Twilight Bark
Members-
Posts
1,010 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Twilight Bark
-
According to the respected Turkish researcher Bilge Umar, the name of the city of Zonguldak (situated on the western Black Sea coast of Turkey) comes from Armenian. I must say I find it incredible that a city so far from the traditionally Armenian-populated regions would have a name derived from Armenian. Now, can you figure out what Armenian word(s) Zonguldak may come from? Hint: It has vast deposits of coal under it. Also, it would probably help to have a good dictionary at hand
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: TB, I can ascertain from your latest posting that A/B has accomplished EXACTLY what he wishes. He has gathered a cult following and thus is continually sticking his finger in the eyes of his detractors. The effort expended due to this older, physically ill, writer living in relative poverty astounds me. Reminds me of the story of Jesus. Dear Khodja, Are your logic circuits on? Because I don't want to form a negative impression of you if you are feeling sleepy, dizzy or not-up-to-thinking-clearly today. Take care of yourself. Best, TB P.S. I would like to terminate this silly and sterile discussion if you don't mind. I wish my presence in this forum to be associated with positive, not negative, things. If I can cheer up a young college student like Harut with Sumerian liguistics or some such, that is a much worthier endeavor than discussing nonsense.
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: TB, When you speak of his unfairness to Armenians, my reaction is that you must be one of the "enforcers" because I too have found many of his observations to be true It is this kind of illogic that permeates the "original" (i.e. vintage a/b) part of his postings. Because I disagree with him I must either be some sort of an SS enforcer, or a foolish simpleton. Is it so hard to see the absurity of that? Again, it's not that a lot of what he writes are not true. Most of what he writes are painfully obvious to many educated (and even many not-so-well-educated) Armenians. The collossal problem with his writings is that he sneaks in completely unjustifiable nonsense into a fluff of platitudes pilfered from other "real" thinkers. The danger lies in the possibility of an unfortunate reader swallowing the whole package hook, line and sinkers because the writer is oh-so-well-known.
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: TB, You have self-appointed yourself as the watchdog over him both here and in the other Armenian web forums Of course I am "self-appointed". Would you prefer someone appointed by a government body or a "party central committee"? As for "here and other Armenian forums". Surely you jest. I did not post any analyses of his posts here. I just posted a series of rational analyses of his posts on Armenian Cafe for a while. That is the total sum of my "following him with a stick". If you have a specific problem with any particular analysis of his logical and moral inconsistencies, please elaborate. [ November 09, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ] [ November 09, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: TB, What is it about A/B that gets so under your skin? It is plural, not singular: Arrogance, hypocrisy, self-pity, self-hate, hate for others, hate for critics, bad style, monologue, spiritual shallowness, intellectual sterility. All of these would be easily ignored, were it not for the unfortunate fact that Mr. Baliozian is regarded as an "intellectual". I find that embarassing.
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: TB, I agree with the majority of what Ara states. The problem is not with the "majority" of what he says. In that case, I also agree with the "majority" of what he says. He fills his posts with impossible-to-disagree-with platitudes that everyone knows (or should know), and slips in appallingly inaccurate or unfair statements, often involving Armenians. He uses this cheap, propagandist tactic on purpose, presumably to extract some personal satisfaction. I find it perverted.
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: I think that A/B brings more light into the "Armenian Room" that anyone living today. He is like the light at the end of a dark tunnel. His detrators are like the demons one will encounter as they reach toward the light of heaven when one passes to the next world. Perhaps you are mistaking the flames of hell with the light at the end of the tunnel. Perhaps one is likely to overshoot and end up in hell instead of heaven, in his rush to get out of the misery you (and a/b) describe. Out of the frying pan, into the flame, so to speak. TB
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: MJ, During the first part of my life I was totally "cured" in the eyes of the Armenian community. I was a good boy who went to church every Sunday, went to Armenian school every Saturday, listened to my parents and teachers. I bought all the Armenian myths. I even finally married an Armenian girl from a prominent Republican family. I kept to myself the things that happened at the church. I did everything to please my parents and nothing to please myself. I was proud Armenian, even thinking that we were a "chosen people." I now know that I was "diseased." But I have been cured from this disease. How peculiar that you see me, the cured one, as diseased. Could it be that the majority of the Armenian community are the diseased ones? Dear Khodja, Your description of your earlier life resembles that of Mr. Baliozian. It is no coincidence that you can relate to what he expresses. The problem is that I do not believe such self-glorifying perspectives, or the constipated, goody-two-shoes behavior are as common among Armenians as a whole (all sections of the society, and all communities, in Armenia and the Diaspora) as you feel they are. Perhaps a scientifically conducted sociological research is in order. Can such a study be funded? This is not a rhetorical question.
-
quote:Originally posted by khodja: TB, MJ et.al., I find your fascination with Ara to be very revealing. If he is the buffoon you claim he is, why do you continually return to discussing him like an insect to a flame? Dear Khodja, With a modest perceptual resolution one may differentiate "fascination" and "irritation". I am irritated by Mr. Baliozian because he uses his stature (deserved or not) as some sort of an "intellectual" to mislead and confuse his readers. A rational analysis of his posts reveals that his agenda is largely personal, and has nothing to do with concern for others. I do not respond to every irritating person on every forum. However, since he does real damage because of his "name recognition", I sometimes feel compelled to publicly dissect his nonsense. TB P.S. Your likening him to a flame is silly. And your likening me to an insect is duly noted. [ November 08, 2001: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ]
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: Noooo.... He is just a shock therapist. Only somewhere on the way he has dropped the therapy, and all that is left is the shock. "Shock without therapy, it is!" Good description. Unfortunately even the shock is usually misguided. I would forgive a/b for not offering therapy if the "illnesses" that he diagnoses were nothing but syptoms of underlying problems, or not real problems at all. He sometimes comes close to spotting one of the true causes of problems, namely the lack of interest in reading and intellectual enrichment on the part of "ordinary" Armenians. However, even then one gets the feeling that he is lamenting about lack of readership ("Darn it! I can't make a living off of you stupid, ignorant simpletons" sums up his apparent sentiment on the matter), rather than about its wider implications. Combine this with a big dose of an already strange combination of self-pity and arrogance, and you get a miserably small signal-to-noise ratio from the old man. He is well-read, but simply lacks the necessary intellectual and spiritual depth. And I doubt very much that he is well-intentioned. Sad, TB
-
Abris Harut! At the end of our story, the guy indeed takes off to be never seen again. Some say he went to the Land of Aratta in the north and enjoyed his early retirement there.
-
Since Harut asked for more, I will add one last Sumerian "riddle". His boss asked the grown-up boy (who is now a courier) to deliver a bag full of "guskin" pieces. When the courier was not back on "adannu", the boss started worrying that the flunkie disappeared for good with his precious cargo. Can you find the Armenian words that sound like the quoted Sumerian words and have the same meanings?
-
quote:Originally posted by MosJan: Twilight BarkJan Sorry It's fine MosJan. A little "light conversation" never hurt anyone. Well, maybe except at a funeral.
-
Dear MJ, The moniker TB is fine. I had considered shortening it before, but it sounded like the short for tuberculosis, so I refrained from doing that. As for the Armenian Cafe, after a period of death, it came back to life with most of the old regulars gone. I did not post there before its re-birth (well, maybe one). It is not terribly active, other than news posts, silly jokes, and simple-minded chauvinistic blurbs. There are occasional pearls, though. Also, for a while I dissected Ara Baliozian's posts there, which are the same as the ones here. I also had a civilized discourse with a "visiting" Turk (who was capable of civil conversation but easily enraged by chauvinists to show his nationalistic colors). Anyway, I will not try to change your feelings about Mr. Baliozian. My feelings about him can be approximated as "pity". I hope you don't mind if I dissect some of his writings every now and then. TB
-
quote:Originally posted by MJ: ... Ara is trying to address (right or wrong) an issue of a national scale... Dear MJ, You know that I respect your opinions and analyses. However, I have to disagree on "Ara". After reading enough of his verbal diarrhea over the years it became ovious that he only writes and cares about his ego. He completely misdiagnoses the root causes of Armenian problems. And his proposed "solution" (between the lines) is that Armenians as a distinct culture must cease to exist (no distinct nation --> no problem; simple isn't it?). There are so many logical and moral holes in his arguments that someone who actually has to make a living cannot address even a significant fraction of them. I tried to do that for a while in "Armenian Cafe" but I cannot keep up with the prodigious "writer" (cannot put enough quotation marks). Mr. Baliozian simply does not have the intellectual or spiritual depth to tackle the issues that he pontificates on. Consciously or not, he veers into an endless lamentation about a lost career that he so evidently never deserved. It's all about himself. Twilight Bark
-
At the risk of interrupting a joyful conversation, I will continue with the original thread, which is nearing its end. "gir" is translated as a "courier" of some sort. I am not sure if it also means "porter" or not. In any case, it has to do with carrying things. It sounds very similar to the Armenian verb for carrying. A porter would be "perna-GIR". Again, there is an obvious indo-european connection (gir <--> carry). Those "indo-european" words that are found in Sumerian (and have counterparts in Armenian that sound close to the original) support the theory that the original indo-european speakers were a lot closer to the Sumerians than Europeans preferred to think, say in Anatolia. The corrolary to this is that Armenians, although undoubtedly intermingled with newcomers, did not have to go through a fictional migration from the Balkans to arrive at their homeland. But that is a different topic.
-
quote:Originally posted by Harut: in Armenian it should be "dpir", meaning "gir". from the word "dpir": dprots, dprutyun, etc. Excellent, Harut. "Dub" in Sumerian means "tablet". The Armenian words for schooling, as well as printing sound very similar to this word. I wonder if there are any other languages that share this. The word "tablet" or "table" (as in a big, flat object) probably also comes from the Sumerian "dub" via "indo-european". Certainly casts doubt on the whole "indo-european homeland in the Russian steppes" theory of European linguists. I don't mean to say that Sumerians were indo-european, but it seems that they must have intermingled with the early indo-european speakers; and they did not trek to the untamed, chilly steppes to do that. Unfortunately for the Sumerian boy, he flunked out of school, and became a "gir". Well, his line of job was not exactly cerebrally intense. Can you guess what this "career" could be?
-
anshu <--> esh The "n" in anshu is thought to be "soft", although nobody has heard a Sumerian speak. Same applies for "u" at the end (just like the "u" at the end of "ururu", or "Aramu" in the Assyrian archives referring to Aram.) It means donkey or ass. Yes, if you think "ass" sounds related to esh, you are right; it is an "indo-european" word. This is one example of an "important" indo-european word showing up in an unlikely place, much earlier than indo-europeans showed up in history. The significance for Armenians is that such words give more credibility to the theory that indo-european origins lie a lot more to the south than self-centered Europeans have thought. Anyway, having enjoyed his donkey rides, the boy now has reached the age when he has to go to "e-dub-a", where he will learn to write, and print "dub"s. The word "dub" is the one of interest, and produced (or contributed to) several loosely related words in Armenian. Again, when trying to link a language from 5000 years ago to the words used today one has to use some imagination (or trained ears, which come later). Now, can you find at least two Armenian words that come from "dub"?
-
And now the Sumerian boy grew up a bit more, and wants to ride an "anshu". This one may require a bit more imagination/creativity, but the connection is there. Let's see if anyone will guess this one.
-
quote:Originally posted by Harut: lobi??? You got it! "Lobi" (in Eastern Armenian) or "lupia" (in Western Armenian). For non-Armenophones, that means "bean".
-
Thanks for your kind words, MosJan. With that encouragement, I will continue adding little droplets along this thread. Now the baby grew a little, and it is time to start eating his veggies. The mother insists that he eat his "lub". Which vegetable could that be? Twilight Bark
-
"Oror" in Armenian can mean both the rocking of the baby and the lullaby that goes along with it. "Gat" in Armenian and "Ga" in Sumerian mean "milk".
-
Due to the underwhelming response, let me just give the answer. It is ururu <--> oror 5000 years ago, Sumerian mothers were using the same word for lullaby as Armenian mothers today. To my knowlegde, with the possible exception of Basque, there is no other language that has this word. After the "oror", the Sumerian mother would be woken up by the hungry cries of her baby and give "ga" to her baby. Sounds familiar? It just shows how ancient some of our cultural and ancestral roots are. Twilight Bark
-
quote:Originally posted by Harut: i think i got it. it's "oo-a, oo-a". am i right? Try again. How about moving beyond the first line?
-
It is silly to think that any useful insight will come from a master of misdiagnosis such as Mr. Baliozian. He is getting confused by just scratching the surface. The condition of the Armenian culture will be improved when we become better parents, especially the men. Our culture will improve when our mothers nurture their boys' souls as much as they nurture their daughters'. Our culture will improve when ordinary Armenians begin to read. How can an individual Armenian help? Not by pontificating nonsense, I can tell you that. One can start by becoming good, dedicated parents, and raising good kids who view Armenians as their extended family. One can do more by becoming an educator in an Armenian school, and by trying to propagate an enlightened, intelligent view of the world and ourselves to the next generation. Generating endless amounts of shallow, simple-minded, hateful garbage (mixed, to be fair, with impossible-to-disagree-with platitudes quoted out of context, to throw off the unsuspecting reader) as Mr. Baliozian has been doing, is unlikely to be helpful to anyone. Twilight Bark
