Jump to content

bellthecat

Banned
  • Posts

    1,641
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by bellthecat

  1. quote:Originally posted by raffiaharonian: As a Melkoniantsi and a scholarship reciepient of AGBU , I feel somehow 'insulted' from the tone of your posting against AGBU. I did not dine with anybody and nor did I kiss anybody's A. to get that. AGBU has assisted thousands of students and numerous schools and institutions , and is one of the first and most concerned Armenian Organizations to try to assist the RoA. Probably they were wrong in refusing the funding of your research, but the needs and expectations from AGBU are greater than the funds available. BTW, did you know that there was such a work by "Shiraz" , in the form of photographs ? I've seen it and is great! Of course it would have been great if you could manage to do your research and I wish we had the means to assist you. Good luck man! Regarding the AGBU, I am not going to go into the specifics, but all I can say is that your view of the organisation is coloured by your experience of it, and mine is coloured by my experience of it - yours seems to have been a good one, mine was not. There isn't really a justification for you to feel "personally" insulted by what I said (and I've heard much worse things said about the AGBU ) The only reason I approached the AGBU was because the "you-know-who" person suggested I did, after talking of the 500,000 (I think) dollars she had just given to a project to record the Armenian experience of the Stalinist terror - I hope they got something more out of it than that silly little "Enemy of the State" video. Steve
  2. bellthecat

    Three in one go

    quote:Originally posted by Gayane: Steve, it isn't "russian" armenia. It's just plain Armenia, dammit...lol It is "Russian Armenia" - the card is a 19th century Russian postcard, depicting an Armenian woman in traditional costume from that part of Armenia ruled by Russia - so to define this region as "Russian Armenia" is actually 100% correct. Steve
  3. quote:Originally posted by dragon: ''Sorry, we are not interested in your project''. ''Good idea, but we have no money for now''. ''Why you don't ask bolsahay badriark for help''? Other versions? ''Don't bother us again''! Looking back it feels like it probably was all of the above, depending on who I asked, and when I asked. I should of asked for 24,000 - 8000 for the project, 8000 for wineing and dining AGBU committee members, and 8000 for the obligatory commemorative thank-you plaque for "you-know-who". But I suppose I should not say too much - they might say YES one of these days! Steve
  4. I didn't mean just "skull and crossbones" I mean ANY depiction of a skull. In Europe it is very common as a symbolic representation of mortality - and it can mean a lot of more obscure things as well. Beyond the occasional depiction of Adam and Eve on gravestones (perhaps a reference to the tradition that death started after the "Fall" and expulsion from Paradise) there is nothing similar to it in Armenian art. Don't Armenians think of death?!! Steve
  5. quote:Originally posted by levonyeshilian: Yesterday night,when i slept,1 Dollar was 695.000 Turkish Lira. In the morning it was 1.100.000 Lira.I lost 40 percent of my money in one night by the economic crisis. .....I'll cry..... You only lost it if you had it in the first place! And if you had enough for it to really hurt, think of those that never had anything - and had to do their Turkish military service because they could not afford the 12,000 dollar "get out in a month" bill. (Is it 12,000 dollars?) Steve PS I remember in 1992 seeing the value of the pound going from 1.95 dollars to 1.40 dollars in less than a week. Since I was travelling abroad at the time, and only had pounds with me, it was serious.
  6. bellthecat

    Three in one go

    And here is another picture. From a postcard from Russian Armenia. null http://armenianarchitecture.homestead.com/files/postcard.jpg
  7. bellthecat

    Three in one go

    Hi, Kazza, whereabouts in Armenia are your grandparents from? Costumes will vary according to the region they lived in. I presume since you are now in England, they were from Turkey. Here's a pic of a group of Armenians from Harput http://armenianarchitecture.homestead.com/files/harputfamily.jpg It is from an old calendar produced by Project SAVE, who have an archive of old Armenian photographs. They had a website, but it seems to be gone, or has moved. There are some details of their current calendar athttp://server43.hypermart.net/assosiation1...000/ne-save.htm Steve PS Isn't the guy that the BBC dig up when they want someone to comment on events in Iran called Teymourian.
  8. quote:Originally posted by MJ: Steve, I didn't say that the "skull and Cross-bone" is an Armenian symbol. But rather, according to the legend, the cross-bones represent the legs of the Armenian lady subject to discussion, and the skull represents her "child." This is the underlying Armenian motif that I have referred to. Sorry, I thought that you were suggesting some sort of connection. But my point is rather interesting - why is there a complete (?) absence of the motif of the skull within Armenian Art? (I had a quick look at a number of books on medieval Armenian art, and did not find the motif once - yet it is very widespread in Europe). Steve
  9. Has anyone here read the original source of the following article? Were there any comments, etc, that accompanied it? Does anyone know the author? Personally, I think the whole story is a fake. Steve Glendale News-Press Monday, February 19, 2001 Letter - Steven D. Kamajian The truth is not for sale In August 1995, I traveled to the Gumri, Armenia to do volunteer medical work. While there, I asked local physicians about ancient churches in the vicinity and I was taken to see some that had been built in 900 A.D. When I marveled at these ancient architectural treasures, I was told that all the really old churches were in the city of Ani, which now is inside Turkey. A few days later, a Russian military officer was brought to me as a patient. The Russian military still has a large garrison in Gumri and the Russians were still staffing the border stations between Armenia and Turkey. As is the custom of that part of the world, after I had provided medical services to the Russian officer, he asked me what he could do for me. I told him I would like to go to Ani. I had my U.S. Passport. The Russian Officer told me that he could do this for me if I kept quiet about the excursion into Turkey as it was not legal for him and I could get him into trouble with both the Turkish and the Russian governments. Two days later, he picked me up at the clinic and we drove 1 1/2 hours to the Turkish-Armenian border. We parked his car inside of the third outermost ring of barbed wire and walked to a guard tower overlooking the Arax River. We faced Ani's ancient Cathedral. We then hiked down to the riverbed and took a small boat over the river to the base of the cliffs. We came to Turkey up under an old fort he identified as the Queens Prison. Turkish Shepherds greeted us -- apparently it was not unusual for a man wearing a Russian military uniform to walk up the hills into the village of Ani. The village of Ani is now mostly low mud huts. That is the best I could describe the primitive dusty town I walked through. Outside of the village, the Turks had planted grain and the fields that were beautiful and just ready for an August Harvest. Standing like a lone centennial in the margins of the city was the massive Cathedral of Ani. A beautiful rectangular cathedral. As I walked to it I was amazed at how simple, how beautiful and how intact the cathedral was. All the windows were still in perfect alignment and the roof was largely intact. As we walked to the cathedral, I was surprised to see that the base of the church was being excavated. I was greeted by a French archeologist. I wish I had kept his card. He introduced himself and his Turkish assistants and asked me what I was doing there with a Russian officer. I told him I was there to look at the Armenian Cathedral. He laughed and said he too was there for the cathedral as he was writing a paper of the Turkish Churches of Ani. I asked him to repeat what he had just said. "The Turkish Churches of Ani" he repeated. I stopped the conversation cold and said, "Look, this is a church, the Turkish people do not build churches." Then I went on to try to point out to him that he was wrong with a half dozen arguments. Look, I said, not only do the Turks not build churches, this church has Armenian writing on the walls, both inside and outside of the building. And this cathedral predated the Ottoman Turk invasion of Anatolia by almost 600 years. I then pointed out that the cemetery I had walked past still clearly had Armenian grave markers flat on the ground and that the city name of Ani is an Armenian name. I pointed out that all of the other geographic land marks around him and all the other ruins were carved with Armenian crosses, Armenian words and that he was just simply wrong, that this was not a Turkish church (a term that does not exist) but an Armenian cathedral and a historic monument. He laughed at me. "Look" he said, "the Turks are paying for me to be here. The Turks are paying for the excavation. As long as they are paying and as long as they tell me what to find, this is a Turkish church." I could not believe it. A man of science and archeologist willing to be so pathologically manipulated. The Russian officer and I departed a few minutes later and retired to the Armenian side of the border. Years have gone by. I am not an Archeologist, but I am sure somewhere in an Archeology Journal an article was published on the "Turkish Churches of Ani." Probably, that article was later referenced in another Turkish-sponsored archeology article and so the process of building a paper trail of lies begins. He who pays the piper calls the tunes. So it goes with the Turks and the Armenians. Picture what would have happened to U.S. History if Germany and or Japan had won World War II. Where would we find references to Pearl Harbor? Or to concentration death camps? The victor writes history. But, the Turks eliminated all of the Armenians in Eastern Anatolia. They achieved their goals. They won. Why then is there any historical mention of the genocide? The very number of international witnesses and the number of children who survived have prevented this piece of history from being buried under a pile of lies. This is why we all still know that the Genocide occurred. The Turks could not destroy the international record of these events. Truth is truth and facts are facts. There are thousands of documents in dozens of countries about the Armenian Cathedral of Ani written before 1200 A.D. You can lie about facts but you can not change the truth. Unfortunately, the Turkish government, and paid Turkish sponsored "historians" have built a paper trial of lies about the genocide of Armenians. Reading their stories reminds one of the simple-mindedness of those modern Nazi's who deny the Jewish Genocide of World War II. Articles cross-reference each other to try to establish the "new truth." It is simple to trace each article to the sponsored author. Yes, there was genocide of the Armenian People. Yes, Hitler did refer to it as an example of what he thought he could get away with. No, this genocide is not taught in Turkish schools, so I do not anticipate that an adult Turk would know about it. No, the Armenians did not participate in a genocide. Yes, the Ottoman Empire was falling apart and all of the subjugated people were trying to form new counties. Ask Arabs, Egyptians, Greeks, Assyrians, Kurds and Armenians. Turkey to this day has no neighbor country as friends. It was not just the Armenians trying to break free from an oppressive empire. Freedom was the motivation. Think of all the empires that have collapsed in our lifetime (Soviet Union, Japanese, Nazi, etc); as Americans we recognize freedom's motivation. To those who suggest that there are just too many Armenians throughout the world in far and distant counties and that these Armenians are influencing all of these distant governments, ask yourself why a people indigenous to central Anatolia for 4,000 years would move? Yes, the answer is simple: Genocide. That is why. Let us do this exercise one more time. You are different from me. I do not like the difference. I am uncomfortable with the differences, and I want you to change. You will not. You enjoy the difference. I start to think of you as less than me. At some point I think of you as less than human. Then it is OK for me to exterminate you. That is how genocide takes place. For all of those in this community that are angry with their neighbors, who are different, open your hearts and your minds as you are on a slippery slope. Truth is Truth. Paid archeologist, paid historians and paid politicians can lie as much as they choose. But they can not change the truth. The churches in Ani are Armenian. There was genocide of Armenians by the Turkish Ottoman Government. Steven D. Kamajian. Montrose
  10. quote:Originally posted by surorus: Levon, It seems to me that prostitution is wide spread in Turkey. How do regular Turkish population react to it? Is it something casual to them? Or are they disgusted? Where is a demand there is a supply, how do Turkish mothers, wifes, and daughters react to prostitution? From what I have seen (I stress the word seen!) - small scale prostitution is not that widespread in all parts of Turkey. Apart from Istanbul, it is mostly confined to those areas that are close to the border, as the women are in Turkey on short-term visas that only last a couple of weeks. They are there because they can enter Turkey easily, Turkey is a rich and economically developed country, travel is easy, and Turkish currency is easily exchanged for dollars. Turkey could stop them entering the country - there must be political reasons why they want the borders completely open. Since most of the prostitutes are not Turkish it is easy for Turkish society to ignore it. In the early 90s there was also a sort of sadistic streak to Turkey's attitude, a sort of "how nice it is that the once mighty and long feared Russian 'empire' is now so low that they are reduced to sending us their women". Traditionally in Turkey, wives are for bearing children and doing household work - there is not a lot of romance or even sex to be expected in that sort of relationship. So husbands can easily contemplate visiting prostitutes without thinking they are destroying "family life". Those attitudes are probably changing in the bigger cities, but not by much I bet (perhaps that's why young Turkish women always look rather sad). Steve null
  11. bellthecat

    Axtamar

    quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Well what makes you say that? Sorry, Kazza, I must have been feeling a bit grumpy when I posted what I said! The poem is "true" to the extent that it represents what Armenians in the 19th century thought was the origin of the name - and the same story is still told by local Turks and Kurds today. But as a proper explanation of the origin of the name, it is a romantic fantasy - and is identical to stories from other parts of the world (in the same way as the tallest tower in every inaccessible castle is always said to have been the home of a beautiful virgin princess). It is also not realistic in that it would be physically almost impossible to swim to the island. Steve
  12. Berj, I think it is OK to object to WHAT someone says (or does not say) in a posting, but I don't think it is appropriate to dissect the writing style of someone (especially if they are not native English speakers). This is not a place to post a doctoral thesis - so it is a bit pointless to criticise the construction of a posting as if it were one! Actually I found your words rather disturbing - as if you implied that it was now normal for academics (like politicians) to write their works with the active intention to deceive "amateur" people by slight of hand (or language). I hope it is NOT normal amongst academics. Bringing up the Phrygian issue is a little bit like nit-picking, considering that most Armenian books also state the same (false) thing about Armenian origin. As to the point about displaying alleged neutrality - nobody is neutral - I am not neutral to deceptions, and I hope I can always recognise them! Steve
  13. quote:Originally posted by MJ: It seems nobody is reacting to this material. But I am fascinated by it for a couple of days, now. Perhaps I am even more than fascinated by it. Just imagine that there is an Armenian dimension under the symbol of “Skull & Cross- Bones” - the Cross-Bones are fully Armenian, and the Skull is half-Armenian, and it has been most powerful symbol of invincibility from Templar Knights through Masons to pirates. I do not recall EVER seeing a scull and cross-bones motif in Armenian art, in any context, from any period. Prove me wrong! On the other hand, Western European art is full of such motifs, from as far back as the Celts before the Roman conquest. Steve
  14. I can check out an original copy of the book if you want (one of the advantages of living near to the city with Europe's biggest public reference library!). There is a more up to date book on the Paulicians / Tondrakians - it is "The Tondrakian Movement" by Vrej Nersessian, London, 1986. It contains a section on "The Key of Truth". Steve
  15. quote:Originally posted by Kazza: Turn it off! I think it will be totally unconstructive, it will just give memebers the opportunity to say Oh, that one got more than that one, etc. I dont think a froum is about rating members "better that each other" you cant rate the value of a member by little black stars! that's not what a forum is about, it's EQUAL contrubution as appreciation, team work! Don't worry, Kazza, you are five stars (gold ones!) Steve
  16. Well, to be serious - I THINK I might have have glanced at Piotrovsky's, "The Ancient Civilization of Urartu" a long while ago - I don't remember anything special about it. However almost nothing was properly known about Urartu until the 1960s, for that reason it is very unlikely that ANY book on Urartu that is more than 25 years old will have usable information. Steve
  17. quote:Originally posted by MJ: By in large, I find that the Armenian sites are very mediocre. In my view, so that these sites attract readers, they have to embrace all-human values, present mature and in-depth views, abandon the narrowly focused "fedayee" realm of mind, and present issues and interpretations beyond the traditional provincial mentality. Are you saying that they are mediocre because they have to "embrace all-human values" or because they have not? There are three things that make a good website: content, more content and even more content! The trouble with a lot of websites is that they do not consider themselves to be primary publishers - how many websites actually have ORIGINAL material - most have just very simplified versions of stuff available in books. And I agree about the lack of depth - even if the content IS original, it is often too simplified to be anything more that a introduction to the subject. Steve
  18. It starts off written in English, but quickly turns into something like Martian! Steve
×
×
  • Create New...