Jump to content

Book Review: Three Apples Fell From Heaven


Azat

Recommended Posts

AN ELUSIVE VISION AND AN AUTHENTIC VOICE

 

By Alan Cheuse. Alan Cheuse is a book commentator for NPR's "All Things Considered," a writing teacher at George...

April 15, 2001

Three Apples Fell From Heaven

 

By Micheline Aharonian Marcom

 

Riverhead, 270 pages, $23.95

 

In Micheline Aharonian Marcom's lyrical first novel, "Three Apples Fell From Heaven," we find another book in which a new writer tries to reach further than her grasp. But from the start you feel as though you are in the presence of an authentic voice, in this case a voice that weeps and wails and growls and shouts and chants and moans and sings about the 20th Century's first--but least-known--ethnic massacre, the 1915 forced march through eastern Turkey of that country's then sizable Christian Armenian minority and the subsequent slaughter of a million of these unwilling pilgrims. Such material presents a heavy burden for any writer. But Marcom is so talented that for most of her book she seems quite capable of carrying it.

 

"In a ditch, in a well, on the banks of the Euphrates River," she begins, "the trajectory of the river has been altered. In the desert, the Mesopotamian beetles drink blood and soup. There is a lake that overflows its bounds, transshapen by flesh. There are limestone houses and burned window frames, piles of manuscript, Gospel and gold buried in the garden. There are manifold dogs who have no need to scavenge. There are muted girls living in the haremlik of the jailmaster's house, in the kitchens and sowing the field. There is a sexton without a face and his brother. There are caravans of invisible grave markers." Children and mothers, fathers and uncles, bakers and professors and poets and farmers make up the Armenian cast. Soldiers and peddlers, jailers and their wives, and decadent politicians are the Turks who appear most often on this pathetic stage. As she assembles this cast of various victims and oppressors (and a few heroes, to be sure, though their number is slim), the novelist swoops into their minds and hearts and then flies up again to the lyrical heights sounded in the opening pages, employing her gift for language to recreate the smells ("the fragance of the air--cabbage, chickpeas, butter, onion, and allspice . . .") and sights and sounds of the harrowing years of the genocide: the inside of a local bathhouse where the water is heated by a fire that has burned steadily for 320 years; a dead child who speaks of the roadsides littered with abandoned babies and the lake bed swollen with decaying corpses; an innocent young Armenian shepherd who rushes home to his own beheading; a worldly American consul overwhelmed by the prospect of impending human slaughter.

 

By the end even the young novelist herself seems overwhelmed, and the story trails away rather than sounding purposefully resolved. But that seems to reflect the normal human response to such horror as the writer has revealed to us. Marcom may never write a book as powerful as this again, because where could she find a subject about which she's so passionate that matches the strength of her voice? She may not even write any fiction again. But her debut will stay with its readers for a good long while.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...