Jump to content

How Armenia Copes With Its Isolation


Armenak

Recommended Posts

How Armenia copes with its isolation in the combustible Caucasus

 

The art of levitation

Nov 16th 2006 | YEREVAN

>From The Economist print edition

 

NOWHERE is living next to big countries trickier than in the

Caucasus. Georgia, Armenia and Azerbaijan were for centuries

swallowed by rival empires; when the last of them, the Soviet Union,

collapsed, three territorial wars broke out, all of which may yet

re-erupt. Now Georgia is in a cold war with Russia.

 

Next-door Armenia's geographical plight might seem the worst in the

Caucasus-or anywhere. It is landlocked and poor; of its four

borders, those with Turkey and Azerbaijan are closed following its

bloody but successful struggle for Nagorno-Karabakh, a province of

Soviet Azerbaijan mostly populated by Armenians. Its other neighbours

are Georgia (under an economic blockade by Russia) and Iran. Yet

despite the war, the economic collapse that went with it and a

terrible earthquake that preceded it, Armenia seems to have levitated

out of trouble.

 

It benefits from an indulgence not afforded to pro-Western Georgia.

Per person, Armenia is one of the biggest recipients of American aid

(thanks to the powerful diaspora there, which remembers vividly the

massacres of 1915). Yet that American help does not trouble Russia,

which has a military base in Armenia. GDP is growing-though still

pitifully low: monthly wages are around $150. Towns and villages in

the beautiful, barren countryside are still poor and dilapidated, but

Yerevan is full of construction cranes and posh cafes.

 

But levitation has its limits. After some progress in the late 1990s,

reforms have stalled. The famed cognac aside, exports are puny.

Armenia relies on foreign aid and remittances from the huge diaspora;

emigration (see article) has put the population well below the

official 2.9m figure. The international balance is also precarious.

Some in Russia want the Armenians to take sides against the

Georgians, perhaps by stirring up the Armenian minority there. "We

refuse to choose," says Vartan Oskanian, the foreign minister.

Indeed: alienating Georgia would be suicidal.

 

But the Kremlin's leverage is growing. Russian firms already control

the energy sector and want a greater stake elsewhere. Mr Oskanian

says "our needs today are too dire" to worry about future risks.

Azerbaijan's hydrocarbons windfall makes it sound confident, even

bellicose, stoking Armenian reliance on Russia.

 

American interest in the pipelines that link the Caspian to the

Mediterranean, doglegging round Armenia, mean that renewed fighting

would echo far beyond the Caucasus. Internationally sponsored talks

about Karabakh limp on-Mr Oskanian met his Azerbaijani counterpart

this week-and Western diplomats try to sound upbeat. But a deal, or

even a fudge that would at least allow normal trade relations, looks

all but impossible. Sporadic shooting continues.

 

One reason is that bad governments in both countries bang the

nationalist drum for want of wider legitimacy. Armenia's Robert

Kocharian has emulated his sponsors in the Kremlin, squeezing the

media and rigging elections. Corruption flourishes. It is hard to

find an Armenian politician who does not want to succeed Mr Kocharian

when his presidential term expires in 2008; it is harder still to

find one who thinks the vote will be fair. Like Ilham Aliev, who

inherited power in Azerbaijan from his father, Mr Kocharian promises

just enough change to pacify America. Unsurprisingly, considering

their history, most Armenians are too cynical to expect much better

from their rulers.

 

Like acrobats in a human pyramid, the Caucasus countries are

inevitably affected by their neighbours' behaviour. Russia's closure

of its border with Georgia, for example, hurts Armenian traders. Such

outsiders' jostling would be much easier to bear if the three

(relative) tiddlers had a common line. But they are all, as Raffi

Hovannisian, a former Armenian foreign minister, says of his country,

"long on civilisation, short on statecraft."

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...