Yervant1 Posted December 2, 2012 Report Share Posted December 2, 2012 WILL RUSSIA REALLY MODIFY ITS TRADITIONAL POLICY TOWARDS TURKEY? http://artsakhtert.com/eng/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=858:-will-russia-really-modify-its-traditional-policy-towards-turkey&catid=5:politics&Itemid=17Friday, 30 November 2012 15:17 Recently, well-known Russian political analyst Michael Alexandrov hasissued an article titled `Turkish gambit: will the Russian leadershiprepeat the Bolsheviks' error?', in which he analyzed theRussian-Turkish relations as of the Soviet Union creation up today andconcluded that continuation of the traditional policy by the RussianFederation's current leadership would contradict the interests ofRussia. It should be noted that the political analyst's emphases areof special interest for the Armenian party in the sense that they aredirectly related to the events in the Armenian people's life takenplace in the second decade of the last century and to theirconsequences.Also worthy of attention are the observations on the neo-Ottomanpolicy of the Turkish leadership and the need to oppose it.What is today's Turkey in the Middle East? It is no secret that withinthe region this country claims to be a superpower backed by the U.S.and NATO power. One of the main directions of the American policy isimplementation of the program `Great Middle East', which can berealized with the increase of Turkey's role and influence in theregion. Russian political scientist M. Alexandrov refers to thecurrent military-political realities associated with the blockade ofIran. The Americans deployed a radar station in Turkey, which isconsidered a component of the U.S. missile defense system. With thebeginning of the 'Arab spring', Ankara enthusiastically joined theWest's efforts to change the regimes in the North Africa countries.According to the political analyst, restoring its influence in theArab world, Turkey will be able to restore the Ottoman Empire, in itsnew form. In the foreign policy, this course was called`neo-Ottomanism'. There is a nuance in this process - while in thepast Turkey played this role exclusively alone, nowadays it isrepresented as a carrier of Western powers' interests in the region. It is needless to note that the Bolshevism period put its black stampon the Armenian people's history. Basing its foreign policy on thesocialist revolution ideology, in the 20s of the last century, Russiadeprived the Armenian people of its historical homeland, sacrificingan entire nation for its own geopolitical ambitions. `Leader of theworld proletariat' Vladimir Lenin strongly wished to make Turkey itsstrategic ally to struggle against the Western imperialism. The 1921Moscow Treaty is a bright evidence of it. By the way, Russians saythat Moscow made great territorial concessions to Turkey by thetreaty. But, it is not a correct definition for us Armenians: thetruth is that the Bolsheviks simply gifted Armenian territories toTurkey - the country, which was defeated in the World War I and whichwas threatened with the danger of disappearing from the world map.Among the Soviet figures, only Chicherin opposed the defeatist policy,but his position did not play a significant role. Kemal Atatürk sent aletter to the Soviet Government, which, in particular, read: «Wepledge to join all our works and military operations with the effortsof the Russian Bolsheviks in order to fight against imperialistgovernments and to liberate all the oppressed». This was not a simpleapplication - Ataturk won a diplomatic victory over the Russians, orrather deceived «all the oppressed». It deceived the leader, which wasnaïve enough to believe that Turkey's Communist Party can become apolitical support for it. But, the father of the Turks planned anotherscenario for this party. The Armenian people greatly suffered from theMoscow Treaty, while the Russians began to provide economic aid toTurkey, as Kemal Ataturk had pledged to join the efforts of theRussian Bolsheviks. Michael Alexandrov refers to Russia's assistanceto Turkey in a large number of weapons and ammunition for creating abasis for the military industry in 1920-1922s. The political analyst notes that as of today the Moscow Treaty isevaluated by the Russian Foreign Ministry as an important diplomaticachievement and even on March 16, 2006, Russia and Turkey marked the85th anniversary of the Treaty. The parties exchanged congratulatorytelegrams. Meanwhile, the Russians had the greatest chance to collapsethe Turkish state by the Brest Treaty. The Armenian historiographyassessment is that the Russians did not only help Turkey recover, butalso gifted it entire Western Armenia. We should note that withRussia's support this country turned into a predatory state in thewhole Middle East region. So, it was a victory for Turkey, and Turkeywill always celebrate this victory. And what about Russia?... And here, M. Alexandrov, without sparing hisown country's rating, states: «With whom else could the Turks signsuch an unprecedented and successful treaty?' Perhaps no country inthe world would make such a shameful deal. And why should Turkey beagainst developing relations with Moscow, basing on the sameprinciples? The economic cooperation between the two countries isincreasing with time - the indexes testify to the growth in the volumeof the commodity circulation. We should pay attention to some emphases in the article. On a seriesof important issues, the Turkish foreign policy does not coincide withthe Russian interests, and moreover, it contradicts them. It concerns,first of all, the Karabakh conflict, in which Ankara actuallyencourages Baku in displaying intransigence. Turkey maintains theeconomic and transport blockade of Russia's strategic ally Armenia,denying the idea of establishing diplomatic relations and opening theborder with it. On the other hand, Turkey is an active participant ofNABUCCO project, which also runs counter to Russian interests. Ankarahas set its control over the Black Sea straits, limiting the volumesof the Russian oil exports via sea. Turkey has also joined theAmerican Air Defense system. Today, Turkey's aggressive policy towardsRussia's ally Syria is obvious. The only compromise between the RF andTurkey is that Ankara has refused to support the Chechen terrorists,and in response to this, the Russians have refused to support theKurdish Workers' Party of Turkey. But, Turkey in no way refuses tocooperate with the Cherkess separatists in the North Caucasus, inspite of Russia's request. Michael Alexandrov concludes that in this case President Putin shouldseriously think over the prospects of the Russian-Turkish relations,because there is a danger that the RF President can repeat the RussianBolsheviks' wrong policy conducted in 1920s. I think we can make some additions to Russian political scientist'sanalysis related to Yeltsin-period Russia's foreign policy in theWest, which allows us to state that the post-Soviet diplomacy towardsTurkey in no way differs from the Soviet one. After the collapse ofthe USSR, Boris Yeltsin visited Bulgaria. At an event within thevisit, Bulgaria's President stated that his country was orientedtowards the West, and the regulation of the Russian-Bulgarianrelations did not mean a return to the past. The RF President voicedno sentence in response to this statement. Then, long discussions tookplace on this visit: Moscow's political circles openly stated thatYeltsin actually dealt a great blow to his own and his country'sreputation. The post-Soviet events in the Balkans also allowedunderstanding the directions of the Russian-Turkish relations -Russia's new leadership continued supporting the West in attacking itstraditional bases. The situation in the Middle East and the Syriancrisis in particular are obvious manifestations of this policy. TheUSA, being Turkey's major ally and strategic partner, restrains itsappetite, if necessary. It turns out that only the USA is able torelease Turkey's hands, or, if necessary, to put pressure on it. Asthey say, the control panel is in Washington. In this case, the Russians really have only to sing 'chastushka' underthe Turkish mugham. But, as Russia will thus lose its influence in theMiddle East, the political mind suggests Vladimir Putin that Russiacan play an active role in a series of issues, using its levers ofinfluence; particularly in the Armenian Genocide issue, it shoulddemonstrate that the policy of Ottomanism, from which the Armenianpeople suffered, is a great threat to humanity. Ruzan ISHKHANIAN Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.