-
Posts
5,522 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Sasun
-
Again you are going into the fallacy of skepticism according to which a doubtful line of thinking becomes the only explanation, while you have no evidence of anything. In other words the only reason you are "explaning" something is that you doubt. You don't really have material evidence, you are simply using the apparent similarity of two different things, but similar does not mean the same. COULD BE and IS are different things. One has to investigate on a case by case bases before crying foul and making widespread accusations.
-
Had I known it would make you so enthusiastic I would have grown up faster Perhaps it is time to organize a new religion?
-
I have to agree with you. In fact, it was wise of you to foresee that I would grow up in the future
-
I would like to catch the person who voted with this answer and slap macaroni and cheese to his face.
-
You may have been under influences when posting this post
-
Siamanto, thank you for your truthful words. They say that ... oops, I forget what they say, something like big minds recognise other big minds OK, we are not big minds, just trying to be sane. I declare that I am not religious but I do appreciate all religions
-
Yes Mouse, I very much agree to your statement about "faith in reason". Strictly speaking there is no proof of anything at all. It is all based on observation and faith that our observations are veritable representations of reality, as well as faith that the way we reason and interpret the observations are truthful. Most people have never thought about this which is equivalent to dogmatizing accepted scientific methodologies as something absolute. That in itself is a self-imposed limitation.
-
Yeah, you were very inspiring It is another question, different from my question. Both are right. Well, everything is possible, and if you are saying that one of the possibilities is that "our knowledge is not enough to explain it" then I don't have a disagreement. But I had the impression that for you delusion or hoax are more preferable answers. That would be another extreme. However, when you see a fellow walking on water then you should certainly consider a miracle as at least a valid possibility. But you are not offering a rational explanation. Skepticism is not necessarily rational, and not even an explanation. I really don't see why skepticism is made such a big deal. Who cannot doubt? I have never met such a person who is unable to doubt. The article that you provided a link for does not mention a number of other people who have witnessed Therese Neumanns stigmata. That's kind of biased don't you think? Just pick a person's testimony who has doubts, but consider all those other folks who are sure of what they saw as delusional or faking, etc... very typical of skeptics I can see why you think that way, because you are not aware of many instances of miraculous events Actually what a skeptic would do is to check the for "vino" and other types of influences, and once nothing is found, conclude that the person is delusional. That's a sad level of investigation. Hmm... why would I revere just because someone had a divine contact? That would not be one of my choices. So my choices would be to either believe or disbelieve. But if it really happened I would be very curious to ask him/her how that happened, what exactly happened during that contact, etc... such things would shed more light on whether I would believe or not. So now it is your turn to answer your questions I think it is pretty obvious...
-
Well, if you define a miracle as something illogical then there really are no miracles, we agree on that.
-
Yes, of course, I kind of assume that miracle or not a miracle, if something happens it could not be illogical.
-
Well, when I put up the questions I was not thinking exactly as acts of God, but let's say with or without the idea that it maybe an act of God.
-
Something that has no explanation by sciences. You can take examples of wideley known types of miracles, for example a man walking on the water. So I guess it is number 1 from your definitions.
-
Thanks Nakharar. Do you mean the last post or the one before?
-
Let's see what the forumers think about this. Please note that one question can't exceed one line, so I had to keep it short. By "seeing" a miracle I definitely mean seeing in normal conditions healthwise as well as seeing without any unnatural influences such as drugs and alcohol. I also mean not just seeing but using other senses. Also you are convinced that it is not an illusion. For instance, water turns into wine in front of your eyes, you can smell and taste it, as well as check in the lab to make sure that it was definitely water and it is definitely wine now. You get the idea...
-
Don't fight, I will take the juice
-
I agree, but I would put it a little differently. Reason is not as bad as superstition, its just that it has objective limits. A reasonable man should understand the limits of materialism and materialistic reasoning.
-
Earlier I posted a link to a case of virgin birth. You can't dismiss it as a hoax or dilusion. These are rare cases of immaculate conception. If I didn't know about it (and I only learned about them recently) I would have a hard time to explain that science does not make it impossible to give immaculate births. Sciense only explains how sex causes a birth, but it doesn't say that all births are caused by sex. Virgin birth is a clear case of abnormality, do you agree? Even now that I have posted the link, nobody seems to come to agreement with the fact that immaculate birth is indeed possible. It is factual, though sciense does not have any explanation. This is a case of limitations of science when facts are not explained. Does that mean that any such claim is true? Of course not, there are many false claims in general. Hmm... why complicate the matter with theoretical concepts that are not precise and could be subject to non unique interpretations? Let's have an example. If you witnessed a miracle, let's say a stigmatism case, then would you try to investigate it, or consider it either a hoax, or a case of delusion, or a mistake, etc? I am not talking about theoretical cases. It seems to me you are inclined to think that nothing abnormal could happen. The priciple that you are mentioning simply does not leave any room for unexplained things to happen. And when faced with hard evidence then you will have to assume that you are delusional. Well, I am sorry, but this is not a scientific method of investigation. Had it been the case how can you tell if you see something you are delusional or not delusional. Only because that something is familiar does not bear any consequence of your state being delusional or normal. In my opinion a delusional state is has to do with specific health abnormalities, and that is something that can be (at least in theory) identified as yes or no. It cannot be dependant on "verisimilariity" of observations. This is plain objective reality. As for hoaxes, again you can't dismiss anything unexplainable as a hoax. That too is not a scientific approach. Of course, this does not mean one has to conclude immediately that anything that looks like a miracle is a miracle. As I said charlatanism is quite likely to happen in such matters. All things are possible, it could be a normal phenomenon, it could be an illusion, it could be a hoax, it could be a delusion. These things are all to be investigated before you can make a conclusion. And if you can't come to a conclusion then it is an open question. That is the scientific approach. Again, you are jumping to conclusions and accusing some very honest people of cheating. I am sure if you were honest you could not have a way to prove that all cases is stigmatism are indeed hoaxes. Yet you your conclusion is not based on facts, it is a conjecture, a hypothesis based on limited experiences and limited knowledge. Being almighty does not mean that one will alwasy use his might. This is a question of free will that we all have and the Almighty does not take it away by not allowing do bad things. Satan is a negative and intelligent power in the universe who/which has free will given by God. Definition of good is subjective, one thing is good for me but not for you, and vice versa. However, one way to define good would be whatever is divine in human is good As for potential divinity, I understand it as divinity not exercised/manifested, and divinity itself is God's qualities. The outer contradictory items can be safely cast away, but I don't see it as a vital necessity. If one really needs them then let them have it. Each person can cast away for himself/herself.
-
You can be classified in the class of unclassified convictions
-
Well, I don't think one is ready to die for false ideas. One can be truly believe in falsehood and die for that belief (as in 9/11), but if one believes that he/she is lieing he/she will not die for a lie. The reason I brought the example of Therese Newmann is that her case didn't occur in a distant past but relatively recently. And there are credible evidences, on of those being the evidence from an "enemy camp", a protestant priest who went there with the aim of exposing charlatanism but seeing that he was wrong instead wrote a testimony of what he saw ( I can provide the name if necessary). I checked your link but it is a typical statement of claims and skepticism. I just don't see what one can learn from there. Of course, there could be many charlatans making claims, and there could be genuine rebuttals of charlatanism. But there could be also genuine testimonies. I think that humans are potentially divine, so I can't be considered a disbeliever in humanity by default But in this case both Jesus and Joan spoke of divine contacts right (in different words though)? What is surprising you give credit for them as humans, but you don't give credit to their words. But why not mention patriotism? And also why not mention her devoteness?I Oh, you sound like Anoushik now... I have answered her but she didn't seem to be convinced. The chances are you won't be convinced either, but let me mention the name of Satan so you may get the idea Why are you assuming that? I am not a believer of some being special and others not. There really is no need to be cynical, you too are potentiall divine, or in other words you too have the "bulb" inside. But I don't think you are trying to make use of it. It maybe due to my poor linguistic skills but I by no mean wanted to suggest that I know something that does not apply to others or belongs to me exclusively
-
You are complicating a simple thing. The law of gravitation existed without our knowleldge and worked exactly the same way with or without our knowledge. Similarly, there are laws that science is not aware of, and those laws work equally well. Moreover, your own personal experiences cannot even compare to the aggregate of all scientific experiences, or experiements I should say. Therefore, many thing indeed exist that some others may have experienced but you have not experienced. You cannnot claim that just becuase you have not experienced something it does not exist. This should not mean that every imagined idea exists, like you are saying about a certain unknown latin word could exist. Please pay attention, I am not saying that everything taht could exist does exist. What I am saying is you cannot deny other poeple's experiences only because you have not experienced. I am just curious how you can make such a prediction. Some time back it would seem very unlikely, and perhaps a lunacy, to claim that matter can be converted into energy. One sure way is observation in normal circumstances. If you see a something miraculous no matter what your knowledge is then you are bound to believe. The bottom line is, one should not assume that his/her personal knowledge is sufficient to define all possible laws of the universe At the core of all religions are fundamental truths that are the same. Outer things can be very contradictory, and it means either some of them are wrong or all are wrong. But if you try to understand the essence of all religons they are the same. I don't mean theological concepts but the essence of teachings. Otherwise, even in one religion there are sects with contradictory doctrines. Of course, they are all wrong in the absolute sense. But surely they are right in some sense and similar. But if you take the fundamental principles Islam, Christianity, Hinduism they are all the same. For example, God is Spirit and is Omnipotent. I don't thing anyone from these religions will deny this. That's not what I meant. God is divine by definition. I am a believer of objective reality. Someone was either born on earth as a human being or not. So as far as I know, there was no person called Zeus, but a diety. A person and diety are not the same thing. However, a person may manifest a diety. Human's are potentially divine, they can all manifest the divine provided they really want to do it. Coming to Jesus and Krishna, they are meant to be human beings and God incarnates at the same time. That means they were manifesting God as human beings, in other words they were manifesting their own divinity, which we all humans share potentially but not actually. As for court testimonies, again a testimony could be true or false, there is not other way, or a mix of true and false where components are definitely either false or true. But when a false testimony is given in court there is certainly a reason for that. Whereas if one is to claim that testimonies about Jesus are false there are not really any solid explanations why a group of people would agree to fabricate a story, and die for that story. The trouble with skepticism is that it is indeed very easy to be skeptic but they won't bother to offer valid explanations. I agree that you have enough reason to be skeptical, and I don't have sufficient proof to prove beyond doubt that such individuals existed due to old history and lack of abundant and un-contradictory records. However, I do not think that it is most important to provide such proofs. What I consider most important is to test the validity of the teachings of these individuals as they exist in the (contested or uncontested) records. Then you will gradually understand intuitively that such things could not have been made up. I don't agree with your statement. Such miracles do not contradict, they simply cannot be explained by existing sciencese. This is a more objective and correct statement because we do know that our sciences are limited and expanding. Actually, I am saying scientific knowledge does not have a complete and precise understanding of all laws. It is limited and imperfect. There are many uncertainties that are not objective uncertainties, we simply don't know. That does not mean that we will never know. My stance is time invariant.
-
Just a point of clarification, the reason I mentioned that Jesus declared his divinity is because Sip was saying as if it was Jesus's followers who had falsely attributed divinity to him while he himself perhaps didn't say anything like that. But my understanding is, Jesus was both human and divine, in other words he was born as a human and lived among humans sharing more or less the same human experiences. At the same time, he was divine in consciousness, he had established a conscious union with God. I don't know if this makes sense to you, but let me not go into detail about what it means to establish union with God. What you are saying about possible motives of Jesus to declare a divine origin in order to promote his philosophy, I wont' say that it is an unreasonable speculation. If I didn't know anything about Jesus' teachings, but if I knew that someone is has good intentions, and is using a "small" bit of a lie for the good cause of humanity, I would consider it possibility that this person indeed has very good motives, and one lie would be attributed to his imperfections, but nonetheless he is a very good person. But let's see if Jesus would indeed do that. Here one needs internal verification, and there really is not much more than that. I would suggest to just concertrate internally on the teachings of Jesus and his deeds. If you concentrate without prejudice and preconceived ideas, just without other thoughts, I am inclined to think that one has to conclude that such a person could not tell a lie, especially that he paid his life for claiming to be Son of God. Why? Because lieing is a selfish act. Jesus died selflessly, he died for the truth. If one dies for the truth, lieing is ruled out. So this is my sense of internal verification. Of course, there are other things to suggest the veracity of Jesus Christ and the Gospels. You might still doubt that scriptural evidence is not solid enough, or as you are saying the whole thing could be pure fiction. Well, such a scenario would have to explain a lot of strange behavior on part of early Christian movements, the apostles, etc... these are facts that cannot be dismissed as they are not isolated cases. It is very hard to imagine a vast and lasting movement based on an imaginative character with some really extraordinary features.... I won't go much longer on that, I just wanted to give you one example. Have you heard of a Catholic stigmatist named Therese Neumann? This woman experienced the "stigmata" of Jesus's torture marks once every week coinciding with the actual weekdays as written in the Gospels. What happened is that every week Jesus's wounds of crucifixion would appear on her body and she would bleed a lot and have visions of the crucifixion. This is not an ancient history, it happened in the first half of the 20th century, and there have been many visitors to her to check and see themselves, there are accounts written down documenting what they saw. Another curious fact is that she did not eat anything else than one piece of small bread (I forget the name, the bread that you get in the church) a day. Why I am mentioning this? Because this is like a very strong suggestion that the Gospels are true and are not invented. If one is not to believe in the authenticity then one has to come up with really-really sophisticated conspiracy theories... BTW, there are other contemporary stories of stigmatism. I will answer to you right away that I believe that Joan of Arc had a divine contact. (Her power, inspiration and charisma are good suggestions she could have divine contact. Her extraordinary and unselfish act also could suggest that). Many others have had divine contacts to one degree or another. It is not as rare as we in a materialistic age come to learn. Of course, divine contact and divine realization are different things. One can have once in a lifetime divine contact, or a few times a lifetime divine contact. On the other hand, Jesus had a permanent union with God, which is what Son of God means. We are all entitled to divine contact, it is not foreign to us humans. As such we are all potential sons of God, we just have to realize it and strive to reclaim our lost divine state. I don't take scriptures literally when they contradict to known facts. To be sure, I am not anything like an expert in scriptural interpretation. However, my understanding is that the Gospels were not meant to be symbolic or allegoric, while Genesis definitely was. We know for sure that the world was not created in 6 days, and things of similar nature. In Gospels too there are some elements that do not make sense if one is to read literally. But the life of Jesus, the story that such a person was born, lived and was crucified, this is by no means an allegory in my opinion. I know of the best way how to approach to the scirptures - it is through internal verification. For that there is an axiom - truth is self evident. Given enough concentration truth will reveal itself, it will be self-evident by observation. This principle could be applied to scriptures. For that one needs to read small pieces of scripture at a time and meditate in silence for a long time. You will be amazed how much better you can understand in this case. By this practice the truths behind allegories and sybolism will become apparent.
-
Why waste my time to make a detailed, well articulated and clearly stated argument, if my opponent is going say "no, you are wrong" following his habits? I might as well spend 2 minutes and type out a few words without much concentration. It's all the same, I will be told to "go away" anyway But if one really wants to understand my post is good enough.
-
It would be good to have some integrity and modesty to acknowledge your limits. What is the point of telling me to "go away". Do you really think I will go away? Ridiculous.
-
Your attitude to religion is based on your misguided emotions about what seems to be negative about religions. And you use words like "science", "logic" while you only have a superficial understanding of those. You cannot think outside of the box of your own creation. Your answers are often "no, you are wrong" type, cynical and without substantiation. Well, if hearing such things annoys you then you are free not to answer to me, as simple as that. Your argument does not support your earlier view. You were saying that Einstein and others could be right on some things and wrong on matters concerning God. It only shows your superficial understanding of God. Your idea that creationism cannot be a valid explanation shows an "intellectual" bigotry and lack of depth. Einstein, for instance, did not find flaws with the idea that this universe with its intelligent and perfect laws probably has an intelligent designer. However, a certain unknown individual such as you without any sort of scientific credibility makes loud statements that creationism is an entirely flawed idea. This is ignorance and bigotry. And as far as other scientists are concerned who didn't believe in God, they nevertheless did not have any scientific works proving that their disbelief is substantiated with any research. If you are going to say "no, you are wrong" you can save it for a proper audience. Here you will have to actually substantiate in order to be right. The fact remains that neither God's existence nor its non-existence have been proven scientifically, and both positions can be held by scientists. Science and moreover logic cannot be used against the existence of God. Hmm... saying it does not mean anything. You have proved to be lacking knowledge and dogmatic. Oh, really? Are you serious?
