Jump to content

As Armenian date approaches, so does dispute over 'genocide'


MosJan

Recommended Posts

 

As Armenian date approaches, so does dispute over 'genocide'

By Michael Doyle, McClatchy Newspapers Michael Doyle, Mcclatchy Newspapers – Fri Apr 23, 4:45 pm ET WASHINGTON — Armenian genocide commemorations continue to attract political, diplomatic and fraternal grief upon the arrival of another April 24 anniversary date.

 

On Capitol Hill , an Armenian genocide resolution lacks the votes needed for House or Senate passage. In downtown Washington , bitter lawsuits ensnare plans for an Armenian Genocide Museum and Memorial. In the White House and on Embassy Row , the phrase "Armenian genocide" still confounds international relations.

 

"We always hear 'it's not the right time' to recognize genocide," said Democratic Rep. Jim Costa of Fresno, a member of the House Foreign Affairs Committee . "There's always something that will come up."

 

On Saturday, President Barack Obama is expected to issue the White House's annual statement commemorating the tragic events of 1915-1923. The statement is typically pegged to April 24 , considered the start of the Ottoman Empire's assault on Armenian leaders.

 

While campaigning, Obama endorsed use of the word "genocide." Last April, however, emulating other presidents, Obama studiously avoided the term in his 389-word statement.

 

"We expect that the president will honor his prior commitment and unequivocally affirm the Armenian genocide (this year)," said Bryan Ardouny , executive director of the Armenian Assembly of America .

 

Obama, though, confronts the same pressures as he did last year. Turkey considers the phrase "Armenian genocide" a gross insult, and the key NATO ally that borders both Iraq and Iran knows how to make its displeasure clear.

 

The Turkish ambassador to the U.S. only returned to Washington several weeks ago, after he had been recalled to Ankara following a March 5 vote by the House Foreign Affairs Committee . By a 23-22 margin, the committee approved the latest version of an Armenian genocide resolution.

 

"If we look at what the president has done in the past ... all the weathervanes point to a statement that refrains from use of the term (genocide)," said Bruce Fein , general counsel for the Turkish American Legal Defense Fund .

 

Turkish Embassy officials declined to comment. Fein, though, insisted it "is still a matter of serious debate" as to whether the Ottoman Empire's actions met the legal definition of genocide. Genocide means the intentional targeting for destruction of a racial, ethnic, religious or national group; it does not cover political groups."

 

The stalled congressional genocide resolution is backed by representatives from California's San Joaquin Valley and other regions with sizable Armenian-American populations. With 140 co-sponsors, however, it lacks the 218 votes needed to pass the House of Representatives .

 

The Armenian Genocide Museum and Memorial is hung up on a different kind of fight.

 

The facility, first proposed in 1996, has already been plotted out, by the same firm that designed Washington's popular Spy Museum . Planners originally wanted the 35,000-square-foot museum open by 2011.

 

For several years, though, the genocide museum's board has been entangled in a legal dispute with onetime museum benefactor Gerard L. Cafesjian and the Cafesjian Family Foundation .

 

Museum board members say Cafesjian tried to delay the project and profit from it personally. Cafesjian says he was shut out of key planning decisions. A federal judge sums up the dispute as "very bitter and very unfortunate."

 

Attorneys are wading through some 8,000 pages of documents provided by Cafesjian and reviewing depositions that, transcripts show, have periodically turned brittle.

 

"I am just getting sick and tired of answering these questions," Hirair Hovnanian, the chairman of the Armenian Assembly's board, said in a deposition last year, acknowledging his hopes that an unnamed "multibillionaire" would fund the museum.

 

Museum planners anticipate needing $60 million to build and operate the facility.

 

"Once the litigation ends, the rest of the museum project will move forward quickly," said Van Krikorian , a board member of both the museum and the Armenian Assembly .

 

Some related work still proceeds.

 

On Wednesday, one block from the proposed museum site, the 93-year-old grandson of Henry Morgenthau , who was U.S. ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, formally donated part of his grandfather's library to the research-oriented Armenian National Institute .

 

Morgenthau's reporting from the Ottoman Empire provided direct evidence of the Armenians' fate, and he's often cited by Armenian genocide resolution supporters.

 

"I like to call myself an honorary Armenian," Henry Morgenthau III said when asked why he donated the family books, "and this seemed like the most appropriate place."

 

MORE FROM MCCLATCHY

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Obama Marks Genocide Without Saying the Word

 

ASHEVILLE, N.C. — President Obama, who as a candidate vowed to use the term genocide to describe the Ottoman mass slaughter of Armenians nearly a century ago, once again declined to do so on Saturday as he marked the anniversary of the start of the killings.

 

Trying to navigate one of the more emotionally fraught foreign policy challenges, Mr. Obama issued a statement from his weekend getaway here commemorating the victims of the killings but tried to avoid alienating Turkey, a NATO ally, which adamantly rejects the genocide label.

 

“On this solemn day of remembrance, we pause to recall that 95 years ago one of the worst atrocities of the 20th century began,” Mr. Obama said in the statement, which largely echoed the same language he used on this date a year ago. “In that dark moment of history, 1.5 million Armenians were massacred or marched to their death in the final days of the Ottoman Empire.”

 

When he was running for president and seeking votes from some of the 1.5 million Armenian-Americans, Mr. Obama had no qualms about using the term genocide and criticized the Bush administration for recalling an ambassador who dared to say the word. As a senator, he supported legislation calling the killings genocide, and in a statement on Jan. 19, 2008, he said that “the Armenian genocide is not an allegation, a personal opinion, or a point of view, but rather a widely documented fact.”

 

Two years later, as president, he used none of that sort of language, though as he did a year ago, he hinted to Armenians that he still felt the same way. “I have consistently stated my own view of what occurred in 1915, and my view of that history has not changed,” he said. “It is in all of our interest to see the achievement a full, frank and just acknowledgment of the facts.”

 

His statement came as the issue has grown as a source of tension between the United States and Turkey, and as a reconciliation effort between Turkey and Armenia that Mr. Obama has championed has seemingly stalled.

 

In March, the House Foreign Affairs Committee voted narrowly to condemn the killings as an act of genocide, defying a last-minute plea from the Obama administration to forgo a vote because it would threaten the Turkish-Armenian reconciliation efforts. Turkey briefly recalled its ambassador from Washington in protest.

 

Armenia announced Thursday that it would suspend ratification of peace accords with Turkey, apparently because it was angered that Turkey was making new demands. Armenia insisted that it was not altogether abandoning the peace process, but analysts indicated that the Armenian government believed Turkey was trying to pressure it to reach a separate peace treaty with another neighbor, Azerbaijan, a close Turkish ally.

 

Although the president’s statement did not use the term “genocide” on Saturday, it was strong enough to provoke a sharp statement from the Turkish Foreign Ministry, which called the language a reflection of a one-sided political perception. “Third countries neither have a right nor authority to judge the history of Turkish-Armenian relations with political motives,” the statement said.

 

Meanwhile, the Armenian National Committee of America, an advocacy group based in Washington, condemned the “euphemisms and evasive terminology” in Mr. Obama’s statement and called it “yet another disgraceful capitulation to Turkey’s threats.”

 

“Today we join with Armenians in the United States and around the world in voicing our sharp disappointment with the president’s failure to properly condemn and commemorate the Armenian genocide,” said Ken Hachikian, the committee’s chairman. He added that Mr. Obama’s failure to follow through on his campaign pledge was “allowing Turkey to tighten its gag rule on American genocide policy.”

 

Clifford J. Levy contributed reporting from Moscow, and Sebnem Arsu from Izmir, Turkey.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Obama Declines to Call Armenian Mass Killings a Genocide

Associated Press

 

 

 

President Obama again declined to call the deaths of 1.5 million Armenians during World War I a genocide, instead on Saturday painting the massacre as "one of the worst atrocities" of the 20th century and "a devastating chapter" in history.

 

 

 

 

Candidate Obama repeatedly promised he'd call the almost century-old massacre of Armenians in Turkey as genocide. President Obama twice now has refused to do so.

 

Obama on Saturday declined to call the deaths of 1.5 million Armenians during World War I a genocide as he had promised as a presidential hopeful, instead painting the massacre as "one of the worst atrocities" of the 20th century and "a devastating chapter" in history.

 

In a statement issued as he and first lady Michelle Obama spent a weekend getaway here in western North Carolina, the president marked the 95th anniversary of the start of the slaughter of Armenians by Ottoman Turks with strong words but intently avoided branding it genocide.

 

It is "a devastating chapter in the history of the Armenian people, and we must keep its memory alive in honor of those who were murdered and so that we do not repeat the grave mistakes of the past," Obama said in his statement.

 

Yet for a second year as president, Obama eschewed calling it a genocide, as he promised during his campaign. Now well into his second year in office, he has not in public used the word many historians employ for the first mass killing of the 20th century.

 

Marking the grim anniversary of the start of the killings, the president instead said: "On this solemn day of remembrance, we pause to recall that 95 years ago one of the worst atrocities of the 20th century began."

 

The statement was less than the full and frank acknowledgment he promised Jan. 19, 2008, when he vowed that as president, "I will recognize the Armenian Genocide," and repeatedly used the word.

 

"I also share with Armenian Americans -- so many of whom are descended from genocide survivors -- a principled commitment to commemorating and ending genocide. That starts with acknowledging the tragic instances of genocide in world history. As a U.S. senator, I have stood with the Armenian American community in calling for Turkey's acknowledgment of the Armenian Genocide."

 

Activists were quick to express disappointment.

 

"Today we join with Armenians in the United States and around the world in voicing our sharp disappointment with the president's failure to properly condemn and commemorate the Armenian Genocide," Armenian National Committee of America chairman Ken Hachikian said. "Sadly, for the U.S. and worldwide efforts to end the cycle of genocide, he made the wrong choice, allowing Turkey to tighten its gag-rule on American genocide policy."

 

For Obama, referring to the killings as genocide could upend pledges to have a closer partnership with Turkey, a vital ally in a critical region. Steering around the word, however, put him at odds with his own pledges to recognize the slaughter as genocide.

 

Instead, he said he had not changed his view from the campaign, even as he declined to state it.

 

"I have consistently stated my own view of what occurred in 1915, and my view of that history has not changed," Obama said in his statement, issued as he played golf at a mountaintop resort. "It is in all of our interest to see the achievement a full, frank and just acknowledgment of the facts."

 

Obama is closely watching as Turkey and Armenia approach an end to the long-simmering feud between the nations. The two countries signed agreements for reconciliation in October, but the deals still need to be approved by their parliaments. The agreements call for the establishment of diplomatic relations and the reopening of their border.

 

The agreement, if ratified, would reopen the border Turkey closed in 1993 to protest Armenia's war with neighboring Azerbaijan. The Turkish parliament has held up ratification of the deal as Turkey presses for a settlement between Armenia and Azerbaijan over a region in Azerbaijan that has been under Armenian control since the war.

 

Turkey's Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan welcomed Obama's comments but cautioned that Turkey would not take further steps to ratify the protocols in parliament until there is peace between Armenia and Azerbaijan. Turkey insists Armenia must withdraw its troops from Nagorno Karabakh before Turkey could reopen its border.

 

White House officials in March unsuccessfully tried to block the Foreign Affairs Committee of the House of Representatives from calling the Ottoman-era killing of Armenians a genocide -- a move the administration worried would imperil those talks.

 

As a result, Turkey recalled its ambassador to Washington, Namik Tan. The ambassador has since returned to Washington.

 

Armenians say that 1.5 million Armenians were killed by Ottoman Turks around the time of World War I. Armenians and several nations around the world recognize it as the first genocide of the 20th century.

 

Turkey denies that the massacres were genocide, saying the death toll is inflated and Armenians were killed in civil unrest as the Ottoman Empire collapsed.

 

 

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...