Arpa Posted December 3, 2010 Report Share Posted December 3, 2010 TREATY??? of GUMRI AlexandropolWas it, is it legal and binding?Also below see the “legalities”?? of Kars and Moscow “treaties”.=====NINETY YEARS OF DELUSION OR, HOW IT CAME TO PASSBy Ara Papyan Times.amDec 2 2010Armenia On December 3 it is the 90th anniversary of the Aleksandrapolagreement. The head of the "Modus Vivendi" Apa Paryan presentsarticles, where it is shown the agreement was illegal. Times.am-Armenian news publishes the three articles by turn. Here isthe first one. The study of history, particularly of the history of internationalrelations, is not an end in itself. In studying history, man tries tolearn from the past, so as to avoid making the same mistakes in thefuture. It seems, then, that we are continually rejecting the lessonsof history and directing ourselves with the delusion of perceivingwhat is desirable instead of what is real. If this were not thecase, then we would not have signed the humiliating Armenia-Turkeyprotocols in Zurich, protocols which provided a temporary sense ofrelief, but which remained fruitless and barren, thereby renderingthemselves exemplars of political onanism. During these very days ninety years ago, the Armenians and Turkswere carrying out negotiations in the ill-fated city of Alexandropol(now Gyumri), perhaps the most difficult negotiations in our briefpolitical history. The negotiations ended with the signing of thatmost burdensome Treaty of Alexandropol, on the 3rd of December, 1920. I shall relate a comparative analysis of the negotiations process,the legal status of the treaty itself and its contents in a futurearticle. At present, a few words on what lead up to the treaty. Of course, the signing of the Treaty of Alexandropol was not someisolated incident. It was a consequence, in particular, of the militaryand political situation in Armenia after the havoc caused by the May,1920 uprising, the ever-increasing Bolshevik-Kemalist co-operation, aswell as the immense gap that had been formed between the authoritiesof Armenia and the people. As the current state of Armenia mirrorsthe Armenia of May-November, 1920 in many ways, I thought it helpfulto discuss certain key points. One question has always bothered me, as I am sure, it has others. Howdid it come to pass that, in almost the absence of an army, theArmenian people managed to defeat or at least provide an adequatedefence to the Ottoman forces in open battle in May of 1918, and justtwo and a half years later, in September-November, 1920, with moreweapons, ammunitions and soldiers than in 1918, it suffered ignominiousdefeat at the hands of the remnants of the very same Ottoman army inthe well-bastioned fortress of Kars? When one studies the documents,press and memoirs of the time, one thing becomes clear: the roots ofthe defeat rested more on morale than on the military or the political. Yes, costly mistakes were allowed in organising the defence; yes,there were many unfavourable circumstances, even accidental ones. And,what, were there none in May of 1918? Of course there were! Butin May of 1918, the Armenian man and soldier was certain that theOttoman army was advancing towards the southern Caucasus to finishwhat it had started with the Armenian Genocide. Therefore, therewere no alternatives to facing and struggling against the enemy;the willingness to fight was borne by the entire people. And also, the real reason for the victory of the first battle overArtsakh (Karabakh) was its own characteristic of being national,aimed at liberation and the fact that its essence was shared amongthe people. But when one casts a glance at the circumstances inSeptember-November, 1920, then it becomes clear that the Armeniansoldier had simply given up on fighting, and the Armenian man, onshowcasing any resistance. The most revealing testimony to that factare the Turkish casualties. According to Kazim Karabekir, commanderof the eastern front of the Kemalist forces, in the course of threedays of battle (from the 31st of October to the 2nd of November,1920), including the taking of Kars, the Turks lost only nine andhad 42 wounded. This served as a realisation of the Bolshevik calls of "the timeshave changed", "these are different Turks". And upon the withdrawalof "the Turks new and made anew", the local authorities had to bury4,386 bodies - 90% of which were women and children - in but threevillages of Shirak (Ghaltaghchi, Aghboulagh and Barapol, as they werethen called). This, too, was a manifestation of the policy of brotherhood towards"the new and made anew" Turks. Most unfortunately, it is the same songbeing sung today, the same old story; only the Bolsheviks gettingassistance from abroad have been replaced by numerous grant-gulpingorganisations and so-called political scientists. As the Bolsheviks were unsure whether or not it would be possible"to destroy Imperialist Armenia" solely by deluding the Armenians andbreaking their spirit of resistance, they combined other steps withthat of propaganda. Starting in May-June, 1919, when Semyon Budyonnymet with Mustafa Kemal, the Bolsheviks provided immense military andmaterial support to the Kemalists under the sway of the dream of aglobal revolution. And those relations were particularly deepened withthe signing of a secret treaty of co-operation between the Kemalistsand Bolsheviks on the 24th of August, 1920. As a matter of fact, one of the signatories to the treaty on behalfof the Turkish party was that war criminal, former Minister of Warfor the Ottoman Empire, Enver *****, something which testifies to thefollowing: although Kemal and Enver despised one another for years,all Turks found common ground in their efforts against the Armenians. Immediately following the secret treaty of the 24th of August,1920, the Bolsheviks transferred over 200 kilogrammes of gold andmuch arms and ammunition to the Kemalists. The provision of militaryassistance is a relatively well-known fact, but few are aware that theBolsheviks supported the Kemalists by directly fighting within theirranks against "Armenian Imperialists". At the end of August, 1920,the first detachment of Bolsheviks, 7,000 soldiers, arrived in Karin(Erzurum). Some time later, another detachment of 10,000 arrived in aid ofthe Kemalists. Whereas the orders of the first detachment were toparticipate in the military actions against Armenia, the second was tobe involved in maintaining the Mesopotamian front, so that the Britishforces stationed there would not be able to strike at the Kemalistsfrom the rear and come to the assistance of Armenia in that way. And so, under these circumstances - deserted by allies Britain andFrance, betrayed by ally Russia, internally weakened and militarilybrought to her knees - the delegation of the Republic of Armeniaarrived at Alexandropol (Gyumri) on the 24th of November, 1920, inorder to commence negotiations with the so-called new, self-declaredrevolutionary Turkey. Ara Papyan"Modus Vivendi" center www.wilsonforarmenia.org Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.