Jump to content

Merkel Scolds Erdogan over Genocide Denial


Yervant1

Recommended Posts

http://asbarez.com/App/Asbarez/images/asbarez_01_460x101.jpg

Friday, February 7th, 2014

 

Merkel Scolds Erdogan over Genocide Denial

http://asbarez.com/App/Asbarez/eng/2014/02/merkel-erdogan.jpg

Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan with German Chancellor Merkel in Berlin this week

BERLIN—German Chancellor Angela Merkel scolded Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan over Turkey’s continued denial of the Armenian Genocide and urged the Turkish leader to “face its history,” reported the Turkish-language version of Hurriyet on Thursday.

Erdogan, who was on an official visit to Germany, warned Merkel and her ruling Christian Democratic Union party to be more cautious in addressing the upcoming centennial of the Armenian Genocide.

“We are aware that in the coming year there are budgetary allocations in your country for the 100th anniversary of 1915 event,” Erdogan reportedly told Merkel.

“I recommend that you address this issue more carefully and caution your party about any allocations,” added Erdogan.

In response, Merkel reportedly told the Turkish leader that Germany is a democratic country and that her government cannot intervene in decisions.

“Turkey must come to terms with its history. We cannot compare the Armenians living in Armenia with the Armenians who were forcibly dispersed around the world,” said Merkel adding that those in Armenia are living under difficult circumstances and urged Erdogan to open the border.

“You are forcing us to accept something we have not done,” said Erdogan, denying the Armenian Genocide again and claiming that the entire Turkish archives are open to the world.

“Do not do injustice against Turkey,” Erdogan urged Merkel.

Prior to his visit to Germany, a member of the German parliament urged Erdogan to end the denial of the Armenian Genocide and apologize for the crime, reported the Bild newspaper.

Erika Stenbach, a member of Merkel’s party, said: “I urge Turkish Prime Minister Erdogan to stop denying the genocide of Armenians and Assyrians by the Young Turk government of the Ottoman Empire 99 years ago,” adding that it is high time for Turkey to apologize to the descendants of the victims of the first genocide of the 20th century.

“It is Erdogan’s duty to face the truth nearly 100 years after that terrible crime and ensure that the Turkish textbooks do not distort this part of Turkish history,” said Steinbach.

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

ERDOGAN-MERKEL AWKWARD CONVERSATION ON ARMENIAN GENOCIDE

Lragir.am
Politics - Friday, 07 February 2014, 17:51

The Hyurriyet has reported details of the recent Erdogan-Merkel
meeting. The newspaper has learned that the Turkish and German leaders
discussed Erdogan's nomination in the upcoming presidential elections,
as well as the Armenian Genocide.

Erdogan hesitated for a moment after Merkel's question about elections
and Merkel said in a joke: "I promise not to tell anyone."

Nevertheless, Erdogan did not give a specific answer, noting: "At the
moment the March 30 local elections are on our agenda. We will focus
on the other issue [presidential elections] as soon as it comes up
on the agenda."

The Armenian genocide was not left out of the agenda as well, which,
according to the Hyurriyet, caused some coldness between the parties of
the meeting. Erdogan who brought up the issue the first said they must
be sensitive about their budget allocations for the 100th anniversary
of the developments of 1915 and called her to warn her group. Merkel
retorted that Germany is a democracy and they cannot interfere while
Turkey should face up to the history. The Armenians living in Armenia
must not be identified with the Armenians who were forced to spread
across different countries of the world. Armenians are in a difficult
situation, and Turkey must open the border with Armenia.

Erdogan echoed that Merkel wants to force them admit something they
have not done, adding that they have opened up their archives to
historians all over the world and called them to come over and study
but nobody came.

- See more at:
http://www.lragir.am/index/eng/0/politics/view/31882#sthash.w53V3Upp.dpuf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Who else have Armenian origin?

 

 

Merkel: There Are Different Armenians

Naira Hayrumyan, Political Commentator
Comments - Saturday, 08 February 2014, 17:05


As 2015, "X hour" for Turkey, is coming up, increasingly more
politicians of world scale say that recognition of the genocide is
inevitable. Quite recently, Bashar Assad compared what is happening
now in Syria with the genocide in Ottoman Turkey. The Kurdish leader
Abdullah Ocalan addressed a letter to the Armenians about the
genocide.. the French President Francois Hollande stated in Ankara
that Turkey will have to face up to its history.

However, what the German Chancellor Angela Merkel told the Turkish
Prime Minister Erdogan is probably the most symptomatic of all. The
Chancellor of Germany, a country which has had to pay for the
Holocaust for many decades, has urged Turkey to admit to its history.
Erdogan said that they should not be responsible for what is not done.
And then Merkel said sacramental phrase. According to the Turkish
Hyurriyet, Merkel noted that the Armenians living in Armenia should
not be identified with Armenians scattered around the world. "Turkey
should open its border with Armenia," Merkel said.

This sacramental phrase outlined two "Armenian fronts" against Turkey,
Armenia and the Diaspora. And the international community, apparently,
intends to support both fronts, regardless of the will of the Armenian
government which works on neither of these fronts.

The international community will definitely support the claims of the
Armenians worldwide who have been of their historical homeland and
property due to the genocide. However, the international community
will also demand that Turkey open its border with Armenia to open
communication in our vast region.

Judging by the expression on the face of Turkish leaders, they have
reconciled with the thought of recognition of the genocide and are
thinking about choosing the least painful way. Europe pushes Turkey to
open the border with Armenia and recognize the genocide as a condition
of rapprochement with Turkey. Turkey may not have territorial losses
but it will have major political losses and appear on the back seat of
politics. Failure to meet these conditions will completely marginalize
Turkey.

In Turkey they are already talking about a broad international front
against Turkey, including not only the western but also the "Shiite
green area". Erdogan's party will resist if he wins the local
elections on March 30 and the presidential election in August. It is
not going to be easy, and the Armenian factor will play a significant
role. It is not a coincidence that Erdogan's key opponent Fetullaha
Gulen is said to have an Armenian origin.


During the opening ceremony of the Olympic Games in Sochi Sargsyan sat
next to Erdogan who had considered it his duty to come to Russia. Most
probably, it had been intended to arrange a private talk between them.
Apparently, there was no conversation because the Armenians living in
Armenia and those scattered around the world are different. And the
goals of the Armenians worldwide are not always the targets of the
Armenian leadership.

- See more at: http://www.lragir.am/index/eng/0/comments/view/31891#sthash.BRadoMe8.dpuf

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I think Germans are being fed up with Muslim Turks in their country, they have millions Turks in Germany most unassimilated and unpleasant to deal with by Germans, and Germans started to tell it like it is. Here in this video we see another German woman starts protesting when a Muslim Turk starts praying loud in a church:

http://youtu.be/BQ-woo76df0

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I had no intention of 'spamming' as you say. To me it did not look a spam but it was related to the subject of how the sentiments in Germany are turning against muslim Turkey in favor of Armenians. This is the first time that Merkel openly and publicly admonished a Turkish leader to acknowledge our Genocide, why this chance? First the mood currently in Germany is against Muslim Turks who mostly refuse to assimilate into German society and a German political party is considering giving then dual citizenship as a solution (up to now immigrant Turks to Germany are not given German citizenship and theoretically can be evacuated any time). Then the other reason for this pro-Armenian stand by the Germany and EU is the Custom Union of Armenia with Russia and rejection of the Association with EU. Clearly EU want nullification of this Custom Union and return of Armenia into EU, hence the change in German attitude.

But rest at peace Yervant1, I WILL NO LONGER MAKE ANY COMMENTS ON YOUR POSTS.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

GERMANY ADOPTING NEW APPROACH TO GENOCIDE ISSUE - EXPERT

15:07 * 12.02.14

German officials' statements on the Armenian Genocide suggest that
the country is adopting new approaches to the issue, according to an
Armenian expert.

Commenting on Chancellor Angela Merkel's recentcall on Turkey to
confront its past and open the border with Armenia, Ara Papyan,
the director of the National Academy's Genocide Institute, said the
country is very likely to express a more clear position on the issue
in the near future.

"One thing is becoming clear about Germany, judging by the statements
of not only Merkel, but also other officials. I see Germany adopting
a new approach to the Genocide issue," he told reporters on Wednesday.

The expert said that Germany, which has itself had a difficult history,
is voicing such an opinion considering its past, urging a country
wishing to join the EU to admit the dark pages of its history.

http://www.tert.am/en/news/2014/02/12/ruben-safrastyan/

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Overall it would be beneficial to have the border open! Now the trade is done through Georgia with outside world and it's a longer route, don't forget that Europeans can go to Asia with a shorter route through Armenia, also rail system will generate a good transit income which is much needed. I know some will say that turkish products will fill Armenia, but those products are coming in through Georgia with a higher price tag already. I doubt that the Kurdish population will come to Armenia in vast numbers if the border opens up.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

TURKISH FM: THE BORDER WITH ARMENIA WILL NOT BE OPENED, UNLESS NAGORNO KARABAKH CONFLICT IS SOLVED

by Marianna Mkrtchyan

ARMINFO
Wednesday, February 19, 16:21

"Turkey's position is clear and this position remains unchanged. The
border with Armenia will not be opened, unless Nagorno Karabakh
conflict is solved," Turkey's Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu said
when asked to comment on the reports that Turkey is going to normalize
its relations and open its border with Armenia.

According to APA, Davutoglu said this at the press conference after
the meeting of Azerbaijani, Turkish and Georgian foreign ministers
in Ganja.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

OPEN BORDER WITH TURKEY CONTAINS MORE RISKS THAN BENEFITS FOR ARMENIA -EXPERT

YEREVAN, February 21. / ARKA /. The opening of the Armenian-Turkish
border will hardly bring economic or political benefits to Armenia,
head of Noravank think-tank in Yerevan, Gagik Harutyunyan, said today.

"When considering the probability that Turkey may open the border
with Armenia we should carefully evaluate all the risks and possible
benefits. Our think-tank conducted such an analysis and the findings
suggest that the risks are bigger than potential economic benefits,"
he said.

He said according to experts, Armenia can export to Turkey some 50
types of products, while Turkey is already selling about 500 types
of goods in Armenia.

As for the political benefits, Harurtunyan said Turkey and Azerbaijan
will not abandon the policy of "two states, one nation" and the
opening of borders will not resolve the Karabakh conflict and reduce
the danger of renewed hostilities.

Relations between Armenia and Turkey remain tense because of Ankara's
biased stance on the Karabakh conflict and its painful reaction to
Armenia's efforts to obtain worldwide recognition of the Armenian
Genocide. -0-

- See more at:
http://arka.am/en/news/politics/open_border_with_turkey_contains_more_risks_than_benefits_for_armenia_expert_/#sthash.kXuJylH0.dpuf

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...