Yervant1 Posted August 16, 2013 Report Share Posted August 16, 2013 TWICE-TOLD STORY 800 YEARS APARTCollected By Jirair Tutunjian, Toronto,7 August 2013The furtive, night-time disappearance of the French Army from ArmenianCilicia in 1921 was an eerie echo of what the Frankish Crusadershad done 800 years earlier in Urfa (Edessa). Urfa Armenians hadsupported the Crusaders against the Turks, just as their descendantssupported the French against the Turks in the First World World. Inboth instances, the Armenians had been promised the protection oftheir European "Christian brothers".Here's Russian-French historian and novelist Zoe Oldenburg'sdescription of the Urfa massacre in her magisterial "The Crusades")."What finally happened was one of the greatest disasters in the historyof the Crusades. The responsibility for this catastrophe belongs to theFranks, to the two Baldwins [kings of Jerusalem] in particular and alsoindirectly to Tancred and his somewhat equivocal attitude. The massacreof the inhabitants of the region of Edessa surpassed in horror thatof Jerusalem and the massacres of the Crusading armies in Anatolia.This time it was literally a case of genocide."The Franks had had the unfortunate idea of evacuating the entirecivilian population of the region (including that of the fortifiedcities) to the right bank of the Euphrates, in order to protect theArmenians against the incursions of the Turkish armies and so theywould be better able to defend the strongholds. It hadn't occurredto them to consider the unwisdom of this mass exodus a moment whenthe great Turkish army was in the neighborhood. So hopeless werethey at directing and organizing the county's hoards of peasants andtownspeople, and so badly organized the transport by boat to the otherside of the river, that Mawdud's army found it child's play to fallupon the wretched people gathered on the plain beside the Euphrates.The Armenians were slaughtered in their tens of thousands before thevery eyes of the Franks who, having already crossed river, watchedpowerless while the hideous butchery took place."'The Franks,' wrote Matthew of Edessa [an Armenian chronicler],'shed bitter tears as they contemplated this scene of desolation. Afterthis signal success, Mawdud returned to Harran with masses of captivesand incalculable booty.' The captives were young women and children,whom the Turks generally spared. The men were killed. Those whoflung themselves into the boats were drowned, because the boats wereoverloaded, and the majority of those who tried cross the river byswimming did not reach the further bank. The carnage, says Matthew ofEdessa, was such that 'the waves of the Euphrates ran red with blood...This day saw the depopulation of the whole province of Edessa.' Thisis no exaggeration. A whole rich and fertile province was transformedovernight into a ruined and wasted land-a desert. It never recovered."Clearly the Franks cannot be held responsible for atrocities committedby the Turks, but it must be admitted that the great exodus undertakenat their suggestion constituted a direct provocation to atrocitieswhich, but for that, the Turks would never have committed on sucha vast scale. It is also fair to say that the whole operation musthave been very badly conducted and that the least the Franks couldhave done was to use their army to cover the retreat of the civilianpopulation. Yet the Franks had crossed the river first, knowingfull well that the Turkish army was on the other side. Lastly, theflight of the local Christians from the Turks, like the Turks' angeragainst the Christians, was the direct consequence of the Crusadesthemselves, which had led the Moslems to regard Christians as enemiesby definition."Although the history of the Armenian people has produced more intragic episodes of this kind than any other, on this occasion it canreasonably be said that massacre might easily have been avoided. Withthe best of intentions, the Franks had brought disaster on the headsof their subjects."After this disaster, from which the Franks emerged intact, having lostneither men nor arms, it is understandable that the already falteringconfidence of the Armenians of Edessa in their new lords was badlyshaken. Indeed, their cherished wish was to have a prince of theirown race again. On the other bank of the Euphrates, the ArmenianKogh Vasil, lord of Raban and Kaisum, commanded a strong army,dependent on neither Greeks nor Turks, still less of the Franks inCilicia. Oshin and Thoros I ruled at Lampron and Vahgah as distantvassals of Byzantium but in practice virtually independent. TheArmenians' want of 'loyalty' to Baldwin of Le Bourg [Frankish leader]is therefore quite understandable."http://www.keghart.com/Tutunjian-Cilicia 1 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.