prove directly to Turks themselves 3.Finally putting the end to this issue 4.Why aren't our archives open? 5.If we killed and massacred the Turks then lets do find out how many exactly.I heard numbers from 40k to 500kIn the absence of real data how does one discredit this information. 6.1st prime minister HK admitted massacring Turks and its a fact we did rebel.No point denying this but what really happened during this rebel times. 7.It seems there are grey areas that we Armenians are at fault for prolonging the denial.If we call the spade ,A spade then lets open everything and challenge anyone!!including Bernard Lewis types. Anyone care to answer?
-
I did something at work which I should of had done and I came home saying to myself "please God let me not get fired" h@? Now that's coming from an atheist. Weird ,very weird.I came close to dying twice in accidents and both times I also prayed for my life.Pathetic! There is something wrong here.One can't be an athist and remember God in crises or maybe its normal?Like last resort,hope etc.YeahYeahYeah but I could of prayed in front of my bicycle but didn't. Sometimes we ourselves don't even know the answers.I simply don't know and can't explain my experiences of praying in crises.
-
I can't find much or anything on Victor Pitchman
-
Arpa We know what happened but in Turkey I assume (I can't be sure 100%) ignorance level is profound and with section 301 in place basically AG is a taboo so in the end result don't you think Hrant Dink's comment. Armenian's being Turks Doctor and Vise versa makes sense? The letter is honest as how Turks think about this issue and it is obvious Diaspora thinks otherwise.It is estimated 70-100K illigal Armenians working in Turkey in addition to Armenian Turks so we should be concern about their safety? What do we really want! Apology?Money?Land? all three? Not going to happen! Lets be real Armenia with 3.5 million people verses Turkey 80 million with the latest military hardware and 5th largest army in the world.What do you think we will get with out unrealistic demands. I say we better find alternative approach.We have no choice! Obviously whatever we have been doing last 92 years is not working...
-
An interesting post.At timers I also questioned the Diaspora tactics as well. Would like to hear your views guys
-
Mustafa AKYOL Dear all, A few days ago a new friend of mine who happens to be an American Armenian played some beautiful songs for me that come from the deepest roots of her ethnic tradition. While I enjoyed the numinous rhythms of that magnetic Armenian music, I realized how similar they were to the tunes of the Turkish classical music that I have grown up hearing. `Despite all the political warfare,' I said to myself, `alas, look how similar we are.' I actually have a similar feeling when I drive along the magnificent mosques and palaces of Istanbul, some of which were built by Armenian architects - men in fez who devoutly worshipped Christ and proudly served the Sultan. Well, we were the children of the same empire, weren't we? We actually lived side by side as good neighbors for centuries until the modern virus called `nationalism' descended upon us. And then hell broke loose. A war of two narratives: I know what you think about that hell, especially about its most horrific episode, the one that took place in the year 1915. Your grandmothers must have told you about the plunderers, killers and rapists who attacked them and countless fellow Armenians. You call the whole tragedy `the Armenian Genocide' and try to convince the parliaments of the world to accept that definition. You also think, I presume, that we Turks are monsters who not only committed that horrible crime, but also refuse to take responsibility for it even after nearly a century. This is how you see history and the present moment, right? Well, as a Turk, let me say that I understand you. Because I see that you sincerely believe in the accuracy of the historical narrative that you were raised on. How else could you have responded to that? However, please note that there is another narrative about the tragedy of 1915, and that is what we Turks have been raised on. Our grandmothers told us that Armenians of the time collaborated with the Russian invaders and started to kill our people. Then, the narrative goes, our people started to kill the Armenians in order to both to protect themselves and to take revenge. `They killed us and so we killed them' is the summary of what 99 percent of the Turks know and think about what you call genocide. And just like you do, they sincerely believe in the accuracy of their historical narrative. So there are two different accounts of what really happened in 1915. I know that in the Western academic world your narrative has gained much more support, but there are serious non-Turkish scholars who tend to agree with the Turkish version, too. When I read the works of professor Guenter Lewy recently, for example, I was convinced that what my grandmother told me was really true. Of course I am no expert on the issue. I don't have enough knowledge to decide whether the truth lies in your narrative, in our narrative, or somewhere in between. But I am open to learning more and reconsidering my position. `Follow the evidence,' one of my core principles reads, `wherever it may lead.' And, believe me, that there are so many people in Turkey who think the same way. Pushing the wrong way: Now since we are getting to know each other, let me be a bit more blunt and take on what you have just done by convincing the U.S. Congress to pass a resolution on `the Armenian Genocide.' If you think that acts like these will push us Turks to be more self-critical and initiate an internal discussion that will lead us to consider your narrative about 1915, you are daydreaming. The reality is quite the contrary. Foreign pressure will make Turkish society only more reactionary. Grounds for internal discussion will vanish. Moreover, our ultra-nationalist nuts will go crazier than ever. Their most militant ones might well target, once again, liberal intellectuals and our Armenian citizens. You are simply fuelling the fire. The leaders of Turkey's Armenian community, including Patriarch Mesrob Mutafyan II, have been warning you about these dangers and urging you to stop playing this resolution game. But sadly, you don't ever listen to them. You accuse them for lacking courage and having a defeatist psychology. But how do you know that you yourselves are not the victims of another psychology - that of the diaspora? Social scientists repeatedly say that diaspora communities tend to go fanatic. Have you ever considered taking a hint? If you would like to hear some friendly advice, here it is: If you really want to see more Turks reflecting on your narrative about the tragedy of 1915, initiate a genuine dialogue. Try to convince not Mrs. Pelosi and her colleagues, but us, the Turks. Write more books and articles, create better movies and Web sites, and organize fair conferences and seminars telling us about your story. And do these not as propaganda tools against the Turks, but as communication efforts toward them. Convey your message calmly, in other words, and it will be heard. But don't try to impose it onto us. We are not a nation of monsters, but we do have a stubborn side. When foreigners start to dictate our history to us, we tend to revert back to our grandmothers' stories. And if we will start listening to your narrative, that will not be because we are pushed into a corner by the politics of a powerful lobby, but because our hearts are touched by the memoirs of a terrible tragedy. Sincerely, Mustafa Akyol A fellow Anatolian
-
The coolest thing I've seen. 1st I keep seeing going clock-right side.Most creative people have right side developed and once I squeezed my eyes it went anti-clock and later going back to clock. Wow I can't wait to show my kids
-
He is like a "budding little plant" We can't stomp on it so early.Trust me if we do things right we can have even more dedicated Turks fighting other denialists. We can not approach this issue like we are fanatics.Little tact goes long way. Regards
-
You guys won't believe this but this Turk wrote this today.In the past he denied the AG but we kept hammering in and finally-well read on i have done a great deal of researh after reading of hrant dinks message, and i have come to a disturbing conclusion. my conclusion is that turkey may be in the wrong in this whole genocide issue. its very hard to see things through a cultural bias; agknoleging people who could be your parents or relatives were wrong in the past, and still are. but after trying very hard and looking at 3rd person sources, i have come to the conclusion despite being turkish, that the armenian genocide did indeed happen. i am not saying the armenians as a whole were innocent; im certain many turks were killed by armenian radicals siding with the enemy, but the killing of a whole population of civilians to control this is inherently wrong. ive also seen evidence that turkey is indeed surpressing kurdish culture and that of those armenians who still live in turkey. as people, there is nothing better than to be free of bias and free of immature notions of superiority. i therefore urge all the other turks on this forum to examine things from the ARMENIAN standpoint, and not to dismiss everything as propaganda- for the third party eye witness account must hold at least a grain of this terrifying truth. a person who supports a nation doing wrongs and doesnt educate himself about it is guilty. turkeys government is not perfect, never was. examine things through foriegn eyes please, and make an honest judgement like i have tried to do. for this is an extremely important issue, because of its moral implications. imagine if we turks are wrong, and the armenian civilians really were massacred by a failing tyranical government. we should seek the truth for ourselfs, and not blindly follow state propaganda wow
-
Numbers do make a difference!! Turks claim Armenians killed them too.According to Havaness K 1st prime minister and bio I read on Andranik we did kill civilians too but lot smaller scale.It could be estimated around 40k so 40k-1.5 million both genocides? Obviously not but Serbs killing 6 k muslims was branded as genocide as well. Don't misunderstand me I know what genocide is but numbers do matter.
-
Barev Vava Jan I can't answer your question honestly.Turks multiply like rats 1920 10 million now almost 80 million but Armenians generally have less kids but still 2.5 million should be enough to reach 8 million now. regards
-
Great Job on that C. Funny how quickly he folded up. Personally I love Turkey to Attack the Kurdistan.Bigger the better.Finally US can shake off the parasite draining our treasury.That money should go to Armenia!! Arpa Thanks for your response!! I bet you are watch Turkey-Kurd invasion closely.I hope they attack!!
-
Thanks Arpa You are right I wasted valuable time with these fanatics but at times I love basting their balls.In some way it has forced me to look at things differently. I read once you said that "who fking needs their approval (AG) anyway" I liked that.It frees US from being a victim to being independent from that past. Thanks for replying
-
Love those links I hate this MFER.Total Parasite
-
I am battling this idiot who could be Turkish agent steering hate disguised as "canadian" Turkish Topix
-
So in 1920 after all the killings 2.5 million? and Estimate 9 million now.almost 4 times increase.I am not sure about this.I think at 1920 we must of been at least 3.5 million to reach 9 by now.Remember we lost Estimated 250k at world war 2 I need more concrete references. Thanks though
-
Thanks for your reply.It helps somewhat but not totally. Arpa Can you help me?
