MJ Posted May 14, 2001 Report Share Posted May 14, 2001 Article in Holocaust and Genocide StudiesThe following is an article concerning Heath Lowry that appeared in Holocaust and Genocide Studies, Vol. 9, Number 1, Spring 1995, pages 1-22 Professional Ethics and the Denial of Armenian GenocideBy:Roger W. SmithCollege of William and Mary Williamsburg, Virginia Eric MarkusenSouthwest State University Marshall, Minnesota Robert Jay LiftonThe City University of New York This article examines Turkish efforts to deny the Armenian genocide of 1915-17. Specifically, it exposes an arrangement by which the government of Turkey has channeled funds into a supposedly objective research institute in the United States, which in turn paid the salary of a historian who served that government in its campaign to discredit scholarship on the Armenian genocide. After a short review of the Armenian genocide and a range of Turkish denial efforts, three documents are reproduced in full. They include a letter that Robert Jay Lifton received from the Turkish Ambassador to the United States, and two documents that were inadvertently included with the Lifton letter, a memorandum to the Turkish Ambassador and a draft letter to Lifton for the Ambassador's signature. After a critical analysis of each document, we discuss the harmfulness of genocide denial and explore why intellectuals might engage in the denial of known genocides. The article concludes with reflections on the relationship between scholars and truth. The will to truth is cowed by pressure of numerous kinds, reasons of state on the one hand, economic necessities on the other, and, not least, the pure careerism of intellectuals who put their expertise in the service of power as a matter of course. When governments and professional elites find reward in the sophistries of might makes right, truth is bound to suffer. [1] Terrence Des Pres It has been said that gentlemen do not read other gentlemen's mail. Butsuppose that one receives a letter from the Turkish ambassador to the UnitedStates rebuking one's scholarship because one has written about what theambassador refers to as "the so-called 'Armenian genocide,' allegedlyperpetrated by the Ottoman Turks during the First World War." And supposethat, inadvertently, the envelope also contains an internal memorandum writtenby the executive director of what claims to be a non-political, scholarlyinstitute and that memorandum reveals much about the mentality of those whoengage in denial of the Armenian genocide. What then? The attempt to confuse and intimidate academics by such letters is an ongoingprocess. The letter that we shall present is from the current ambassador, buttwo of us have received such letters from his predecessor. The difference isthat only in the letter to Robert Jay Lifton is there created an opportunityto see what takes place behind the scenes, what assumptions guide the work ofscholars who engage in denial, and what the implications are in terms ofprofessional ethics. Our concern is not with the person who wrote the memorandum and drafted theletter, but with the role such scholars perform in the subversion ofscholarship and with their assumptions which substitute a narrative of powerfor the search for truth. In such narratives, as Terrence Des Pres has noted,"knowledge" is what serves the interest of the powerful (particularly thestate), the goal of knowledge is seen as control rather than freedom, and"truth" is whatever officials (and their adjuncts) say it is. [2] The Armenian Genocide and Turkey's Attempt to Deny It From 1915 to 1917 the Young Turk regime in the Ottoman Empire carried out asystematic, premeditated, centrally-planned genocide against the Armenianpeople. One of the documents authenticated by Turkish authorities in 1919 isa telegram sent in June 1915 by Dr. Sakir, one of the leaders of the secretorganization that carried out the planning and implementation of the genocide.He asks the provincial party official who is responsible for carrying out thedeportations and massacres of Armenians within his district: "Are theArmenians, who are being dispatched from there, being liquidated? Are thoseharmful persons whom you inform us you are exiling and banishing, beingexterminated, or are they being merely dispatched and exiled? Answerexplicitly...." [3] The evidence of intent is backed also by the outcome of the actions againstthe Armenians: it is inconceivable that over a million persons could have dieddue to even a badly flawed effort at resettlement. Moreover, the pattern ofdestruction was repeated over and over in different parts of Turkey, many ofthem far from any war zone; such repetition could only have come from acentral design. Further, the reward structure was geared toward destruction ofthe Christian minority: provincial governors and officials who refused tocarry out orders to annihilate the Armenians were summarily replaced. [4] Armenian men were drafted into the army, set to work as pack animals, andsubsequently killed. Leaders were arrested and executed. Then the deportationsof women, children, and the elderly into the deserts of Syria and Iraq began.The American ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, Henry Morgenthau, immediatelyrecognized that the forced marches into the desert, and the atrocities thataccompanied them, were a new form of massacre. "When the Turkish authoritiesgave the orders for these deportations, they were simply giving the deathwarrant to a whole race; they understood this well, and in their conversationswith me, they made no particular attempt to conceal the fact." [5] The ambassadors of Germany and Austria, representatives of governments alliedwith Turkey, also quickly realized what was taking place. As early as July1915, the German ambassador reported to Berlin: "Turks began deportations fromareas now not threatened by invasion. This fact and the manner in which therelocation is being carried out demonstrate that the government is reallypursuing the aim of destroying the Armenian race in Turkey." And by January1917 his successor reported: "The policy of extermination has been largelyachieved; the current leaders of Turkey fully subscribe to this policy." [6] More than one million Armenians perished as the result of execution,starvation, disease, the harsh environment, and physical abuse. A people wholived in eastern Turkey for nearly 3,000 years lost its homeland and wasprofoundly decimated in the first large scale genocide of the twentiethcentury. At the beginning of 1915 there were some two million Armenians withinTurkey; today there are fewer than 60,000. Despite the vast amount of evidence that points to the historical reality ofthe Armenian genocide_eyewitness accounts, official archives, photographicevidence, the reports of diplomats, and the testimony of survivors [7], denialof the Armenian genocide by successive regimes in Turkey has gone on from 1915to the present. [8] The basic argument of denial has remained the same, it never happened, Turkeyis not responsible, the term "genocide" does not apply. The tactics of denial,however, have shifted over the years. [9] In the period immediately afterWorld War I the tactic was to find scapegoats to blame for what was said to beonly a security measure that had gone awry due to unscrupulous officials,Kurds, and common criminals. This was followed by an attempt to avoid thewhole issue, with silence, diplomatic efforts, and political pressure usedwhere possible. In the 1930s, for example, Turkey pressured the U.S. StateDepartment into preventing MGM Studios from producing a film based on FranzWerfel's The Forty Days of Musa Dagh, a book that depicted aspects of thegenocide in a district located west of Antioch on the Mediterranean Sea, farfrom the Russian front. [10] In the 1960s, prompted by the worldwide commemoration of the fiftiethanniversary of the genocide, efforts were made to influence journalists,teachers, and public officials by telling "the other side of the story."Foreign scholars were encouraged to revise the record of genocide, presentingan account largely blaming the Armenians or, in another version, wartimeconditions which claimed the lives of more Turks than Armenians. [11]Thereafter, Turkey tried to prohibit any mention of the genocide in a UnitedNations report and was successful in its pressure on the Reagan and Bushadministrations in defeating Congressional resolutions that would havedesignated April 24 as a national day of remembrance of the Armeniangenocide. [12] The Turkish government has also attempted to exclude anymention of the genocide from American textbooks. Stronger efforts still havebeen made to prevent any discussion of the 1915 genocide being formallyincluded in the social studies curriculum as part of Holocaust and genocidestudies. [13] There have also been attempts by the Turkish government to disrupt academicconferences and public discussions of the genocide. A notable example was theattempt by Turkish officials to force cancellation of a conference in Tel Avivin 1982 if the Armenian genocide were to be discussed, demands backed up withthreats to the safety of Jews in Turkey. [14] The U.S. Holocaust MemorialCouncil reported similar threats over plans to include references to theArmenian genocide within the interpretive framework of the Holocaust MemorialMuseum in Washington. [15] At the same time, Turkey has sought to make anabsolute distinction between the Holocaust and the Armenian genocide, definingthe latter as "alleged" or "so-called." The documents we have, however, showthat, in private, such labeling drops off (a point to which we shall returnand discuss in detail). Finally, in the 1980s the Turkish government supported the establishment of"institutes", whose apparent purpose was to further research on Turkishhistory and culture. At least one also was used to further denial of Turkishgenocide and otherwise improve Turkey's image in the West. To our knowledge,the memorandum and letters that we reproduce in full provide the first directevidence of the close relationship between the Turkish government and one suchinstitute. Before turning to that evidence, we shall provide backgroundinformation on the origin, funding, stated purposes, and tax status of theinstitute from which that evidence comes. The Institute of Turkish Studies The Institute of Turkish Studies, Inc., located in Washington, D.C., wasestablished in 1982 with a grant of three million dollars from the Republic ofTurkey. [16] Information about its current finances is not readily available,but in 1989 it had expenditures of $264,593, of which $121,062 was for grants.That year it received gifts of nearly $240,000. The sources of the gifts areunknown to us, but in the past much of its financial support has come fromAmerican corporations that sell military equipment to the Turkish government.In 1992 the Institute began a fund-raising campaign to double its endowment tosix million dollars, with funds to be raised from businesses in America andTurkey. The organization itself has a staff of two: an executive director and asecretary. There is also a board of directors, which includes severalacademics among its members. In various directories of associations, its purposes and activities are listedas: To provide funding for research centers and scholars interested in Turkish studies; to encourage development of Turkish studies in university curricula. Bestows awards. Maintains 5000 volume library on the Ottoman Empire, Turkey, and Turkish history. Grants for the academic community of U.S. specialists in the field of Turkish studies; support includes awards to individual scholars and to institutions. The Institute's fields of interest are said to be "Turkey, higher education."In terms of activities, it is said to provide grants to individuals andinstitutions for "research, publications, scholarship funds, fellowships, seedmoney, conferences and seminars, including matching funds, grants toindividuals." Its own brochure published within the first years of the founding of theInstitute, however, throws a somewhat different light on its stated purpose.The Institute states that it has received grants from major defensecontractors, such as General Dynamics and Westinghouse, and with this supportthe Institute "shall continue to play a key role in furthering knowledge andunderstanding of a key NATO ally of the United States, the Republic of Turkey,among citizens of our country." [17] Unfortunately, the phrase "furtheringknowledge and understanding" includes measures that have been construed asdenial of the Armenian genocide. Under United States tax law, the Institute falls within section 501©3 of theInternal Revenue Filing Status: Charitable organization; educational organization; literary organization; organization to prevent cruelty to children; organization for public safety testing; religious organization; or scientific organization. Given its tax filing status, the Institute for Turkish Studies is exempt fromtaxation. Contributions to the Institute are tax deductible. The executive director of the Institute from its inception to 1994 was Dr.Heath W. Lowry, who received his doctorate in history from UCLA. His mentor atUCLA was Professor Stanford Shaw, whose history of Turkey strenuously deniesthe reality of the Armenian genocide, while, at the same time, blaming thevictims, who are depicted as disloyal, rebellious, and terroristic. [18] It isLowry who wrote the memorandum and drafted the letter for the ambassador thatare now made public for the first time. In 1994 Dr. Lowry became the first incumbent of the Ataturk Chair in TurkishStudies at Princeton University. The chair was established through a $1.5million grant from the Republic of Turkey. In its Report of the Institute ofTurkish Studies, Inc., 1982-1992, the Institute cites its "key role . . . inencouraging the Government of Turkey to embark upon a plan of endowing aseries of Chairs in Turkish Studies at major American Universities. In anadvisory capacity the Institute has been involved in every stage of thisprocess." The report notes that the chair at Princeton is "fully establishedand funded" and that the Institute supports "the further creation of endowedchairs at three other U.S. Universities." [19] Analysis of the Lowry Memorandum Let us now consider what Lowry's memorandum reveals about the mentality andtactics of denial, then turn to the letter, commenting on its style andcontent. Memorandum from Dr. Heath Lowry, Executive Director of the Institute of Turkish Studies, Inc., to Nuzhet Kandemir, Turkish Ambassador to the United States, September 26, 1990 M E M O R A N D U M - - - - - - - - - - _TO_: H.E. AMBASSADOR NUZHET KANDEMIR: _FROM_: DR. HEATH W. LOWRY; _REG_: COMMENTS ON THE "ARMENIAN GENOCIDE" INCLUDED IN THE ROBERT JAY LIFTON STUDY ENTITLED: _THE NAZI DOCTORS, MEDICAL KILLINGS AND THE PSYCHOLOGY OF GENOCIDE_; _DATE_: SEPTEMBER 26, 1990. PER YOUR REQUEST CONVEYED TO ME BY MS. HILAL BASKAL OF YOUR STAFF, I HAVELOCATED AND READ LIFTON'S _THE NAZI DOCTORS_, WITH AN EYE TO DRAFTING A LETTERFOR YOUR SIGNATURE TO THE AUTHOR. LIFTON'S WORK, A MASSIVE TOME OF XIII + 561PAGES, IS AUTHORED BY A PROFESSOR OF PSYCHIATRY AND PSYCHOLOGY AT JOHN JAYCOLLEGE AND THE GRADUATE CENTER OF THE CITY UNIVERSITY OF NEW YORK [NOTE: THELATTER IS THE SAME INSTITUTION WHERE PROFESSOR RUSTOW OF THE I.T.S. BOARDTEACHES]. HE IS A WELL KNOWN AUTHORITY ON THE TRAUMA OF WAR AND HIS MAJORWORKS INCLUDE: _DEATH IN LIFE_ (1968) _HOME FROM THE WAR_ (1973) _THE LIFE OF THE SELF_ (1976) _THE BROKEN CONNECTION_ (1982) IN SHORT, LIFTON IS A RECOGNIZED AUTHORITY IN HIS OWN FIELD WHO CLEARLY KNOWSABSOLUTELY NOTHING ABOUT THE SO-CALLED "ARMENIAN GENOCIDE." INDEED, A CAREFULPERUSAL OF HIS BOOK, REVEALS THAT IN ITS 561 PAGES HE MAKES THE FOLLOWING FEWREFERENCES TO THE SUBJECT: _P. XII._ "BUT I FOUND THAT NAZI DOCTORS DIFFERED SIGNIFICANTLY FROM THESE OTHER GROUPS, NOT SO MUCH IN THEIR HUMAN EXPERIMENTATION BUT IN THEIR CENTRAL ROLE IN GENOCIDAL PROJECTS . . . _(PERHAPS TURKISH DOCTORS, IN THEIR PARTICIPATION IN THE GENOCIDE AGAINST THE ARMENIANS, COME CLOSEST, AS I SHALL I LATER SUGGEST) . ." [NOTE: LIFTON DOES NOT PROVIDE ANY SOURCE FOR THIS STATEMENT FOLLOWING THIS PASSAGE; _PP.466-7_: I SHALL REFER TO OTHER GENOCIDES -- NOTABLY THE TURKS' ANNIHILATION OF ABOUT ONE MILLION ARMENIANS IN 1915- _NOT WITH ANY CLAIM TO COMPREHENSIVENESS_ BUT ONLY TO SUGGEST WIDER APPLICATION NOTE: AGAIN NO FOOTNOTED SOURCE. MORE IMPORTANTLY IS LIFTON'S ADMISSION THAT HE DOESN'T CLAIM ANY EXPERTISE ON THE SUBJECT HE IS GOING TO ADDRESS; _P. 470_: THERE SEEM TO HAVE BEEN DEFINITE PARALLELS IN TURKISH HISTORICAL EXPERIENCE PRIOR TO THEIR MASS MURDER OF ARMENIANS IN 1915. WITHIN THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE, THROUGHOUT THE LATTER PART OF THE NINETEENTH CENTURY, THERE WAS AN ATMOSPHERE OF PROGRESSIVE 'DECAY AND DISINTEGRATION', ALONG WITH A CONTINUOUS IF LOSING STRUGGLE FOR SPIRITUAL AND POLITICAL UNIFICATION. THE TURKS ALSO EXPERIENCED HUMILIATING FORMS Of FAILED REGENERATION IN THEIR DISASTROUS MILITARY ENTERPRISES DURING THE 1912 BALKAN WAR (IGNOMINIOUS DEFEAT AT THE HANDS OF THEIR FORMER SLAVES AND WARDS, THE GREEKS AND THE BULGARIANS) AND THEIR ABORTIVE RUSSIAN CAMPAIGN IN 1915 AS A GERMAN ALLY. _VAHAKN N. DADRIAN_ OBSERVES THAT THE TURKS MOVED CLOSER TO GENOCIDE AS THEIR PERCEPTION OF THEIR SITUATION PROCEEDED 'FROM THE CONDITION OF MERE STRAIN, TO THAT Of CRISIS, TO A PRECIPITATE CRISIS, AND EVENTUALLY TO THE CATACLYSM OF WAR.' [19] _FOOTNOTE 19_: VAHAKN N. DADRIAN, "THE ROLE OF TURKISH PHYSICIANS IN THE WORLD WAR I GENOCIDE OF OTTOMAN ARMENIANS," _HOLOCAUST AND GENOCIDE STUDIES_ I (1986, FORTHCOMING); DADRIAN, "THE COMMON FEATURES OF THE ARMENIAN AND JEWISH CASES OF GENOCIDE: A COMPARATIVE VICTIMOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE," IN ISRAEL DRAPKIN AND EMILIOI VIANO, _VICTIMOLOGY; A NEW FOCUS, VOL. IV (LEXINGTON, MASS: D.C. HEATH, 1974, PP. 99-120. SEE ALSO, HELEN FEIN, ACCOUNTING FOR GENOCIDE: VICTIMS -- AND SURVIVORS -- OF THE HOLOCAUST (NEW YORK: FREE PRESS, 1979, PO. 10-18. _NOTE_: THE SOLE SOURCE FOR LIFTON'S COMMENTS IS THE ARMENIAN AUTHOR: VAHAKN DADRIAN. P. 473: "AGAIN, THERE ARE SUGGESTIONS OF SIMILAR CURRENTS IN THE TURKISH SITUATION. THE YOUNG TURKS' WHO SOUGHT TO REFORM THE OTTOMAN EMPIRE SPEARHEADED 'A MAJOR CAMPAIGN TO CHANGE THE SOCIAL STRUCTURE OF OTTOMAN SOCIETY AS AN ANTIDOTE TO INTERNAL DISCORD AND CONFLICT, AND ALSO AS A MEANS OF RECAPTURING. IMPERIAL, PANTURKIC GLORY.' THEIR CURE INCLUDED AN ADMIXTURE OF RELIGIOUS AND POLITICAL IDEOLOGIES,' AND AND GENOCIDE BECAME A MEANS FOR [ BRINGING ABOUT ] A RADICAL ..... CHANGE IN THE SYSTEM.'" [34] _FOOTNOTE 34_: SEE DADRIAN, "TURKISH PHYSICIANS" AND "COMMON FEATURES" [19] _NOTE_: AGAIN, LIFTON'S SOLE SOURCE FOR HIS VIEWS ON THE TURCO- ARMENIAN QUESTION ARE THE TWO ARTICLES OF DADRIAN CITED IN FOOTNOTE 19. P. 475: IN THE CASE OF THE TURKS, WHATEVER THEIR ATTITUDE TOWARDS SCIENCE, THEY DID PUT FORWARD A MYSTICAL VISION OF PAN- TURANIANISM (OR 'TURKIFICATION') _WHICH ALLEGED A PREHISTORIC MYTHIC UNITY AMONG TURANIAN PEOPLES BASED ON RACIAL ORIGIN_' [43] AND ONE CANNOT DOUBT THE EXPERIENCE OF TRANSCENDENCE OF TURKISH NATIONALISTS IN THEIR REVERSION TO FUNDAMENTALIST MOHAMMEDANISM AS A CALL TO AN ANTI-ARMENIAN-CHRISTIAN CRUSADE -- ALL ON BEHALF OF A NEW VISION OF OTTOMAN GLORY." _FOOTNOTE 43_: DADRIAN, "TURKISH PHYSICIANS" [19]. _NOTE_: ONCE AGAIN, LIFTON'S _SOLE_ SOURCE ID DADRIAN P. 488: "ARMENIANS WERE DESCRIBED AS '_A CANCER, A MALIGNANCE WHICH LOOKS LIKE A SMALL PIMPLE FROM THE OUTSIDE, WHICH, IF NOT REMOVED BY A SKILLFUL SURGEON'S SCALPEL, WILL KILL THE PATIENT'" [108] _FOOTNOTE 108_: A YOUNG TURK ACTIVIST, QUOTED IN KUPER, _GENOCIDE_, P 40 [LEO KUPER, _GENOCIDE: ITS POLITICAL USE IN THE TWENTIETH CENTURY_ (NEW HAVEN: YALE UNIVERSITY PRESS, 1981), PP. 19-23, 210-214 _NOTE_: AGAIN, LIFTON IS SIMPLY CITING AN ALREADY PUBLISHED (AND VERY WELL KNOWN) BOOK BY A JEWISH EXPERT ON THE HOLOCAUST. P. 493: "ONE CANNOT SAY THAT ANY PARTICULAR LEVEL OF TECHNOLOGY IS REQUIRED FOR GENOCIDE: THE TURKS KILLED ABOUT A MILLION ARMENIANS BY MEANS OF SHOOTING, CLUBBING, BEATING, SLAVE LABOR, STARVATION, AND OTHER FORMS OF TORTURE," _NOTE_: THERE IS NO FOOTNOTE APPENDED TO THIS STATEMENT, BUT IT IS CLEARLY TAKEN FROM THE DADRIAN ARTICLES AS WELL. ********** IN SUMMATION, WHAT WE ARE FACED WITH HERE ARE SEVEN REFERENCES(COMPRISING ABOUT ONE FULL PAGE OF TEXT) IN A BOOK OF 561 PAGES. THEY AREBASED ALMOST EXCLUSIVELY ON THE ARTICLES BY DADRIAN (EACH OF WHICH HAVE BEENTHE SUBJECT OF DETAILED MEMOS BY THIS WRITER IN PAST YEARS), TOGETHER WITHREFERENCES TO THE WORK OF HELEN FEIN (WHOSE BOOK INCLUDES A FULL CHAPTER ONTHE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE) AND LEO KUPER (WHOSE BOOK CONTAINS A VERY LONG CHAPTERON THE GENOCIDE). STATED DIFFERENTLY, LIFTON, IN HIS BOOK PUBLISHED FOURYEARS AGO IN 1986, IS SIMPLY USING THE EXISTING LITERATURE ON THE HOLOCAUSTAND GENOCIDE. CONSEQUENTLY, OUR BASIC PROBLEM IS WITH AUTHORS SUCH AS DADRIAN,FEIN, AND KUPER, EACH OF WHOM ARE NOW SERVING AS SOURCES FOR AUTHORS SUCH ASLIFTON. THESE FACTS MAKE IT RATHER DIFFICULT TO REGISTER OUR UNHAPPINESS WITHLIFTON PER SE, AS HE WILL QUITE JUSTIFIABLY RESPOND BY GIVING US REFERENCES TOHIS SOURCES, I.E. DADRIAN, FEIN, AND KUPER. OUR PROBLEM IS LESS WITH LIFTON THAN IT IS WITH THE WORKS UPON WHICH HERELIES. LIFTON IS SIMPLY THE END OF THE CHAIN, THAT IS, FROM NOW ON WE WILLSEE _ALL_ WORKS ON GENOCIDE OF THE JEWS, INCLUDING REFERENCES SUCH AS THOSEMADE BY LIFTON ON THE BASIS OF THE WORKS OF DADRIAN, FEIN, KUPER, HOVANNISIAN,ET. AL. THOUGH THIS POINT HAS BEEN REPEATEDLY STRESSED BOTH IN WRITING ANDVERBALLY TO I.A.D.A.-ANKARA, WE HAVE NOT YET SEEN AS MUCH AS A SINGLE ARTICLEBY ANY SCHOLAR RESPONDING TO _DADRIAN_ (OR ANY OF THE OTHERS AS WELL). I STRONGLY RECOMMEND THAT IT BE POINTED OUT TO ANKARA THAT LIFTON'S BOOKIS SIMPLY THE END RESULT OF THE TURKISH FAILURE TO RESPOND IN A PROMPT FASHIONTO THE DADRIAN ARTICLES AND THE FEIN AND KUPER BOOK. ON THE CHANCE THAT YOU WILL STILL WISH TO RESPOND IN WRITING TO LIFTON,I HAVE DRAFTED THE FOLLOWING LETTER, WHICH, DUE TO THE ABSENCE OF AN ADDRESSFOR LIFTON WILL HAVE TO BE SENT TO HIM IN CARE OF HIS PUBLISHER. Draft of letter to Dr. Robert Jay Lifton, prepared by Dr. Heath Lowry, to be signed by Ambassador Nuzhet Kandemir D R A F T L E T T E R - - - - - - - - - - - MR. ROBERT JAY LIFTON% BASIC BOOKS, INC.10 E 53RD. STREETNEW YORK, NEW YORK 10022 DEAR MR. LIFTON: YOUR 1986 PUBLICATION ENTITLED: _THE NAZI DOCTORS, MEDICAL KILLINGAND THE PSYCHOLOGY OF GENOCIDE_ WAS RECENTLY BROUGHT TO MY ATTENTION. NEEDLESSTO SAY, I WAS SHOCKED BY REFERENCES IN YOUR WORK (PP. XII., 466-7, 470, 473,476, 488, & 493) TO THE SO CALLED "ARMENIAN GENOCIDE," ALLEGEDLY PERPETRATEDBY THE OTTOMAN TURKS DURING THE FIRST WORLD WAR. I WAS EVEN MORE DISTURBEDWHEN YOUR CITATIONS REVEALED THAT YOUR SOURCES CONSISTED Of ARTICLES AND BOOKSBY THREE INDIVIDUALS (VAHAKN N. DADRIAN, HELEN FEIN AND LEO KUPER), NONE OFWHOM ARE HISTORIANS OF THE PERIOD IN QUESTION AND NONE OF WHOM RELY ON PRIMARYRESEARCH IN THEIR OWN WORKS. IN SHORT, YOU HAVE SIMPLY PASSED ALONG QUESTIONABLE SECONDARY SOURCESAS EVIDENCE fOR A NUMBER OF CONTENTIONS WHICH ARE, TO SAY THE LEAST, HOTLYDEBATED AMONG CONTEMPORARY SCHOLARS WRITING ON THE PERIOD AND EVENTS INQUESTION. IT IS PARTICULARLY DISTURBING TO SEE A MAJOR SCHOLAR ON THE HOLOCAUST,A TRAGEDY WHOSE ENORMITY AND BARBARITY MUST NEVER BE FORGOTTEN, SO CARELESSIN HIS REFERENCES TO A FIELD OUTSIDE HIS OWN AREA OF EXPERTISE. FOR TURKS, WHOARE JUSTIFIABLY PROUD OF OUR LONG AND CONTINUING ROLE AS A HAVEN FORMINORITIES (INCLUDING THE JEWS EVICTED FROM SPAIN BY THE INQUISITION), IT ISPARTICULARLY DISQUIETING TO FIND OUR OWN HISTORY DISTORTED IN WORKS DEVOTED TOTHE HOLOCAUST OF WORLD WAR II. TO COMPARE A TRAGIC CIVIL WAR (PERPETRATED BY MISGUIDED ARMENIANNATIONALISTS) AND THE HUMAN SUFFERING IT WROUGHT ON BOTH THE MUSLIM ANDCHRISTIAN POPULATIONS, WITH THE HORRORS OF A PREMEDITATED ATTEMPT TOSYSTEMATICALLY ERADICATE A PEOPLE, IS, TO ANYONE FAMILIAR WITH THE HISTORY INQUESTION, SIMPLY LUDICROUS I AM ENCLOSING COPIES OF WORKS BY TWO AMERICAN EXPERTS ON THE HISTORYOF TURCO ARMENIAN RELATIONS, PROFESSORS JUSTIN MCCARTHY AND HEATH LOWRY, ANDWOULD HOPE THAT IN THE INTERESTS OF OBJECTIVITY AND FAIRNESS YOU WILL NOT ONLYREAD THEM, BUT REFLECT HAVING DONE SO IN ANY FUTURE WORKS YOU MAY PUBLISH. SINCERELY YOURS, NUZHET KANDEMIR AMBASSADOR, REPUBLIC OF TURKEY WASHINGTON, D.C. Letter from Ambassador Nuzhet Kandemir to Robert Jay Lifton, October 2, 1990 TURKISH EMBASSY 10/16 certified mailWASHINGTON, D.C. 4047-434 October 2, 1990 Mr. Robert Jay Liftonc/o Basic Books, Inc.10 E 53rd StreetNew York, NY 10022 Your 1986 publication, _The Nazi Doctors: Medical Killing and thePsychology of Genocide_, was recently brought to my attention. Needless tosay, I was shocked by references in your work (pp x11, 466-7, 470, 473, 476,486, and 493) to the so-called "Armenian genocide" allegedly perpetrated bythe Ottoman Turks during the First World War. I was even more disturbed whenyour citations revealed that your sources consisted of articles and books bythree individuals: Vahakn N. Dadrian, Helen Fein, and Leo Kuper, none of whomare historians of the period in question and none of whom rely on primaryresearch in their own works. In short you have simply passed along questionable secondary sourcesas evidence for a number of contentions which are, to say the least, hotlydebated among contemporary scholars writing on the period and events at issue. It is particularly disturbing to see a major scholar on the Holocaust,a tragedy whose enormity and barbarity must never be forgotten, so careless inhis references to a field outside his area of expertise. For Turks, who arejustifiably proud of our long and continuing role as a haven for minorities(including the Jews evicted from Spain by the Inquisition), it is particularlydisquieting to find our own history distorted in works devoted to theHolocaust of World War II. To compare a tragic civil war (initiated by Armenian nationalists) andthe human suffering it wrought on both the Muslim and Christian populationswith the horrors of a premeditated attempt to systematically eradicate apeaceable people is, to anyone familiar with the history in question, simplyludicrous I am enclosing copies of works by two American experts on the historyof Turco-Armenian relations, Professors Justin McCarthy and Heath Lowry, andwould hope that an the interests of objectivity and fairness you will not onlyread them but also reflect having done so in any future works you may publish. Yours Sincerely [ signed ] Nuzhet Kandemir Ambassador The memorandum indicates that Lowry has been engaged in an ongoingrelationship with the Turkish government, and that he has regularly offeredadvice on denial both to the Turkish ambassador to the United States and toother persons in Turkey (IADA-Ankara). The memorandum also provides evidence of the desire to check scholars fromreferring to an Armenian genocide. Indeed, the process by now may even bealmost bureaucratic. It is easy to surmise that someone at the embassyidentifies books and articles that mention the genocide (is denial part of hisor her official duties?), the list is turned over to Lowry at the request ofthe ambassador, and Lowry examines the works in question, provides a report inthe form of a memorandum, and then prepares a letter for the ambassador'ssignature. Lowry reads Lifton's book, not out of interest or to be informed: he does itas a service to the Turkish government, "with an eye to drafting a letter foryour [the ambassador's] signature to the author." Why a scholar would conceiveof his or her craft in this fashion is not a question that admits of easyanswers. But as we shall suggest in another section of the article, it is notuncommon. What is clear from the memorandum, though, is that Lowry identifieswith the power of the Turkish government. He twice refers to "our problem,"that is, the availability of works that discuss the Armenian genocide,suggesting that he sees himself as part of a power constellation engaged butin furthering the perceived interests of the government of Turkey. Lowry is critical, in fact, of the ineptitude of the deniers who thereby failto serve what he assumes are Turkey's interests. He has repeatedly told,verbally and in writing, those in power that they must attack and discreditarticles or books by Dadrian, Fein, Kuper, and others, yet not a single attackhas been written. He underlines the date of Lifton's book -1986- and suggestsimplicitly that four years is simply too long: material must be subjected todamage control at the earliest possible moment. And one does wonder why ittook so long in this case, since Markusen and Smith received letters along thelines addressed to Lifton within months of the appearance of their essays in_Genocide and the Modern Age_. [20] Lowry's own work contains many questionable assertions and conclusions. Hedenies that Hitler ever uttered the widely quoted remark: 'Who, after all,speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?" [21] And in his recentbook, _The Story Behind Ambassador Morgenthau's Story_, he asserts thatMorgenthau's account of the genocide is nothing but "crude half-truths andoutright falsehoods . . . from cover to cover." [22] His conclusions do not infact follow from his analysis or the evidence he can marshal. Quiteastonishing, however, is his claim that what Talaat, a principal architect ofthe Armenian genocide, had in mind for the Armenians was not destruction, but"segregation," that the fate of the Armenians was to be that of African-Americans in the South in 1915. [23] Lowry apparently seeks to discredit the work of any author who treats theArmenian genocide as historical reality. But those in Ankara, with whom he hascommunicated again and again on how to discredit works on the Armeniangenocide, have not heeded his words. "I strongly recommend that it be pointedout to Ankara.... " Had people listened to me, he suggests, "we" wouldn't befaced with "our" present "problem." Analysis of the Letter to Lifton Various perspectives on denial can be brought to bear on the content of theletter. Smith notes that typically the denial of genocide involves denial thatthe events took place, that the perpetrator bears any responsibility for thedestruction, or that the term "genocide" is applicable to what occurred.Deborah Lipstadt, in her work on the Holocaust, speaks of the "Yes, but" modeof denial: applied to the present case, Yes, Armenians died, but so did Turks.Yes, Armenians were killed, but they brought it upon themselves. Yes, theconflict took place, but it was a civil war within a global war. Likewise,Israel Charny has pointed to a "template of denial," the rules of whichinclude: do not acknowledge that the genocide took place; transform it intoother kinds of events; portray the victims as the perpetrators; insist morevictims were from the perpetrator's group; and relativize the genocide inwhatever way possible. [24] The letter is too limited in purpose to displayall of the elements depicted in these overlapping perspectives, but they arefound in the larger literature of denial of the 1915 genocide. In terms of the letter itself, however, we want to call attention to twoaspects of denial that are part and parcel of Turkey's denial tactics. Thegoal of each is to prevent recognition of the fact that what the Ottomangovernment did to the Armenians in 1915 constitutes genocide. First, there is an attempt to remove the label "genocide" from the Armenianexperience. This is done in part by not differentiating between the victims ofthe massacre and of warfare, of blaming the victims as the initiators ofviolence (thus suggesting that they got what they deserved, even though itnever happened), and describing the genocide as a civil war within a globalwar. In the end, the genocide of over a million Armenians is made to appearlike an "amorphous human disaster." [25] A second theme, unique to the Turkish case, is the determination to deny theArmenian genocide by acknowledging the Holocaust. [26] This involves in partspecial efforts by Turkey to recognize the tragedy of the Holocaust and showcompassion for its victims. But Turkey has also gone to extraordinary lengths,including threats and disruption of academic conferences, to prevent Jews fromlearning about the Armenian genocide. Moreover, one notes that Lowry'memorandum stresses that Lifton relied upon the work of other scholars, butthis, he argues, is precisely why it is necessary to discredit at the outsetauthors such as Dadrian, Fein, and Kuper. The danger Lowry sees is that "fromnow on we will see all works on the genocide of the Jews" containingreferences to the Armenian genocide. Such references would allow forcomparison and the conclusion that, for different reasons, both Jews andArmenians have been victims of genocide. There is another aspect to this,however, that can best be addressed in terms of the letter -- the attempt ofthe Turkish government and its intellectuals to draw a sharp and decisivedistinction between the Holocaust and the experience of the Armenians in 1915. The letter states that to make any comparison of the Holocaust and theArmenian genocide is ludicrous. But it is not ludicrous: the similarities havebeen pointed out by many scholars, most recently by Robert Melson in his majorwork on Revolution and Genocide: On the Origins of the Armenian Genocide andthe Holocaust. [27] Other leading Jewish scholars of the Holocaust, in fact,describe the Armenian massacres and deportations into the desert as genocide,and one that approximates the Holocaust in important respects. Yehuda Bauer,for example, not only points out the similarities between the Armeniangenocide and the Holocaust, but states that on a "continuum of murderousbehavior, the Armenian massacres would figure nearest to the Holocaust. [28]Similarly, the late Lucy Dawidowicz stated that the Armenian genocide in its"extent and horror most closely approximated the murder of the European Jews."She continued: "The once unthinkable 'Armenian solution' became, in our time,the achievable 'Final Solution,' the Nazi code name for the annihilation ofthe European Jews." 29] Concluding Reflections on the Memorandum and Letter To confront denial is to face a recurrent question: do those who engage indenial of a well-documented genocide actually believe their own words, or dothey know better, but disregard the facts for personal or political reasons?The issue is complicated in that denial is, at times, a deliberate distortionof the facts to serve some presumed advantage. But denial may also be a"defense mechanism" that functions to reduce stress and inner conflict. As adefense mechanism, the events and feelings that one wants to deny are notcompletely removed from consciousness, but are rather placed in a morefavorable light through a kind of selective emphasis and reappraisal. Whilethis distorts the truth, the person who uses such a strategy may not be awarethat he or she is doing so to make the situation less threatening.Nevertheless, denial as distortion of truth and as self-servingrationalization are often intertwined and reinforce each other. In the case of Lowry and the ambassador, there is a sense in which their wholeenterprise involves a retelling of the Armenian genocide to place Turks in afavorable light and Armenians in a bad light: in such accounts the victim isinvariably blamed for the genocide; indeed, is cast in the role ofperpetrator. But for all the reinterpretation and selective uses of history,there is a clue that the ambassador and Lowry know that the Armenian genocidetook place, which would make their public statements to the contrary appear tobe calculated distortions of the truth. To return to the documents at hand. The letter Lifton received and the draftof it by Lowry are explicit in denying the genocide, and speak of the"so-called 'Armenian genocide,' allegedly perpetrated by the Ottoman Turksduring the First World War." However, when we examine the memorandum, adifferent story appears, with a decided gap between the public discourse ofthe letter and the private discourse of the memorandum. On the first page ofthe memorandum, the executive director of the Institute of Turkish Studiesapproaches the subject, and the ambassador, delicately, referring to the"so-called 'Armenian Genocide.'" Yet a few pages later, when he gives his"summation," Lowry speaks openly without using such terms as "alleged" or"so-called": he now writes, without quotation marks, about "the ArmenianGenocide" and "the genocide." It is hard to believe that he would present suchlanguage to the ambassador unless he knew that the ambassador would not beoffended. The Harmfulness of Genocide Denial We should not be surprised by instances of what many would consider to beinappropriate use of academic credentials and skills, since, after all,academics and professionals have contributed in direct ways to genocidalkilling projects, including the Armenian genocide and the Holocaust. They havedone so by lending their talents and prestige to racist, victimizingideologies that are central features of many genocides, by helping to createand administer the policies and technologies of mass killing, and by actuallyengaging in the killing. [30] If highly educated academics and professionalshave been able to repudiate their ethical codes and serve as accomplices andperpetrators of actual genocides, it is likely that they would be even moreable to engage in an activity in which no one is killed. It would be a mistake, however, to underestimate the serious harm caused bydenial of genocide, particularly denial wrapped in the guise of legitimatescholarship. In this section, we examine the harm done by pseudo-scholarlydenial of known genocides and consider the assertion, put forth by somescholars, that deliberate denial is a form of aggression that ought to beregarded as a contribution to genocidal violence in its own right. Then webriefly address the question of what might motivate academics to make a careerout of denial of genocide. Some of the ways in which denial of genocide causes "violence to others" haveidentified by Israel W. Charny in his essay on "The Psychology of Denial ofKnown Genocides," in which he emphasizes that denial conceals the horror ofthe crimes and exonerates those responsible for it. [31] This point is echoedby Deborah Lipstadt, who, in her recent book on denial of the Holocaust,writes that "Denial aims to reshape history in order to rehabilitate theperpetrators and demonize the victims." [32] Denial also, according to Charny,"attacks the historical spirit and morale" of the survivors and thedescendants of those killed and places "further burdens on their recovery."[33] In short, denial prevents healing of the wounds inflicted by genocide.[34] Furthermore, it constitutes an "attack on the collective identity andnational cultural continuity of the victim people." [35] A number of scholars have argued, in fact, that the deliberate denial of aknown genocide is a harmful act that deserves to be included in the same moraldomain with indirect and direct contributions to the actual genocides. Thus,Charny states that "Denials of genocide make no sense unless one sees in themrenewed opportunities for the same passions, meanings, and pleasures that wereat work in the genocide itself, now revived in symbolic processes of murderingthe dignity of the survivors, rationality, dignity, and even history itself'(emphasis in original). [36] Indeed, denial may be thought of as the laststage of genocide, one that continues into the present. A kind of doublekilling takes place: first the physical deed, followed by the destruction ofremembrance of the deed. Historian (and Holocaust survivor) Erich Kulka regards the denial of genocideas an offense in its own right, asserting that "Attempts to rewrite Holocausthistory on the pretext of 'revisionism,' aided by scholars with academicbackgrounds, must be viewed as intellectual aggression," a repetition inthought of what was enacted earlier as physical deed. [37] In his recent bookon denial of the Holocaust, Pierre Vidal-Naquet characterizes RobertFaurisson, whose "scholarly" denials of the Holocaust have been widelydisseminated, as a "paper Eichmann." [38] We concur with Charny, Kulka, and Vidal-Naquet in regarding denial of genocideas an egregious offense that warrants being regarded as a form of contributionto genocidal violence. Denial contributes to genocide in at least two ways.First of all, genocide does not end with its last human victim; denialcontinues the process. But if such denial points to the past and the present,it also has implications for the future. For by absolving the perpetrators ofpast genocides from responsibility for their actions and by obscuring thereality of genocide as a widely practiced form of state policy in the modernworld, denial may increase the risk of future outbreaks of genocidal killing. Why Might Intellectuals Engage in the Denial of Known Genocides? There are several possible motivations for denial of genocide, and these canbe complex. The motivations to which we would call attention include: self-serving ideology, bigotry, intellectual confusion, careerism, identificationwith power, and a particular conception of knowledge. It seems unlikely,however, that denial rests only on one of these motivations; moreover, theparticular combinations of motivations may vary with individuals. Also, whatprompts denial may vary with different examples of genocide: anti-Zionism, forexample, may help explain denial of the Holocaust, but in terms of its contenttells us nothing about why the Armenian genocide has been denied. On the otherhand, if we focus not on the content of the motivation, but on its form(ideology) and goals (political and psychological purposes), then themotivations for denial in these two cases may have more in common than appearat first glance. Ideology, Bigotry and the Denial of the Holocaust Scholars who have analyzed deniers of the Holocaust have concluded that theyare primarily motivated by ideology. Thus, Vidal-Naquet, in his examination ofFaurisson and other French "revisionists," asserts that "all revisionists areresolute anti-Zionists." [39] Similarly, on the basis of her even morecomprehensive survey of Holocaust deniers, Lipstadt concludes that "it isclear that deniers have no interest in scholarship or reason. Most areantisemites or bigots." [40] These answers are no doubt correct, but they are incomplete. It may be thatall revisionists are anti-Zionists, but there are surely anti-Zionists (someof them Jewish) who do not deny the reality of the Holocaust. Similarly, thereare people who are highly antisemitic, but are well aware that the Holocausttook place. Intellectual Confusion, Rationalization Clues to the thinking of academics who question the reality of the Armeniangenocide have been provided by Israel Charny and his colleague Daphna Fromer,who sent questionnaires to sixty-nine scholars who signed an advertisementwhich, in the words of Charny and Fromer, "questioned insidiously the evidenceof the Armenian genocide" and appeared in several newspapers, including theNew York Times and the Washington Post. [41] In analyzing the comments of theseventeen scholars who provided "active responses" to their mailing, Charnyand Fromer discerned a number of "thinking defense-mechanisms" that enabledthe scholars to engage in "the denial of genocide." These mechanisms includedwhat the authors term "scientificism in the service of denial," i.e., theclaim that not enough empirical evidence is available to justify anunequivocal position on the reality of the genocide; and "definitionalism,"i.e., acknowledging deaths, but denying that they were the result of"genocide," thus shifting responsibility for the genocide away from theTurkish government and trivializing the killing of over a million Armenians asthe inadvertent result of famine, war, and disease. Whether anyone is led into denial by such reasoning is an open question, butsuch thinking does serve to make denial easier thereafter, while, at the sametime, it preserves the appearance of objectivity. Careerism, Power, Knowledge "Careerism" is a complicated phenomenon, but for our purposes we wouldidentify two (non-exclusive) forms that it may take: one that is oriented moretoward material goals, and one that involves more the satisfactions that gowith power. Both share the "thoughtlessness" that Hannah Arendt saw as theessence of the "banality of evils": an imaginative blindness that prevents onefrom reflecting upon the consequences of one's actions. [42] But elsewhereArendt also speaks of a "willed evil," and the second type of careerism is notfar removed from this: not simply the obliviousness to hurt, but theinfliction of hurt. [43] Intellectuals who engage in the denial of genocide may be motivated in part byeither type of careerism, or by both. The more insidious form, however, is thesecond type of careerism. Here material rewards are important, but more so,the opportunity for certain psychological and social satisfactions: a sense ofimportance, of status, of being in control, all of which can come throughidentification with power, something we believe we have shown in thememorandum we have analyzed. The price for intellect in the service of denial,however, is a particular conception of knowledge, one in which knowledge notonly serves the ends of those in power, but is defined by power But to definetruth in terms of power is to reveal the bankruptcy, irrationality, and aboveall, danger, of the whole enterprise of denial of genocide. Inherent in sucha view of knowledge is both a deep-seated nihilism and an urge to tyranny. Concluding Comments: Scholars and Truth Scholarship is, or should be, a quest for truth. What scholars write and sayin that quest matters a great deal. Directly or indirectly, our wordscontribute to a shared consciousness -- to the constellation of beliefs that asociety forms in connection with issues of any kind. Scholars' contributionsto that shared consciousness become especially important in relation to asociety's struggles with large, disturbing, and threatening historical events. Nowhere is scholarly research and commentary more significant than inconnection with genocide. Here the scope of mass murder and the depth of itsmoral violation defy understanding and arouse every kind of confusion, whetherin the form of diffuse passions or resistance to painful evidence. Carefulscholarly evaluation can hardly eliminate these confusions, but it candiminish them in favor of reasoned interpretation and the channeling ofpassion into constructive policy. Generally speaking, the extremity of humanharm brought about by genocide raises the stakes of scholarly commentary. Where scholars deny genocide, in the face of decisive evidence that it hasoccurred, they contribute to a false consciousness that can have the most direreverberations. Their message, in effect, is: murderers did not really murder;victims were not really killed; mass murder requires no confrontation, noreflection, but should be ignored, glossed over. In this way scholars lendtheir considerable authority to the acceptance of this ultimate human crime.More than that, they encourage -- indeed invite -- a repetition of that crimefrom virtually any source in the immediate or distant future. By closing theirminds to truth, that is, such scholars contribute to the deadlypsychohistorical dynamic in which unopposed genocide begets new genocides. Those of us who wish to be true to our scholarly calling have a clearobligation here. We must first expose this form of denial. At the same time wemust ourselves bear witness to historical truths -- to the full narrative ofmass murder and human suffering. To be witnessing professionals in this wayrequires that we take in grim details so that we can tell the story withaccuracy and insight. It is a task to which we must bring both heart and mind,an approach that combines advocacy and detachment. We require sufficientdetachment to maintain rigorous intellectual standards in evaluating evidenceand drawing conclusions. At the same time our moral advocacy should require usto open ourselves to suffering as a way of taking a stand against cruelty andkilling, whatever its source. Notes 1. Terrence Des Pres, "Introduction: Remembering Armenia," in Richard G.Hovannisian, ed., The Armenian Genocide in Perspective (New Brunswick, NJ:Transaction Books, 1986), p. 10. 2. On scholarship as commitment to power, see Terrence Des Pres, "On GoverningNarratives: The Turkish-Armenian Case," Yale Review, 75:4 (October 1986), pp.517-531. Richard Cohen of the Washington Post provides an excellent example of"truth" being whatever officials say it is. He recounts in an article entitled"Killing Truth," how after a brief reference to the Armenian genocide in aprevious column, the Turkish ambassador invited him to the embassy for a talk.Cohen writes: I found myself sitting at one end of an enormous table in the embassy of Turkey. At the other end was the ambassador himself and what he was telling me was that the crime I had always thought had happened, simply had not.... What the world persisted in calling a genocide was actually a civil war -- one with atrocities on both sides and one in which the central government in Constantinople lost control of its own troops and could not protect the Armenians. There never was a policy to exterminate the Armenians. Cohen, who thought that "the genocide was a given -- that no one couldpossibly dispute that it had happened," was thrown into turmoil by theambassador's claims, and now found that the ambassador had "dented hisconfidence." The problem of denial had now included Cohen: "And so year byyear, person by person, the genocide blurs, doubt corrodes it, and the easyword, 'alleged,' creeps in to mock the Armenian anguish. The goal of suchdenial, he believed, was not so much the rewriting of the past as such, butthe control of the present and the future. He concluded his article with theobservation that perhaps the "last victim of any genocide is truth." RichardCohen, "Killing Truth," The Washington Post, 31 May 1983, p. B 1. 3. Vahakn N. Dadrian, "A Textual Analysis of the Key Indictment of the TurkishMilitary Tribunal Investigating the Armenian Genocide," Armenian Review, 44:1(Spring 1991), pp. 26-27. 4. Vahakn N. Dadrian, "The Documentation of the World War I Armenian Massacresin the Proceedings of the Turkish Military Tribunal," International Journal ofMiddle East Studies, 23:4 (November 1991), p. 560. 5. Henry Morgenthau, Ambassador Morgenthau's Story (Garden City, NY:Doubleday, Page: 1918), p. 309. 6. Dadrian, "The Documentation," p. 568. 7. Here we can cite only a few of the many works that document the Armeniangenocide. Among the contemporary accounts, see: Leslie Davis, TheSlaughterhouse Province: An American Diplomat's Report on the ArmenianGenocide, 1915-1917 (New Rochelle, NY: Aristide D. Caratzas, Publisher, 1989);Henry Morgenthau, Ambassador Morgenthau's Story (Garden City, NY: Doubleday,Page; 1918); and Arnold J. Toynbee, ed., The Treatment of the Armenians inthe Ottoman Empire: Documents Presented to Viscount Grey of Fallodon,Secretary of State for Foreign Affairs (London: Hodder and Stoughton, 1916).The Armenian Genocide in the U.S. Archives, 1915-1918 (Alexandria, VA:Chadwyok-Healey Inc., 1990) provides 37,000 pages of documentation inmicrofiche. For recent studies, see three articles by Vahakn N. Dadrian, "TheSecret Young-Turk Ittihadist Conference and the Decision for the World WarI Genocide of the Armenians," Holocaust and Genocide Studies, 7:2 (Fall 1993),pp. 173-201; "The Documentation of the World War I Armenian Massacres in theProceedings of the Turkish Military Tribunal," International Journal of MiddleEast Studies, 23:4 (November 1991), pp. 549-576; and "Documentation of theArmenian Genocide in Turkish Sources," in Israel W. Charny, ed., Genocide: ACritical Bibliographic Review (London: Mansell Publishing; New York: Facts onFile, 1991), Vol. 2, Ch. 4; Tessa Hofmann and Gerayer Koutcharian, "'Imagesthat Horrify and Indict': Pictorial Documents on the Persecution andExtermination of the Armenians from 1877 to 1922," Armenian Review, 45:1-2(Spring/Summer 1992), pp. 53-184; Robert Melson, Revolution and Genocide: Onthe Origins of the Armenian Genocide and the Holocaust (Chicago: University ofChicago Press, 1992); and Donald E. Miller and Lorna Touryan Miller,Survivors: An Oral History of the Armenian Genocide (Berkeley: University ofCalifornia Press, 1993). For an extensive bibliography on the Armeniangenocide, see Richard G. Hovannisian, The Armenian Holocaust: A BibliographyRelating to the Deportations, Massacres, and Dispersion of the ArmenianPeople, 1915-1923 (Cambridge, MA: Armenian Heritage Press, 1980). On theavailability of survivor testimony in the form of oral history, see Miller andMiller, pp. 212-213. Most of the oral histories are in Armenian and have notbeen translated; on the other hand, many survivor memoirs exist in English:among the more detailed are Abraham H. Hartunian, Neither to Laugh nor toWeep: A Memoir of the Armenian Genocide (Boston: Beacon Press, 1968) andEphraim K. Jernazian, Judgment Unto Truth: Witnessing the Armenian Genocide(New Brunswick, NJ: Transaction Books, 1990). 8. There is a substantial literature on denial of the Armenian genocide. See,Rouben Adalian, "The Armenian Genocide: Revisionism and Denial," in Michael N.Dobkowski and Isidor Wallimann, eds., Genocide in Our Time: An AnnotatedBibliography with Analytical Introductions (Ann Arbor, MI: Pierian Press,1992), Ch. 5; Marjorie Housepian Dobkin, "What Genocide? What Holocaust? Newsfrom Turkey, 1915 1923: A Case Study," in Hovannisian, ed., The ArmenianGenocide in Perspective, Ch. 5; Richard G. Hovannisian, "The Armenian Genocideand Patterns of Denial," in Hovannisian, ed., The Armenian Genocide inPerspective, Ch. 6; Clive Foss, "The Turkish View of Armenian History: AVanishing Nation," in Richard G. Hovannisian, ed., The Armenian Genocide:History, Politics, Ethics (New York: St. Martin's Press, 1992), Ch. 11;Vahakn N. Dadrian, "Ottoman Archives and Denial of the Armenian Genocide,"in Hovannisian, ed., The Armenian Genocide, Ch. 12; Vigen Guroian, "ThePolitics and Morality of Genocide," in Hovannisian, ed., The ArmenianGenocide, Ch. 13; and the following articles by Roger W. Smith, "Genocide andDenial: The Armenian Case and Its Implications," Armenian Review, 42:1 (Spring1989), pp. 1-38; "Denial of the Armenian Genocide," in Charny, ed., Genocide,Vol. 2, Ch. 3; and "The Armenian Genocide: Memory, Polities, and the Future,"in Hovannisian, ed., Armenian Genocide, Ch. 1. See also the wide-rangingdiscussion by Israel W. Charny, "The Psychology of Denial of Known Genocides,"in Charny, ed., Genocide, Vol. 2, Ch. 1. 9. See, for example, Hovannisian, "The Armenian Genocide and Patterns ofDenial," in Hovannisian, ed., The Armenian Genocide in Perspective, pp. 115131; and Roger W. Smith, "Genocide and Denial," pp. 15-20. 10. Edward Minasian, "Musa Dagh: The Film That Was Denied,"Journal of ArmenianStudies, 11:2 (Fall/Winter 1985 86), pp. 63-73; Hovannisian, "Patterns ofDenial," pp. 120-21. 11. Hovannisian, "Patterns of Denial," pp. 113-14, 124-27, 129 30. 12. Leo Kuper, Genocide: Its Political Use in the Twentieth Century (NewHaven, CT: Yale University Press, 1981), pp. 219-20; Smith, "Genocide andDenial," pp. 22-23. 13. Leo Kuper, "Problems in Education on Genocide," Internet on the Holocaustand Genocide, 14, (Feb. 1988), Special Supplement, p. 1. 14. Israel W. Charny and Shamai Davidson, eds., The Book of the InternationalConference on the Holocaust and Genocide: Book 1, The Conference Program andCrisis (Tel Aviv: Institute of the International Conference on the Holocaustand Genocide, 1983), pp. 269-315, and Israel W. Charny, ed., Toward theUnderstanding and Prevention of Genocide (Boulder, Colorado and London:Westview Press, 1984), pp. 364-372. 15. New York Times, 22 June 1982, p. A 4. 16. Our description of the Institute of Turkish Studies, Inc. is drawn fromthe following sources: "The Institute of Turkish Studies, Inc.," a brochurepublished in Washington, DC, by the Institute, not dated, but includes theDirector's Report for 1983 84; Report of the Institute of Turkish Studies,Inc., 1982-1992 (Washington, DC: Institute of Turkish Studies, Inc., 1992);Encyclopedia of Associations, 26th ed-1992 (Detroit and London: Gale Research,Inc., 1991), 1:l 133; Stan Olson, ed., The Foundation Directory 1992 Edition(New York: The Foundation Center, 1992), p. 228; William Wade, ed., NationalDirectory of Nonprofit Organizations, 1991, Volume 1: Organizations withRevenues of $100,000 or More, Part 1: A-O (Rockville, MD: The Taft Group,1991), pp. ix, 1078; and Speros Vryonis, Jr., The Turkish State and History:Clio Meets the Grey Wolf, 2nd ed. (Thessaloniki and New Rochelle, NY:Institute for Balkan Studies and Aristide D. Caratzas, Publisher, 1993), Part3. We are grateful to Dr. Rouben Adalian for making a copy of the brochurepublished by the Institute of Turkish Studies available to us. 17. "The Institute of Turkish Studies, Inc.," p. 11. 18. Smith, "Denial of the Armenian Genocide," in Charny, ed., Genocide, 2:83.I Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.