Guest Posted September 13, 2000 Report Share Posted September 13, 2000 I never thought I would post here again. Well, you know, many people like to identify by color and race especially if they are influenced by the Western way of thoughts. I am Chinese, and we never had this concept. My people only identify through their common culture of 8,000 years. Our race incorporated many different nationalities and it is still continuing this process today. It really bothers me when I visit Korean and Japanese forums and those people there constantly talk and brag about their supposed kinship with the Mongols and the Turks only because they all speak Altaic languages. Yet, scholars are still not firm in their research especially with the inclusion of Korean and Japanese into this language group. And, in their forums they also constantly belittle everything Chinese as if we never existed. It gives me a sense of them having some inferior complexes. Needless to say, Chinese do not have to remind Koreans, Japanese, Vietnamese, Thais, Laotians, Burmese, etc. of where they got their written language, food, architecture styles, music, philosophy, religion, etc. We know it was all from us, and not from Genghis Khan (Jengiz Han). It is also hard to imagine how Koreans can claim kinship with the Turks of Turkey. They are both completely different; believe me. Yet, there is an ancient relation between the nomadic ancestors of the Turks and their struggles against the Chinese. Why is it that whereever Turkish people have migrated to, they have never lived peacefully among its neighbors? From China all the way to modern Anatolia, they have left a trail of bloodshed and horror. They are a predatory race. They take by force what nature has denied them. Chinese history can attest to this. From the very beginning, many thousands of years ago, the Turkish ancestors (Huns) have endlessly fought the Chinese. The Great Wall in China kept them at a distance. Occasionally, they raided deep into China. And, sometimes, the Chinese under strong generals counter-attacked, chased and raided back into the Huns pasture lands in Mongolia. Around 100 A.D.s, a brilliant Chinese general--Prince Ban Chao fought an all-out war against the Turkish Huns. He beheaded and lopped off the heads of the hated Huns. All the adult Hun males were slaughtered; and the Chinese armies pursued them into what is now the country of Ukraine. All the adult Huns were killed. So many were killed, that it is said that only children and weak Hun women survived. These remnants of the Huns rejuvenated 3 centuries later under Attila and sacked Rome. Some of Gen. Ban Chao's officers and soldiers remained in Iranian empire and Black Sea area on goodwill missions and to safeguard the Chinese caravans carrying silk along Central Asia. After this victorious bloodbath and cleansing of the Huns from China, one obedient tribe of the Huns were allowed to remain in China and serve as border guards. They later changed their tribal name to "Goksalan Turk," or "Sky Braves." They, too later became strong enough in the 5th cent. to constantly raid China. Then, in the late 7th cent. A.D., China was reunified under a vigorous and warrior aristocrat. Emperor Li Shimin was half-Chinese and half-Turkish (Dulgor tribe on his mom's side). He understood Turkish tribal warfare methods. Unlike some other Chinese emperors, he not only felt content to drive the Turks back beyond the Great Wall. But, he even took the offensive and invaded their territories. Employing the best Kung-fu skilled warriors, polished good Chinese sabers, banners raised, the soldiers marched off playing the Chinese drums, cymbals and the sorna (Chinese folk oboe). Everywhere they met success against the Turks. From 620s-640s A.D., Li Shimin decisively beat back the Turks and eventually enslaved them. He was recognized as their "heavenly Khan." All the Turks were deported into China proper. For many years, the Chinese nation lived in peace, prosperity and celebrations. Some Turks themselves eventually assimilated into the Chinese race. But, some complained of inhumane treatment and abuse. In the early 700 A.D.s, one tribe broke away under Bilga Kagan and his adviser, Kultegin. They fled back into Mongolia and developed the first Turkish written language (still used by Mongols today). Their descendants were later betrayed by their kindred Uigur tribes. The combined Uigur-Chinese armies finally crushed the Turks and they moved on to Central Asia and the Middle East under a new Oguz confederacy. Today, the Uigur Turks are still a minority group controlled by China. Their ancestors willingly surrendered to the Chinese king. They chose to be Chinese, and they are "Chinese Turks." I learned to speak some of their language and I know about how they feel. I remember 2 years ago, a Turkish tourist middle-aged man from Izmir visited Beijing, China. He toured the Great Wall of China. He knelt and kissed the wall. He then said: "Allah Wakbah." Myself and this tall Chinese policeman cornered him and asked what he meant by all this? He said in English: "That his blood and ancestry belonged here on this wall." The Chinese policeman find out his intentions, and then with much joy hugged this Turkish tourist. And, I said: "This wall is the heritage of everyone. So many people died on this wall." I said in broken accent Uigur language: "Hosh galdanez. Chok menet tarum. Esem miseh bizim. Yalla Alla." To my surprise, this Turkish man understood everything I said. All the words. He hugged me, and we all took pictures. Chok menet tarum- I am grateful. Chinese and Turks today are no longer enemies. But, we dumped the trash for other unfortunate people to clean up. Chinese were enemies of Turks in ancient past. Now, Armenians, Arabs, Greeks, Russians and Iranians carry this burden. The Chinese ancestry of Mamikonyan family makes this even more interesting, because their early Chinese ancestors may have fought Turks on the Great Wall in China. Chinese-Turks-Armenians all had a shared linkage and destiny. Armenian brothers (as well as Iran), hang in there! Your day will someday come. If we did it to the Turks 1,300 years ago, then you can too. We pass our war banners on to you. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted September 14, 2000 Report Share Posted September 14, 2000 Wow! What an excellent post! So full of insight into the savage origins of the Turks. Damn, they started their crap way way back! My only hope for Turkey, is that one day they will realize that they are not Turks. It is similar to how the Indigenous peoples of Latin America are realizing that they have been deceived and robbed, and taught to hate their heritage by their Spanish conquerors. There is a gradual awakening of these people (For the best insight into this listen to Rage Against the Machine's "People of the Sun)." You know, I have never cared for the Kurds, due to my family's prejudice, but I admire how they are at the forefront battling the Turkish Deceit State. One day the indigenous peoples of the land that we now call Turkey will rise up reconquer. The Kurds are already doing this with their rapid birthrate which will eventually surpass that of the "Turks." The Cumhuriyeti Turkiye will come crashing down, as it is built on the blood that cries to the heaven's for vengeance. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted September 14, 2000 Report Share Posted September 14, 2000 chinese scholar, I have asked you something about the relationship between mamigon and kala mamukan in the other topic. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Guest Posted September 14, 2000 Report Share Posted September 14, 2000 First quake reaction to this article by opponents >>>I don't quite understand... OB (Turk) - from IP address 195.34.133.61 September 14 2000 at 8:26 AM ...how you speak of "living in peace" first, and handing over the banner of war to your Armenian brothers afterwards... Besides, your description of the historical events show that not only Turks were an agressive nation and slaughtered a lot of other nations, but also your Chinese ancestors, if not more. That's the second discrepance in your essay... As if other nations had been less agressive in their history... Look at the history of every empire, colonialist or local. Look at the crusades. Look at USA today. Have they been less bloody? Another discrepance is that you have the guts to call the Uighurs in western China as satisfied, peaceful Chinese citizens, many of them feeling Chinese... This is simply not true. There is an ongoing struggle of the Uighurs against the oppressive Chinese regime today. Anyone denying this looks like an ostrich hiding his head in the sand. So, what is your intention, praising peace or adverseness?... ************************************************ >>> I found a few contradictory and incorrect statements in your post.FJ (Jew) - from IP address 207.245.95.87September 14 2000 at 9:36 AM First, you called the Turks a "predatory race". Yet, you praise the Chinese for annihilating every male Hun and rejoice at the "victorious bloodbath and cleansing of the Huns from China". Sounds like a massive double-standard to me. Who did Huns cleansed and whose male population have they eliminated? Second, Mongols do not use ancient writing for their language today. Instead, cyrillyc-based alphabet is used. Third, you mention Atilla's Huns, Blue Turks and Oguz confederacy as the only strong Turcic empires. But what about Khazar Empire, most remarkable Jewish-Turcic state? It existed from about 300 to 900 AD and was a model for inclusive and tolerant society. Something Chinese can not even manage today. Are you excluding it because it doesn't fit your "predatory race" theory? Finally, my friend's girlfriend is Uighur. Interestingly enough, she has no kind words for the Chinese. Perhaps is because a good half of her family was slaughtered by them in 1950s. The survivors fled into then-Soviet Khazakhstan and remained there. Curiously, even the US consul was aware of the "friendly" treatment of her people by the Chinese: as soon as she mentioned her ethnicity and her parents' place of birth, he gave her a legal US refugee status. ************************************************ >>> Thank You, Friend..and a Hearty "Sip Fun Do Cha" for this article..CH (Chinese-Orthodox Christian) - from IP address 136.223.4.40September 14 2000 at 10:21 AM Thank You.. Post more. Disregard the Zionist and Liberal and the Turk Ob. ************************************************ Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
kyuneli Posted September 1, 2001 Report Share Posted September 1, 2001 To Chinese Scholar,Construction of the Great Wall started in the 7th century B.C. The vassal states under the Zhou Dynasty in the northern parts of the country each built their own walls to protect them against neighboring Chinese Clans. After the state of Qin unified China in 221 B.C., it joined the walls to hold off the invaders from the Xiongnu tribes in the north and extended them to more than 10,000 li or 5,000 kilometers. This is the origin of the name Of the "10,000-li Great Wall".and it did not keep outKublai Khan Kublai Khan (1215-1294), Mongol military leader, founder and first emperor (1279-1294) of the Mongol Yuan dynasty in China, grandson of the Mongol conqueror Genghis Khan and his best-known successor. Kublai Khan completed the conquest of China that was begun by his grandfather. From 1252 to 1259 he aided his brother Mangu Khan in the conquest of southern China, penetrating successfully as far as Tibet and Tonkin. Upon the death of Mangu in 1259 he became the khan, or ruler. Between 1260 and 1279 he succeeded in driving the Kin Tatars out of northern China and in subduing rebellious factions among the Mongols. In 1264 he founded his capital on the site now occupied by Beijing; it was called Khanbalik, which is romanized as Cambaluc or Cambalu. He relinquished all claims to the parts of the Mongol Empire outside China, consolidated his hold on China, and in 1279 established the Yuan dynasty as the successor to the Southern Song dynasty. He undertook foreign wars in attempts to enforce tribute claims on neighboring states, conquering Burma (now known as Myanmar) and Korea. His military expeditions to Java and Japan, however, met with disaster. His name was known all over Asia and also in Europe. The court at Cambaluc attracted an international group of adventurous men, including the famous Venetian traveler Marco Polo. Kublai Khan did much to encourage the advancement of literature and the arts. He was a devout Buddhist and made Buddhism the state religion, but during his reign other religions were also tolerated.Kamil Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted September 6, 2001 Report Share Posted September 6, 2001 to chinese scholar before talking about turkish barbarism, have a look at what china is doing to the tibetans, uighur turks and other minorities in china and the international condemnation it receives. also, do not forget the dozens of famines inside china throughout last century and this one that the chinese government - unsuccessfully - tried to hush up. i have enormous respect for the chinese civilisation, not least because of the very crucial contributions they made to mankind, not the least of which are paper, the printing press, paper currency, porcelain, the compass, gunpowder, silk, tea, and the smallpox vaccine. i also respect the chinese greatly for still preserving a written tradition that stretches back to almost 1500 BC. but, with all due respect, barbarism has unfortunately been a companion of all civilisations from the greek to the mayan, and the chinese one is no exception. also, please do not forget that amongst your contributions to mankind numerated above, all of them save silk, the compass, tea, and porcelain were passed to the rest of mankind by uighur turks (paper, the printing press, the smallpox vaccine), or the mongols (printed currency, gunpowder). they were not the only things. both the turkish and later the mongol empires created a pax turcica and mongolica which enabled the silk route to function properly. and surprise surprise, as soon as the mongol empire fell, the silk route collapsed because there was no central authority to protect it, and wasn't one until the russian invasion of central asia in the 19th century, and that, as we all know very well, contributed little (so to speak) to the reemergence of the silk route. if left on your own, you would not have passed a thing to the rest of mankind in your splendid isolation as "the middle kingdom", you arrogant lot. one final note: i am sure as a scholar you know the things the shang dynasty (first recorded dynasty of china, traditionally considered to be the inventors of chinese writing) used to do with the skulls of their victims, don't you? regards, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted September 6, 2001 Report Share Posted September 6, 2001 “Well, you know, many people like to identify by color and race especially if they are influenced by the Western way of thoughts. I am Chinese, and we never had this concept. My people only identify through their common culture of 8,000 years.” This is not entirely accurate. African students in China complained aboutChinese racism in international platforms, and the Chinese throughout history referred to Turks and other “northern barbarians” as “fire-haired monkeys”. The Chinese still refer to the non-Han minorities in southern China as “monkeys”. A Chinese-paid English academic at Oxford is known to hava said that “the Chinese say that they brought morals to Tibet, all of whom had venereal disease” to which the reply on the Tibetan side was “you know how we call venereal disease in Tibetan? Chinese disease!” “Our race incorporated many different nationalities and it is still continuing this process today.” In a process called forced assimilation and, at times, genocide. Your race is currently conducting above-ground nuclear tests in the vicinity of Uighur cities in Sinkiang to make sure that all the Uighurs get radiated and are unable to reproduce viable offspring. “It really bothers me when I visit Korean and Japanese forums and those people there constantly talk and brag about their supposed kinship with the Mongols and the Turks only because they all speak Altaic languages.” If people speak related languages, then you have a strong case that they are related. For instance, hate it though Tibetans may, they cannot ignore the fact that their language belongs to the Tibeto-Burman subgroup of the Sino-Tibetan languages, the “Sino” part of which refers to the Chinese dialects. “Yet, scholars are still not firm in their research especially with the inclusion of Korean and Japanese into this language group.” This is true, but there are two theories that are gaining ground these days: 1) that the Indo-European, Uralic, Altaic, Inuit (Eskimo) and most Paleosiberian languages belong to one vast Eurasiatic family, and 2) it is the Austroneasian elements in both Korean and Japanese that blur the picture, otherwise, their inclusion in the Altaic family appears to be pretty sound (to those who are not linguists: Austronesian languages are those that are spoken in Indonesia, Malaysia, Polynesia, Micronesia, Melanesia and Madagascar, in addition to a few islands off southern China.). “And, in their forums they also constantly belittle everything Chinese as if we never existed. It gives me a sense of them having some inferior complexes. Needless to say, Chinese do not have to remind Koreans, Japanese, Vietnamese, Thais, Laotians, Burmese, etc. of where they got their written language, food, architecture styles, music, philosophy, religion, etc. We know it was all from us, and not from Genghis Khan (Jengiz Han).” If they do that they are an immature and ignorant bunch. Just ignore them. “It is also hard to imagine how Koreans can claim kinship with the Turks of Turkey. They are both completely different; believe me.” The Swedes and Bangladeshis are kinsmen even though they are completely different from one another. “Why is it that wherever Turkish people have migrated to, they have never lived peacefully among its neighbors? From China all the way to modern Anatolia, they have left a trail of bloodshed and horror. They are a predatory race. They take by force what nature has denied them. Chinese history can attest to this.” The same holds true of the early and later Greeks in Antiquity (the Greeks arrived in Northern Greece shortly after 2000 BC, and expanded to the south a few centuries later, and there is a 400-year long break in the archaeological record of the area between 1200 BC-800 BC, when they had destroyed the indigenous civilisation and later established their own culture), of the Romans (“They make a wilderness and call it an Empire, they make a desert and call it Peace” in the words of the Carthaginians), of the Vikings, the Russians, the Byzantines (ask the Armenians in this Forum what the Byzantines had done to them prior to our arrival and how the Cilician kingdom came into being), the Indians, the Persians, the Vikings (ancestors of the Scandinavians, the most peaceful and civilized members of Europe today), the Europeans of the last 500 years, the Mayans, the Inca, practically everyone who built an Empire. The difference between all of them and you is that your trails of blood and horror were largely confined to China, to your own people, and ours was spread to Eurasia because Eurasia being southern Siberia, subject to permafrost nine months a year, is not exactly conducive to the existence of large numbers of human beings. So whenever there was a population increase, or people have had enough of the killing cold and dreary pastures and realised life was better to the south and west, they migrated south and west. Not because they were bloodthirsty savages. “Around 100 A.D.s, a brilliant Chinese general--Prince Ban Chao fought an all-out war against the Turkish Huns. He beheaded and lopped off the heads of the hated Huns. All the adult Hun males were slaughtered; and the Chinese armies pursued them into what is now the country of Ukraine. All the adult Huns were killed. So many were killed, that it is said that only children and weak Hun women survived.” Speaking of genocides…. “After this victorious bloodbath and cleansing of the Huns from China, one obedient tribe of the Huns were allowed to remain in China and serve as border guards. They later changed their tribal name to "Goksalan Turk," or "Sky Braves." “ The name is “Göktürk” (originally “Köktürk” , dear. It means Blue Turks or Sky, Celestial Turks. “They, too later became strong enough in the 5th cent. to constantly raid China. Then, in the late 7th cent. A.D., China was reunified under a vigorous and warrior aristocrat. Emperor Li Shimin was half-Chinese and half-Turkish (Dulgor tribe on his mom's side). He understood Turkish tribal warfare methods. Unlike some other Chinese emperors, he not only felt content to drive the Turks back beyond the Great Wall. But, he even took the offensive and invaded their territories.” So it took a half-Turk to unite you guys defeat the full-Turks, the Chinese could not do either themselves. “Employing the best Kung-fu skilled warriors, polished good Chinese sabers, banners raised, the soldiers marched off playing the Chinese drums, cymbals and the sorna (Chinese folk oboe).“ Sorna is what we call zurna, and comes from Iran. The Armenians have it, too. By the way, Kung-Fu is a more recent invention, I thought, was it in place that far back in time? (only curious). “Everywhere they met success against the Turks. From 620s-640s A.D., Li Shimin decisively beat back the Turks and eventually enslaved them. He was recognized as their "heavenly Khan." All the Turks were deported into China proper. For many years, the Chinese nation lived in peace, prosperity and celebrations.” Not all, dear. The Oghuz (my ancestors) were to the west of those enslaved. “Some Turks themselves eventually assimilated into the Chinese race. But, some complained of inhumane treatment and abuse.” Can you tell us why? “In the early 700 A.D.s, one tribe broke away under Bilga Kagan and his adviser, Kultegin. They fled back into Mongolia and developed the first Turkish written language (still used by Mongols today). Their descendants were later betrayed by their kindred Uigur tribes. The combined Uigur-Chinese armies finally crushed the Turks and they moved on to Central Asia and the Middle East under a new Oguz confederacy.” This is a bit of an over-simplification but generally true as a nutshell history. At that time, “Turk” was a name given to a small group of Turkic tribes. “Today, the Uigur Turks are still a minority group controlled by China. Their ancestors willingly surrendered to the Chinese king. They chose to be Chinese, and they are "Chinese Turks." I learned to speak some of their language and I know about how they feel. I remember 2 years ago, a Turkish tourist middle-aged man from Izmir visited Beijing, China. He toured the Great Wall of China. He knelt and kissed the wall. He then said: "Allah Wakbah." Myself and this tall Chinese policeman cornered him and asked what he meant by all this? He said in English: "That his blood and ancestry belonged here on this wall." The Chinese policeman find out his intentions, and then with much joy hugged this Turkish tourist. And, I said: "This wall is the heritage of everyone. So many people died on this wall." I said in broken accent Uigur language: "Hosh galdanez. Chok menet tarum. Esem miseh bizim. Yalla Alla." To my surprise, this Turkish man understood everything I said. All the words. He hugged me, and we all took pictures. Chok menet tarum- I am grateful. Chinese and Turks today are no longer enemies. But, we dumped the trash for other unfortunate people to clean up.” “Allah Wakbah” is probably a horrible corruption of “God is Greatest” (Allahu Akbar) in Arabic. As for “yalla alla” I can’t make head or tail of it, even though I am familiar with a good many Turkic languages, including Uighur. Besides, your apparently friendly encounter with this man is in stark contrast to the lines following it, don’t you think so? “Chinese were enemies of Turks in ancient past. Now, Armenians, Arabs, Greeks, Russians and Iranians carry this burden. The Chinese ancestry of Mamikonyan family makes this even more interesting, because their early Chinese ancestors may have fought Turks on the Great Wall in China. Chinese-Turks-Armenians all had a shared linkage and destiny. Armenian brothers (as well as Iran), hang in there! Your day will someday come. If we did it to the Turks 1,300 years ago, then you can too. We pass our war banners on to you.” So shall we wish you good luck in a future genocide of the Turks to be carried out by most of Eurasia, or what? Grow up, man. You seem to be an intelligent guy in some places. You can do better than that. Regards, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted September 6, 2001 Report Share Posted September 6, 2001 quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:to chinese scholarbefore talking about turkish barbarism, have a look at what china is doing to the tibetans, uighur turks and other minorities in china and the international condemnation it receives. also, do not forget the dozens of famines inside china throughout last century and this one that the chinese government - unsuccessfully - tried to hush up. one also wonders why taiwan (free china) is still not uniting with mainland china. is there something they don't like about it, and if there is, what is it? also why did so many people try to leave hong kong when it was about to get united with china? could tienanmen have something to do with it?i have enormous respect for the chinese civilisation, not least because of the very crucial contributions they made to mankind, not the least of which are paper, the printing press, paper currency, porcelain, the compass, gunpowder, silk, tea, and the smallpox vaccine. i also respect the chinese greatly for still preserving a written tradition that stretches back to almost 1500 BC. but, with all due respect, barbarism has unfortunately been a companion of all civilisations from the greek to the mayan, and the chinese one is no exception. also, please do not forget that amongst your contributions to mankind numerated above, all of them save silk, the compass, tea, and porcelain were passed to the rest of mankind by uighur turks (paper, the printing press, the smallpox vaccine), or the mongols (printed currency, gunpowder). they were not the only things. both the turkish and later the mongol empires created a pax turcica and mongolica which enabled the silk route to function properly. and surprise surprise, as soon as the mongol empire fell, the silk route collapsed because there was no central authority to protect it, and wasn't one until the russian invasion of central asia in the 19th century, and that, as we all know very well, contributed little (so to speak) to the reemergence of the silk route.if left on your own, you would not have passed a thing to the rest of mankind in your splendid isolation as "the middle kingdom", you arrogant lot. one final note: i am sure as a scholar you know the things the shang dynasty (first recorded dynasty of china, traditionally considered to be the inventors of chinese writing) used to do with the skulls of their victims, don't you? regards, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
whiteangel Posted January 3, 2002 Report Share Posted January 3, 2002 I might be a little too late in joining this discussion topic. But, Mr. Ali Suat represents the classic example of the Turkic nationalism that seeks to usurp other people's accomplishments and claim the fame. This is utter distortion of truth. They have been doing this to the Sumerian, Chinese and Persian accomplishment and history for far too long. Visit any Turkic website on the Internet and you find ample examples of this. Often, they do not have the adequate studies and source to back up their claims. What does he mean by "Uighur people carrying Chinese culture into the Near East and Europe?" He has not studied that the downfall of the Silk Road was caused by the Islamic Arab and Turkish invasions/destruction in the area. Prior to that the Chinese, Sogdians, Bactrians, Indians, Persians, Armenians, Byzantines traded freely and without disruption for centuries on the Silk Routes. If you read the history of Dvin, the Arsacids in Iran, you will find the interactions of ancient China, Persia and Armenia. Before the Turks ever left Mongolia. Even during the Mongol era, it was Chinese agents themselves who carried the influence and stimulus to the West (not the Uighurs). Read on: "The Chinese blood of many Russians and Persians. Unknown to many... Little do we know that Europe and the West was not as mighty as it is now. Many white people, for example the Russians and Iranians may have a trace of Chinese ancestry. This I found out from another site: While numerous foreigners came to China in the Mongol era, there was also a movement in the opposite direction. This has obviously attracted less interest in the West. A host of many unknown Chinese people travelled as far as Iran and Russia and settled down far from their native country. When travelling from Beijing to Kabul in 1221-22, the monk Chang-chun had noted the presence of Chinese craftsmen in Outer Mongolia and in the Samarkand area. He had also learned that Chinese weavers had settled in the upper Yenisei valley. It is said that in the 14th cent AD, there were Chinese quarters in Tabriz, Iran and even in Moscow and Novgorod. They along with Muslims, dominated the trade and tax business in Russia. Even now, in Russia, the Chinese abacus calculator is much in use. The right hand minister of the Hulagu Khan was a Chinese by the name of Bolad Ching Sang. The man had 26 or more native Persian Muslim wives. He helped introduced paper currency (chao) to Iran during the Ilkhan as a more feasible mean of collecting tax compared to the native metal currency. Chap(from the Chinese "chao") is still a word used by Iranian people today for "printing." A Chinese general, Kuo Kan was in command of the Khan Hulagu's armies at the siege of Iran, Damascus and Baghdad in 1258. Over one thousand Chinese foot soldiers and hydraulic engineers were employed on the irrigation of the Tigris and Euphrates basins. The Mongol policy was to transfer the best qualified technicians from one end of the Eurasian continent to the other. Thus, the Mongol domination ensured the diffusion of certain Chinese techniques in the empires of the Ilkhan in Iran and the Golden Horde in Russia. Chinese influence is perceptible in Persian miniatures, and also in Iranian ceramics, music, and architecture of the Mongol epoch. It is very light, soft and bright compared to Arab and Turkish music and architecture. Some people have even thought that they could see traces of Chinese influence in Italian painting of the 14th cent., and more particularly in Lorenzetti's "Massacre of theFranciscans at Ceuta" (c. 1340). But, it is above all in connection with the 2 great inventions of modern times in Europe that the question of stimuli and contributions from China arises. The introduction in the 14th cent. in both the Ilkhan and Golden Horde Mongol empires of Iran and Russia of Chinese influences: playing cards, printed fabrics, and paper money was obviously connected with the appearance of wood engraving in Europe and consequently of printing with movable type. Paper money was printed at Tabriz, a great cosmopolitan centre in Iran during the Mongol era where Muslim, Greek, Italian, Armenian, Jewish, Arab, Uygurs, Mongols and Chinese all met and intermarried. The Iranian historian, Rashid al-Din (c. 1247-1318), who had made Chinese medicine known in his "Treasure of the Ilkhan on the Sciences of Cathay (1313), is the first to mention the Chinese invention of wood engraving. Wood engraving, known in Europe 30 or 40 years before the knowledge of printing,was immensely successful there. Holy pictures, playing cards, and little bookswith text and illustrations were printed. As for the idea of using movable type, it is to be supposed to have spread into Europe also during this time via Russia or Iran. As for the other great invention of modern times, the firearm, we know that Mongols had employed Chinese siege engineers with firearm weaponry during the campaigns in Iran, Caucasus and Arabia. In Europe, they were used for the first time at the Battle of Sajo in Hungary in 1241 We must ask ourselves this question: "Why is it that the Western academia,especially pertaining to the studies of history is so prone to leave out or omit the accomplishments of non-whites? We know for a fact that the Mongols were not just primitive and blood thirsty savages in the simple sense. They are barbarians, but not in the same category as the Vandals, Vikings, Zulus, etc. The Mongol Khans were shrewd and cunning statesmen as well as warriors. As you see, they had utilized Chinese expertise in the governing and taxing of Persia and Russia. Genghis Khan was not much different from Alexander Great if we remove the Western biases. Western views of history is often tainted and biased by race prejudices and an obsessive sexual impulse. When there is race mixing going on between non-white men and white/Caucasoid women, they cannot view the history and accomplishments from a clear lens. I have wrote a dissertation on this same topic, only to be coldly rejected. I wonder why? Even, the Chinese, Turks andPersian scholars do not deny they past. ---------------------------------------------------- Sources: Rashid al-Din's "Secret History of the Mongols." David Montgomery's "Mongol War Machine." Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Twilight Bark Posted January 8, 2002 Report Share Posted January 8, 2002 quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:both the turkish and later the mongol empires created a pax turcica and mongolica which enabled the silk route to function properly. and surprise surprise, as soon as the mongol empire fell, the silk route collapsed because there was no central authority to protect it, and wasn't one until the russian invasion of central asia in the 19th century, and that, as we all know very well, contributed little (so to speak) to the reemergence of the silk route.While I also have little patience with the jingoistic attitude exemplified by "chinese scholar", you also demonstrate appalling deficiencies in your overall outlook on history, nation and culture. You have to work much harder to cleanse yourself from the silliness otherwise known as the "Official Turkish History". While the "pan banditica" established by the organized crime structures otherwise known as "empires" may have provided temporary stability over a wide area, their (I mean the empire builders', not their subjects') contribution to human culture are grossly exaggerated by their cultural heirs, be it post-Romans (Europeans) or post-Ottomans ("Turk"s). quote:if left on your own, you would not have passed a thing to the rest of mankind in your splendid isolation as "the middle kingdom", you arrogant lot. It might have taken a little longer. But their inventions would most definitely leak out eventually. A bloodthirsty empire was not necessary to leak out the inventions of the Near Easterners. And one was not necessary for the Chinese. Knowledge cannot be contained in one area forever. It is just a matter of timescale; and don't worry, it would not be a geological time scale As members of a "tribe" that suffered too much under a variety of empires, while having aspired to establish no such thing for ourselves, it is Armenians' morally defensible duty to expose the stupidity represented by empire-worshipping strains in modern culture and scholarship. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Twilight Bark Posted January 8, 2002 Report Share Posted January 8, 2002 Yikes! quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:and the Chinese throughout history referred to Turks and other “northern barbarians” as “fire-haired monkeys”. From the beginnings of the Turkish Republic, there was a constant desire to identify with the "superior blond-eyed, fair-haired people". You parrot the same strain of thought (I am beginning to think that you sympathize with Grey Wolves but that's another topic; many left-wing Turks have amazingly right-wing ideas about language, nation, culture and history). The fire-haired "monkeys" were most probably the "Saka", or the Scythians. The Scythians were one of the most bloodthirsty and barbaric of the "Indo-European" tribes, and formed natural alliances with the Mongolian/proto-Turkic tribes. One theory about the name "Turk" is that it comes from "Tarkhun", an diety that Scythians worshipped and passed onto the tribes that became later the "Turks". However, the thought that the "original" Turks were blond-haired and blue-eyed is a fantasy encouraged by the German pseudo-scholarship that was very popular among the elite of the early Turkish Republic. Get rid of it already. quoteThe Chinese still refer to the non-Han minorities in southern China as “monkeys”. Such derogatory descriptions are very common in "culture clashes". Arians and Dravidians called each other similar names when they first interacted. While I completely disagree with "all cultures are equally violent and bloodthirsty" suggestion usually made by the "winners" of history, making fun of "foreign" cultures and races is nearly universal. No big deal. quote:“Our race incorporated many different nationalities and it is still continuing this process today.” In a process called forced assimilation and, at times, genocide. Your race is currently conducting above-ground nuclear tests in the vicinity of Uighur cities in Sinkiang to make sure that all the Uighurs get radiated and are unable to reproduce viable offspring. Come on now, Ali Suat. Really. What do you think the modern "Turk" is a result of? You base your argument on the premise that those living in glass houses should not throw stones. Heed your own premise. quoteIf people speak related languages, then you have a strong case that they are related. For instance, hate it though Tibetans may, they cannot ignore the fact that their language belongs to the Tibeto-Burman subgroup of the Sino-Tibetan languages, the “Sino” part of which refers to the Chinese dialects. Absolutely not. Linguistic relationship alone does not imply such ancestral commonality. Thanks to empire builders that you appear to admire, the linguistic relationships are buried too deep under the noise to provide much guidance one way or the other. quote:“It is also hard to imagine how Koreans can claim kinship with the Turks of Turkey. They are both completely different; believe me.” The Swedes and Bangladeshis are kinsmen even though they are completely different from one another. Ridiculuous. They obviously have totally different ancestry. They probably diverged not long after Homo-Sapiens walked out of Africa. quoteThe name is “Göktürk” (originally “Köktürk” Anyway, although I do not know "your" physical characteristics, it is a safe bet that you either completely lack any close ancestral relationship with the Oghuz, or your Turkic ancestry is small compared with West Anatolian (pseudo-Greek)/East Anatolian (Armenian and Kurdish)/Balkan/Arab/Iranian/Circassian/Laz components (my apologies to any groups that I missed) On many other points addressing hypocrisy and jingoism, I can easily agree with you. However, you must urgently address the hypocrisy in your world view as well. I address this to all persons behind aurguplu moniker, in the friendliest and most humanistic sense. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted January 11, 2002 Report Share Posted January 11, 2002 quote:Originally posted by whiteangel:I might be a little too late in joining this discussion topic.But, Mr. Ali Suat represents the classic example of the Turkic nationalism that seeks to usurp other people's accomplishments and claim the fame. Mr. Ali Suat has had his academic career ended by a bunch of Turkish nationalists and religious guys at a Turkish university partly because he didn't agree with their theories and openly said so, so it would be a little illogical to say the least if he defended the theses of the nationalists himself. This is utter distortion of truth. They have been doing this to the Sumerian, Chinese and Persian accomplishment and history for far too long. Visit any Turkic website on the Internet and you find ample examples of this. Often, they do not have the adequate studies and source to back up their claims.This is true, but please refer back to the above paragraph. What does he mean by "Uighur people carrying Chinese culture into the Near East and Europe?" He has not studied that the downfall of the Silk Road was caused by the Islamic Arab and Turkish invasions/destruction in the area. He has studied the formation and downfall of the silk Road as a student at Oxford (Oxford is not a Turkish University), and can cite numerous western works currently used as standard textbooks where pertinent info re the Silk Road can be found. Alternatively, anyone can form such a bibliography by simply starting out with the works of Bernard Lewis, for instance. Prior to that the Chinese, Sogdians, Bactrians, Indians, Persians, Armenians, Byzantines traded freely and without disruption for centuries on the Silk Routes.Not without disruption. The disruption was caused mainly by Northern Asian tribes, which included, but were not confined to, Turks, and the Indı-Iranian tribes, which included the Scythians. If you read the history of Dvin, the Arsacids in Iran, you will find the interactions of ancient China, Persia and Armenia. Before the Turks ever left Mongolia.First, Turks were probably not in mongolia in the beginning. They were first at the foot of the Altai mountains, and then on the Eurasian steppe, by about 1st millenium BC. Even during the Mongol era, it was Chinese agents themselves who carried the influence and stimulus to the West (not the Uighurs).This is wrong. During the Mongol era, it was mainly the Uighurs who did it (documentation on this abounds). Some Chinese of course may have contributed to it, too, but it was mainly the Uighurs. Read on:"The Chinese blood of many Russians and Persians. Unknown to many... Little do we know that Europe and the West was not as mighty as it is now. Many white people, for example the Russians and Iranians may have a trace of Chinese ancestry. This I found out from another site: While numerous foreigners came to China in the Mongol era, there was also a movement in the opposite direction. This has obviously attracted less interest in the West. A host of many unknown Chinese people travelled as far as Iran and Russia and settled down far from their native country. When travelling from Beijing to Kabul in 1221-22, the monk Chang-chun had noted the presence of Chinese craftsmen in Outer Mongolia and in the Samarkand area. He had also learned that Chinese weavers had settled in the upper Yenisei valley. It is said that in the 14th cent AD, there were Chinese quarters in Tabriz, Iran and even in Moscow and Novgorod. They along with Muslims, dominated the trade and tax business in Russia. Even now, in Russia, the Chinese abacus calculator is much in use. The right hand minister of the Hulagu Khan was a Chinese by the name of Bolad Ching Sang. The first part of the name (Bolad) sounds definitely un-Chinese, and very similar to the Turco-Persian name Bulat, which means "steel" (the name may be of Iranian origin).The man had 26 or more native Persian Muslim wives. He helped introduced paper currency (chao) to Iran during the Ilkhan as a more feasible mean of collecting tax compared to the native metal currency. Chap(from the Chinese "chao") is still a word used by Iranian people today for "printing." A Chinese general, Kuo Kan was in command of the Khan Hulagu's armies at the siege of Iran, Damascus and Baghdad in 1258. Over one thousand Chinese foot soldiers and hydraulic engineers were employed on the irrigation of the Tigris and Euphrates basins. The Mongol policy was to transfer the best qualified technicians from one end of the Eurasian continent to the other. Thus, the Mongol domination ensured the diffusion of certain Chinese techniques in the empires of the Ilkhan in Iran and the Golden Horde in Russia. Chinese influence is perceptible in Persian miniatures, and also in Iranian ceramics, music, and architecture of the Mongol epoch. It is very light, soft and bright compared to Arab and Turkish music and architecture. The last sentence sounds like racia stereotyping to me. How do you juble up Turkish, Mngolian and Arabic music and architecture all together (by the way what architecture did the Mongols then have?)?Some people have even thought that they could see traces of Chinese influence in Italian painting of the 14th cent., and more particularly in Lorenzetti's "Massacre of theFranciscans at Ceuta" (c. 1340). But, it is above all in connection with the 2 great inventions of modern times in Europe that the question of stimuli and contributions from China arises. The introduction in the 14th cent. in both the Ilkhan and Golden Horde Mongol empires of Iran and Russia of Chinese influences: playing cards, printed fabrics, and paper money was obviously connected with the appearance of wood engraving in Europe and consequently of printing with movable type. Paper money was printed at Tabriz, a great cosmopolitan centre in Iran during the Mongol era where Muslim, Greek, Italian, Armenian, Jewish, Arab, Uygurs, Mongols and Chinese all met and intermarried. The Iranian historian, Rashid al-Din (c. 1247-1318), who had made Chinese medicine known in his "Treasure of the Ilkhan on the Sciences of Cathay (1313), is the first to mention the Chinese invention of wood engraving. Wood engraving, known in Europe 30 or 40 years before the knowledge of printing,was immensely successful there. Holy pictures, playing cards, and little bookswith text and illustrations were printed. As for the idea of using movable type, it is to be supposed to have spread into Europe also during this time via Russia or Iran. As for the other great invention of modern times, the firearm, we know that Mongols had employed Chinese siege engineers with firearm weaponry during the campaigns in Iran, Caucasus and Arabia. In Europe, they were used for the first time at the Battle of Sajo in Hungary in 1241We must ask ourselves this question: "Why is it that the Western academia,especially pertaining to the studies of history is so prone to leave out or omit the accomplishments of non-whites? We know for a fact that the Mongols were not just primitive and blood thirsty savages in the simple sense. They are barbarians, but not in the same category as the Vandals, Vikings, Zulus, etc. The Mongol Khans were shrewd and cunning statesmen as well as warriors. As you see, they had utilized Chinese expertise in the governing and taxing of Persia and Russia. Genghis Khan was not much different from Alexander Great if we remove the Western biases.Western views of history is often tainted and biased by race prejudices and an obsessive sexual impulse. When there is race mixing going on between non-white men and white/Caucasoid women, they cannot view the history and accomplishments from a clear lens. I have wrote a dissertation on this same topic, only to be coldly rejected. I wonder why? Even, the Chinese, Turks andPersian scholars do not deny they past.----------------------------------------------------Sources: Rashid al-Din's "Secret History of the Mongols."David Montgomery's "Mongol War Machine." Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted January 11, 2002 Report Share Posted January 11, 2002 quote:Originally posted by Twilight Bark:Yikes! Ali Suat, in an earlier post you claimed to agree that your ancestry was overwhelmingly Anatolian. Now you appear to have made an about-face. Curious. OK, let's address the curiosity. In the earlier postings I did not claim the ny ancestry was overwhelmingly Anatolian (if I did, then I was wrong). What I cliamed was that my ancestry had a significant Anatolian component, in addition to the Turkic and other components. After all, I speak Turkish as native language and claim TUrkish ethnicity. This must have come from somewhere. Therefore, I do not think I have made an about-face. Curiosity addressed?Combined with an earlier tell-tale sign, I am beginning to conclude that I am not corresponding with a single person, but a group of people. You guys should keep certain traits of "aurguplu" consistent. I do not know what the earlier tell-tale sign was, but you certainly have read it wrong: i am one single person, my name is ali suat urguplu (and my username here is a contraction of this and not a nickname, so I am definitely not hiding an identity, and you can actually identify me by just checking with oxford), graduate of pembroke college, oxford in 1990 with an upper second in oriental studies, thus feeling pretty confident to reply to matters historical. clear?Anyway, although I do not know "your" physical characteristics, it is a safe bet that you either completely lack any close ancestral relationship with the Oghuz, or your Turkic ancestry is small compared with West Anatolian (pseudo-Greek)/East Anatolian (Armenian and Kurdish)/Balkan/Arab/Iranian/Circassian/Laz components (my apologies to any groups that I missed) On many other points addressing hypocrisy and jingoism, I can easily agree with you. However, you must urgently address the hypocrisy in your world view as well. i do not consciously entertain any hypocrisy either in my world view or anything else. if i may have been inconsistent in several views that i expressed, point out what they are, and i shall reply. if i have made factual errors, i shall be ready to admit them, too. but come up with something factual if you please.I address this to all persons behind aurguplu moniker, read above re the aurguplu "moniker". and don't call it a moniker again, because it's my name. in the friendliest and most humanistic sense.really? Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted January 11, 2002 Report Share Posted January 11, 2002 twilight bark, 1. it is true that in the early republic days people wanted to associate with the "superior" northern strain of the white race in turkey, partly because of too much association with the germans (not a healthy habit). but this does not deny the fact that some turks (i mean people who are known to have spoken turkish) were white. turks assiilated a lot of other people around them, and were assimilated into a lot of others, too. i do not believe that any race of humans is superior to any other, and therefore have no incentive to invent imaginary lineages of turks. 2. the english and the bangladeshis are related, although this is much obscured by the different racial types they display today: english and bengali both belong to the indo-european family of languages, and to speak related languages, you must at least share part of your ancestry. 3. the turks were not formed by detonating nuclear bombs in anatolia to eliminate the native population. the turks were alive and kicking long before they came to turkey, stayed in anatolia as turks for almost a millenium, and until the last quarter of the 19th century there were no mass killings of the native (or, more accurately, earlier) anatolians, otherwise the armenians, greeks and kurds together would not have made up about a third of the anatolian population, nor would the turks be physically indistinguishable from whatever earlier anatolian population they lived in the vicinity of. by the way, slighting the uighur genocide being perpetrated by the chinese is tantamount to slighting the armenian genocide by the turks can you accept the latter, and if not, then how do you speak of the uighur genocide in such a slighting manner? regards, ali suat (a single person and not a group, and ny name not a moniker) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted January 11, 2002 Report Share Posted January 11, 2002 twilight bark, on the name "turk": the earliest version of the name is "törük" or "türük" (the köktürük alphabet, being of semitic origin, did not distinguish between ö and ü). it comes from "törümek/türümek" (modern turkish "türemek") which means "being generated, coming into existence". thus the name probably means "born". now other languages have very similar semantic parallels, e.g. latin "gens", greek "genos", english "kin" and old iranian (scythian) "zantu" all come from the same root and mean "people, tribe, clan", and this root is related to a root which meant "coming into existence, being generated" (look at the word generated, it comes from the same root). a good number of ethnonyms that people use the world over are similar semantically. the scythian sky god may have been called "tarkhun", but this has nothing to do with the name "turk". most ethnicities historical or extant have ethnonyms that they themselves invented, and other names by which the outsiders call them. thus the armenians call themselves "hye", the germans "deutsch", the chinese "han", the japanese "nihon", the greeks "hellen" etc. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Twilight Bark Posted January 11, 2002 Report Share Posted January 11, 2002 quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:... to speak related languages, you must at least share part of your ancestry. Absolutely not. Many a Jamaican would attest to that Seriously, in many cases the language is simply imposed, and whole regions adopt it out of "convenience" (in its most general sense). That's not to say a Bangladeshi does not share any ancestry with a Swede. However, it is unlikely that the extent of it is higher than with, say, Ethiopians. And take any Tamil (Dravidian) from the region, and their shared ancestry with a garden variety Bangladeshi would be much, much higher. It would be entirely silly for the poor Bangladeshi (behind whose back we have been talking ) to identify with a Swede more than with a southern Indian. quote:3. the turks were not formed by detonating nuclear bombs in anatolia to eliminate the native population. the turks were alive and kicking long before they came to turkey, stayed in anatolia as turks for almost a millenium, and until the last quarter of the 19th century there were no mass killings of the native (or, more accurately, earlier) anatolians, otherwise the armenians, greeks and kurds together would not have made up about a third of the anatolian population, nor would the turks be physically indistinguishable from whatever earlier anatolian population they lived in the vicinity of. My point was that the modern Turkish identity is largely a product of "forced" assimilation. By "forced" I don't necessarily mean "at gun-point". When a typical "Turkish" person from modern Turkey glorifies (or even symapthizes/identifies with) the "ancient Turkish", he is doing nothing other than glorifying the group that bullied (most of) his ancestors and changed their cultural identity, language, and religion, in other words the essence of their being. Therefore, I am disappointed to see an otherwise enlightened Turk do that. However, I have absolutely no problem with a Turk being proud of the achievements of the republican Turkey, whatever they may be. The shameful parts, we don't have to touch in this thread. quoteby the way, slighting the uighur genocide being perpetrated by the chinese is tantamount to slighting the armenian genocide by the turks can you accept the latter, and if not, then how do you speak of the uighur genocide in such a slighting manner?Slighting the plight of Uighurs was not my intention. Believe me, I sympathize with the Uighurs for the very reasons that you mentioned. quote:ali suat (a single person and not a group, and ny name not a moniker)It's obviously OK by me even if it is a moniker, since mine obviously is. Regards,Twilight Bark (a moniker) Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Twilight Bark Posted January 12, 2002 Report Share Posted January 12, 2002 quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:OK, let's address the curiosity. In the earlier postings I did not claim the ny ancestry was overwhelmingly Anatolian (if I did, then I was wrong). What I cliamed was that my ancestry had a significant Anatolian component, in addition to the Turkic and other components. After all, I speak Turkish as native language and claim TUrkish ethnicity. This must have come from somewhere. Therefore, I do not think I have made an about-face. Curiosity addressed?No, it has not been addressed.You previously implied that you were essentially of the same stock as the ancient population of Urgup. You just can't have it both ways, that's all. quote... you can actually identify me by just checking with oxford), graduate of pembroke college, oxford in 1990 ....Having one "valid" personality as the front of a group does not exclude the possibilty that a group exists. However, I take your word for it. quote... hypocrisy ... but come up with something factual if you please.I did; right in the post you are replying to. Anyway, the important thing is all of us should make a conscious effort to eliminate hypocrisy and jingoism from our world views. I try, in my humble and small way, to encourage Armenians to do the same. quote:in the friendliest and most humanistic sense.really?Really. That shouldn't be so hard to believe. Friendly and firm are not mutually exclusive.[ January 11, 2002: Message edited by: Twilight Bark ] Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted January 16, 2002 Report Share Posted January 16, 2002 twilight bark, as i understand the issues about my name being my name and me not representing anyone other than myself are resolved, i shall move on to the issue regarding my ancestry and the apparent inconsistency some of my postings may exhibit: i am an ethnic turk (whatever that means) in that i come from a family that describes itself as turkish and most - not all - of its members whom i know speak or spoke turkish as mother tongue. by my past postings you can see that i have a strong tendency to use language as a (but not necessarily "the") determinant factor in ethnicity (in the rare event that i am interested in such a pursuit), hence my obsession and admitted over-generalisations regarding language and ethnicity. as for the people of urgup being descendants of the older folks, here it goes: the area has been inhabited for the past few thousand years, and apparently no newcomer has ousted those who were there before, rather, the population grew like a snowball, with the addition of ever more snow with each new invasion. this can be seen from the fact that the people of the area do not have either a pronounced asian or mediterranean type. they rather have a sort of generalised south-east european look, with perhaps a hint of asia in a few individuals with high cheekbones and almond eyes. as far as the culture goes, it seems to me that language and religion are the only two aspects that have not survived: the people speak turkish, and even the local greeks (karamanlı spoke a weird form of turkish and not greek, apparently for centuries. of course, the local turkish is dotted with greek and pre-greek vocab, and it is intersting to note that the pre-greek (mostly hittite) vocab in the local dialect is much closer to the original hittite form than to the hellenised versions found elsewhere, hence my suspicion that hittite may have survived there until the arrival of turks in the 11th century (we know it was there in the 6th). now the turkish tribe that settled there is called karaman, a clan of the powerful afshar division of the 24 oghuz tribes that entered anatolia, and my father's side happens to descend from one karaman family and this happens to have been documented way back. since muslim turks, like the greeks and possibly the hittites before them, were MCPs (male chauvinist pigs), the female line remains largely undocumented, and it is in this that i suspect our anatolian heritage lies: we guys do not look like the central asians a bit, rather, we are indistinguishable from the local greeks, and more tellingly, from the ancient ones (their remanis have been found), so there must be a strong local component. so we are in brief descendants of central asian fathers and anatolian mothers, so is much of our culture. and to those who are aware of this, this "clash of cultures and civilisations" business, which pits our paternal cousins against our maternal ones, is sheer nonsense. as an individual i can accomodate both the asian and anatolian aspects of my heritage without problems, in fact with pleasure, to me one enriches the other, but i realise i differ from many turks (and not a few armenian and greek diaspora members) in this respect, i believe the difference stems from the fact that i have striven to get acquainted with both of them without carrying the prejudices of one onto the other. few people seem to be either willing or able to do this. i hope this clears things a bit. cheers, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Twilight Bark Posted January 16, 2002 Report Share Posted January 16, 2002 quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:we guys do not look like the central asians a bit, rather, we are indistinguishable from the local greeks, and more tellingly, from the ancient ones (their remanis have been found), so there must be a strong local component. Make that the main component. quoteso we are in brief descendants of central asian fathers and anatolian mothers, so is much of our culture.Tracing your ancestry to one particular family 50 generations ago is certainly interesting and amusing. However, do not lose sight of the fact that the number 2 raised to the power of 50 is a very, very small number representing the fraction of "you" that are coming from "them". The political power of the "newcomers" far exceeded their actual numbers. For the vast majority of Turks, the Central Asian component is miniscule compared with the Anatolian one. Picking the Central Asian component (that may not even exist in many cases) as the one that really matters is the central dogma in contemporary Turkish chauvinism. quote:and to those who are aware of this, this "clash of cultures and civilisations" business, which pits our paternal cousins against our maternal ones, is sheer nonsense. as an individual i can accomodate both the asian and anatolian aspects of my heritage without problems, in fact with pleasure, to me one enriches the other, but i realise i differ from many turks (and not a few armenian and greek diaspora members) In fact, the cultural outlooks of Greeks and Turks are more similar to each other than to Armenians. To me, Greeks and Turks form one cultural unit; they just have to realize it yet Armenians have their share of chauvinists as well. However, Armenians have embraced and cherished their "mixture" without any complexes. The mainstream Armenian thought consistently defines Armenians as a mixture. There may be discussions about the make-up of the mixture, or how to define the beginning of a proper "Hye" nation, but elevating and glorifying one warlike (to put it kindly) component over others is just not a part of mainstream Armenian self-image. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted January 17, 2002 Report Share Posted January 17, 2002 twilight bark, 1. o.k. i agree that it has to be the main component. we are certainly much more anatolian than central asian. in my particular case, i also happen to have a lot of caucasian (georgian and circassian), slavic (russian and serbian), northern greek (epirean) blood, and there also were some tatars and possibly kurds in the family way back. i have not found any traces of armenians, but this of course doesn't mean that they weren't there (it may be there in the female lineages). 2. i can trace my ancestry way back, because some of the families that went into my make-up were involved in statecraft from very early on, and for a long time: my paternal grand-grandfather's family history goes back to the early thirteenth century (they emerged as the seljuks were crumbling), so does my maternal grandmother's lineage (younger by a few decades). i know this is a fairly rare case with turks, since muslims do not keep official birth/circumscision records the way christians keep baptismal/communion records, and since a great majority of archival material is either destroyed/not published or hidden, but we happen to have both own copies, and also our lineage is written in history books. 3. i agree to a certain extent that the greeks and turks form a single culture (you'll have a hard time convincing either party, though). i think that culturally turkey can be divided into several areas: 1. thrace: not anatolia: balkan culture. 2. istanbul & environs. 3. the aegean (both sides of it) and western mediterranean coast of anatolia. 4. eastern mediterranean coast of anatolia to urfa-siirt (arabic presence). 5. central anatolia 6. eastern anatolia and northern part of southeastern anatolia. 7. the black sea coast. i think that the greek culture is most prevalent in the aegean, the culture of istanbul and environs is, although greek, is to be set apart on account of the uniqueness of byzantium and istanbul, the inner anatolian greek culture (cappadocian plain) is very different from that of the coast, and the black sea coast has a separate culture, not typically greek, not turkish, but has a character of its own. the eastern mediterranean all the way to urfa-siirt has a strong arabic (muslim and christian) presence. inner anatolia also has a discernible hittite component. eastern anatolia has an armenian and kurdish character, together with a nomadic turkish culture visible here and there. turks are pretty much everywhere, but interwoven into the older elements like the threads of a carpet. people from one area aree more similar to one another regardless of ethnic background than their ethnic brethren in other areas. this of course flies in the face of any nationalism or other -isms (i have a problem with -isms, i have never seen any good come out of any one of them). cheers, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
whiteangel Posted January 24, 2002 Report Share Posted January 24, 2002 The term "bolad" was more a title than name. Some Armenians who served the Golden Horde in Russia also had this "bolad, bulat" title affixed to their own personal names. I think it meant "strong?" In genetic studies the Anatolian Turks and Iranians (probably includes Kurds and Tabrizi Turkic speakers) are the closest genetically in scale and DNA. Refer to this site: http://www.assyrianfoundation.org/genetics.htm Language can change easily but not genetics. This is true in Anatolia. One Turkish emirate during the Seljuks was said to be of entirely Armenian origins (Danishmend). And, there was an Armenian prince of the Artsruni family? who took his kingdom over to the Turks and became Moslem. Examples like this explain why Turks spoke an Asian tongue but still maintain their Anatolian Caucasoid features. The Turkmens had mixed much with the Iranians before moving on to Azerbaijan and Anatolia. Even the Turkmens themselves in Central Asia had mixed with the nomadic Iranian Scythian tribes before entering Iran under the service of Abbasids. So this question of race and origins are clouded in the distant past. here is a site that details the genetics of modern Central Asians. Not surprisingly they fall intermediate between Europeans and Mongol/Chinese. Uzbeks and Turkmens were not studied in this research. I assume they are more Iranoid than the Kazakhs, Kyrgyz and Soviet Uygurs. The southern Tarim Basin Uygurs who were also not studied may have stronger Han Chinese components, as I have seen that facially they look more Chinese and Iranian than they do Mongol and Korean. Refer to this site: http://www.journals.uchicago.edu/AJHG/jour...820/970820.html Even this study confirms that Anatolian Turks are closer to the British on the genetic scale than they are to Central Asians. There is no "genocide" of Uygurs in China. Not when you compare to what the Turks did to the Armenians in the past and what they are now doing to the Kurds in the present. The situation in western China is different. In the Xinjiang ("East Turkestan") region of China, there are at least 12 ethnic groups living there. The Uygurs are but only one of them. Some Han Chinese have been living there for thousands of years. They were the ones who did not assimilate, Turkify and Islamicized. Now, what are the Uygurs to do with these people if they are granted independence? There will be wholesale slaughter and massacres as what happened during Tamerlane's invasions of this area and during the brief interlude of the "East Turkestan Republic" in the late 1930s. Many, if not most Uygurs are really the descandants of native Iranian and Han Chinese who "Turkicized" during the late 800 ADs invasions by Uygurs from their flight from the Kyrgyz in Mongolia. Even when the Yaolokai (Yaylakar in Uygur) royal family and generals took over the Tarim basin, they allowed the Tang Chinese ruling Cao family to remain as governors in Turfan while the native Tocharians and Han Chinese convicts/merchants who settled there were compelled to adopt the Turkish Uygur language of the "beylar" (headman in Uygur). Uygurs must accept the fact that they are not the only indigenous people in this region. The Tajiks living there are probably the closest linguistic survivor of the Indo European Tocharians who lived there before the arrival of either Han Chinese or Turkics. Even today, amongst the Uygurs there is a tribe of outcasts called "Aynu" whom the Uygurs derogatorily refer to as "Abdali" (slaves). Their language is closer to Tajiki and Persian (with lots of remnant Tocharian vocab.) although ethnically they are considered "Uygur." It is only the Chinese govt. who promotes the salvation of this group's language and culture. It is no wonder why the Tajikis and Aynus increasingly join the Chinese army and border police in this region, because they resist "Turkification." They are the true aboriginals who have lost much of their land and people to this onslaught in the past. Now, how is this a genocide? It is reaction to Pan-Turkism. Many Uygurs, the young ones, even long to leave their province to settle in the interior metropolises of China. They are not politically inclined like the Tibetans. They just want to get by in life and make a living. It is only the Soviet Uygurs who try to instigate troubles. Now, they can do just that with Turkish and USA covert operations through Afghanistan. ------------------------------------------------ Onik, whiteangel Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
aurguplu Posted January 24, 2002 Report Share Posted January 24, 2002 whiteangel, 1) i agree with most of what you say concerning the genetic makeup of anatolian and central asian turks. in fact, few if any educated turks would disagree. what few people realise is that we are perfectly happy wit the fact that we are central asians+anatolians+iranians+slavs+greeks+armenians+anyone else we came across. of course, if you have been mixing with people, your culture is also going to be mixed. i can pick you any carpet from central anatolia, and the motifs on it will be anywhere from china to greece, so is the case with the rest of our culture. this is accepted fact. as for myself, i can cite over a dozen nationalities that went into my own genetic makeup, and at least three with their pre-conversion (christian) names (anna, roxelana, mara). this doesn't make me any less turkic, since i profess to be a member of the turkic nation and none other. now as far as the uygurs are concerned, we know that they are not alone in chinese turkestan (but they form - or formed - the majority). i might differ from a good few other turks in that i am not in support of a separate state for them (if every nation got a separate state of its own, we might well end up with a thousand states, none of them viable, and also, i find it a matter of political honesty (admittedly, the two notions are frequently mutually exclusive) not to wish for another state what i don't wish for mine). the thing is that we have over here a number of uygur turks who had been horribly treated by the chinese authorities (not that they treat the han chinese any better), and these things with above-ground detonations can not by any stretch of the imagination thought to be benevolent, and their effect would clearly be genocidal. i do not know whether uygur harass or harassed other ethnic groups, i know that there have been clashes in kyrgyzstan between the uygurs and the kyrgyz, we of course could not take sides since both of them are turkic. much as i may condemn the armenian genocide and the persecution of the kurds in turkey, i cannot fail to see similar things taking place elsewhere on earth, and some of my kinsmen falling victim to them. if i can be expected to do the former, i can expect in return that the latter be taken into account and adequately condemned and taken action against by the world community. regards, Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Twilight Bark Posted January 24, 2002 Report Share Posted January 24, 2002 Dear Ali,I respectfully have to make a few adjustments to the spin of your article. quote:Originally posted by aurguplu:what few people realise is that we are perfectly happy wit the fact that we are central asians+anatolians+iranians+slavs+greeks+armenians+anyone else we came across. A classic case of "yes, but ...". Turks accept the obvious, and try to forget it as soon as they can. The overbearing presence in Turkish cultural consciousness is the glorification of the central asian component far, far above all others. Viewing the vast majority of one's ancestors as subservient to the identity of a warlike tribe is not exactly honest or desirable. When Turks understand and cherish the fact that they are "Turks" and not Turks, they will have evolved to a much higher cultural plane. quote: of course, if you have been mixing with people, your culture is also going to be mixed. i can pick you any carpet from central anatolia, and the motifs on it will be anywhere from china to greece, so is the case with the rest of our culture. this is accepted fact. [qb]as for myself, i can cite over a dozen nationalities that went into my own genetic makeup, and at least three with their pre-conversion (christian) names (anna, roxelana, mara). this doesn't make me any less turkic, since i profess to be a member of the turkic nation and none other. case in point quotenow as far as the uygurs are concerned, we know that they are not alone in chinese turkestan (but they form - or formed - the majority). i might differ from a good few other turks in that i am not in support of a separate state for them (if every nation got a separate state of its own, we might well end up with a thousand states, none of them viable, and also, i find it a matter of political honesty (admittedly, the two notions are frequently mutually exclusive) not to wish for another state what i don't wish for mine). Yes, the real incentive is to avoid hypocricy. Of course, one can equally easily avoid hypocricy by advocating a world where every nation that wishes to have the trappings and privileges of a state receives them as a natural right. The usual bogus argument advanced against this right by the current states (i.e. defenders of the status-quo) is that small states are not viable. That is nonsense. It assumes that all these states and the states they separated from will be so hostile as to reject trade and cooperation with each other. A perfect example of self-fulfilling prophecy. "You can't secede without an ugly and long fight, and if you do we will make your life miserable". On the other hand, in an enlightened world, the purpose of a state would be cultural preservation and not much else. As such, the economic activities that decide whether a state is viable or not can continue unhindered. quote:the thing is that we have over here a number of uygur turks who had been horribly treated by the chinese authorities (not that they treat the han chinese any better), and these things with above-ground detonations can not by any stretch of the imagination thought to be benevolent, and their effect would clearly be genocidal. i do not know whether uygur harass or harassed other ethnic groups, i know that there have been clashes in kyrgyzstan between the uygurs and the kyrgyz, we of course could not take sides since both of them are turkic. much as i may condemn the armenian genocide and the persecution of the kurds in turkey, i cannot fail to see similar things taking place elsewhere on earth, and some of my kinsmen falling victim to them. if i can be expected to do the former, i can expect in return that the latter be taken into account and adequately condemned and taken action against by the world community. Much as sympathize with the Uigurs, the scale of their plight is nowhere near that experienced by the Armenians. Close to Kurds' perhaps, but nowhere near the Armenians'. As for Uigurs being your kins, they are much less your kin than the Armenians you are conversing with on this forum. Best wishes from one of your closer kins ,Twilight Bark Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
khodja Posted January 24, 2002 Report Share Posted January 24, 2002 Interesting how Armenians get into discussions of the "mixed" Turkish genetics, culture and ancestry yet walk around with blinders concerning the mixtures of the Armenians. We are part Jew, part-French, part-Assyrian, and part-Mongol/Chinese. A new book emanating from the ROA is a biography of the Queens of Armenia. The mix of our queens is duplicated in the mix of the Armenian people. The chauvinists among us will deny the glaring documentation of this fact. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Twilight Bark Posted January 24, 2002 Report Share Posted January 24, 2002 quote:Originally posted by hagarag:Interesting how Armenians get into discussions of the "mixed" Turkish genetics, culture and ancestry yet walk around with blinders concerning the mixtures of the Armenians. We are part Jew, part-French, part-Assyrian, and part-Mongol/Chinese. A new book emanating from the ROA is a biography of the Queens of Armenia. The mix of our queens is duplicated in the mix of the Armenian people. The chauvinists among us will deny the glaring documentation of this fact.Hagarag,You must have been talking to the most rabid of the chauvinists. Even the ultranationalist Armenians define Armenians as a mixture. Not the same mixture as you have in mind perhaps, but a mixture nonetheless. Whatever the case may be, taking the ancestry of the queens and kings as representative of the population in general is ridiculously simple minded, and is meritless unless supported by information about population movements. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.