Jump to content

Cemal Ozkaya contradict Weems...


Guest Fadi

Recommended Posts

... One of Weems affirmations, is that two numbers existed for the Armenians... that they had those hiden of 1.5 million refugies, and the other of 1.5 million perished, they have used the second for propaganda reasons(again for Weems) and the other to keep it for themselves(Weems suppose that it was the number believen by the Armenians,(1,5 million survivers))

 

But one of the main references for the denialists contradict his affirmation.

 

In Inayetullah Cemal Özkaya's book "Le Peuple Arménien et les Tentatives de Réduire Le Peuple Turc en Servitude."

 

We can read.

 

"The majority of national organizations, all the committees, the majority of the publicists, the ecclesiastics and Armenian orators, that presented memoirs, write books, brochures, journals, give interviews, that pronounced speeches of these last years, advanced 1,5 million, the number of Armenians, that escaped the massacres perpetrated by the Turks during the first World War, they were waiting in exile the exact moment, that would permit them to enter in their original country." (My translation, so may be, some grammatical mistakes)

 

p. 244

 

Now this author affirmation is right, I have observed the same thing. BUT, Weems allege that the number of 1.5 million refugies were hidden by the Armenians, when they showed the other numbers build up for propaganda reasons. The contrary is right, the Armenian publications of more then a million perished, were the ones hidden, and the one of 1,5 million refugies were the ones made public, everyone can read old records they will see it by themselves.

 

For example, the letter sent by the Armenians to France, in 11 Dec. 1918, about the fact that only 300,000 Armenians died, and that the construction of an Armenia still justified, since there is 1.5 million refugies that are waiting to enter and form their New Armenia. (From "Archives des affaires étrangères France, Levant, 1918-1929, Arménie V. M. 2m fo. 47.)

 

Denialists are very easy of citing these references from the French archives, because, it will show the clear purpose of the Armenian delegation to under-estimate their own losses and over-estimate the survivers, The King-Crane report criticised also by the Armenian delegation, concluded that 1 million died, and that it would be near impossible because of these losses, to form an Armenia majoritary of Armenians, so they planned a kind of calculation etc...

 

On the other way, Armenian delegations have used other techinics in order to justify such an Armenian state, reports of more then a million Armenian perishing would threaten the possible construction of an Armenia in a region that is ethnicly mixed, so investigations leading to a million or more victims always ended up of the accusation of the Armenian delegation on the allies for what happened to them, a kind of guiltiness put on the allies, and would be only repared by the construction of an Armenia...

 

For example when Armenia was not on the list of Nations, and that reports of victims were talking about a million and more, for example the League of Nations, that was stating that at Max. 900,000 survived and that probably 1 million or more perished... Just after we have Boghos Nubar writing in Newspapers that Armenia is not on the list of Nations and that they have lost more then a million of their population, and that they served for the allies(we know here what he is trying to do. We served for you, we died, it is your responsability now) etc...

 

So now we have Weems that reading denialist works remark something, then with some lies(like the fact that Armenians have hidden these numbers, when it was the compleat opposit), some distortions auto-proclam himself expert of the subject, and surprisaly this biggot know Turkish, Ottoman Turkish, Russian and Armenian, in order to "study" their files.

 

[ March 20, 2002, 07:22 AM: Message edited by: Domino ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

LOL... you know what guy's ?

 

The copy of the book "Le Peuple Arménien et les Tentatives de Réduire Le Peuple Turc en Servitude."

 

I had in my hands is probably the same as the one used as reference by Dr. Kevork K. Baghdjian to write his book "La confiscation par le gouvernement turc, des biens arméniens dits "abandonnés""

 

How I know it ? Thats a secret.

 

PS: In case some don't know who he is http://www.acam-france.org/contacts/livres...s/baghdjian.htm

 

[ March 20, 2002, 09:23 AM: Message edited by: Domino ]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Yep coincidences...

 

I would LOVE... that you could have understood French to the point of reading that book... It is chocking that I am the only one having that fun I feal isolated in my happiness with that book.

 

His theories about the Haykazans, and the Haykazanian(their language)

 

This book itself is a contradiction.

 

For example he talk about the Haykanzans(supposed to be US Armenians), that were not Armenians as the historic habitants of Armenia, that were the true Armenians... then say that the Haykazans came on the territory and mixed with the others(the true habitants of historic Armenia), then these Haykazans were called errnically Armenians...

 

Here is the Problem, he allege that when the Haykazans came on the region, they were minorities, and they mixed... and there language mixed... then, even taking his theory, he is contradicting himself... Suppose that you have a Chinese mother and Russian father, then you Marrie a Russian, in the new region that your mother came too, and you teach your child the language of the region that has been mixed... Can we tell that your child is a chinese ? Or more likely, more Russian the Chinese, and as a nre ethnic group, that has been mixed with a minority of Chinese with a majority of Russians...

 

The theory of the author is contradicting, this man is contradicting himself, he tell that Armenians are not really Armenians but Haykazans, the minorities camming in the region and living ommongs the majorities... and their language mixed... if we could have taken only one ethnic group, then it is more likely that it would be the majority that would chose our ethnic group after the assmilation, then present Armenians that he call Haykazans, would be more the product of the people of Anatolia then the Haykazans that he say we come from...

 

Another funny thing is when he talk about Sumerians living on the Area before the Armenians, he try indirectly to link them with the Turks, and tell us that the Turks were the actual encestors of these territories... he never tell it directly, but he contradict himself again by talking about the Seljuks that came on the region, when he previously suppose that there was Turks there...

 

He then make this clear when he talk about an attemp from the Armenians to eradicate the Turks in 1915, he say that Armenians tried to get rid of the ottocton population, this mean he is trying to compare Armenian alleged Attemps with Europeans that tried to expulse and kill American indians...

 

Its a funny book that should be read.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...