Boghos Posted February 3, 2002 Report Share Posted February 3, 2002 From ANN Groong: "The Vice Chairman of the True Path Party, Mr Hasan Ekinci, issued a pressstatement last week charging that Christian minorities in Turkey are athreat to national security and that they should not be allowed the samerights as the Muslim citizens of the country. As minorities protestedagainst this statement, Mrs Tansu Ciller, the Chairperson of the same partytelephoned Patriarch Mesrob on Friday, 1 February, to say she was "sorry"for her deputy's public statement, and that she respected the rights of theminorities in Turkey." Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted February 4, 2002 Report Share Posted February 4, 2002 boghos, pm silvio berlusconi of italy made a statement after the 11th september attacks saying that "the islamic civilisation is infreior to ours, and that we ought to be proud of ours, and not let them in etc" or something to that effect, to the amazement and strong condenmation of a substantial majority of the eu population. there are (or were) far right EMPs in the european parliament, who made statements comparable to that of ekinci regrading the muslims and other europeans of non-european origin. one of the pillars of the eu is freedom of speech. now god was most generous in handing out the faculty of speech to almost everyone, but he was a little bit less generous with the faculty of making sense when one speaks, hence the remarks of ekinci. under the turkish penal code currently in force, imbecility is not a criminal offence. in fact in turkey it is a highly useful trait, making a successful career in politics a good deal easier, as a cursory glance at out national parliament would reveal. currently the legal system is undergoing revision to match eu standards, but as far as i know, the penal code does not identify imbecility as a criminal offence, either. so we will have such people making some statements. maybe his was a belated reaction to the recent row over the movie (the beads of salkım hanım). at any rate, even a half-wit like ciller had the good sense to apologise to the patriarch, so i think we should regards this guy as an enfant terrible and not put too much store to his actions. do not forget: what you say about something says as much about you as it does about the thing you are talking about. regards, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Boghos Posted February 4, 2002 Author Report Share Posted February 4, 2002 Dear Ali, *let me answer to your posting and add a few other ideas* I don´t think an act or speech by Berlusconi or Haider or whomever justifies somebody else´s idiocy. Don´t be defensive. Keep in mind that however ridiculous and right wing populist Berlusconi is, he never advocated second class rights to anybody in the EU or Italy. Ekinci is just stating the obvious: since christians (read: Armenians) have de facto second class rights, let´s make it de jure so. I also understand that he might be directing his discourse to the Islamists. But in any case Turkey´s secular democracy seems to be unavoidably becoming less so, no less because the counter force to islamic political presence is not an improvement in democratic institutions but quite the contrary. A country that feels weak and threatened will almost always move to the right. That is the case, unfortunately, of Turkey. Turkey is arguably the longest living Third World military dictatorship either explicitly or implicitly. And there resides the problem: the belief, even by many so called left leaning Turks, that the military are the guardians of secularism and hence, democracy. That simply is not so. Isn´it interesting that there is an Alparslan Turkesh bulvar in Ankara ? The extreme right in Turkey has much more legitimacy than that of any European country, France included. I remember when he passed away, I was in Istanbul, all the papers reported his death as that of an elderly patriot that served the Republic so well. The only mild exception was Cumhuriyet. [ February 04, 2002: Message edited by: Boghos ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Fadi Posted February 5, 2002 Report Share Posted February 5, 2002 Ali, even if it seem to mean the same, from what I recall from Berlusconi, it is not exaclly what he said. What he said was more like. "Our Eastern Civilisation is a superior civilisation then the Islamic civilisation" its something like this if I remember. Second, I agree with Boghos that this kind of acts or speechs etc... can not be justified by finding other speech... this statment by Berlusconi, was also said in the media's in a more indirect way. When something happened that was behind any proportion for the West, it was in the mind of many, an Islamic civilisation crime against Christian civilisation. This statment was not made in normal time, and it would be surprising that anything like this would have been said by a prime minister or a ministary or whatever in a normal time. What he said, was like "politically correctly" acceptable(in Western world) in that moment of rage. [ February 04, 2002: Message edited by: Domino ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted February 5, 2002 Report Share Posted February 5, 2002 dear Domino, dear boghos, i was not trying to be defensive, nor was i trying to defend the idiotic statement of ekinci. but the simple matter is this: the guy has made his way into the parliament, and this system called democracy that we admittedly do not administer very well, gives you the right of speech. so he speaks. what can you do, if you are ciller (not that she is any better), other than apologise to the patriarch. if you get him chucked out of your party, he'll move to anap or mhp, and of course by getting himself terminated over such a matter he'll be the darling martyr of the grey wolves, ensuring a step upward. i know that you do not much enjoy turkish in this forum, but allow me to add one couplet that (in my humble opinion) summarises the issue reasonably well (sorry for the rude nature of it): sıçtı cafer bez getirsulu sıçtı tez getir those who know turkish may perhaps come up with a matching english or armenian equivalent for the benefit of the forum members. (mj sorry for the rude word it contains) regards, ali suat Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.