Armenia Amid a Sea of Uncertainty
© "Russia in Global Affairs". № 4, October - December 2004
http://eng.globalaffairs.ru/numbers/9/714.html
This survey has been prepared by Professor Grigor Akhinov of Moscow State University on the basis of scenario-building exercises completed under the Armenia 2020 project. The larger part of the research was done by Aslan Global (U.S.), the School of Cultural Politics headed by Pyotr Shchedrovitsky, and McKinsey & Company.
To assess the situation in the Republic of Armenia and the prospects for its development, research has been conducted on the following 13 topics: “Partnership between the state and the private sector to stimulate economic growth and improve the quality of life,” “Growth of productivity and the transition to an information society,” “The future of corruption and prospects of state management reforms,” “The diaspora and the future of Armenia,” “Prospects for regulating border problems,” “Scenarios for the educational system of Armenia,” “How to reverse emigration?,” “Sociological research: Already globalized nation or still broken world?,” “Small Armenia in the big world,” “Self-interested or public-spirited oligarchs?,” “Mono-nationality – the life of non-Armenians in Armenia,” “Religion and the church” and “Culture, economy and integrity.”
The following eight scenario-building exercises have been conducted: “Armenia joins the European Union: Coming back home,” “Armenia joins Russia: From Russia with love,” “Corporate-led development: Noah’s Park,” “Syrian development scenario: On the road to Damascus,” “Singaporean development scenario,” “Continued Balkanization,” “Eastern Express” and “Thirty years with a right to correspondence.”
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
At the start of the 21st century, the countries that once made up the Soviet Union have approached a momentous point in their history. The inertial development model which is characteristic of a majority of the former Soviet republics (now known as the Commonwealth of Independent States), and which continues to function thanks to the partially surviving ties and potential from former times, is almost exhausted. Now, the ex-Soviet republics must choose a program for their further development, which equally takes into account their foreign-policy orientation, as well as the creation of a social and economic model.
The world now tends to form interstate associations which are largely economic in nature (the European Union, the Common Economic Space of Russia, Ukraine, Belarus and Kazakhstan, the North American Free Trade Agreement, etc.). The newly independent states bordering on the mighty development centers, such as Russia, the EU or China, will have to set their priorities and decide for themselves what structures they would like to integrate into. They should also decide whether they are ready to sacrifice their independence in political and economic decision-making, in exchange for benefits from their participation in the more powerful supranational organizations, and whether the integration scenario is the only possible solution to their development tasks.
The Republic of Armenia must find the answers to these questions, as well. The land-locked country is surrounded by a hostile environment and does not possess an abundant supply of natural resources. Even though the economic growth rate in Armenia has stood at five to seven percent a year on average since the mid-1990s, its GDP, together with the population’s incomes, does not exceed 60-65 percent of the 1990 figures.
What does the future hold for Armenia? In order to determine the prospects for the country’s long-term development proceeding from its potentialities and the uncertainty factor, representatives from a broad range of groups launched the Armenia 2020 project. Participants included Armenian scholars, representatives of the Armenian communities in Belgium, Britain, Canada, France, Germany, Russia, the United States and other countries, as well as several organizations (see the full list on p. 144) The survey was conducted by means of a scenario-building exercise.
About 80 percent of ethnic Armenians polled in the country and around the world said that Armenia must focus on the development of a knowledge-based economy and the creation of new jobs. Seventy-five to eighty percent stated that the Armenian government must be the main factor in improving the population’s wellbeing, and that it must pursue an active policy for attracting foreign investment in the country. An analysis of Armenia’s social structure and requirements shows that a program for institutional reform – should it be proposed – would be supported by 70 percent of the Armenians.
In preparing various possible scenarios, the members of the project assumed that Armenia’s population will remain unchanged at 3-3.5 million people with a total area of about 30,000 square kilometers. A majority of the experts agreed that by 2005-2006 the current model of Armenia’s inertial development will be exhausted, so they worked out scenarios for the subsequent period ending in 2020. They did not consider obviously negative variants leading to economic collapse, a decline in the population’s incomes, reductions in the number of the population and the loss of territory.
FOUR SCENARIOS FOR 2008-2020
1. Integration into the European Union
This scenario can be described as the ’Ireland model.’ (Ireland, which joined the European Economic Community in 1973, availed itself of the advantages offered by the common European market and turned from a relatively backward country into one of the fastest-developing economies in the Old World.) This scenario provides that at some time before 2020, Yerevan, together with Baku and Tbilisi, may meet the criteria for joining the European Union (depending upon its economic situation, level of democracy and a rule-of-law state) and become full-fledged EU members. (Due to political reasons, one of these three Transcaucasian states joining the EU without the other two seems unlikely.) Obviously, Armenia’s accession to this larger and more developed economic space would bring about the country’s stable growth. In order to meet the integration requirements, Armenia would have to liberalize its economy, which would accelerate its development given its relatively cheap yet productive source of manpower. The adoption of European standards would strengthen democracy and civil society, as well as boost investment in science and education.
This seemingly optimum scenario, attractive to many of the post-Soviet states, runs up against a very large obstacle in the case of Armenia. The basic principle of European integration requires the member states to renounce part of their national sovereignty and delegate the decision-making powers to supranational bodies. As the European process deepens, the scale of powers delegated to pan-European bodies will only increase. If Armenia is prepared for such a move, in the next two to three years it will have to make a major decision concerning the loss of much of its independence. Meanwhile, according to a public opinion poll, about 80 percent of the respondents (both in Armenia and among ethnic Armenians abroad) said that a high degree of the nation-state’s sovereignty, that is, independence in making fundamental decisions, is an indispensable condition. The poll revealed that it is essential for Armenia to become an ’umbrella’ for an absolute majority of Armenians around the world, and a guarantor of their unity. In other words, the European choice, to which many of the post-Soviet states are now gravitating, is not an obvious choice in Armenia’s case.
2. Stagnation in isolation
This scenario can be described as the ’Paraguay model’ (Paraguay is a small South American state, rather isolated and unstable and for a long time governed by military regimes which pursued inconsistent and contradictory policies.) In this model, the dominant role belongs to a centralized state and a strong army. In an underdeveloped rule-of-law state, much of the economy goes into the informal sector. The cheap manpower and dirigiste measures can ensure short-term growth. This, however, will be followed by stagnation due to regional isolation and the lack of investment needed for the reproduction of human and technological capital.
The ’Paraguay model’ can be implemented in two ways, depending on the form and degree of Armenia’s interaction with the rest of the world.
The closed version of Armenian development: Let us assume that Armenia finds itself outside the global economy; it is not integrated into the regional or world markets and has to build a closed national economy. If the world economy remains open, isolationist tendencies in Armenia will be checked by a negative reaction created by the Armenian diaspora, and by the need to preserve a geoeconomic balance. But if the world economy grows less open, Armenia will become an autarky, that is, a closed political and economic society with drastically cut imports.
Since Armenia is not rich in natural resources and has a poorly developed infrastructure, it will be unable to build an effective closed economy. It will undergo de-industrialization – due to the shortage of raw materials, above all energy resources, the low capacity of the domestic market and the lack of access to foreign markets. The only surviving industries will include power engineering, tourism, repair services, and a few others. Export-oriented enterprises will, most likely, continue to be sold to foreigners. These developments will reduce industrial Armenia to a small region which will comprise the Yerevan area and a narrow strip of land around Lake Sevan. The rest of the country, under such a scenario, would be forced to leave the international and even national market, as it will start using primitive forms of exchange.
Thus, over a period of 10 to 15 years, on a large part of Armenian territory there will emerge a system of economic relations similar to those existing in small feudal mountainous states. At the same time, the country will experience a natural population growth, as well as the restoration of the more traditional ways of life. The birth rate will increase from the present 1.8 children per family to 2.2-2.5 children. The increase will be due in large part to Nagorno-Artsax, a de facto independent entity in neighboring Azerbaijan, which maintains close ties with Yerevan (the birth rate in Nagorno-Artsax averages more than three children per family).
It is at this time that we shall witness the peak of ’Armenianship outside Armenia.’ The country will become an exporter of certain kinds of manpower (healthy and strong men who have learned certain trades or soldiering) to the entire ’Land of the Five Seas’ (the territory between the Caspian, Black, Mediterranean and Red Seas, as well as the Persian Gulf). These people will not be simply emigrants but ’seasonal workers for an indefinite number of seasons.’
There will form a regular flow of human capital: people will go from the Armenian periphery to the central industrial regions (Yerevan, Lake Sevan). Once they are adapted to the contemporary world they will disperse throughout the region. However, this will be a closed flow: the bulk of those who leave Armenia will later return to the country. In the meantime, there will emerge several basically different ways of life in Armenia and in the Armenian community.
People living in and around Yerevan will lead a European way of life, but they may be subjected to the influence of clans arriving from the mountain regions of Armenia who are engaged in illegal business activity. The mountain regions of the country will engage in its traditional forms of business, gravitating toward illegal production. The level of industrial development in Nagorno-Artsax will be somewhat higher than in the mountain regions.
Apart from the old diaspora holding high positions in some large European countries, there will emerge a new Armenian diaspora, comprised of those people living in the mountainous areas who will leave Armenia to do unskilled work.
Although this scenario is not attractive, it is not catastrophic. Should things develop in Armenia the way we have described, the country will face a serious generation gap (the younger generation will seek integration into the open world, as opposed to the older generation gravitating toward the traditional way of life). This is not characteristic of Armenia and its culture and may result in the loss of its uniqueness. At the same time, Armenia will escape global political and economic cataclysms, typical of a phase transition, and the Armenian nation will be able to preserve its geocultural identity.
The open version of Armenian development. This model will be translated into life at the level of the Armenian diaspora. While there is economic stagnation inside Armenia, the diaspora becomes a form of the nation’s spatial development and, simultaneously, an instrument for geoeconomic interaction between the mother country (the Republic of Armenia) and the outside world. The Armenian elite are a small but united group of society, which is well-informed about modern models for organizing activity, cooperation, and information exchanges. Moreover, it is capable of rapidly mastering these forms.
According to this scenario, in the period until 2007 the diaspora will prepare a new agenda for the Republic of Armenia, entitled “Uniting the fragmented people,” which will be aimed at addressing mutual sociological problems and building mechanisms for political, economic and cultural cooperation between the mother country and the diaspora.
From 2008 to 2015, a united economic network will be built (above all, in trade), which will involve the mother country, posing as the originator of Armenian uniqueness, with the diaspora serving as the conduit of this uniqueness.
Actually, the real issue is the restoration of a structure of mutual relations similar to the one that existed in Soviet times. In the Soviet Union, the Armenians were part of the Soviet cultural, scientific and military elites. Now they are becoming part of the elite community in the world’s major countries which have a developed Armenian diaspora (Russia, France, the United States, and others). In this scenario, the mother country will exchange human capital for a ’development rent,’ posing as a seller of a certain humanitarian ’product’ built on the basis of Armenian uniqueness.
However, the leadership of the Republic of Armenia may adopt a policy of autarky, for one reason or another, at any time. If so, the closed version of its development will be implemented very soon (within two to three years) and this scenario will continue for a long period of time (not less than a decade).
3. Russia’s outpost
This scenario can be described as an ’Israel model.’ (Israel, surrounded by hostile countries, maintains its existence largely due to its military might, which by far exceeds the war potential of all its neighbors. It also owes much to the generous economic, political and military support of the United States which has an influential Jewish community. Actually, Israel is the main U.S. outpost in the Middle East.)
This scenario can be implemented if Russia consolidates and extends its political and economic influence in the post-Soviet space and becomes a guarantor of stability and security in various regional conflicts. The main prerequisite for this scenario must be the inability of the peoples in the Caucasus to receive stability and order from the outside, that is, from ’foes.’ But from the point of view of the Caucasian mentality, even Russia is a ’foe,’ not to mention the U.S., while Armenia is a ’friend’ and the outcome of the Artsax war has enhanced its authority. This is why it would be expedient for Russia to continue assigning the key role in the region to Yerevan.
This scenario would bring relative peace to the Caucasus, cause the U.S. to gradually withdraw its presence from the region, and give Armenia the unofficial status of ’Russia’s representative in the Caucasus’ which presupposes all forms of military and economic aid from Moscow. The Republic of Armenia will develop economically due to its highly skilled manpower, investment in education and scientific research, and extensive support from the diaspora and other countries. However, this growth will not be consistent because Armenia will be checked by the chronic hostility of its neighbors, a low level of regional integration, active emigration, and Armenia’s high transaction costs which affect the final price of its products; despite a cheap labor force, these are going to be restricting factors for growth. The bigger the role that Russia plays in guaranteeing regional security, the stronger military and political positions there will be for Armenia. At the same time, it will lessen the chances that the Armenian diaspora will have for participating in the development of the nation-state.
This scenario may have dramatic ’offshoots’ under the common name of a ’Transcaucasian war.’ This war may be provoked by an aggravation of the conflict in Georgia and its subsequent breakup, fresh confrontations over Nagorno-Artsax, or by clashes in Kurdistan. The war may last the life of a generation and become a post-industrial catastrophe for the entire region.
4. Regional leader
This scenario can be described as a ’Singapore model.’ (Singapore, a tiny state in Southeast Asia void of any resources, transformed into an economic ’tiger’ after it stepped up the development of an innovation economy.) This scenario presupposes Armenia’s rapid transition to an innovation model of development through the application of the latest technologies in all spheres of life. This model boosts economic development due to cheap manpower, large investments in education and infrastructure, and consistent liberalization of the economy. It also depends upon the leading role of a centralized state, extensive transit trade, and more attention to critical stages in production.
This model may also have two variations – closed and open, both presupposing a high degree of Armenia’s sovereignty.
The closed version. If globalization retains its tendency toward network development and if the regional status quo remains, the Republic of Armenia and the Armenian diaspora can pool their efforts and start the process of restructuring the national economy on the basis of high-tech industries. With growing employment, Armenia can achieve high economic growth rates and improve the wellbeing of an absolute majority of its population.
The open version provides for Armenia’s close interaction with large integration communities – the European Union or a Russia-led community. At the end of the first decade of the 21st century, Russia, the United States and representatives of the diaspora will pool efforts to start the implementation of regional projects which will provide an opportunity for the reconciliation of the conflicting parties in Transcaucasia. Thus, for the first time there will be the need for a transport ring between the participating countries, as well as for an integration structure. Russia’s purposeful actions for forming new Euro-Asiatic infrastructures, specifically to serve the North-South corridor (North Europe – Russia – Iran – Gulf countries – India), must play a major role in achieving viable agreements.
The aforementioned regional projects may include the creation of an interregional common market in Western Asia and Transcaucasia, comparable in capacity and turnover to the European market. On the face of it, the ethnic, religious, geographic and resource heterogeneity of the region, not to mention its tendency for military and political conflicts, rules out any hope for the success of a policy of integration. However, the history of Europe, for example, testifies to the contrary: just a few decades ago few people could have imagined that Germany and France, which tried their best to destroy each other in the two most brutal wars of the 20th century, would become close allies and the driving forces behind European integration.
Like the European Union, a West Asian community may start from a purely economic partnership that will not presuppose any political superstructure. With clearly expressed common interests (economic development), this economic union could include not just former enemies but even those states that are formally in a state of war. The desire to settle regional conflicts will be a driving force behind the integration. In turn, such a union of states would be a means for settling the conflicts.
The integration process in the Transcaucasia-Western Asia region can be boosted by the following factors:
an understanding by Russia’s political elite of the need for macroregional associations (viewed as mechanisms for implementing Russia’s economic strategy);
a close union between Russia and Armenia, which would guarantee stability in the region;
coming to power of a new generation of governing elites in the five countries of the region (Azerbaijan, Armenia, Georgia, Iran and Turkey);
a common interest of the business communities in the five countries in security issues (above all, energy security) and in the development of the tourist industry.
These efforts could result in the signing of a treaty on the establishment of a common economic space in Western Asia, which would comprise Azerbaijan, Armenia, Georgia, Iran and Turkey. These could be joined by Iraq, Lebanon, Syria, Jordan, Palestine, Israel and Pakistan. At a later date, the participating countries could conclude a treaty on a West Asian transport nexus, providing free travel for people and goods (but not capital and not all services). This nexus could be built around the political and economic structure of the ’Land of the Five Seas’ (Azerbaijan, Armenia, Georgia, Iran, the Asian part of Turkey, Iraq, Syria and Lebanon). This communication network would be the restoration of perhaps the oldest ring infrastructure in history, which has not functioned for several centuries due to constant tensions in the region. Today, a unique opportunity presents itself for reanimating this ancient transport system, together with the development of a regional market.
The West Asian nexus could be linked up with the global trade network via Beirut, Alexandria, Suez, and the Gulf ports. The emergence of a new ethnocultural platform in Central Asia would raise the issue of building a Caspian transport nexus which, crossing the West Asian ring, would cover South Russia, Azerbaijan, Armenia, Georgia, Iran, Afghanistan, Tajikistan, Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan. The Astrakhan-Aktau route would provide access to the global trade space. The successful creation of the two rings would pave the way for the creation of a new regional market, above all a market of energy resources.
The implementation of this scenario would help Armenia develop an innovation-based economy and become a regional economic headquarters. The transport ring can create prerequisites for building a new, common identity amongst the countries in the ’Land of the Five Seas,’ which in the long term will allow them to overcome all their ethnic, religious, cultural and historical differences.
What measures should be taken for the realization of this scenario? First, it will be necessary to establish a group of institutions (including a Development Council under the president of the Republic of Armenia, and a Russian Strategic Administration) and introduce a conceptual formula which acknowledges that “the infrastructure belongs to the region rather than the country.” Under the patronage of the great powers, a West Asian economic union will be set up, uniting Azerbaijan, Armenia, Georgia, Iraq, Iran and Turkey. At this time, the transport nexus and the regional market will be built. At this point, the agenda of contemporary Armenia, which has been “Looking for a niche for itself in the open world,” would be considered fulfilled.
The possible developments, described in the Armenia 2020 research, provide for an intricate scenario trajectory. In reality, events may develop at a slower pace and the aforementioned processes may require not 20 years, but possibly 25-30 years. However, this will not greatly alter the essence of the developments. The above four scenarios are not mutually exclusive alternatives. The larger part of the models described provide that Armenia will participate, in one way or another, in a global post-industrial project. At the same time, Armenia’s preservation of a fair degree of its sovereignty is the main condition for the realization of the country’s potential.