Guest Posted January 11, 2001 Report Share Posted January 11, 2001 Russian, Azeri presidents issue declaration on strategic cooperation 9 Jan 2001ITAR-TASS [FBIS Translated Text] Russian, Azeri presidents issue declarationon strategic cooperation Text of report by Russian news agency ITAR-TASS Baku, 9 January: Russia and Azerbaijan are ready to placebilateral relations on a "new higher level of strategicpartnership", the leaders of the two countries have stated in theBaku Declaration which was signed today. Moscow and Baku express readiness to cooperate in the interests oftransforming the Caucasus into a region of peace and goodneighbourliness and consider the development of bilateral relationsto be an important prerequisite for the implementation of thistask. Russia and Azerbaijan "confirm their adherence to the policy offurther developing bilateral cooperation in the political, tradeand economic, military and humanitarian fields as well as inculture, science, education, information, tourism and sport". The document stresses that Moscow and Baku are ready to developlong-term bilateral military and military-technical cooperation inaccordance with the security interests of the two countries and ina manner which is not directed against third states and which doesnot contradict the international obligations of the RussianFederation and Azerbaijan. In the Baku Declaration, Putin and Aliyev proclaim thatAzerbaijanis living in Russia and Russians living in Azerbaijan are"organic components of Russian and Azeri society and an element inpreserving the closeness between the peoples and promoting thestrengthening of their friendly relations". The heads of state noted that approaches to Caspian problems hadgrown closer and confirmed their readiness to continue regularcontacts, including through the special working group at the levelof the deputy foreign ministers of the Caspian five. The bottom line for Russia and Azerbaijan is that the "Caucasusstates themselves play the main role in determining approaches tosecurity and developing cooperation in the region". In thisconnection they note "the key significance of highest levelcontacts" between Azerbaijan, Armenia, Georgia and Russia and "willseek to make them even more productive". Russia and Azerbaijan favour a political solution to the NagornyyArtsax conflict on the basis of the relevant UN Security Councilresolutions and OSCE decisions. Russia welcomes the directdialogue which is being conducted at the highest level betweenAzerbaijan and Armenia, while Azerbaijan voices hope that "Russianinvolvement in resolving the Nagornyy Artsax conflict" will bestepped up further. The Baku Declaration expresses serious anxiety over the spread inthe Caucasus of terrorism, extremism and aggressive separatismwhich pose a threat to the peaceful future of the region. Onaccount of this, Moscow and Baku have decided to continue andfurther improve fruitful cooperation between their foreign policy,power and law-enforcement structures. The leaders of the states express their adherence to the policy ofcooperation within the CIS format and attribute great significanceto deepening multilateral economic cooperation, particularly toestablishing a CIS free trade zone. Russia and Azerbaijan state their strict observance of theprinciples of the UN Charter and decisions of the UN SecurityCouncil and oppose any actions and attempts to interfere in theinternal affairs of sovereign states "under the pretext ofupholding the law or humanitarian grounds". Moscow and Baku favour preserving the system of treaties in thesphere of arms control and disarmament and agree that the ABMTreaty "retains its intransient value in contemporary conditions". Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 14, 2001 Report Share Posted January 14, 2001 IRNA (Islamic Republic News Agency)Jan 14 2001 Russia, Azerbaijan to develop military cooperation, minister Moscow, Jan 13 IRNA-Itar-Tass-ACSNA -- The visit of Russian PresidentVladimir Putin to Azerbaijan on January 9-10 resulted in politicaldecisions, which open broad prospects for cooperation in the militaryand other spheres, Defense Minister Marshal Igor Sergeyev has told thepress. I think that concrete proposals about the development of military-technical cooperation between Russia and Azerbaijan will soonbe drafted, he said. The cooperation will be based on the decree of the Russianpresident, which limits it in connection with the conflict inNagorno-Artsax, he remarked. Russia and Azerbaijan have signed an agreement to train Azerbaijaniservicemen in academies and schools of the Russian defenseministry. Azerbaijan is our old, historical friend and neighbor,Sergeyev noted. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 14, 2001 Report Share Posted January 14, 2001 NATO ISN'T GOING TO DEAL WITH Artsax SETTTLEMENT PROBLEMS 12.01.2001, MEDIAMAX, YEREVAN. "The OSCE and the Minsk group are dealing with the Artsax conflict settlement, and involving NATO in this process would have counter-effect on it", said in Brussels NATO Secretary General Lord George Robertson replying to the question of Mediamax. G. Robertson said the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe is able to deal with this problem independently, and NATO has no wish to "duplicate" the efforts of the OSCE. NATO Secretary General expressed the hope that the parties of the Artsax conflict "will get together as soon as possible and resolve the problem amicably". In his words, this would be in the interest not only of the Southern Caucasian region but the whole European continent as well. George Robertson will start his visit to Yerevan on Monday, January 15. -0- Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 14, 2001 Report Share Posted January 14, 2001 "AZG" Armenian Daily # 5, 01-13-2001RUSSIA DEMANDS $16 MILLION WORTH DEBTS FOR NUCLEAR FUEL The government of Russian Federation has officially warned Armenia that it will not supply the recurrent batch of nuclear fuel for Armenian Nuclear Power Plant until the Armenian government pays a $16 million worth debt to Russia accrued in the passed years. The Armenian government tries to pay its debts in due time but the problem is that currently it cannot find this sum of money. We hoped that Russia would provide an $11 million worth loan, which would be transferred to RosEnergoAtom. However, industrial infrastructures coordinating minister David Zadoyan said that Russia refused to provide the loan. Russia also refused an Armenian proposal on establishing a joint enterprise on the basis of Hrazdan Hydro power plant in return of debts. According to unofficial sources, the head of Russian HFJ company Anatoly Chubais takes interest in the Hrazdan plant. Armenian energy minister Karen Galustian is leaving for Moscow January 16 to discuss with his Russian counterparts issues regarding nuclear fuel and gas supplies. Judging by Russian side's announcements, it becomes clear that tough discussions are awaiting Armenian minister. A special focus is expected to be placed on Russian gas supplies issue. The head of HayRusGasArd company Roland Adonts is now in Moscow to discuss with the management of ITERA consortium the issue of Armenia's gas debts payment time-table. It is interesting that along with the nearing of the date for privatization of Armenia's energy distributing companies the Russian side is toughening its positions. There are opinions that in this way Moscow is displaying its displeasure with the fact that Russian ITERA and RusEnergoAtom were left out of the short-listed candidate companies for the deal. Tatoul Hagopian Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 14, 2001 Report Share Posted January 14, 2001 "AZG" Armenian Daily # 5, 01-13-2001SHEVARNADZE PUZZLED The notable warming up of Russian-Azerbaijani relations caused panic in Georgian political sphere. Of course, the Moscow-Baku cooperation is not directed against a third country, but for official Tbilisi the change of the direction of his ally Azerbaijan's policy is very troubling. The thing is that Georgia was to have a strategic position in Azerbaijan-Georgia-Turkey-West, and Uzbekistan-Azerbaijan-Georgia-Ukraine-Moldavia oil pipeline construction and regional Traseca, Inogate economic-energetic projects. Azerbaijan's Russian orientation ruins all the Georgian dreams. Till recently the president of Georgia Edward Shevarnadze was "feeding" Georgian nation with the expected incomes of the oil transfer. Georgia is the nowadays' Caucasian captive. Shevarnadze is pondering - 2 billion US$ foreign debt, mass unemployment, collapsed economy... The only functioning sector of Georgia's economy is the money transfers from Georgians living in Russia. Azerbaijan "betrayed" him, Armenia needs help itself, Russia is drawing forwards unacceptable conditions, and the only neighbor that can be relied on is Turkey. Actually, if Azerbaijan changes its orientation, all the west-oriented policy of Georgia can be not only unjustified, but also may harm the country. The traditional Russian-oriented Georgians who have been under the Russian dominance for 200 years demand from Georgian west -oriented authorities to stop the flirting with Turkey and US. In Georgian parliament announcements biding to change the orientation to Russian side are made more and more often. Not everything is lost, though. Russia says, " brother Georgians, dear coreligionists, if you don't want to starve to death, and we are sure you don't, lets cooperate again. Help is, well, to be more exact, do not let Chechen guerillas to settle in Pankis ravine, don't complain to NATO, that Russian troops are a threat, please, inform NATO that Russian military units of Akhalkalak and Batumi are not going to change its places for another 15 years... and then there will be no problem- we are ready to review the visa regime law between our countries!" And Shevarnadze is thinking hard... by Tatoul Hagopian Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 14, 2001 Report Share Posted January 14, 2001 quote:Originally posted by MJ:Russian, Azeri presidents issue declaration on strategic cooperation9 Jan 2001ITAR-TASSMoscow and Baku favor preserving the system of treaties in thesphere of arms control and disarmament and agree that the ABMTreaty "retains its intransient value in contemporary conditions".I think the ABM treaty referenced above is one of the "key words." Bush is pushing for the repeal or the revisiting of the ABM treaty. Putin (Russia) is opposed. I just don't understand what does it have to do with Azerbaijan. Do you think Russia is building a coalition in UN? Doesn't sound too convincing to me? In what way is tis treaty related to the Russian Radar installation north of Baku? Does anyone have an idea where is this headed? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 14, 2001 Report Share Posted January 14, 2001 Also, there seems to be a strange coincidence. The awareness of the faultiness of the Baku-Cheyan pipeline is growing in Turkey, Turkey is demonstrating steps towards its rapprochement with Armenia, the energy policy of the US is being reshaped, Russia is demonstrating steps of rapprochement with Azerbaijan... A paradigm shift? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 15, 2001 Report Share Posted January 15, 2001 I will not be surprised if some new "11-th Red Army" makes a move from Chechnya to Azerbaijan, Kharabagh and then to Armenia under a pretext of relocation to Gumri base, leaving Karabagh under Azeri dominance. And there will be a new Nzhdeh, new Dro...Actually all this is in history book. Just reveiw the history of 1918-th Armenian Republic. It's all there. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 quote:Originally posted by MJ:What a nightmare... (:MJ, the nightmare is about to come... just follow the news Well, you can see that the saying: Only Jews can earn from both Coca-Cola and Pepsi at the same time... really works only on Jews, not Armenians. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 What a nightmare... (: Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 Almost all Armenian national movements and independence uprisings have the following scenario in their core: - initial unification of people- military victory- internal betrayal on the basis of ambition and self-interest- paradigm shift of position with loss of key ally- military defeat Take each and every Armenian uprising case after king Arshak II: 1. King Arshak and sparapet Vasak againts the Persians (betrayed by the church and some counts) 2. King Pap and sparapet Moushegh against the Persians and the Bisantine (betrayed by the church and some counts) 3. King Gagik and sparapet Vahram against the Bisantine and Seljuks (betrayed by the Catholicos and some counts) 4. Davit Beg and sparapet Mkhitar against the Sefevi Iran and Ottoman Turkey (betrayed by counts, no doubt about church's participation) 5. 1890-s to - 1920 period. Numerous betrayals on each stage of the movement, complete anarchy mainly based on ambition. So, what's happening now? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 quote:Originally posted by Artur: MJ, the nightmare is about to come... just follow the news Well, you can see that the saying: Only Jews can earn from both Coca-Cola and Pepsi at the same time... really works only on Jews, not Armenians.Why do you think I push for wine industry in Armenia Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 Berj, I think we can also add:-lack of continuity and inability to aggregate political experience and wisdom;-it's all darn complex, and one may lose his head trying to figure out what's the right thing to do. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 Finally I am back in town, and can comment on some of the postings that interest me. I think it’s time to move strategic orientation of Armenia from East to West. Considering the pitiful financial and political situation in East (Russia) it’s not in our best interest to align with them. Look at Russia, it resembles Weimar Republic, unstable, poor economy, extremist movements are widespread corruption. If Armenia wants to be in better financial shape it’s in its best interest to align itself with politically and financially more stable West. After the World War II Greece had the similar dilemma, East or West, and chose West, which enabled it to prosper. What will we gain from our alignment with East, military protection from Turkey? Why would Turkey risk becoming a pariah state, when its economy is in shackles. Only a few months ago IMF’s infusion of money enabled it to delay devaluation of Turkish Lira, and meet the interest payments on its sovereign debt. As far as we know there is no real military thread from Turkey. What will we gain from our alignment with West. First, money infusion to desperate Armenian economy, second, political stability. I was wondering what do you guys thing about pegging dram with euro. It becomes more and more common for unstable economies to peg their currency to stable currency. (Argentina, Honk Kong, etc. are examples who have pegged their currency to a dollar) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 Alpha, I don't think completely orienting itself towards West is wise for Armenia - neither from economical nor from political points of views. Armenia is not a Western country, and it has not much to offer to the West. On the other hand, it is not Eastern country, either. Throughout history, it has played a role of a conduit between the West and East - whether it is through merchant business or through filtration and transmission of cultural and other values between West and East. In my view, that's where it belongs now, too. But it is a difficult role to assume due to it's vagueness. I think at no point Armenia has to ascribe to one or another orientation. Politics is a dynamic game. Armenia has to conduct politics resembling compressible fluid - when it is squeezed, it has to compress, when it is let loose, it has to expend. Always has to adjust its shape (not the content) to the container it is put in. This vibration would make Armenia a dynamic, flexible, progressive and growing country, I belive. I hear many times that Armenia has to learn from Israel. I am not sure if it is a correct analogy. If from anybody, I think Armenia has to learn from Turkey as how to maneuver between West and East. In the arena of politics and diplomacy, Turkey is the classic, centuries-old example of success, no matter how much one may resent their oppressive nature. It is the country, which has successfully played the card of a military and diplomatic buffer between the West and the East, and has acquired an important international function throughout its entire existence. Things change radically, almost every decade, in the geopolitical neighborhood of Armenia. I think, Armenia has to change accordingly. The hard thing, I guess, is to hold your hand on the pulse of the region, and take timely measures for regulating your own "blood pressure." There can not be a clear cut Armenian political, military and diplomatic doctrine, I think. It has to be fluid. All it takes, perhaps, is professionalism. As to the money, I am not sure that dram has to be pegged to Euro. The future of Euro is not clear to me, for example. It would be a little bit of an exaggeration, I think, to claim that it is a stable currency. I see it rather being pegged to $. Effectively and unofficially, it is already pegged to the $. This idea has existed in Armenian diplomatic corpse for about a dozen of years, as I recall. But the problem is Armenia has not been able to bring together a visionary government, yet. The time is not ripe. Until the "fedayees" are out of the picture, nothing on a large scale may succeed in Armenia, I think. I, personally, have no idea how that problem can be resolved in the short run. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 MJ, what I meant by realigning with West was that current geopolitical conditions commands Armenia to change its course from more Eastern orientation to Western. I agree with you assessment that “Politics is a dynamic game. Armenia has to conduct politics resembling compressible fluid - when it is squeezed, it has to compress, when it is let loose, it has to expend. Always has to adjust its shape (not the content) to the container it is put in.” I just think current conditions dictate Armenia to look at the West not East. We don’t want to be aligned with the loosing side. Global affairs are pretty much dominated by Western powers, and we must align our interests to match theirs, since we can’t do the opposite. I somewhat disagree with your view on Euro. It’s more stable that it gets credit for. Once the recession hits US, major flight of capital from here will boost Euro. It’s true that unofficially dram is pegged to dollar, but so is every other currency in other emerging markets. Since US is too far geographically, and our potential trading partners are in Europe pegging dram to Euro will be the better alternative. Pegging dram to major currency will force the “fedayee” government to be more accountable. Basically they won’t have many things to say in the country’s economy, but it will be done in Brussels. Although Armenia has achieved an amazing level of macroeconomic stability, but it’s inability to capitalize on that in order to attract new investments is just a result of poor government decisions. Pegging dram to Euro will give more confidence to investors, and subsequently will create an inflow of capital. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 Alpha, just one comment: Countries like Russia don't go down alone. They take with them anybody they can reach to. Don't underestimate their ability to destroy Armenia. Regarding Euro vs. $, it is a complicated issue, and nobody knows the answer. Besides, we haven't asked yet neither EU or the US, whether they agree to it or not. But I generally agree with the direction of your thoughts, despite the possible protests of anti-globalists. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 Clearly Russia is in downhill. It resembles British Empire after the world war II, with the exception that it’s not going down quietly. Orienting Armenia toward Russia, is similar to orienting Cilician Armenia toward crumbling Mongol Empire, for which we paid dearly (devastating invasion of Mamluks). We should find stronger partners that are on rise not declining empires who are desperate to reestablish their former influence. I want to know what are the advantages of having Eastern Orientation. May be I am missing something on this issue. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 But I am not sure that Armenia has an Eastern orientation either. To me it is lost in the dark without any orientation. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 16, 2001 Report Share Posted January 16, 2001 We are trying to align ourselves with the West. The article below is a proof of that. Armenia, Align With the West Armenia has for the first time voiced its intention to become an equal member of the European Community in the end of the past millennium. In experts' opinion, shared by Armenian authorities as well, Yerevan's European bet "is likely to be of declarative nature and is invoked to point out Armenia's desire to take an active part in all political and economical processes, more or less affecting the Large Caucasus region. Yerevan is not going to apply for the EC membership officially right now, though it has reserved the right to do it at any moment. It is symptomatic, that Yerevan, having announced its desire to become an equal member of the expanding "European family", in the person of its Foreign Affairs Minister has ventured to make a number of loud statements being of a great importance for the EC. Thus, Vardan Oskanyan has pointed out that Turkey, claiming for soon joining the EC, does not have a chance to achieve its "blue European dream" without acknowledging the fact of genocide against Armenians in 1915 - 1923 and normalization of relationship with Armenia. The latter, however, is still ready to establish a constructive dialogue with Ankara without any prior conditions, Mr. Oskanyan has stressed. In the beginning of the new millennium and 2001, Yerevan plans to boost its regional influence and to strengthen its geopolitical and geoeconomical positions in the Large Caucasus by implementing the project of the Armenia - Iran gas pipeline. By the way, the Armenian minister has marked, that it is Iran which remains by the key regional partner of Yerevan. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 28, 2001 Report Share Posted January 28, 2001 http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg26436.html Dashnaks seeking key ministerial post to defend Artsax - paper Aykakan Zhamanak26 Jan 01 Text of Avetis Babayanyan report by Armenian newspaper AykakanZhamanak entitled "Revolutionary Federation - Dashnaktsutyun needsa power-wielding structure" [subhead] It is necessary to "save Artsax" Everybody is sure that President Robert Kocharyan is bringing theDashnaks to power. But nobody can say why. Why the Dashnaks? Isit because in 1998 the Dashnaks protected the candidature ofKocharyan? But other parties also protected Kocharyan. Why hasKocharyan chosen just the Dashnaks? Is it not because Kocharyansupports the ideas of the Dashnaks or is a secret member of theDashnaktsutyun? Yesterday a group of MPs discussed one of thetheories for this turn of events which we present for yourattention. But this is only a theory. According to the MPs, Robert Kocharyan has decided to show brevityand resoluteness and to settle the Artsax problem in accordancewith the norms of international law. During his time in power hehas signed numerous international agreements which confirm theprinciple of territorial integrity. The settlement of the Artsaxproblem in the framework of the principle of the territorialintegrity of Azerbaijan was impossible until today because of anumber of basic reasons: in Armenia Vazgen Sarkisyan was againstit, Sarkisyan who led the Yerkrapa Union of Volunteers and whofought for the liberation of Artsax, while in Artsax SamvelBabayan who was an authority among the veterans of Artsax, alsoopposed it. Today Vazgen Sarkisyan is killed, the Yerkrapa unionis divided and disrupted and Samvel Babayan and his entourage arein prison. The only organized force which may be against thefulfilment of this programme is the Dashnaktsutyun. Till today theDashnaks were trying to prove that they had saved Artsax.Regardless of how much the Dashnaks wish to protect today'spresident, in the name of their traditional ideology they areobliged to state that they will not exchange Artsax for anything.In Armenia something always happens to forces that behave likethis. And as the Dashnaktsutyun is a pro- authorities party, theauthorities decided not to terrorize it but to bribe it. Thatmeans that according to this theory Kocharyan is trying to giveposts to the Dashnaks as a result of which their radical attitudeto the Artsax issue may change. But the problem is that the Dashnaktsutyun wants more than it maybe given. The Dashnaktsutyun wants the Ministry of InternalAffairs, which may not be given to the Dashnaks, any other ministry- please. But the Dashnaktsutyun wants the Ministry of InternalAffairs or the National Security Ministry or Defence Ministry. Butwhy do the Dashnaks want any power-wielding structure and theauthorities not want to give them one? Here the account is veryclear - the Dashnaktsutyun hopes that at the moment that Kocharyanhands over Artsax (of course, if it has a power-wieldingministry) it will be possible to apply the 1998 scenario and, againwith the help of Artsax, to reach absolute power by means of astate coup. This perspective is so evident that everybodyunderstands it. So if Kocharyan does trust any power-wieldingstructure to the Dashnaks anyway, it means that from today he isorganizing a state coup against himself. If he does not trusttrust them with any, that means that he really is intending to handArtsax over. The first theory is no less dangerous than thesecond. Of course, when they have gained power the Dashnaks willfirst of all start war in the name of Artsax. And as during theyears of Kocharyan-Dashnaktsutyun authority the country was tooweak, it is quite evident that the Second Republic will also havethe same fate as the first. But who knows within what country oursmall Armenia will be included: Russia, Turkey or Azerbaijan? Credit: Aykakan Zhamanak, Yerevan, in Armenian 26 Jan 01 p 3 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 29, 2001 Report Share Posted January 29, 2001 RUSSIAN FRONTIER-GUARDS ARE TO GUARD THE STATE BORDER OF ARMENIA AS LONG AS THERE IS A TURKISH THREAT IN THE REGION, SERGE SARKISSYAN SAID YEREVAN, 29 January. /ARKA/. Russian frontier-guards are to guard the state border of Armenia as long as there is a Turkish threat in the region, RA Minister of Defence Serge Sarkissyan said at the press-conference. He stressed the fact that the decision also concerns the Russian military base situated on the territory of Armenia. "Wwe shall think of the issue" when the threat of Turkey stops existing in the region, the minister stated. In his answers to journalists' questions Sarkissyan said that "nothing threatens Armenian-Russian strategic partnership". The minister added that Russia has activated its participation in the peaceful settlement of Nagorno-Artsax conflict lately.--0--M.S. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted January 31, 2001 Report Share Posted January 31, 2001 http://groong.usc.edu/news/msg26547.html TURKEY AND RUSSIA: A STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP?By Kubilay KultiginCentral Asia/Caucasus Institute BIWEEKLY BRIEFING Wednesday, January 31, 2001 In late October, Russian Prime Minister Mikhail Kasyanov visitedTurkey and proposed to raise bilateral relations to the level ofstrategic partnership. Amidst calls for closer relations PresidentVladimir Putin declared that Turkey was a traditional and importantpartner for Russia. Russia is actively courting Turkey as it isseeking to increase Turkish energy dependency on Russia and aspiresfor a larger share from the lucrative Turkish defense pie.,Without any effective US response, recent developments inTurco-Russian relations may have adverse ramifications for USinterests in the region. BACKGROUND: The three-day visit of Prime Minister Kasyanovproduced a number of agreements, including one to the effect oflifting mutual personnel quotas on their respective embassies.Thus, the two sides scrapped a psychologically significant cold warpractice that used to limit the number of diplomatic and consularpersonnel in their embassies. Turkey and Russia also agreed to theestablishment of a defense cooperation commission whose task is toexamine potential arms sales from Russia to Turkey and anintelligence cooperation agreement against terrorism. The newlyestablished defense cooperation commission was tasked to seek newapproaches to facilitate Russian arms sales to Turkey. Last year Turkey had announced that it wants to spend US$ 150billion over a span of 25 years on arms acquisitions. Kasyanovstipulated, in no uncertain terms, the importance Russia attachesto the US$ 4 billion attack helicopter tender that aRussian-Israeli consortium came in second after AmericanBell-Trexton. Russia also offered joint production schemes andsales to third countries, a condition the Turkish General Stafffinds attractive due to its changing strategic thinking which aimsto promote the strengthening of Turkey's indigenous defenseindustries. Russian hopes were somewhat revived in recent weeksdue to the possibility of the adoption of a House ofRepresentatives resolution which would have recognized the allegedArmenian genocide. Though the resolution was withdrawn at the lastminute, Ankara appears to be willing to use the Russian offer forpressuring Bell-Trexton for better conditions. In the field of energy, the highlight of the visit, Russiacommitted itself to sell more electricity to Turkey through atripartite scheme that involves Georgia as well. Kasyanovconfirmed earlier energy deals that foresee further gas sales toTurkey and personally inspected the progress made on the much-hypedBlue Stream project. The two sides agreed to increase bilateraltrade up to an annual US$ 10 billion, currently standing at US$ 7-8billion, including the so-called suitcase trade. Deputy PrimeMinister Ilya Klebanov followed up on the Kasyanov visit inNovember while Russian President Vladimir Putin and his Chief ofGeneral Staff are expected to visit Ankara in coming months. IMPLICATIONS: President Putins pronunciation of Turkey as atraditional partner caught many by surprise in Ankara but the callis indicative of the new direction of Russian policies vis-a-visTurkey. Moscow wants to become Turkey's principal energy providerand a respectable arms supplier in Turkey's ambitious defenseacquisition scheme. This of course, is in tandem with Russias newforeign policy concept that stipulates a priority to economicfactors. Not surprisingly, Moscow avoided talking about thegeopolitical rivalry in the Caucasus and Central Asia region butrather focused on increasing bilateral trade and energy deals. Thesheer weight of Russian natural gas sales in Turkeys overall energyimportation situation is self-explaining. According to 1999figures, 67 percent of Turkish gas imports originated from Russia. Gazprom announced in October that it was about to complete workboosting the capacity of the western pipeline which passes throughUkraine and the Balkan s, from 8 billion bcm of gas to 14 billionbcm a year. In addition, Blue Stream is expected to carry another16 billion bcm a year, which will increase the total of Russian gassupplies to 30-36 billion bcm in a decade. This is all the moreimportant now than ever. Due to a lack of effective forwardplanning and strategic foresight, Turkey is experiencing apolitically embarrassing energy crisis. Given the urgency ofsteady energy supplies, domestic resistance to Blue Stream has beenovercome and the project is progressing ahead of time. Yet, BlueStream is effectively developing against the Trans-Caspian projectand other American energy priorities in the region. Turkmenistanis the most visible loser in this scheme. Should Turkey continue to be rebuffed by the European Union andUS/European arms sales be held up because of human rights anddemocratization concerns, Ankara may become more receptive towardsRussian overtures particularly in the area of arms acquisitions andaccelerate its increasingly assertive regional Turkish foreignpolicy. Russia is quite sensitive about Chechen activity inTurkey, which Ankara is carefully keeping to a minimum. Theintelligence cooperation agreement aims to facilitate the exchangeof intelligence against Chechen and PKK activists in Turkey andRussia respectively. Mutual realism on the issue already becameevident during Prime Minister Ecevit's visit to Moscow last yearwhen he remained silent about the Chechens just when Russian forceswere attacking Grozny. The volatility in the region washighlighted later when more than sixty Chechen rebels crossed intoGeorgia in October and asked to proceed to Azerbaijan or Turkey. CONCLUSIONS: The Turkish-Russian relationship is destined to beframed by the dominance of energy. Russia is keen to increaseTurkeys energy dependency and solidify its dominance in the Turkishenergy market. Russian calls for a strategic partnership havereceived a lukewarm reception in Ankara as the Turkish GeneralStaff believes that such overtures are primarily geared towardswinning lucrative Turkish defense contracts and easing Turkishconcerns about further energy dependency on Russia. However, otheractors in Ankara, notably the Ministry of Energy, appear to becontent with the emerging energy association. Turkey's plan to expand its domestic natural gas network suggeststhat Turkey will surely remain vulnerable in the foreseeablefuture. In light of Turkeys recent tendency towards moreindependent policies in regional affairs and a subsequent lesseningof sensitivity to US security interests, Russian calls to upgraderelations should not be overlooked. The warming of Turkish-Russianrelations, albeit motivated by purely Realpolitik concerns anddevoid of any social or cultural basis, may acquire a purelyEurasian character at the expense of US strategic interests in theregion. Increased Turkish-Russian interdependence may be a mixedblessing for the US. Such a development is likely to decrease thepotential for direct confrontation between the two rivals in theCaucasus and Central Asia. AUTHOR BIO: Kubilay Kultigin is a Political Science PhD candidatein Turkey. His research interests include Russian perceptions ofTurks, Turkish-Russian relations, Turkish-Ukrainian relations andBlack Sea/Caucasus security issues. Copyright 2001 The Analyst All rights reserved Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.