Armenak Posted November 6, 2006 Report Share Posted November 6, 2006 Georgia is not pleased with its dependence on its enemy, Russia, for natural gas; neither is Armenia which is Russia’s ally. As a matter of fact, both countries are looking for alternative natural gas sources. In this context, Georgia is holding meetings with Azerbaijan, Turkmenistan and Iran. And Armenia believes that the Iran-Armenia natural gas pipeline, still under construction over the last several years, would curb its dependence on Russia. The construction of this natural gas pipeline started in 2004 after an agreement between Armenia and Iran’s national natural gas company, NIGC. The pipeline which starts from the vicinity of the Iranian city of Tabriz, will end in the Iran-Armenia border and then will be linked to Armenia’s own natural gas pipeline. Forty kilometers of the 160-kilometer pipeline, extending from Kacaran to Mergi, is expected to be completed next month. The second part of the pipeline, which extends to Armenia’s Ararat region, will be completed in 2007 and is expected to be linked to the existing ArmRosGazprom (ARG) pipeline there. As the name suggests, ARG is a joint natural gas pipeline project. Until early November, Armenia owned 45 percent of this pipeline, Russian natural gas giant Gazprom 45 percent and the remaining 10 percent belonged to an obscure intermediary company called ITERA. However, the percentage of shares has changed after a deal between Armenia and Gazprom in early November. According to the agreement reached early this month during Armenian President Robert Kocharyan’s visit to Moscow, Armenia increased its shares in the ARG Company from 45 percent to 58 percent. This increase took place after ARG announced new shares amounting to $119 million and Gazprom bought these shares. With these new shares, Gazprom has effectively taken control of the 5th unit of the Hirazdan electricity plant along with the Iran-Armenian natural gas pipeline. The basis of this recent development lay in the agreement signed between Armenia and Gazprom in April 2006. Under the deal, Gazprom raised the natural gas price for its ally, Armenia, from the preferential $54 per 1,000 cubic meters to the still preferential $110 per 1,000 cubic meters, which will remain in force until Jan. 1, 2009. This in fact was a favorable price for Armenia, which is highly dependent on Russia for natural gas. However, there was a price to Russia’s compromise. In return, Russia demanded concessions from Armenia as regards the acquisition of the Iran-Armenia pipeline and the 5th unit of the Hrazdan electricity generating plant. Russia particularly insisted on limiting the Iran-Armenia pipeline’s diameter to 700 millimeters instead of 1.420 millimeters as stipulated in the original agreement reached with Iran. The reason is obvious. Russia was trying to block the transfer of Iranian natural gas via Armenia to Georgia and Ukraine in particular, and to Europe through the Black Sea, by keeping the diameter of the pipeline limited. The recent deal and latest news reports show that Russia achieved its goal and prevented use of the Iran-Armenia pipeline for the transfer of natural gas to other countries. Armenian Prime Minister Andranik Markaryan defended the recent agreement and said it would be illogical to have a separate ownership for the Iran-Armenia pipeline since Gazprom already controlled natural gas supply in Armenia, thereby trying to rationalize the deal. This recent deal I have dwelled upon is a geo-political achievement for Russia (thanks to this deal Russia has limited the potential significance of the Iran-Armenia pipeline in the future) while sealing Armenia’s dependence on Gazprom, and consequently on Russia. This is the picture the recent geo-political success of Russia, using its natural gas card. http://www.zaman.com/?bl=columnists&al...06&hn=37976 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MosJan Posted November 8, 2006 Report Share Posted November 8, 2006 PROPERTY OR BALLOON IN RETURN FOR DEBT It is difficult to tell whether Armenia cheated Russia when it gave its enterprises to it in return for debt or Russia forced Armenia to give its enterprises. Considering the situation in the context of the Property for Debt policy, the Russians have been cheated. There is a popular evaluation that Russia made Armenia repay its debt by property to get hold of some more components of the Armenian economy. At least for the time being, this evaluation is not realistic because property can be a tool as long as it works. When the enterprise is not working, the opportunities of pressure on Armenia diminish, and in addition its reputation diminishes among the public when they see that the Russians do not make investments in these factories. For Russia, it would be more desirable to keep the Armenian government in debt and under the constant threat of demanding repayment rather than nullify the dept by factories. Therefore, it is more probable that the Armenian government has managed to cheat the Russians by transferring factories to them, which require immense investments to operate, whereas the prospect of reoperating them is not quite bright. The problem is that most enterprises, which have been given to Russia require scientific technology. Meanwhile, Russia is facing a problem of curing its economy from “oil addiction” and upgrading it. In other words, the Russians fail to make investments in technology in Russia, let alone Armenia. The problem would be different if these factories were attractive, but after the collapse of the Soviet Union they have only become worn. It is also possible that Russia is simply solving a problem of hindering the West. The point is that the companies obtained by the Property for Debt Policy would attract Western companies, which have greater financial possibilities to invest in technology unlike the Russians. However, no serious company is known to the public, which was interested in and wanted to buy these factories before the Policy. This also shows that the factories transferred to Russia are not attractive and competitive, and the investments needed to reoperate them cannot produce the anticipated outcome. The vivid evidence to this is the information that the idea of auditing this deal is pushing forward in the Russian government. The Audit Chamber of Russia even made an arrangement with the Audit Chamber of Armenia to conduct audit of the deal. Much earlier an opinion had been expressed in the Russian elite that in reality the factories cost les than they had been assessed. In other words, in Russia they also think that they had been cheated. It sounds incredible, even bold and brazen, but there is no need to think that the Armenian government was bold when it cheated Russia. Of course, not. Of course, our government were sure that after taking the box home the Russians would find out that it was empty and the recovery was imminent. And when the time came, the government was already prepared. And they started cramming the mouth of the “bear” with power distribution networks, gas pipelines, water power plants, fifth generating units, Armentel. And if Russia’s anger was mitigated, we may say we had a narrow escape but if not, we did not escape at all. Although it does not matter any more because there is no more to give. JAMES HAKOBYAN Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.