Jump to content

Insurers Owe Armenians Billions


Guest

Recommended Posts

Insurers Owe Armenians Billions in Genocide-Era Benefits, Study Shows

 

Ongoing Liability Documented in Major Armenian Forum Article

Dr. Hrayr Karagueuzian

 

Princeton, N.J. (7 August 2000)—New York Life, the Equitable, and other major insurance companies issued life insurance policies to several thousand Armenians in the Ottoman Empire. Almost all the policyholders—and their beneficiaries—were sent by the Turkish government to die in 1915–16. The benefits, which amounted to over 20 million 1915 dollars, remain due and payable, according to a study appearing in the journal Armenian Forum.

 

The first to draw attention to the insurance policies was Henry Morgenthau, the American envoy to Turkey in 1915. In his memoir, Ambassador Morgenthau’s Story, he recounted a haunting conversation with Interior Minister Talaat, one of the architects of the Armenian Genocide. Talaat wanted American life insurance companies to submit "a complete list of their Armenian policy holders. They are practically all dead now and have left no heirs to collect the money. It of course all escheats to the State. The Government is the beneficiary now."

 

The state did not succeed in collecting the information or the money. Nor did anyone else. Since the publication of Morgenthau’s memoir in 1918, the number of policies, the amount of benefits, and their final disposition have remained a mystery.

 

Now Professor Hrayr S. Karagueuzian of UCLA, working with newly declassified documents, has found answers to these lingering questions. His findings appear in a 56-page article in Armenian Forum.

 

Karagueuzian has found that New York Life alone had more than ten thousand outstanding policies in the Turkish empire in 1915. These policies were worth over ten million dollars. The numbers for the French Union-Vie are similar. The Equitable had around one thousand policies. Other American and European insurers were also active.

 

The insurers were acutely aware of their liability and scrambled to find ways out of it, Karagueuzian has shown. The president of the Equitable, Judge W. A. Day, for example, insisted on death certificates issued by local civil authorities. The perpetrators of the Genocide, however, were not in the habit of issuing such certificates.

 

The insurance companies also tried to shift liability for payment of the policy benefits onto Turkey. On this matter, Karagueuzian draws attention to a parallel case, also arising in 1915: the sinking of the Lusitania by Germany. In this case it was established that the perpetrators and the insurers bear separate and independent legal and financial obligations to the victims.

 

Karagueuzian notes that insurers stonewalled on Holocaust-era claims until legislators and insurance commissioners threatened their business. Similar pressure is building up, especially in the California legislature, to address claims arising from the Armenian Genocide.

 

In addition, a class-action lawsuit has been filed in federal district court in California. The lawsuit demands that New York Life release additional information about unclaimed policies issued in the Ottoman Empire.

 

The information uncovered in the Armenian Forum article makes it possible to vigorously pursue these claims, which have remained unpaid for eighty-five years.

 

The article, "Unclaimed Life Insurance Policies in the Aftermath of the Armenian Genocide: Legal and Historical Bases of Claims," appears in Armenian Forum, vol. 2, no. 2, pp. 1–56.

http://www.gomidas.org/forum/then-l.htm

Link to comment
Share on other sites

It figures...I let my subscription to Armenian Forum lapse, and the very next issue has their most interesting article yet (for my tastes). Guess I'll have to re-subscribe.

 

 

[This message has been edited by Pilafhead (edited January 30, 2001).]

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Policy Unpaid In Genocide; Armenians Sue New York Life Over Benefits

David Rogers Staff Writer

 

The Daily News of Los Angeles

January 30, 2001

 

LA CANADA FLINTRIDGE - Setrak Cheytanian must have feared the

worst.

 

It was 1910 and ethnic tensions were rising against Cheytanian and

other Armenians living in the Ottoman Empire, now Turkey.

 

That year, relatives say, Cheytanian bought a 3,000-franc life

insurance policy from New York Life Insurance Co.

 

Four years later, he gave a copy of the policy to his America-bound

sister-in-law. Shortly after, Cheytanian was killed.

 

''Apparently, Setrak gave the insurance policy to my mother because

she was coming to New York, thinking that since the policy is from

New York Life, it would be safe in New York,'' said Martin

Marootian, the lead plaintiff in a lawsuit that claims the

insurance company never paid benefits for policy holders who died

in the Armenian genocide around 1915.

 

''My mother's been trying to collect on this since 1923,'' said

Marootian, 85, who lives with his wife in La Canada Flintridge.

 

Attorney Brian Kabateck, who is representing Marootian and 49 other

plaintiffs, said he finds the case historically fascinating.

 

''They're remarkably similar to what the insurance companies were

giving over Holocaust claims. You can't prove the policy holder's

dead; you need to provide a death certificate, when of course

generally when there's a genocide they don't hand out death

certificates,'' he said.

 

Many such policies were sold. A 1915 letter from New York Life's

James H. McIntosh to Secretary of State William Jennings Bryan

said the policies amounted to more than $ 10 million in sales.

 

The company is by no means trying to duck its obligations,

officials said.

 

''Any statement that the company has historically ignored Armenian

claims is simply not true, because we have found in our archives

records of benefits paid to numerous Armenian policy holders killed

in 1915, even when the policies had lapsed,'' said New York Life's

William Werfelman.

 

In the early days of World War I, nationalism was on the rise in

the mostly Muslim nation, in which 2.5 million Armenians were a

Christian minority.

 

Beginning on April 24, 1915, Armenians inside the Ottoman Empire

were rounded up. Poor people and intellectuals were killed,

Armenian men were used for slave labor in the Turkish army, and

Armenian women and children were relocated, historians say.

 

''The way they relocated them was to make them walk - the women and

children and the elderly - to walk through the Syrian desert. Many

of them died en route,'' Marootian said. < The Turkish government

does not acknowledge that genocide occurred.

 

Werfelman of New York Life said the company needs proof that

Marootian is a rightful heir before his claim can be settled.

 

''We have repeatedly asked for that information,'' he said. ''That

is the primary obstacle to resolving the Marootian policy matter.''

 

Kabateck said he was surprised at that claim.

 

''That's a new one. Because that's something we can actually

document if they ever asked us for it,'' he said. ''I guess it

just demonstrates that 85 years hasn't changed anything - it's one

roadblock after another.''

 

Werfelman declined to say if New York Life is discussing a

settlement.

 

The company has also challenged a Los Angeles federal court's

jurisdiction over the case.

 

Werfelman noted the policies gave jurisdiction over disputes to

courts in France and England.

 

''It's important to preserve our rights under the law, including

jurisdictional issues,'' said Werfelman. New York Life has filed a

motion to transfer the case to France or England, for which a

hearing has been set for Feb. 5.

 

But Kabateck said SB 1915, a bill that Gov. Gray Davis signed into

law last year, gives courts in California jurisdiction over

insurance claims related to the Armenian Genocide. He also noted

that French and English courts don't allow class-action suits.

 

Sam Kadorian, 95, of Van Nuys is the only genocide survivor who is

a plaintiff to the suit. He vividly remembers being in the middle

of a pile of boys being speared with swords and bayonets.

 

''I got a souvenir - the point of a sword in my right cheek,''

which left a scar he still has, Kadorian said. ''To this day yet,

every time I look in the mirror, it all comes back.''

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...