-
Posts
5,522 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Sasun
-
"If you want to make an apple pie from scratch, you must first create the universe." Carl Sagan
-
I know it all, where is the need for me to talk about things?
-
What an interesting topic
-
Onnig, same old same old, you just contradicted Jesus quoting from someone else. Again, Jesus said "whoever is not against us is for us". I am not only not against Jesus, but also a believer in Jesus. Now who are you to tell me the I don't believe in Jesus... you will never learn, I give up on you... Actually, I take it back. That quote has nothing to do with what I am saying, but you nevertheless would like to contradict Jesus.
-
If you take temporary heaven and hell inbetween lives, as well as punishment and rewards in lifetimes too then there is no contradiction. But what are the chances that a person has not committed any sins in his life (in other words he was perfect) and would at some point commit a sin. Usually it is the opposite, going from less perfect to more perfect.
-
There is no clear and uncontradictory indication that some of us will go to hell and stay there eternally. Now regarding the quotes you brougth. This quote comes from a passage where Jesus speaks against temptations, particularly people who will tempt innocent children, etc. The fire is eternal, yes, but will a human soul stay in the fire eternally? This quote does not answer that question. These quotes come from Mathew's "Final Judgement" passage. First of all, out of 4 gospels only Matthew has this passage, this makes one wonder if the final judgement is such an important concept that Jesus has taught then why it is not found in the other Gospels. There are also other gloomy, contradictory passages in Mathew that are not found in the other Gospels. Secondly, if you read the whole passage, something is not clear. It is said that the fire is prepared for the devil and angels, not human souls. Then it may follow that whoever is sent there is either the devil or the angels. The final judgement may be very well for the evils spirits, not human souls. The reference to sheep and goats maybe a reference to good and evil, not human souls. It is not clear. In general, there are many minor and not so minor contradictions in the Bible, including the Gospels. Therefore, one concludes that if there are 2 conflicting accounts one of them must be wrong, it is not possible that something is both white and black. The overwhelming message of Jesus is that we shall be forgiven, that if we ask something from our Heavenly Father He will give. If one believes in eternal punishment that means that a human soul which is nothing else than God's child will ask for salvation from eternal hell but God will not give. This is clearly a contradiction. Therefore, I personally do not accept the concept of final judgement where some souls will go to eternal punishment, and some souls will go to eternal life. I do not force my view upon anyone, but I will point out the contradiction. To believe in a cruel God one must reject some of the fundamental messages of Christ that show the inherent holiness of human souls. (e.g. Jesus says that Kingdom of Heaven is inside ourselves. This seems like a contradiction if we consider that the Kingdom of Heaven will spend eternity in hell. Even a limited time in hell seems like a contradiction, which makes one wonder what hell is. Another example would be Jesus addressing the crowd and calling them the "light of the world". Obviously, to send the light of the world to eternal hell is a contradiction) I believe all souls will in time go to eternal life. In the meantime, there will be many lives for each soul, and many times the soul will spend limited times in heaven and hell, depending on how one lives the preceding life. This is the case of soul reincarnation. Jesus has hinted of reincarnation. He may have said more about reincarnation that has not been recorded. If necessary I will post the appropriate quote. Onnig, I understand your stance, you are quoting some gloomy passages. You are right, those passages do exist. In questioning you I had neglected the Mathew contradictions that often Old Testament believers like to quote. However, the gloomy passages contradict to the majority of passages in the Gospels. When the minority of accounts contradict to the majority it is safer to follow the majority. As to John's Revelation, it is better not to even discuss, as it is not an account of what Jesus has said per se, it is a vision that is not so easy to interpret. My questions are concernting the Gospels anyway. And finally, there maybe many ways to understand and interpret Jesus. However, they should not be taken with hostility, which was the mistake the apostles did before Jesus taught them the right thing, which is "whoever is not against us is for us" Mark 9:41. This statement alone should eliminate all sectarian fights between various Christian paths and churches. Unfortunately that is not the case. If one believes in Jesus s/he cannot be considered wrong or somehow un-Christian. That's how I understand, and I strongly object anyone who will call me un-Christian or God-hater ... If you want I can bring all the necessary quotes to support my position, but I believe you should be familiar already.
-
For a vegetarian BBQ is unholy (unless it is a BBQ vegetables)
-
Oh my... you will certainly receive some punishment in hell for making this false accusation.
-
Onnig, for your information this thread does not belong to you. You can't tell people not to post. Everyone has the right to post as long as it is not offending and is not too much off topic. And not, disagreeing with your point of view is NOT off topic.
-
Onnig, stop the cheap accusations... you are only further discrediting yourself.
-
Onnig, don't try to avoid the qustion with an irrelevan quote. I remind you, you are claiming that hell is eternal, and I challenge you to prove that Jesus said so.
-
Onnig, stop making cheap accusations. You are the one who started making personal remarks. Who do you think you are to tell me I believe in a false Christ? And who are you to tell me I am a God hater? That speaks of your ignorance - when you feel that your understanding is challenged you make personal comments about your opponents faith. That is bigotry. Your theology fails to make sense, I regard it contradictory and shallow. I am not the one to take all kinds of claims about Christ lightly hence I will challenge everything that you say. But note that I didn't start calling you a satanist, that is what is childish. Look at you, trying to push for your theology and condemning your opponents to hell. You are fit for medieval inquisitor. Your theology contradicts to the spirit if Christ's teachings, you should yourself learn Christianity before you try to teach others.
-
As it is??? But you are an ignorant, you can't tell about things that you don't know.
-
Onnig, that is who you have believed, the false Christ I am getting tired of shallow bigots...
-
NO. You have not proved, you should prove that according to Jesus hell is eternal, otherwise you are an impostor trying to change the meaning of Jesus's teachings. I don't think you understand. That's exactly what I am saying, that Jesus is forgiving, that God is forgiving. While you are saying that God sends people to eternal hell. You maybe wishing it, but too bad for you, that's not true <_< . Don't you realize how controversial you sound? Huh... are you an all knowing authority to say that? That's a cheap accusation by you calling me satanic or whatever. Are you sure you are not satanic since you have taken the job to misinterpret Christ's teaching by your own likeing? My all-knowing bigoted friend, Jesus tells us to see Him in everyone and to love everyone. This is clearly written in the Gospels. That means we are all inherently good. Who the hell are you to condemn anyone to eternal hell?
-
Technically you are correct. However, to believe in resurrection is a small thing compared to the whole magnitude of Jesus Christ. There are far more important things than merely to believe in a miracle. As I said before, there have been many miracles performed by more less ordinary people. A miracle means very little, one cannot be called God only becuase he can do a miracle.
-
Onnig, please also prove that Jesus is for death penalty. I have at least one unquestionable instance where he forgave the prostitute while clearly the Jewish code was for stoning her to death.
-
Onnig, I didn't deny that hell exists. Please refrain from cheap accusations. What I deny is that Jesus taught that some souls will be sent to hell ETERNALLLY never to be forgiven. From where I stand from blasphemy is what you and others are doing, to frighten people with false ideas that God is cruel and will punish people to eternal suffering. Well, you are contradicting to Jesus!!! Now are you a Christian if you are contradicting Jesus?
-
So is that all one needs to do to be a Christian?
-
But did the apostles perfectly learn all that Jesus taught them? Can we take apostles words as absolute truth? What I want to know is if you think apostle's words are good enough to follow compared to Jesus's words. I don't think that apostles were nearly as perfect as Jesus, and that they had understood and taught Christ's messages correctly at all times. No doubt, they have done their best, to the best of their knowledge (with the exception of traitor Judas). Peter denied Jesus out of fear, surely it is not a sign of perfection, but he did repent after that and his service to the humanity is undeniable. Given the record that he made a mistake, it maybe that he also didn't teach the truth exactly the way Jesus had wished.
-
But your application got one thing right I guess...
