-
Posts
5,522 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Sasun
-
Sip, apparently you don't understand the essence of Christianity: God is our Heavenly Father according to Jesus Christ. Please pay attention to the word "father". A human father has a respect for his children, so does God, only His respect is pure, permanent and absolute. The idea of a father is very basic because it is so well known, and your idea of a God is more applicable to an arrogant, selfish powerful being who does not care for some small creatures. In other words, it has nothing to do with the God that Jesus was talking about. You got it all wrong my friend. That is in no way Christianity. I would suggest before you make more statements about Christianity to read the Gospels and learn what Jesus Christ has said of God, of himself, and of men, then see if your opinioin of the Christian idea of God makes any sense.
-
But that is a human approach - compell people to do good. Is this what you are expecting from God? The divine way is not that. God has respect for each and every human being's free will, no matter what they do. An absolute love also means this kind of respect. Human love is limited and also limiting and binding. Divine love is far more superior.
-
Anoushik jan, I think I have passed that age to read children's book Do you read children's book?
-
Good point Zartonk, every once in a while a sane word is needed But we can't help it, Sip wishes to go to Hell
-
I don't know anything Anoushik, I just make up things to raise controversy
-
Interesting Anoushik, I have not read it. Why don't you tell us about it? We must go further and further away from the topic! Oh, BTW, where are those God-damn moderators to split the topic? Oh wait I remember myself being one in my previous life
-
Yeah, but I also said that between lives you stay for some time in the astral world, and in that world there are bad planets and good planets. So by "Hell" I meant one of the bad planets. The name is not so important. Clearly (according to my understanding) you will also face a bad karma in this and next life, but it is a function of your good deeds. I believe other than your crazy ideas ( ) you are a good person, so you never know where you will end up being. However, let me put it this way, if you are willingly and knowingly opposing to the God who is source of happiness then you can't be happy.
-
It looks like you have taken a few right steps towards the direction of Hell, just the place you wish to go.
-
Armat, that means all of us have some degree of faith in God. Faith is actually an intuitive knowledge of God. We are so ungrateful that we only remember God when we need him, while God remembers us always yet he does not have a need to do so. It is just absolute, pure and permanent divine love.
-
Yeah, but they don't reject what their senses tell them. It's just that in addition to material things they also believe in other things. BTW, I am not speaking on their behalf, my analysis does not pertain to them. I am speaking about an additional source of knowledge, not denying our senses as such. Having said this, I don't see how your point connects to my point. Actually, I too keep it to real But we have different understandings of reality. Well, I agree to that point that often we humans would like to imagine simplistic explanations, but nevertheless it is not hard to figure out what is imagined and what is not. If for some that is not the case then perhaps they live in a box. So basically, the majority of people have their own boxes. It maybe a church-dogma box, a materialistic box, a flat-earth box or a box that even they don't understand. I am afraid you have put yourself in a materialistic box thinking matter is all the reality there ever is. I can understand a statement of "I don't understand", but I cannot see how "We don't understand" could follow from that. How do you know that WE, each and every one of us don't understand? Well, well, you are denying an alternative route of arriving at knowledge. I don't know who you were in your past life but I am sure you were not Columbus I would suggest to think about your senses and the physiology of learning and you will see that my analysis above is valid.
-
Sip, you have not realized anything special. What you are talking about is basically, believe in your eyes, senses, touch, etc... everyone does that, who does not? But from there, you are making an invalid conclusion, that basically, if your eyes cannot see then it cannot be true.
-
Ah, Sip, so spiritual people cannot tell imagination from experience? How do you know what is going on in someone else's mind? You are so sure that it is iamgination, but on what basis can you say that? In most cases peaple can tell when they are imagining. Another thing is, according to those who experience through the spiritual eye, one can see the past and the future. Seeing the future can be simply verified by waiting and seeing, so if your vision does not materialize then you can say OK that was not true. But if your vision takes place in reality then it cannot be imagination, can it? Spiritually advanced people have seen long ago what scientists are discovering now. Those things are actually recorded, you just don't know, and given that you are so attached to materialism the chances are you will never try to know. Basically, Sip, you call the pictures of reality a reality and deny that there is an actual reality beyond the pictures. I disagree, reality is most real only when observed directly. What we see through our senses and analyze with our minds are pictures of reality, not the reality itself. This is what materialism is about. Pictures of reality, or the material world, is real too, but it is real only as pictures. There is a higher and permanent reality beyond matter, and that is what spirituality is about.
-
Sip, just think about your evidences. You are using 5 senses to observe everything right? If you did not have 5 senses what would you know? Now think about your senses, how the information is passed from evidences to you. In a nutshell, your senses send signals to your brain, not directly but through nerves. Then your brain processes the information and you make sense of things. Now, suppose you had that information directly in your brain instead of using the senses, then nerves. What would you think of that information - is it true or false? If you asked me I would say direct information is more true than information that has reached me through the intermediaries of senses and nerves and other organs. As to the flaw in logic, no Sip, there is no flaw. I am not saying that not remembering is a proof of reincarnation. All I am saying is not remembering does not mean it did not happen, and not knowing does not mean it does not exist. It seems to me not knowing and not experiencing is the main reason why you don't believe any of the things that you mentioned. That is a very subjective point of view, you can't claim that to be objectively true. As to the spiritual eye, it is true because it is tested and everyone can test if there is a will. No blind faith is necessary. You never tried yet you are so convinced that it is not true. How many years of training is necessary to be an expert in a field of science? It takes many years, hard work and perseverance. After you spend due time and effort some scientific truths become clear to you, and you are on the path to potentially make your own discoveries, not that it is granted. Spiritual practices are just as the same, they take huge amounts of effort and time invested before one can go beyond the limits of 5 senses. To claim that it is not true while there is evidence that it is true from individuals who are experts in that field is not serious. Likewise, you can't deny a scientist's claim without experimenting or basing your opinion on others' experiments. Basically, direct observance of the truth is on the basis of science. Try to think outside of the box. You are saying you can bring tons of evidence that you indeed where a child? Fine, but if I was blind and deaf what use would that be to me? I do need senses for your evidence to mean anything to me. Without sense I would have to either take it by faith, or reject it. (Actually, I would not even know that you exist since I was lacking certain senses). This is precisely the case with your disbelief in the spiritual eye. Instead of five senses you need to develop your spiritual eye and dormant intuitive powers to grasp the truths which can only be observed by intuition and seen by your spiritual eye. I too need to do the same, everyone needs that. There is no blind faith necessary but without trying you will never know. You, I and every human being has a spiritual eye, it is a faculty that must be developed by practice. Like one's brain without schooling and practice in thinking is nearly useless, so the spiritual eye is blind without training. Does any of this make sense?
-
All those things can be seen and experienced, so they are not really self-defined as it may seem. Some people remember their past lives, as Plato did. Most of us don't remember when we were 10 days old or when we were in our mothers' wombs. But that does not mean we did not have those stages of life.
-
I don't know the details about the pergutory as defined in Catholicism (as far as I know only Cahtolics have that concept). I believe more in a different version which I have come to learn: there are three types of worlds - Physical in which we live, Astral and Causal. Accordingly, we and all living beings have 3 bodies - physical, astral and causal. We all know what the physical world is. The astral world consists of subtle energy-like matter, not physical matter. The astral bodies are more or less like the physical body of each soul, and many souls choose to wear their young bodies. The causal world and causal bodies consist of elements of ideas, thoughs/consciousness. Thus our souls wear three garments - physical, astral and causal. When we die (or leave the physical world) we are left with two bodies - astral and causal, and we go to the astral world. The astral world is much larger than the physical world. There are many astral planets where living souls go after they leave the earthly bodies. Now, these planets are not all the same, some are heavenly where everyone whishes to go, but some are really bad where there are constantly wars and suffering. There are different gradations of these planets. Some are extremely good, some are just fine but less than the former ones, some are good, average, then some others moderately bad, etc.. Souls normally are placed in planets that correspond to their acts and state of consciousness in their last life on the earth. A kind and virtuos person's soul will be on a good planet (or Heaven) and an aggressive criminal will be placed on a bad planet (or Hell). Spiritually aspiring souls go to the topmost astral planets, and extremely spiritual people go even further to the causal world which is infinitely more joyous, one has a nearly complete freedom. Souls spend different times in the heavens and hells or in the causal world, it all depends on their capacities and previous lives and progress in spirituality (if any). After that they come back to earth with new bodies compelled by their own cherished desires. Advanced souls spend hundreds of years in very good places before coming back, while ordinary souls spend a few years and come back. The concept of purgatory is that some (or all, not sure) souls after dying have a second chance in the purgatory of correcting themselves. If they succeed then they will go to heaven, if not to hell.
-
No worries, I don't take it personally. I don't remember any time that you have said anything personal to me. Depends on what you mean by rejection, it is not necessarily black and white.
-
Yes, Anoushik, if you fall in a vicious cycle of karma then you are basically in eternal hell. That does not mean that there is no hope. Gospels are not called the "good news" for no reason, they indeed are good news for us as they provide a way out of our self created mysery. That is why prophets in various places and ages have willingly taken birth to help their fellow human beings. Jesus Christ came to earth to save us by his teachings, and he took the bad karma of many-many people on him. That is why he died in such a cruel way. He took a huge amount of sins on him and suffered the accumulated karmic punishment. You see, God is so fair and just that he didn't break his own law of unbiased law of Karma and did not spare Jesus from the punishment of those other people. Anyway, the main point is, yes, you should not mess with karma or may end up in an expanding hole. On the other hand, Karma gives you a wonderful opportunity to invest good acts into your future. Do good now, and your good acts will never be lost. And since you are a good person you will automatically do good, so your good Karma will keep accumulating even though you don't do any special effort. (Actually Jesus has exactly pointed this principle too by saying omething like "what you have will be given to you, what you don't have will be taken away from you", meaning if you have predominantly goog qualities, those good qualities will automatically increas, and if you have predominantly bad qualities and some good qualities, you will loose those good qualities). If you do good now you will reap the benefits in the future and undo bad karma from previous lives or earlier stages in this life. Doesn't Jesus say "you reap what you saw?". That is exactly the principle of cause and effect, or law of karma.
-
Karma had a funny incident on me today. I went too walmart, browsed around, didn't buy anything, got hungry and decided to eat something. Ordered a Subway sandwich, only to discover that I don't have my wallet on me. Asked the guy to keep my sandwiches till I go to my car and get it. Went back to the car but could not find my wallet. Looked for it everywhere I had been in Walmart, could not find. Asked the customer serivce - nope, noone had found a wallet. I had a couple of credit and bank cards, $40 cash, some important cards and pieces of paper, driver license, etc... anyway, I left my phone number at customer service without much hope and rushed home to call the credit card companies and bank to cancel all my lost cards. I was on my way when Walmart called: somebody had found my wallet outside and returned to customer service. Well, happy at the surprise news, I turned back to Walmart. On my way back I decided to give that $40 cash to the finder as a reward. Got my wallet, it had become wet in the snow. Checked everything was there but oops, all $40 cash was gone This guy had done exactly as I had planned to do and rewarded himself without waiting for me Well, needless to say, I went back to Subway, paid for my sandwich and enjoyed it while thinking with appreciation of this tricky karma business.
-
Anahid, thanks I dont mind Sip, I know he is going to find flaws whatever I say and say something cynical. Nothing has changed since year 2003
-
The law of Karma is not the only law, there are many other spiritual laws. I mentioned the Karma only because we were discussing tragedies and such things. Once again (may I ask you to read carefully before jumping to conclusions?) - the law of karma is simply a universal justice system. If there was no justice I am sure you would raise an uproar that there is no justice and God is not fair That is why there is a quite exacting justice system in place. Yes, God is kind and forgiving. That is why if you pray to God and ask for forgiveness you will be forgiven and the mechanical effect of karma will be cancelled or diminished on you. That too is a spiritual law called Divine Love. Jesus said "Ask and you shall be given". This is a very significan spiritual law. God is both just and loving and forgiving. Having said the above, justice and forgiveness do not contradict to each other as it may seem. If you think about it deeply, a loving God would be expected to have an absolutely fair and impartial justice system, and that is the case. If this is too complicated I will give a simple example: a mother has 2 children, both are naughty. If the mother punishes the first child but forgives the second child then obviously this mother does not love the first child as much. Therefore, a truly loving mother will punish or forgive both children fairly and equally. Capish? Oh, well, God does a lot of other things...
-
Well, we both agreed that we have differences. As to reincarnation, whether or not you believe in it, I think we both agree that one should live by spiritual laws, and we both agree that following Jesus Christ's teachings will free one from a very bad state - no matter how we understand it. That's more important than believing in reincarnation.
-
Sip, you are actually repeating what the church says. I don't agree church's interpretation of eternal hell. I believe there are good states and bad states in between life times, but none of them is eternal. Also there are states during one's lifetime that are more important than states during death. So, for example, Jesus says in the Bible that certain acts lead one to be "cast in eternal fire". The church is saying it is eternal hell after one dies, and you are repeating it (I wonder if you have actually read anything in the Bible and tried to understand on your own ) But there is a different interpretation for that, yes, an eternal bad place, but is it really a hell in the afterlife? What about a hellish state during ones life, not after death? What about a mental anguish that one can experience during life because he realizes he has done wrong and his conscience is causing him pangs? I would call that hell too. Or what about an endless, vicious cycle of hellish life and death because you have done so many wrong things that your bad karma just keeps accumulating and punishing you? I would call that an eternal fire too. So, basically, I would not like to just accept church's interpetation because it has contradictions. I try to understand it by comparing it to other religions. If one religion can be right then other religions also can be right, likewise if one religion has no chance at all of having any truth then no other religion can be true. I think all major religions are truthful, therefore it is always good to learn from them. Sip, so tell me, have you read anything in the Bible? If so then it would be good to talk about specific text rather than general. The Bible is a huge collection of books, by the way I have not read all of it. But the Truth I am talking about is contained in the Gospels of the New Testament. Suppose there are some older texts that are not as truthful, I can't tell without reading them.
