How Should Turkey Face Genocide Charges?

[DominO123]

The most interesting point is the one I've put in bold. Germany sent to the Ottoman empire, countless records involving the Armenian massacres, on request and agreement, those records are nowhere to be found. I will write more about this maybe later. I didn't knew this was included in the German resolution.

 

----

 

 

KurdishMedia, UK

June 23 2005

 

How should Turkey face genocide charges?

 

23/06/2005 Bianet.org - By Tolga Korkut

 

Academics urge the government prepare "facing the past" vis-a-vis

"Armenian Genocide" charges in the Ottoman Empire. Macar advises the

state give up denial, while Caglar points to the fact that Turkey

needs to consider international community.

 

BIA (Istanbul) - As Turkish leaders angrily rebuff the recent German

Parliament decision calling Turkey recognize `Armenian Genocide' in

1915, political scientists Prof. Baskin Oran of the Ankara University

and Associate Prof. Elcin Macar of the Yildiz Technical University,

are of the opinion that German parliament's is a political call,

which bears no legal obligation for the Turkish Republic.

 

According to Turkish academics the main question here is: What does

it mean for the Turkish Republic to take historic responsibility for

the 1915 Armenian expulsion.

 

However Prof Bakir Caglar of Istanbul University is of the opinion

that `recognition of genocide' would bring in its wake certain `legal

responsibilities' for Turkey.

 

Facing the past

 

Recalling refusals and threats by the government directed at

academics who urge for an open discussion of the issue, Turkey has to

stop preventing public discussions on the Armenian problem, Macar,

told bianet.

 

"The state has to give up claiming that such a thing never happened,

embracing this as the official argument, and being a side in the

discussion,' said Macar. `If you are for leaving the issue to

historians, then you should really leave it to historians. You can't

prevent discussions.'

 

`Saying that `we have opened the archives' means `let us look into

the truth because we don't know the truth.' But the Turkish state is

continuing to act as if it knows the truth,' said Macar.

 

The German parliament has made the following calls on the German

government:

 

* The German government should help the Turkish Grand National

Assembly, the

Turkish government and the Turkish society to face its past,

 

* It should help set up a commission of Turkish and Armenian

historians,

* It should have the archives, which were sent from Germany to

Turkey,

opened to public,

 

* It should demand that the canceled Armenian conference takes place,

 

 

* It should contribute to the normalization of relations between

Turkey and

Armenia.

 

Oran: How can members of the `deep state' in 1915 be defended?

 

Baskin Oran of Ankara University argues that the `individuals, not

institutions or states, are responsible for the genocide.'

 

Oran underlined the fact that the Turkish Republic is the state which

demolished the Ottoman Empire: `The Turkish Republic has not taken

upon itself anything of the Ottoman Empire, except for the `Duyun-u

Umumiye, the public debt owed by the Empire to individuals. And it

was normal for the Republic to take that debt upon itself. For,

otherwise it would have remained outside the international system.'

 

`I don't understand why the Republic of Turkey, who has crushed the

Ottoman Empire, is now coming into the defense of the `Teskilati

Mahsusa' (Special Forces) henchmen of the `deep state' of 1915, and

the deep state itself,' said Oran. `The Republic of Turkey has no

legal responsibility.'

 

Apologizing

 

According to Elcin Macar, Turks may apologize for the deportation of

Armenians in 1915 and express that this was a mistake of their

ancestors.

 

`If Turkey apologizes, it would be in the form of: `We apologize for

what our ancestors have done,'' said Macar.

 

According to Oran however, the state must first apologize to the

Turkish public.

 

`If the Republic of Turkey is going to apologize, it should first

apologize to the Turkish public,' said Oran. `For having masked the

issue for all these decades, for not discussing it, and for banning

the discussions.'

 

International law issues

 

According to Prof. Bakir Caglar of the Political Sciences Department

of Istanbul University, settling accounts with the past isn't

something that can be done on one's own. `This can only be possible

through means and groundwork of international law,' said Caglar.

 

Caglar said in the face of increasing number of parliament decisions

across Europe the issue gains three dimensions in terms of

international law:

 

* The recognition of the genocide becoming a legal responsibility.

 

* The issue of insurance: The international companies that assumed

the insurances of Armenian property are still operational. The legal

procedure on the issue is continuing in the United States.

 

*Property in land: It is certain that real estate belonging to

Armenians were seized. This is a legal problem for Turkey. (TK)

 

BIA News Centre

21/06/2005