Jump to content

WILLFUL DISREGARD OF REALITY


Yervant1

Recommended Posts

WILLFUL DISREGARD OF REALITY

 

Editorial, June 2013

 

"Oh, Armenian people, your only solution is in your united force."

 

Yeghshe Charents.

 

"Turkey Offers Nuclear Partnership to France if Paris Reviews its

Stance on Armenian Genocide" "Ankara Angry at Recognition of Armenian,

Assyrian and Greek Genocides by New South Wales" "Obama Tells Insurance

Companies Not to Recognize Armenian Property Rights".

 

The above related headlines appeared in Armenian publications in the

same week in May.

 

The first headline is about a nuclear business agreement between Ankara

and Paris. France expects to earn billions in the deal which will

see the French construct Turkey's second nuclear plant. In these hard

times (French general unemployment is 10 %; for young people it's 25%),

President Francoise Hollande knows French-Armenians will not complain

too vociferously if he breaks his word to the Armenian community and

forgets the bill which would have penalized Genocide denial.

 

The second headline is about Ankara's anger at New South Wales in

Australia because that state has recognized the Armenian, Assyrian

and Greek Genocides. Armenians, although few in number in Australia,

received recognition because they formed an alliance with the 400,000-

strong Greek-Australian community and the well-organized 65,000-strong

Assyrian-Australians.

 

The third headline is about President Barak Obama's attempt to sabotage

American-Armenian efforts to recover, from Turkey some of what that

country owes Armenians. Why is Obama working against us?

 

Because we know that Turkey is more important to him than the

million-plus Armenian-Americans.

 

The often-difficult circumstances Armenians have lived for nearly two

millennia have made most of us realists, if not hard-nosed, in our

personal affairs. The realism has helped us survive in our ancestral,

but occupied homeland, and even prosper in foreign shores. We know-in

the words of Euclid-"there's no royal road in life", especially for

Armenians. Most of us are taught, from early age, that we have to

earn our success. So why do we abandon our hard-earned realism when

it comes to international affairs impacting us as a nation? Why do

we suddenly become naïf?

 

When Francois Hollande of France shilly-shallies about his promise to

Armenians, when US presidential candidates promise to recognize the

Genocide but "change their minds" after they take office, and when

the majority of the countries at the UN dismiss our just case... why

are we surprised and indignant?

 

When injustice takes place around the world we shrug and say "the

big fish always eat the small fish" or "states are not moral entities".

 

We know these as bitter realities, but forget them when it pertains

to our national interests and out the window goes "Yeghoonk oonees

kloukht kereh" Armenian proverb.

 

We choose to forget the nature of politics. To re-word an Armenian

phrase, certain American politicians support us not for "our brown

eyes" but because we have a considerable number of votes in their

districts or because Turkish votes are negligible or non-existent.

 

It's rare-as in the case of Canada-where a government acknowledges

the Genocide because it believes in doing the right thing, despite

blackmail and threats by Turkey.

 

It's no accident that Uruguay was the first (1965) to recognize

the Genocide. It did so mostly because the Armenian community in

Uruguay was well organized and the country had no relations with

remote Turkey. France was also a pioneer in Genocide recognition

because there are 400,000 French-Armenians. Although the various

governments of Israel, Jordan, Syria, and Egypt know that Turkey

committed genocide against the Armenians, they will not acknowledge

the fact because Turkey is a friend.

 

Another stark example of the determining role of self-interest in

international politics is the case of Mahatma Gandhi, the much-honored

leader of India's independence movement. "Saintly" Gandhi refused

to condemn the Turks in 1915 because he didn't want to alienate the

Muslim faction in his movement. And he had the nerve to accuse the

British Raj of hypocrisy.

 

Our willful disregard of historic facts goes back millennia. Although

the Crusaders repeatedly betrayed us, we maintained our alliances with

them. We also continued to believe the "Christian" West would save

us from the Ottoman sultans, although Britain, Germany and Austria

sided with the vicious Sublime Porte.

 

We bemoan that we desperately need unity of vision and action in

our national and local affairs but turn around and boast about our

own individualism. We blame Armenians for being "all chiefs and no

Indians" and then act like single-minded, prescient pundits.

 

We pride ourselves that we are an industrious and peaceful people

who have not coveted their neighbors' lands. In the same breath we

express pride in Medzn Dikran who had six kings chained to his victory

chariot and who conquered most of Asia Minor and the Middle East. A

psychiatrist or neurologist might diagnose that perhaps various parts

of our brains have delinked from one another.

 

Throughout history conquerors have habitually changed the toponyms

(place names) of the lands they have conquered and introduced names

of their own liking to underline their ownership of the land. Due

to historic vicissitudes in ancient Armenia Minor ("Pokr Hayk"),

towns and regions called Sber, Nicopolis, Aghuyn, Taranghi, Mouzour,

Tasdarag, Gohombeneh, Khorsapia, Posatourn, Kuntusa had disappeared

long before the Seljuks drowned the land in blood. Over the centuries

Urfa (now Sanliurfa) has been called Urhoy, Urha, Urhai, Riha,

Justinopolis, and Edessa. Adana was Adaniya, Edene, Batana, Ezene,

Erdene, Ta Adana, Azzana... Marash (now Kahramanmarash) was Germanicia

Caesaria, Kermanig. Aintab (now Gaziaintab) was called Hantab/Hatab by

Crusaders, Khantap by Hittites, as well as Ayintaba. What Armenians

now call Lake Van was Pzounyah or Dosba Dzov in ancient times while

Lake Sevan was Gaboudan, Kegharkouni, Keghama Dzov. But despite the

universal custom of toponym changing, Armenians continue to get irate

when they hear Turkey has replaced Armenian place names with Turkish

ones. One Armenian author has even published a book on the dastardly

deed of the Turk.

 

We have every right to remind the world of the toponym changes,

but we also have to admit that since Turkey occupies our mountains,

rivers, lakes and cities fulminating about what Turkey has done and

is doing is waste of our energies.

 

We have to tackle our national challenges the way we face our personal

problems. We have to be realistic and remember how diplomacy has

always operated. We should discard our delusions about ourselves

and others. We should look into the mirror-blemishes and all. And

we should not lead ourselves down the garden path-there are odar

volunteers on standby for that job.

 

http://www.keghart.com/Editorial-Reality

  • Like 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...