Jump to content

An Interview with Prof. Richard Hovannisian


Guest

Recommended Posts

Armenian News Network / Groong

July 8, 2000

 

by Anahit Minasyan

ARMENIAN GENOCIDE PANEL IN ISTANBUL

 

The 11th Biennial Conference of the International Oral History Association met at Bogazici University (formerly Robert College) in Istanbul, June 15-19, 2000. Oral historians from around the world gathered to discuss the conference theme of `Crossroads of History: Experience, Memory, Orality.' One of the major sub-themes was "Remembering Violence and Conflict."

 

It was around this subject that Professor Richard Hovannisian of the University of California, Los Angeles, organized a panel titled "The Face of Conflict and Trauma in the Twentieth Century: The Armenian Experience." A capacity audience attended the session on June 16, but only days earlier the panel had disappeared from the conference program.

 

Following is an interview with Professor Richard Hovannisian by Anahit Minasyan. Ms. Minasyan participated in the conference with a paper titled "French-Armenian Repatriation in Soviet Armenia in the 1940s: The View from Below."

 

* * * * *

 

Anahit Minasyan: Professor Hovannisian, how did it happen that you decided to organize a panel based on the memories of survivors of the Armenian Genocide in a conference to be held in Istanbul?

 

Richard Hovannisian: I learned in the spring of 1999 that the International Oral History Association (IOHA) would hold its next conference in Istanbul in 2000, focusing on themes relating to remembering the twentieth century.

 

One of the sub-themes was remembering violence and conflict. It immediately struck me that we have gathered more than 800 oral history interviews at UCLA with survivors of the Armenian Genocide and that it would be most appropriate to organize a panel on survivor memories, especially as the conference was to be held in Istanbul, where the genocide had been planned and put into motion.

 

My topic was `Bitter-Sweet Memories: The Last Generation of Ottoman Armenians.' I began with a demographic breakdown of the 800 interviews and then presented a synopsis of the happy childhood memories of the interviewees, their home life, schools, holidays, customs, and then the sudden disruption of that life, the enduring trauma of the deportations and massacres, the attempted assistance and intervention of certain Turkish officials and individuals who opposed the genocidal policies of the Young Turk government, the rescue of the survivors, and the memories and attitudes of the survivors after several decades of living in the Diaspora.

 

 

AM: Who were the other participants and what were their subjects?

 

RH: When it comes to Armenian Oral History it is natural to think of Donald E. Miller and his wife Lorna Touryan, who together interviewed more than a hundred survivors and have written a book and several articles based on the materials gathered.

 

Miller, who heads the program in religion at the University of Southern California, spoke on the subject, `Remembering Traumatic Life Events: Interviewing Survivors of the Armenian Genocide of 1915.' As usual, he was both scholarly and straightforward, not trying to camouflage his words or keen analysis.

 

The third panelist was Joanna Bornat of the Open University of the United Kingdom. I had not previously met Dr. Bornat, but I had been in correspondence with her regarding her project to interview elderly Armenians in Gumri (formerly Leninakan; Alexandropol) following the destructive earthquake of 1988. She and Pam Shakespeare, together with their Armenian collaborator, Mariam Haroutunian, found in the interviews that time collapsed and the trauma of that tragedy became instantly linked with the horrific memories of Turkish invasion and violence during World War I. Her topic was `Learning from Memories: Some Issues for Workers and Older People in a Troubled City.'

 

 

AM: In view of the site of the conference and the continuing denial of the Turkish government did you face any difficulties relating to your panel?

 

RH: It may have been only an oversight, but I received no notification of acceptance of our panel for a long time after all other participants had been so informed. Both Dr. Bornat and I inquired as to the delay and were told that the panel proposal had somehow slipped through the cracks, and, with apologies, we were finally notified that the panel had been approved.

 

We subsequently learned through knowledgeable sources that there had been considerable behind-the-scene discussions regarding the Armenian panel. In fact, these led to a change in the conference venue.

 

It was thought that the local sponsors of the conference would include the Turkish Historical Foundation and the Turkish Oral History Association. Most of the conference sessions were initially scheduled to be held in the Royal Mint and other historic buildings in old Istanbul through the cooperation of the Turkish Historical Foundation.

 

In later notices the participants were informed that all sessions would be held on the campus of Bogazici University (Robert College). It was not until I reached Istanbul that I learned that dissension between the local Turkish organizing committee and the Turkish Historical Foundation over inclusion of the Armenian panel resulted in the demand of the Foundation that the panel be deleted from the program.

 

The Turkish organizing committee and the History Department of Bogazici University, together with the International Program Committee of the IOHA, rejected the demand and decided to proceed without the anticipated assistance of the Foundation, which interestingly enough has the reputation of being rather `left-wing' when it comes to Turkish politics.

 

AM: On what grounds did the Foundation object to the panel and to your participation?

 

RH: That is perhaps the most disturbing aspect of the story. In looking for an excuse to oppose the inclusion of the panel and especially of my personal participation, the Foundation used a most amazing press release posted on the Turkish web site `H-Turk' by Mr. Vincent Lima, the editor of the quarterly magazine, The Armenian Forum.

 

In that release about a preliminary dialogue between several Turkish and Armenian scholars at the University of Chicago earlier in the year, Mr. Lima alluded to my absence by characterizing me as being a racist and averse to such exchanges. The statement was untrue and was refuted, but this did not matter, as the Turkish Historical Foundation had found a strong weapon with which to sustain its argument that `Hovannisian has stated that he will never sit around the table with Turks.'

 

Curiously, the Turkish scholars who had participated in the Chicago conference had come away with a similar impression. While there is no doubt in my mind that Lima's press release was merely used as a convenient ploy to prevent open discussion of the Genocide in the IOHA conference, it is nonetheless deplorable that the opportunity was given to use an Armenian source to further the attempt to suppress the panel.

 

Perhaps as a final effort of the Turkish organizing committee to satisfy all sides, the Armenian panel was not listed in the preliminary program that was posted on the IOHA conference web site shortly before the conference opened.

 

This omission was brought to my attention by Dr. Bornat, and both she and I protested to the committee. She was told in reply that it had been thought more appropriate to put her talk in a session dealing with memories of earthquakes and that my and Miller's presentations would best fit into a plenary sub-session on conflict and trauma in general.

 

That sub-session of one and a half hours duration had more than 10 presenters listed, meaning that each person would have about 5 minutes to speak. We found this to be unacceptable, and as the result of our insistence, the panel was ultimately reinstated and the three of us had two hours for our session. As you yourselves witnessed, it was one of the best attended and lively panels and according to many persons perhaps the most productive of the four-day conference.

 

 

AM: What were your impressions of your reception in Istanbul and at the conference?

 

RH: The reception was both polite and cordial. Student assistants were in the international airport to meet conference participants and get them to their hotels or to Bogazici University. The conference coordinator, Professor Gunhan Danisman, was most solicitous of us, and there was a warm and friendly atmosphere among scholars and students in attendance.

 

I was impressed with the intelligence and quest for the unfettered truth by a new generation of Turkish students. They showed a deep interest in the subject and asked meaningful questions about survivor memories and memoirs. Following the session, many of them approached the panel participants, as well as Mrs. Lorna Miller and Dr. Vartiter Hovannisian, with further inquiries and commendations.

 

Overall, it was an uplifting experience. I also hope that our participation and openness during the conference may have helped to dispel some of the unfounded rumors that had been circulating prior to the meeting. The social events and mixers gave the opportunity for much interaction with Turkish scholars and students and with the other participants, who had come from every continent. It was truly an international conference. The next one will be held in South Africa.

 

I was also pleased that you gave a very informative talk about the life experiences and memories of those French Armenians who repatriated to Soviet Armenia during the 1940s only to become disillusioned and to leave when the opportunity presented itself, and dealt very much with the question of identity and the sense of such persons of not belonging fully anywhere, except perhaps in an imagined Armenia.

 

 

AM: While you were in Istanbul, did you have any contact with the Armenian community?

 

RH: Fortunately, Vartiter and I remained in Istanbul three days after the conference and were able to become acquainted with the important educational, religious, and social welfare programs of the community, which supports more than twenty schools and more than thirty-five churches.

 

We attended the year-end program and banquet of the Bezciyan school in the old quarter of Kum Kapu, visited the Armenian newspapers Marmara and Agos. The latter journal is relatively new and has become the most widely circulated Turkish Armenian newspaper because most of its news is written in Turkish, which has become the predominant language of the community.

 

The community is made up of the old `Bolis' Armenians (now in a minority) and those from the provinces, who over the last several decades have migrated to Istanbul and taken leading positions in the parish councils and cultural organizations.

 

While people who originated in the provinces may send their children to Armenian schools, they themselves have little or no knowledge of the language and must rely on the Turkish-language Armenian press for in-depth news about Armenia and Armenian issues.

 

We had the pleasure of visiting the island of Kinali in the Sea of Marmara, a place where several thousand Istanbul Armenians spend the summer months. And we were most impressed with our visit to the Sourp Prgich National Hospital, which includes numerous clinics and state-of-the-art equipment, divisions for both dependent and ambulatory elderly Armenians, and a residence and clinic for mentally-ill patients.

 

The chairman of the hospital's board, industrialist Arsen Yarman, takes a personal interest in every resident and has supervised the hospital's impressive renovation and modernization during the past several years.

 

 

AM: What are your concluding thoughts on the IOHA conference in Istanbul?

 

RH: Putting forward our panel and seeing it through to a successful conclusion was a challenging endeavor. I realize that, despite the many obstacles along the way, the panel ultimately remained on the program because of the firm stand of the International Program Committee, the Turkish Organizing Committee, and the History Department and Administration of Bogazici University and because of our own perseverance.

 

For this, I am most grateful. I am also glad that I was able to interact with Turkish colleagues, some of whom I knew by name but not in person. I believe that such exchanges are very useful, especially when extraordinary energy does not have to be spent on contesting whether or not a genocide occurred.

 

I hope that this meeting, along with others in which an Armenian-Turkish dialogue is evolving, will help to bring us out of the dead end, which unfortunately has characterized most encounters in the Middle East Studies Association and other scholarly organizations in the United States.

 

A new generation of Turkish students and younger scholars is willing to question and sometimes contest the official governmental version of history. They realize that facing the dark side of their history is necessary and in the end for their own good.

---------------------------------------------

Anahit Minasyan is a gradute student at Central European University. She's in Paris researching her doctoral thesis on the return movement of the '50s.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...