DominO123 Posted July 25, 2003 Report Share Posted July 25, 2003 (edited) In all the history of Ottoman empire, there has been one direct counting of a goup of the Armenian population. Those being the number of Armenians in schools, those aging from 5-15, the number is so precise that it takes even the last digit. Based on the scool inscription lists. Those lists have been presented by Krikor Zohrab in his work "La Question Arménienne à la Lumière des Documents"(The Armenian Question in the light of documents). This list has been achieved in 1902, and represented those recorded in mid 1901 I have decided to use Izmit as the references, because of the drown borders, and the fact that the Armenians children were known to have had a good education, life expectancy was high(where we could apply the stable population theory), and Armenian growt was stable. The Ottoman statistics of Armenians there for the year 1911 was of 57,789, and McCarthys correction give that population to 70,659. In the year 1901, registered boys in Izmit Armenian schools were of 5,404 and of girls, 3,103. It is understanble, since boys were going more to school in those years than boys. So in order to use this number as bases, we should presume that the number of boys and girls were equal. Here, about 85% of the boys(from 6-17 years range) having gone to school is a good approximation, but there is a distinction between having gone to school and having compleated school. It is normal and logical, that for example, there were less students in 5 than 1 etc... so the numbers of Armenian children counted as registered, and how much Arenian children have already frequented school is different, if we supposes that the reduction is pretty constant from the 6-14 years range, than 15% should be reasonable substracted. How is that? Well, supposes that 85 % of the boys were in first grade at age 6 Grade 1: 85%(6 years old)Grade 2: 80%(7 years old)Grade 3: 75%(8 years old)Grade 4: 70%(9 years old)Grade 5: 65%(10 years old)Grade 6: 60%(11 years old)Grade 7: 50%(12 years old)Grade 8: 45%(13 years old)Grade 9: 40%(14 years old)------------40%(15 years old)------------40%(16 years old)------------40%(17 years old) I know that in the middle the variation should be the greatest and in the extremities not so, and that we can not class the age categories in a pack etc... But that would not have big impact. The mid-value would be about 65%, that may be an exageration, if it is, than we will end up with an underevaulation of the Armenian population, and that is probably what we will get. But what I am searching is what was the "at least" population rather than the population. (5,404/65) * 100 = 8,314That would be about the number of boys ranging from 6-14 in Izmit.Now, we copy this half pyramid to the girl population. 8,314 * 2 = 16,628 So that means, that in 1901, in Izmit, there was at least 16,628 Armenian children ranging from 6-14Using the Theory of stable population(which McCarthy uses), we would supposes that in this 8 year ranges, there was 16,628 Armenian children ranging from 6 to 14. And since we supposes that the population is stable. We can extrapolate on the 0-5 year ranges. (5/8) * 16,628 = 10,392. And do the same for the ranges from 15-20(because of the higher life expectancy, and the overestimation will be ballanced with the possible underestimation of the 0-5 ranges, I use here McCarthy logic, to show that from his method of stable population he is wrong). (5/8) * 16,628 = 10,392 So now, we take the Armenian population that ranges from 0-20, and we come to 33,256 for the year 1901.Now, for the people aging from 21 years and older. We uses the pyramidal reduction of the half. That means, that we take the ranges from 21-61 and apply the half of the other range. That would mean, that we supposes that there was about 33,256 Armenians aging 21 years and more. Adding both numbers, we find the total number of Armenians living in Izmit in 1901.33,256 * 2 = 66,512 Now, the calculation of McCarthy for the year 1911-1912 was of 70,659 Now, lets extrapolate for the year 1911. With a little growt rate of 1.5% The real number was possibly higher. Ading that growing rate, we come to the population of Armenians for the year 1911 in Izmit, of 77,190.A correction factor on McCarthys number of 1.09, which is considerable, assuming that what I have found was the "at least" rather than the actual number supposedly found by McCarthy. If anyone find that I have used a little reference and all based on it to find out the last number... McCarthy technic is even more ridiculous, because he uses the household method and build the rest of the pyramid on it, while the children or women methods are considered to be much much more precise. EDTITED: I just realised that I forgot to specify something very important, the % per grade were not representative of how much children in % there was in each grade, but rather supposing that every children(85% of them) started all together from Grade 1, and that since it is 85% children ranging from 6 to 17, the 15-17 will be out of range. That was only used to find the middle value.(I added the out range values, to make it clearer why it ends up to 65%) Edited July 26, 2003 by Fadix Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.