Jump to content

gamavor

Members
  • Posts

    5,027
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    176

Everything posted by gamavor

  1. That Terrible Day: The Byzantine defeat at Manzikert, AD 1071 The battle of Manzikert was such a shattering defeat that the Byzantines were never able to speak of it as other than "that terrible day". It was on that terrible day in 1071 that "Anatolia, heartland of Byzantium... was lost forever to Christendom" (Streater p 257). In one catastrophic day the eastern Roman Empire had lost its major recruiting region, its major grain producing region, and its vital trade route between Constantinople and the riches of the East. The Emperor Romanus IV Diogenes was crowned on January 1st, 1068. According to Norwich, he was an arrogant man with a strong sense of his own importance but he was also a brave soldier. Romanus understood the threat the Seljuks posed to his empire. At home in Constantinople, Romanus had to deal with Michael Psellus and the Ducas family who, according to Norwich, loathed him and his rise to power and were resolved to bring about his destruction. The strength of this ill-feeling towards him made it virtually impossible for Romanus to leave Constantinople on campaigns, because every time he left there was the possibility of one of his enemies attempting a coup. This, however, played to his advantage because he was able to devote his energies to improving the army, obtaining new equipment, implementing new training programs and recruiting new forces. The truce that had recently been made with the Turkish leader Alp Arslan was continually being broken by the marauding Turkomans and was generally considered by Romanus as a failure. Romanus was already planning a campaign for 1071, with an army of some seventy thousand men. According to Runciman, the army assembled by Romanus in 1071 was: no longer the magnificent force it had been fifty years before..... The cavalry regiments, sixty thousand strong, that had patrolled the Syrian frontier... were now disbanded. The imperial guards, hand-picked and highly trained Anatolians, were far below their old strength. The bulk of the army consisted now of foreign mercenaries, the Norsemen of the Varangian Guard, Normans and Franks from western Europe, Slavs from the north, and Turks from the steppes of southern Russia, Petcheneg, cuman and Ghuzz. Out of these elements Romanus collected a force of nearly a hundred thousand men, of which perhaps half were Byzantine born.... (Runciman p 62) This expedition crossed the Bosphorus in the second week of March 1071, and then headed eastward. The historian Michael Attaleiates was present; it is his version of events of that summer that remains the most detailed and trustworthy account of the Battle at Manzikert. Two-hundred miles into the journey, Romanus' demeanour is said to have changed dramatically. Attaleiates suggests that Romanus had been disturbed by various bad omens, among them being the sudden breakage of his tent pole, the unexplained fire in his tent that damaged most of his personal possessions and the loss of many of his best horses and mules. The Emperor's determination remained firm, realising that if he were to return to Constantinople without having engaged the Seljuks on the battle field, he would have little chance of maintaining his role as Emperor. According to Norwich, Romanus sent the greater part of the Roman army towards Lake Van, under the command of the experienced general Joseph Tarchaniotes, while he himself and his senior commander Nicephorus Byrennius continued with the remainder of the army towards the little fortress town of Manzikert. Tarchaniotes and his force met with misfortune of some sort, but it is not certain what happened. Later Moslem historians claimed that he had been overwhelmed in a great battle, but there is no contemporary evidence for this. Norwich believes that Tarchaniotes may have deliberately abandoned the emperor and was really a traitor, a tool of the Ducas family. On the other hand, Runciman tells us that Joseph Tarchaniotes was Turkish born, and commanded the largest contingent of mercenaries, the Turkish Cumans. He believes that 'the Cumans, remembering that they were Turks and in arrears with their pay, had gone over in a body on the previous night to join the enemy' Whatever happened to Tarchaniotes, Romanus was now left to fight the Turks with less than half his army. His corps d'elite, the Norman and Frankish heavy cavalry, decided to take no part in the battle. (Runciman p 63) There is no certainty about the actual date and location of the battle; the actual date varies from 5th August to 26th of August. Moslem historians are unanimous that it took place on a Friday in August; Michael Attaleiates says that it was a moonless night, and, according to Norwich, this means that it must have been the 26th. The most likely location is a fairly level steppe with rougher and hillier country close by, beyond which is a line of foothills cut through with ravines and gullies - ideal ambush territory - about a mile or two from the fortress of Manzikert. There are no contemporary eye-witness accounts of the events of that day, other than Michael Attaleiates. According to Jasper Streater "Arab historians for two centuries wrote of it in great detail, and sometimes in rhyme, and no two agreed on the size of the armies engaged." (Streater, p 258) Anna Comnena refers to the battle very briefly towards the end of her history when she is narrating her father's dealings with the Turkish sultan Saisan: (Alexius) made a speech, explaining his decision in full.'If you are willing' he said, 'to yield to the authority of Rome and to put an end to your raids on the Christians, you will enjoy favours and honour, living in freedom for the rest of your lives on lands set aside for you. I refer to the lands where you used to dwell before Romanus Diogenes became emperor and before he met the sultan in battle - an unfortunate and notorious clash which ended in the Roman's defeat and capture..' (Anna Comnena, 15,vi) Anna's husband, Nicephorus Byrennius, whose grandfather took part in the battle, also wrote an account of the action. According to this, fighting began on the day before the actual battle, when Romanus sent out a detachment of troops to drive off what he believed to be a small band of turkish marauders, then later a larger detachment led by Byrennius himself. Byrennius found himself 'confronted with what must have been a considerable proportion of the entire Seljuk army' (Norwich p 349) By nightfall, it must have been clear that the Byzantine army would have to fight when the day came. The expected battle did not take place on the next day. Instead, a Turkish delegation came with an offer of peace. Romanus dismissed the idea of a division of the Armenian territory proposed to him by the embassy. According to Streater, this was an inexplicable error on his part, a failure to exploit the growing rift between two branches of Islam, the Shi'ites and the Sunni. Alp Arslan had been intent on marching against the Fatimid dynasty in Egypt and only turned north reluctantly to deal with the Byzantine threat. Romanus could have exploited the Moslem quarrel to his own advantage. His refusal made the battle certain. It seems likely that Romanus now organised his men on the battle field in the style of the traditional army manuals, that is, a long line several ranks deep, with the cavalry on the ends. Romanus himself took the centre, with Bryennius on his left and a general named Alyattes on his right. The rearguard was composed of the private armies of the great landowners, under the command of Andronicus Ducas, the nephew of the late Emperor. Andronicus should never have been allowed to participate in the battle, let alone to lead the rearguard, as he made no secret of his contempt and loathing for Romanus. However, Romanus no doubt thought it better to have Andronicus under his watchful eye, rather than at home in Constantinople where he was likely to stir up more trouble, or so Romanus thought. The imperial army advanced across the steppe towards the Seljuks, who steadily withdrew into a crescent, allowing their archers to shower the Byzantine's flanks with arrows. The cavalry, probably angered by the Seljuks' archery, followed the Seljuk horsemen towards the foothills and fell straight into prepared ambushes. The Emperor remained on the battlefield, frustrated by the lack of enemy. Realising that there was nothing further to gain from pursuit, especially as the sun was setting and he had left his camp practically undefended, Romanus ordered the imperial standards to be reversed, the signal to withdraw. Alp Arslan had been waiting for this signal from his observation point in the hills above and ordered his men to attack. As Arslan's men poured down onto the steppe, the Romans broke in confusion. Many of the mercenary units retreated, assuming that the Emperor had been killed or captured, and this allowed the Seljuks to infiltrate the front line and separate it from the rearguard. Had the rearguard acted correctly by moving forward they would have prevented the Seljuks' escape. Instead, Andronicus spread the word that the emperor had been killed and the battle lost, and subsequently fled. This act caused more confusion among the remaining troops and more and more of them fled the battlefield. Only the Emperor remained with his personal guards around him. Romanus fought valiantly until the end: The emperor was completely isolated and deprived of reinforcement. Then he charged, his sword bare, killed more than one Turk and forced others to flee. But finally, surrounded by a mass of enemies, he was wounded in the hand. Recognized by the enemy, hemmed in on all sides, he was captured when an arrow wounded his horse, which slipped and lost its footing, felling its rider at the same time (Hallam p 42) Romanus was treated by Alp Arslan with the respect that his position entailed. For the next week, Romanus remained as a guest in the Turkish camp and ate at Alp Arslan's table. The peace terms were more than moderate and merciful. The Sultan only demanded the surrender of Manzikert, Antioch, Edessa and Hieropolis as well as one of Romanus' daughters as a wife for one of Arslan's sons. The ransom for Romanus was even reduced from ten million to half a million, with a further three-hundred and sixty thousand in annual tribute. Romanus was then allowed to return to Constantinople, because of the very real danger of a threat to his throne. Romanus had hoped to return to Constantinople as Emperor, but these feeling were not shared by the inhabitants of Constantinople. The news of the defeat had come as the second cracking blow in one year, as 1071 had also seen the fall of Byzantine Italy to the Normans led by Robert Guiscard. This is how the arrival of the news was described by Nicephorus Byrennius: A very few days passed before one of the fugitives arrived at Constantinople as bearer of evil tidings, and then there was another, then a third and a fourth, having nothing precise to announce except the catastrophe itself...... The matter was discussed in council by Empress Eudocia, Romanus' wife, who was asking what she had to do. Everyone agreed that it was necessary provisionally to abandon Romanus to his fate, whether he was prisoner or dead, and that the empress must secure the power for herself and her sons. Everyone was still in suspense when it was decided that the empress-mother and Michael Ducas, the eldest of her sons, should share the empire under the following conditions: Eudocia should have the honours due to the mother of the emperor, but she should share with her son the reality of supreme power... (Hallam p 42) Romanus was able to gather together what was left of his army with the intention of marching into Constantinople and reclaiming the throne from his step-son, Michael VII Ducas. There were two battles before Romanus reached Constantinople, both against John Ducas and in both Romanus was defeated. After the second battle he gave himself up to Andronicus, agreeing to renounce all claims to the throne and to retire to a monastery. In return he was given assurance that no harm would come to him on his return to Constantinople However, Andronicus put Romanus on a mule for the five-hundred mile journey back to Constantinople and allowed him to be attacked by onlookers, one of whom poked out his eyes. Romanus died in the summer of 1072. The Battle of Manzikert can be seen as the most disastrous battle in the history of Byzantine civilization. Romanus was a brave and gallant leader, but it was his naivety in trusting Andronicus with leadership of the rearguard and his lack of information of the enemy's movements which caused the East Roman army's worst defeat ever. http://www.dicksonc.act.edu.au/Showcase/Cl.../manzikert.html
  2. This is a bit tooo much....
  3. gamavor

    Galatians

    Fair enough, very good!
  4. A California lawyer who has waged an ongoing battle with Yahoo Inc. (YHOO.O) over personal attacks made against him on Yahoo message boards has filed a proposed class-action lawsuit against the company. A MESSAGE TO STEPHANGALTON.. by: kerrythescummyhippy 08/06/04 01:29 am Msg: 259 of 565 41 recommendations You swine. You vulgar little maggot. You worthless bag of filth. You are a canker. A sore that won't go away. You're a putrescent mass, a walking vomit. You are a spineless little worm deserving nothing but the profoundest contempt. You are a jerk, a cad, a weasel. Your life is a monument to stupidity. You are a stench, a revulsion, a big suck on a sour lemon. You are a bleating foal, a curdled staggering mutant dwarf smeared richly with the effluvia and offal accompanying your alleged birth into this world. An insensate, blinking calf, meaningful to nobody, abandoned by the puke-drooling, giggling beasts who sired you and then killed themselves in recognition of what they had done. I will never get over the embarrassment of belonging to the same species as you. You are a monster, an ogre, a malformity. I barf at the very thought of you. You have all the appeal of a paper cut. Lepers avoid you. You are vile, worthless, less than nothing. You are a weed, a fungus, the dregs of this earth. And did I mention you smell? Try to edit your responses of unnecessary material before attempting to impress us with your insight. The evidence that you are a nincompoop will still be available to readers, but they will be able to access it more rapidly. You snail-skulled little rabbit. Would that a hawk pick you up, drive its beak into your brain, and upon finding it rancid set you loose to fly briefly before spattering the ocean rocks with the frothy pink shame of your ignoble blood. May you choke on the queasy, convulsing nausea of your own trite, foolish beliefs. You are weary, stale, flat and unprofitable. You are grimy, squalid, nasty and profane. You are foul and disgusting. You're a fool, an ignoramus. Monkeys look down on you. Even sheep won't have sex with you. You are unreservedly pathetic, starved for attention, and lost in a land that reality forgot. And what meaning do you expect your delusionally self-important statements of unknowing, inexperienced opinion to have with us? What fantasy do you hold that you would believe that your tiny-fisted tantrums would have more weight than that of a leprous desert rat, spinning rabidly in a circle, waiting for the bite of the snake? You are a waste of flesh. You have no rhythm. You are ridiculous and obnoxious. You are the moral equivalent of a leech. You are a living emptiness, a meaningless void. You are sour and senile. You are a disease, you puerile, one-handed, slack-jawed, drooling, meat-slapper. On a good day you're a half-wit. You are deficient in all that lends character. You have the personality of wallpaper. You are dank and filthy. You are asinine and benighted. You are the source of all unpleasantness. You spread misery and sorrow wherever you go. PS: I have never read anything that colorful in English:) http://news.messages.yahoo.com/bbs?action=...7172369&mid=259
  5. gamavor

    Galatians

    I hope by Dashnaks you mean traitors, that were once the first one to kiss the turkish ass (members of Turkish parliament, strongly opposing Armenian Republic, Arabasized bastards whose first love is Lebanon and Syria).
  6. gamavor

    Job Predictions

    Thank you Azat! I was thinking lately about career change. Given that three things - Sports, Music and the hatred towards Lawyers, unify the whole World, playing for the Rangers seems as a good alternative.
  7. Then ask the moderators to move it to International, Arabistancho!
  8. Arabistancho-Semitcho, this section is Republic of Armenia!
  9. Eve, there are tons of stupid laws, some still in force in USA. There were times in Texas and Louisiana, during the "era" of the so-called Blue Laws. Those were the times when you cannot buy beer on Sundays. In order to do so, you need to by special coupons on Saturday and then you may buy alcohol on Sunday. Then there were laws against erotic items, laws against hawking, also walking close to the river bank with agricultural instruments in your hands. Some are still preserved by the way. Ah, Columbus, Columbus.... f*** your curiosity!
  10. Amerikanski, if you think that there is anyone who do not know your family history you are wrong. The whole Universe knows. Stop it for Christ sake. I'm sick and tired of reading idiotic posts, not that I'm obliged, but since the thread is "What is Armenian", if you are Armenian, I'm Eskimo! And Vigil, go get a boyfriend/girlfriend. If you can't just go and take cold shower! Off Be, askan abush joghovurt!
  11. gamavor

    Perfect Manhood

    I hadn't expected anything less from you: lol: Should I punish myself with hundred lashes or somebody will volunteer!
  12. Poor guy.... Only in Russia babe..
  13. gamavor

    Armenian Nobility

    Ironically in the Anglo-Saxon culture there was (and still at large) a rule, a dictum that says: The King is always right and innocent. Translated into Armenian it would read: The Nakharar (Feudal) is always right and innocent. I don't know if we invented anarchism, but for sure feudalism is our patent.
  14. Wow, that's a CV that even I cannot beat! I read about this guy and his business mind really made me feel GOOD! As far as I remember he was listed in Forbes' one of the best CEOs for 2002. Besides that he is in the first 10 chart of Russia's nuevo reach, I guess.
  15. Vigil, why you need anybody to help you? Are you handicaped or what?
  16. BS, to put it mildly! So, you are saying that because you are living in a degenerated society(I agree) you are also degenerated? If so, could you please post your nude picture here in HyeForum, lets say while making love with somebody, just to proof how degenerated you are. BS, again! If you only knew how little I care whether she is Armenian or not! Is anybody forcing you to watch TV? I quit long time ago, because the TV screen makes you feel small! I don't remember saying that all Armenians are bad. That would be prime example of dishonesty to myself, since I happened to be an Armenian by blood and I'm proud of my heritage. All I said is that I have hard time falling in love with all the Armenians, because most of them are not to my liking, not nesesseraly for reasons why others may dislike them. EDit: i fixed the quotes... i hope
  17. Agreed! Disagreed! If you are talking about Iran, well yes and no! It is also calculated politics. They don't help you because of your blue eyes (are you blue eyed ). They cooperate with you because they need you. Same way we need them. All true, however you conclusions are wrong! In politics, just like in life you should never ever rely on somebody else. You should do always what is best for your personal gain and your interests. If you don't, you will remain forever a loser. That is life.
  18. OK, do it but please keep the Joke!!!
  19. You should know by now that I hate too long posts as long as they are not articles. Blaming media, African-Americans or the social conditions for ones miserable low life is a Middle Eastern excuse, which I don't buy! Nor I'm going to date ugly Armenian girls, no matter how Armenian they are! First and foremost beauty in my book - inside and outside.
  20. Oh, Vigil are you telling me that Armenians were happy under f**** turkish or arab yoke?!
  21. Vigil, how many times you have been screwed up by foreigners and how many times by Armenians. How many times those "perfect" Armenians acted like total pigs be it in casual life situation or when it comes to making important decisions. One reason why I hate so much the Turks besides everything else, is that they made us racists. And why should a foreigner convert to being Armenian? Is there any benefit out of it? Morally or otherwise?
  22. Here is what Radio Yerevan has to say on the subject: Group of concerned HyeForumers call Radio Yerevan: - Please explain to us what is an Armenian? Radio Yerevan: -From nose to waist - pictures of the wild nature, from waist to toe - unbelievable but true!
×
×
  • Create New...