Jump to content

Armat

Members
  • Posts

    1,900
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Armat

  1. Great Post! After reading Dadrian I came away somewhat not fully satisfied. His chapters on Hamidian massacres are totally inadequate to me.The key to AG must be studied from Hamidian perspective because it shows we had more then reasons enough not to trust the Turks and finally saw an opportunity for indipendance. Armenian "revolt" can be explained by the treatment of Armenians prior to 1915 which again Dadrain does not even try.I learned great deal about AG but still so many gaps remain.I still don't know to what extant Armenians rebelled.If you read McCarthy he paints massive rebellion and I read few personal accounts from Van where rebels were seriously arming the population.Armenian rebel bands may be 10-15 each around 2-3k was still a large force.Have you seen rebel photos?They certainly don't look passive victims.Now question is which truth is the truth. Massive revolt?(Turkish view) or inadequate passive non essentials one (Armenian view) I think it may be somewhat be in between. I truly feel we need a historian who can represent the era without exagirations.It just makes it easier for Turks to say "Your Armenian Historians are extremely biased) I'll give a good example. 1895 Oct 1,Istanbul massacre Dadrian says something like this.Armenians were demonstrating against their ill treatments and shots were fired and massacred begun. then I read several different versions Hnchaks demonstrating and wanting to cause riot and 1st shot was by an Armenian who killed a Turkish policeman hence why the Turks got crazy and started massacring the Armenian in the capital. I tend to believe the "Turkish version" but still does not justify the massacre.What I am trying to say is truth does not justify the Turks but puts weight and credibility of our claims.I am sure a Turk reading the same account from Dadrian won't even read anything else by him. Anyway I agree with your post.
  2. Hi baby!!I missed this forum as well.I still love Aram even more.Weird I find his music powerful by every year I get older.Sometimes it takes time to appreciate great music. Check this young girl playing Aram Khachaturian Sonatina 1959 one of my faves.She is unreal for her age. Have a great day
  3. Arpa great post. I will get into it more time allowing.I sense that by rejecting the fables and myths one possibly is closer to God?By saying I am athist it seems closer then people on TV trying to convert thousands by religious indoctrination. Universe is mysterious and it just could be that our brains are incapable to grasp its essence although I did practice Zen and I suspect the enlighten state comes closest for realization of God.Interesting in Zen practice one must renounce his ego as important.I felt this many times that our personality,likes,dislikes,thoughts are insignificant in front of these powerful force. I will get into your other comments later Not much sun today
  4. Sip I am not joking but this is far the best sharpest comment I read on God.Like it a lot. Here is what I suspect we feel. Universe and everything in it including humans are made with the same substanc but vibrate on different level and that substance say the building block of everything is in us as well so we do feel at weird interludes something profound but can't explain exactly. I think Heaven,Hell and all the religious fantasy are man made that is figment of our imagination.Universe is a brutal place and like you said we are nothing in comparison.
  5. Domino I am totally confused on Istanbul massacre of 1895 Oct 1 Official number dead 70 which I read it was a telegraph sent to England by British diplomat then I read Dadrian putting the figure 2000 and more? Something does not add up obviously.Its not even close.What do you think about this
  6. Domino and others check this out See the Video here Elegant Universe -- Can String Theory detect God?
  7. True.I never claimed to know God.I guess I am unfortunate category.I have to overcome a lot to believe myths like Adams/Eve,Floods (just about every culture has a disaster myth) Resurrection (idea copied from Egyptians and Egyptians copied from Assyrians and Sumarians) See?Too much for me to overcome.
  8. If I none believer is meant to go hell then be it at least I will kick the crap out of Kemals,Envers and Talats
  9. Do I think God Exist?NO I find it almost laughable the whole Adam/Eve story.When a earthquake happens,innocent get slaughter,kids getting cancer where is GOD?If God created people he/she/it did a horrible job.Too many defects.One can argue those defects were in place for a reason but I am not buying. God is a creation for our ultra ego and nothing else.
  10. Armat

    Armat - Gazar

    Crap I thought I was the only Armat Funny.Like it
  11. I read this 1st time and it is a very uniqe article,the ones you don't come across often.Thanks for posting
  12. Interesting article.Notice the bold part Long jail term for newspaper editor confirms Azerbaijan's poor ranking in world press freedom index Reporters Without Borders condemns the sentence of eight and a half years in prison and fine of 200,000 manats (230,000 dollars) imposed yesterday on newspaper editor Eynulla Fatullayev because of an article about Azerbaijan's support for US military operations in the region. He was found guilty of `terrorism threat' (article 214.1 of the criminal code), tax evasion (article 213.2.2) and inciting racial hatred (article 283.2.2). `Fatullayev's conviction is simply outrageous as there was absolutely no evidence for these charges,' the press freedom organisation said. `This prosecution and an earlier one were politically motivated and mark a dangerous development for press freedom in Azerbaijan. We call on President Aliev to display clemency and have him released. Our hopes are also pinned on the European Court of Human Rights. It should tell the Azerbaijani authorities that this travesty of justice fools no one.' Reporters Without Borders added: `The article for which Fatullayev was convicted was just a foreign policy analysis. The authorities used it to punish a journalist who, in their view, was overly critical. This verdict comes amid a steady increase in harassment of the independent press, which is why Azerbaijan was ranked 139th out of 169 countries in our latest world press freedom index.' Fatullayev, who edits two of the country's most important dailies, Realny Azerbaijan and Gundelik Azerbaijan, was tried by a serious crimes court in Baku headed by judge Mehdi Asadov, who ordered the seizure of the newspapers' 23 computers as well as imposing the jail term and fine. The trial, which began on 10 October, focused on an article headlined `The Alievs prepare for war,' which appeared in the Russian-language Realny Azerbaijan in May. Fatullayev argued in this article that Azerbaijan would be exposed to reprisals if the United States attacked Iran and he cited possible Azerbaijani targets. The charge of inciting racial hatred was based on the fact that he also warned that this policy could revive ethnic tension within Azerbaijan. After the verdict was read out, Fatullayev ironically thanked the court for its `overly mild' sentence. He also referred to Elmar Husseynov, the editor of the independent weekly Monitor, who was gunned down in March 2005. In an article in March of this year, Fatullayev accused the authorities of obstructing the investigation into his murder. He received death threats following the article. This is the second time Fatullayev has been tried and convicted this year. In April, he was found guilty of libelling the army in an article accusing the Azerbaijani armed forces of sharing responsibility with their Armenian counterparts for the deaths of hundreds of civilians during an attack by Armenian troops in 1992 on the village of Khojali in the disputed Nagorno-Karabakh region. His two newspapers, Realny Azerbaijan and Gundelik Azerbaijan, have been closed since May, when much of their material was confiscated on the grounds of a violation of fire prevention regulations. It was in May, after Reporters Without Borders added President Aliev to its list of press freedom predators, that the authorities announced that they would no longer cooperate with the organisation. Azerbaijan fell four places (to 139th position) in the 2007 world press freedom index. Seven journalists are currently in prison in Azerbaijan.
  13. I've been reading Journal of Armenian studies Vol. VIII,NO2 Fall 2006 on page 105 DR.Dillion who was an eye witness to Hamidian massacres.Interesting how a Kurd is saying killing Armenians was close to nothing as far as state punishment. So far I got this on Dillon Dillon, E. J. "The Condition of Armenia." Contemporary Review but can't find the actual one Domino?Arpa?
  14. Anahid Please read about the Dashnak organization before forming opinions which you clearly sound ignorant.Read the Andranik bio please. If my memory serves me right they even tried to invite Turkish army to fight against the bolsheviks.Its a pity that I believe (its my believe) that Dashnaks were responsible of losing western Armenia.
  15. To be honest I am little disappointed that Turks didn't invade Iraq.They just showed muscle but no action.I WANT THEM TO ATTACK THE KURDS!!!
  16. Let me express my 2c If Isreal denys the AG because she needs Turkey bla,bla then what Armenians did was little ego massage for the only country which we have direct open border without problems!! Besides the honorary degree could of been for other subjects such as math that he is good at.Its about time that we play ball as well.
  17. AK-47 I watched that before.I mean serious scholarly rebuttal.
  18. I am little disappointed that this loud mouth McCarthy (all over UTUBE) has not been seriously challenged.That's my point.If he is saying garbage which I think he is then why have Armenians not seriously challenged his views.
  19. Domino The Talat telegram.Wasn't the one Turks say it was a forgery by Adonian?
  20. Domino,Arpa,Vava and others We know that B.Lewis and Macarthur are two pillars of Turkish denials however has anyone serously challenged their views? Has Dadrian.Hovanisian,Papazian ever wrote a rebuttal papers? If not then why not.
  21. Domino your box is full so I am posting it here.I would love those materials to have and thanks for great posts. armat@verizon.net
  22. Domino Great post.To be honest I never considered the nationalization of economy at all to be a factor.This is comes totally new to me. I am tying from work and got 10 min. Armat, beside Musa Dagh, and Van, how many pseudo-successful so-called revolt could you find? Musa Dagh was not successful, had the ship not arrived they will have been killed. In Van the success was an Armenian myth, when the Russians arrived there, already a large number of Armenians were killed. Even Nogales admit it, and let me remind you that this psychopath (and anyone having read his work will have to conclude he is indeed a psychopath) who brought to the ground Armenian churchs, buildings to the ground one after the other admitted it. It is sad that the real reason we could not hang on to our homeland were our infighting,and 1917 Russian revolution.Our moral was pretty low.At Kars half the army desserted.Read the Andranik book.The amount of details are unreal.He takes you right there.You'll find out his frustrations with Dashnaks and along with host of other problems. What you are saying AG was planned prior to Van revolt and Russian winter Enver's defeat? Or the nationalism of Young Turks and their idology by default was on collision caurse with Armenians?Since like you said they were not assimilble?Interesting. Must go now.This is getting real interesting.
  23. Vava There were Georgian,Russian Armenian volunteers in Russian army and it was not a small number in addition to Andranik,Dro,Njdeh,Sepu etc. groups which were not small at all.
  24. Guys Let me clarify (Zareh understood me well) AG no matter how you cut it its a fact! Within this AG I like to know how much what Turks say such as Justin Macarthy, B.Lewis is true. Now let me bring you an example Turks say we killed 500k muslims as well. Now that sounds absurd right?Sure it does however do we have a solid evidence saying no that's a lie we only managed to kill 40k? See?Dashnak archives are not accessible as far as I know so in this vacuum Turks can come up with any number they like in fact we have not been successful against this allegation. Another fact Armenian rebels were very active prior of AG and Armenian soldiers in Ottoman army being killed later was directly relates to "perceived disloyalty"Understand this if you got Rebel bands roaming the country,supplying arms,aiding the Russian army then same ethnic group serving in your army would you trust them? I may get lot of heat on this but Dashnaks did deliberately intentionally provoked massacres in order to get the allies to invade Turkey.Our own people sacrificed our people for political gains. I would like to see Dashnak archives fully opened.This organization needs to answer lot of questions which it has not. We should not be afraid of truth.
×
×
  • Create New...