Jump to content

Ashot

Members
  • Posts

    5,065
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    5

Everything posted by Ashot

  1. THE OUTLOOK THE MISSIONARY REVIEW of the WORLD RECENT REPORTS FROM TURKEY Missionary Review July, 1916 The Russians continue to advance in Asia Minor, but more slowly than at first. As they occupy the Armenian territory, the surviving Christians come out of their hiding-places and peace is restored to the remnant - but Asia Minor as a whole is in a pitiable condition. The havoc wrought by the Turks can be better realized when we think that the number of Armenians, men, women and children massacred or starved to death in the past year would take three days and two nights to pass a given point marching twenty abreast without a break! The American Board received a cable from the charge daffier at Constantinople, urging that all the missionaries in the interior of Asia Minor be withdrawn on account of increasingly tumultuous conditions, but a message from the United States Consul at Tiflis, Russia, stated that conditions in the region of Van are suitable for the missionaries who were driven out to return. The American Board new has four stations under the Russian flag, Van, Bitlis, Erzroom, Trebizond, and has found the Russian officials extremely friendly. Matters, evidently, are very different in the Turkish territory and on the Russian side of the line. The American Board expects the male missionaries to return to Van at an early date. They will travel via Russia and the Caucasus and, for some time to come, will be occupied mainly in relief work. The missionaries still in Asia Minor (one hundred and twelve in number) are advised to consult with Treasurer Peet at Constantinople and the Unites States Embassy as to the wisdom of their remaining at their posts. A company of eight missionaries from eastern Turkey, desiring to leave for home, have been detained at Beirut since January 1st, the Turkish government refusing to allow the United States battleship Des Moines to take them off. In America, the Committee for Armenian and Syrian Relief has been stirred to renewed activity by a recent cablegram which states that many of the Armenian exiles, deported from their homes by Turkish soldiers, are reduced to eating grass and are dying of starvation by hundreds. "Sufferings among exiles have been greatly increased on account of their having refused to accept Mohammedan religion in accordance with offers generally made them. The fortitude of most of the people under the sufferings which they are undergoing is wonderful, and they are not losing their Christian faith. The men of the families of many of the exiles are still serving in the Turkish army." The Committee has commissions at work in several cities of Turkey and Persia and relief is being distributed under the direction of American missionaries and United States consuls, each city being the distributing point for a large section of country where are thousands of destitute people. It is estimated that in Turkey, Persia, Syria, and Palestine there are approximately a million Armenians, Nestorians, and native Christians who are destitute and suffering for want of food and the necessities of life. Missionary Review
  2. PUBLIC OPINION (New York) combined with THE LITERARY DIGEST The Literary Digest for June 17, 1916 The ARMENIAN EXILES are eating grass in a vain effort to postpone the death by starvation that has already overtaken thousands. The only alternative to death for these unfortunates of the Turkish Empire is the adoption of the Mohammedan, faith. Some, indeed, yield to this extremity, but we learn from the New York Evening Post that "the fortitude of most of the people under the sufferings which they are undergoing is wonderful, and they are not losing their Christian faith. The men of the families of many of the exiles are still serving in the Turkish Army." Mr. Henry Morgenthau, late Ambassador to Turkey, has given out that one of the main reasons for his recent resignation was his "great desire to make known to the people of the United States some of the conditions in the Turkish Empire, especially as those conditions affect the Armenians." In an interview in the New York Times he recalls his childhood tears over the scenes in "Uncle Tom's Cabin" and "Evangeline"; but all these things, he avers, are nothing compared to what went on in Turkey under his own eyes. Most of the stories that have reached the United, he says, are founded on facts. He continues: "The Armenians were living just as quietly and peacefully as possible, in friendship and close contact with their Turkish associates, when suddenly they were picked out to be deported. It was then that my heart bled for them. I had been given the privilege of dispensing charity without stint and with full authority on behalf of the English, Russian, French, and Italian nations - even the Serbians had sent me money, and Russia and Italy permitted me to help the poor Montenegrins in my charge. Suddenly, without available funds, I was confronted with the terrific problem of the destitute Armenians. Can you conceive how I felt? It was then that I sent an appeal to the Secretary of State for help, and the response came promptly." "If the people of the United States could only see the distress as I have seen it. If they could see the gaunt, little figures of children, the little orphans brought to Constantinople by friendly Turkish officers, the need of prompt aid would be fully realized. There were two children I shall never forget who had lost their parents, and, nearly dead, were mere skeletons covered over by skin. There were women who came into Constantinople whose condition I cannot describe women who had to become Moslems in order to save their lives and reach the city." "If I dared repeat the tales I have heard, sworn to and signed, they would make men and women weep and every one would see the need of sympathy and help. I wish I had the power to picture an Armenian refugee encampment and to tell how an American missionary hospital fed from its back door a thousand starving persons a day on an average of 3 cents a person with the $30 a day we gave it." "There is no use of accusing anybody or finding fault with any one. What this great country should do to show its appreciation of the wonderful blessings that have been showered upon us is for each one of us to make up his mind to do his share. Picture that you are personally responsible for the starvation of one or two persons if you do not give funds to save them. Twenty-five dollars will enable an Armenian family to be established in comparative comfort. I believe every person would be happier to sacrifice something and give $25 for the Armenians." The money so far received has not been sufficient to help many people. The Turkish Government at first interfered with relief-efforts, but is now showing a change of heart. The present as well as the prospective need is immense. Americans may think they have been generous until they reflect on the 30 cents per capita of our relief-donations: "It may be a Little indiscreet to say this, but I want to say that unless help is given to the suffering Armenians as well as to the destitute Moslems in Turkey, there will be a fearful amount of starvation next winter. They have not sufficient seed to plant their crops or animals to plow their soil. There is less than 10 per cent. Of the arable land under cultivation." "The United States with its 100.000.000 people has contributed only the insignificant sum of $30.000.000 to all of suffering humanity abroad. We ought to drop our heads in shame. Our 100.000.000 people, who have average wealth of $1.600 have not given more than 30 cents a piece. Every one who has not contributed ought to be ashamed of himself. These Armenian people are exposed to the weather with very scanty clothing and nothing to eat, with disease rife among them, and hundreds are dying from starvation. We are the only people to whom they can appeal for help to-day, the only people who dare express their sympathy by actual giving. The people of other nations are afraid and unable to do it." "We can raise in this country easily $500.000.000. That is only $5 per capita. If we are worth $1.600 each on an average, that is less than one-third of 1 per cent. Let the whole world understand that we are not willing to profit by this war, but we are willing to disregard profit and to be a big brother listening to the needs of the whole world." "We have been hearing of the brotherhood of men. If we are all brothers, and we are, have we a right to live on in comfort and luxury and allow these people to starve? I do not think we have. I believe that it is our duty, it is our privilege , for each of us to assume the guardianship of as many of the Armenian people as we can. I do not preclude the other countries. They are suffering just as much. I believe the moral force of America will be doubled and trebled if the rest of the world understands that we are ready and willing and anxious to help the suffering masses." p.134 AMERICAN PARTICIPATING IN ARMENIAN FREEDOM The U.S flag by a Russian officer amid the Allied forces outside the Governor's house at Trebizond just after the capitulation by Turkish forces. This ancient city on the Black Sea was the seat of Armenian massacres. The Literary Digest
  3. BEAT OFF 4,000 TURKS MARCH 12, 1916 Details of their defense against the Turkish troops and their escape ever the rugged paths of Mount Moses were given yesterday by Ohannes Klijeian, one of the forty-five Armenian refugees who arrived Friday on the Royal Italian steamship America. Most of these refugees have been discharged from Ellis Island and the majority of them have gone to various places in Pennsylvania, where arrangements have been made for them to obtain employment. "Our decision to fight the Turks," said Klijeian, "was reached by watching the fate of other Armenians. We had seen them sent off to exile, then had heard of the terrible persecution they suffered and of their murder. Each village was notified that its inhabitants must make ready to go. Our time came. We held secret meetings, we realized that we were going to certain and horrible death, and, knowing that resistance could not be worse, decided to fight to the last. "It was on Aug. 5 that four villages, of which my own home, Bityas, was one, united their populations. There were 618 from my village and a few more than 4,000 in all. When the Turks learned that we had gone up into Mousa Dagh (Mount Moses) 200 soldiers were sent after us. We had 127 rifles, some old shotguns and horse pistols. We had reached the upper crags of the mountain and had had time to dig hasty trenches and roll large rocks together, making the best barricade we could. The Turks attacked us, suffered severe losses, and were driven back. "Then they made arrangements for a more general attack, dragging up two field guns, which wrought havoc in our ranks. Peter Gragosian, a boy of 14, crept down through the brushwood and among the rocks. He was so close he could hear the Turks talking. With five bullets he killed four gunners. "The Turks were bent on reaching us, and 4,000 strong, succeeded in having a part of their troops occupy high ground threatening our camp. Reinforcements kept coming up the mountain, and we knew something must be done. There was a hurried council of our leaders to meet what we knew was the crisis. As a result of the council our men crept around the Turkish positions in the dead of night, closed in suddenly with a fuallade, and it succeeded, for in a few moments the Turkish camp was thrown into bewilderment and alarm, and the troops, thinking it a much more substantial attack than it was, broke and fled in all directions. "Then followed many days of ???lety and hardship. They kept coming after us and we defended ourselves as best we could. We had captured some guns and ammunition from the Turks, which we used against them." Later, as THE NEW YORK TIMES has told, the women among these refugees made a huge white flag, with a red cross in the center, the display of which on the mountain brought French warships to the rescue. New York Times
  4. MORGENTHAU SEES WILSON MARCH 10, 1916 WASHINGTON, March 9.--Henry Morgenthau, American Ambassador to Turkey, made a detailed report today to President Wilson on his work in Turkey since the outbreak of the war. Mr. Morgenthau also spoke of the need for supplying sufferers in Palestine with more food soon and recounted vivid stories of massacres of Armenians. New York Times
  5. RUSSIANS SEIZE PORT OF RIZEH THURSDAY, MARCH 9, 1916. LONDON, March 8.--The Russians found only sixteen Armenians alive in Erzerum out of the usual Armenians population of 40,000, according to information received in Petrograd and forwarded by Reuter's correspondent in the Russian capital. "The Turkish inhabitants or Erzerum," the correspondent adds, "stated that a few days before the capture of the fortress by the Russians all the Armenians in the town were driven out by the police in a westerly direction, where the Kurds, who had been forewarned, massacred all of them." Armenian Refugees Here The armed Italian liner America arrived in the bay yesterday from Naples and Geneva with 187 cabin passengers and 1,727 steerage passengers, the largest number of immigrants bought to this country on any one ship since the war began. Many of the Italians on board were young and able-bodied, but they explained that the Italian Government had released they had families in this country. On the boat were forty-five Armenian refugees, who had been brought to this country by the American Committee of Armenian and Syrian Relief. All were formerly inhabitants of the villages Habatlee and Batyas on Mount Moses, bordering on the Mediterranean, eighteen miles from Antioch. Late last Summer, they said, the 10,000 inhabitants of the two villages received word from Turkish officials that they had been ordered deported to a desert in the interior. During the time given them for preparation to leave their village, about 5,000 men, women, and children fled to refuges on Mount Moses, the remainder being driven under a guard of soldiers to some place in the interior from which none are known to have escaped. The refugees on the mountain twice repulsed a force of Turks sent to dislodge them. Finally they stole from the mountain fastnesses to a slope near the Mediterranean which was patrolled by numerous French ships. Here they said out a huge square of white cloth, made by sewing sheets together, with a large red cross in the center made of cloth from garments. This was observing by a French cruiser, which brought rescue to the whole party, which numbered at the time 4,200. All were taken to port Said, and many of them will be brought to this country in small numbers by the American Committee. New York Times
  6. ARMENIANS GET RELIEF MARCH 8, 1916 A reply was received yesterday from the Department of state in Washington to the recent letter of Dr. William A. Shedd relative to the Armenian situation. Dr. Shedd wrote to Secretary Lansing, asking guidance from him in an effort to obtain intercession on the part of the United States Government to save the suffering Armenians from further Turkish persecution. The letter from the State Department, signed by Second Assistant Secretary Alvey A. Adec, says in part: "In his latest telegram (received by the department on March 1) the Armenian Charge dataries at Constantinople states that during his last interview with the Turkish Minister for Foreign Affairs the Minister emphatically asserted that all deportation of the Armenians had ceased and that no more would take place and that Protestant and Catholic Armenians who had been deported would be allowed to return to their homes. The Charge adds that some amelioration of the Armenian situation is already noticeable and that American relief is now being distributed among the surviving Armenians without local official interference." Contributions for the suffering Armenians may be sent to Charles R. Crane, Treasurer, American Committee for Armenian and Syrian Relief, 70 Fifth Avenue, New York City. New York Times
  7. RUSSIANS SLAUGHTER TURKISH THIRD ARMY MONDAY, MARCH 6, 1916 LONDON, March 6.--The Russian soldiers at Bitlis, according to a Petrograd dispatch to the Morning Post, took a terrible revenge on the Turkish troops for the cruelty which the Turks were alleged to have practiced to ward the Armenians in that district. The correspondent says: "Terrible slaughter followed the capture of the Turkish positions at Bitlis. The Russian troops had witnessed at Van, Mush, and many other places, an appalling sight, the massacre: namely, by Turkish fanatics of tens of thousands of Armenian Christian men, women, and children. It was unlikely after such deeds that any quarter should be given. This colossal killing completed the destruction of the Turkish third army. New York Times
  8. PLEA FOR THE ARMENIANS MARCH 5, 1916 Reminding his hearers that in 1823 President Monroe, Daniel Webster, and the entire American nation protested against the massacre of the Greeks by the Turks, George Haven Putham. speaking last night at the dinner of the Stationers and Publisher's Board of Trade at the Hotel Astor, asserted that the United States today should protest against the similar massacre of the Armenians. "It is the duty of all of us," he said, "at this crisis to support the President in fulfilling the duty of the republic, the Government and the American people. It is our duty to protect Americans, Whether they be at home or abroad. One hundred years ago France went mad under Napoleon. Today we see another great nation which has been affected by madness. It is the duty of the other States of the civilized world to surround it, to stop its fury, and to drive it back to the kennel, where it can do no harm. "To me it is a disgrace that this country has done nothing to protect the Armenians from massacre by the Grandsons of the men against whom our government and our forefathers protested when they massacred the Greeks. Today, I regret to say, we seem to do nothing yet it is the plain duty of the United States to use its influence to relieve the smaller nations from pressure and to prepare to take our place in their interest in the conference that will conclude this war." "The President of the Board of Trade, Arthur P. Jackson, presided, and the toastmaster of the evening was Stephen Farrelly. The other speakers were the Rev. Cyprus Townsend Brady and Burges Johnson, Professor of English at Vassar College. New York Times
  9. DETAIL ARMENIANS' PLIGHT MARCH 2, 1916 Dr. Samuel T. Dutton, Secretary of the American Committee for Armenian and Syrian Relief, has received from several German nurses, who are in the Armenian section of Turkey, letters confirming reports from other sources of the Armenian population. Dr. Dutton said yesterday that, while he could not make public the names of the nurses, he was in a position personally to vouch for their trustworthiness. There are several communications. One of these says in part: "Just now I am coming back from a ride on horseback through ------------- plain where thousands of exiles are lying on fields and streets without any shelter, exposed to the power of any kind of brigands. I found men and women badly wounded, their bodies cut open and with broken skulls or in a terrible condition through stabs with the knife. Fortunately I was provided with clothes, so I could change their bloody things and then bring them to the next inn, where they were nursed. "Many of them were so exhausted from the enormous loss of blood that they died in the meantime." Still another report says in part "The camp in ---------- itself is the saddest thing I have ever seen. Right at the entrance a heap of bodies lay unburied. I counted thirty-five in another place twenty-two, right close by were the tents of those people who were very ill. In one single day the burial commission buried as many as 580 person." For the relief of these conditions the American Committee for Armenian and Syrian Relief is appealing for funds. Contributions may be sent to Charles R. Crane, Treasurer 70 Fifth Avenue. New York Times
  10. THE AMERICAN REVIEW OF REVIEWS THE KURDS: THEIR CHARACTER AND CUSTOMS MARCH, 1916 BY YOUEL B. MIRZA In the closing years of the nineteenth century, the Kurds attracted the attention of the civilized world by falling upon the Armenians and massacring them. Taking advantage of the cataclysm in the Western world, the Kurds and the Turks appear now to be determined upon settling once for all the question of exterminating the Armenian race. The wholesale murder of the Armenians is not due to religious hatred, as it was at first supposed. A chief reason for this slaughter is economic jealousy. The Armenians are thrifty, industrious, and, for the most part, a well-educated people. Practically all the rug industry in the Orient is controlled by them. They live and dress better than their neighbors. Such things have always hurt the false Kurdish pride The recent atrocities inflicted upon the Christian races by the Kurds in this war have been observed and published broadcast. The aim of this article is not to review the well-known subject of Armenian massacres, but rather to give the reader information gathered from first-hand observations of the Kurds, their land, and their predominating characteristics. The origin of the Kurds has not been satisfactorily settled, but it is believed that in their veins flows the blood of Chaldeans, Babylonians, and Assyrians. In early times the Kurds preferred mountains for their place of habitation, and took great pride then, as they do now, in being called "Gurdu," a title which signifies "warrior." Today the "Gutu" are better known in the Occident as Kurds, and number about two million, five hundred thousand,1 and have their abodes mostly in Kurdistan. Their land, which is extremely mountainous, rises to the east of the upper Tigris in the direction of Urumiah. The area of this space is sixty thousand square miles. There is not a mile of railway in the whole country and neither is there a road fir for traveling except by caravan. No people are more mistrusted by the Persians and the Turks than the Kurds. They do not consider a man's religion and standing; they would rob a Turk or a Persian as well as an Armenian or a Greek. The Ottoman Porte and the Persian Shah have not the power to interfere; for that very reason, I Believe, the Russian rule in northern Persia was a great blessing to the peace-loving peasants, as Russia was the only government which was able to establish order and to create fear among the Kurds. Of two million, five hundred thousand Kurds, there is no one who calls himself lawgiver and ruler, no one who assumes the authority to punish his fellow Kurd. Law with a Kurd is a personal matter. Each individual considers himself his own king and prince. A monarchy of self-control is unknown among them. The Kurdish mind is his constitution , his gun and sword the means by which he enforces his law and justice. Such a state of affairs is not, of course, favorable to the establishment of a stable government, nor is such an atmosphere conducive to the development of the better qualities of human nature. Occasionally some queer stories have been told by visitors to Kurdistan; one of these remains in my memory as exemplifying the schooling of a young Kurd. My grandfather, who had been doing missionary work among the Kurds, related the following conversation with a chieftain: "You have several sons, I understand?" "Yes," answered the chief. "Are they all married?" "All but poor Ali, and no girl will marry him, because he is not a successful thief and robber." "Well, what are you going to do about it?" "Oh, I have advised him," responded the chief, "to carry with him a gun and a sword, and I have explicitly impressed upon his mind, that no matter how bloody and evil the deed he might commit, it will only add respect and honor to his name and family." Such is the advice of the Kurdish father to his son. The word kill is the most used term in the whole Kurdish vocabulary. If tow Kurds were in conversation, it would not be very long even for one who knows nothing about the language to detect the word "ulderam,"2 "I shall kill him." It would indeed be very unusual to see a young Kurd without a club in his hand, a dagger in his belt, or a gun on his shoulder. Allegiance of any description is, according to philosophers like Rousseau, a folly, if not a crime, and quite beneath the dignity of a human being. Such is the philosophy of the Kurds. They love personal liberty and under no condition will they willingly subject themselves to any ruler. The Kurds take no interest in modern reforms. They dislike the light of civilization. We hear of every known nationality and people in America except the Kurds. Civilization has never penetrated the Kurdish character; they have preferred their barbaric freedom to law and justice. They have no established homes; in summer they live in tents of goats-hair on the mountain tops, and in winter in mud villages. Their usual diet consists of bread and buttermilk, and cheese made of goat's milk. They have experienced little change since "Noah's Ark rested on the Mount of Ararat." James Bryce, in his "Transcaucasia and Ararat," p.256,gives a graphic picture of the Kurds: Through the Empires of Assyria and Persia and Macedon, through Parthian Arsacidæ, and Iranian Sassanidæ, through the reigns of Arabian Khalifs, and Turkish Sultans, and Persian Shahs, these Kurds have roamed as they roam now, over the slopes of the everlasting mountains, watering their flocks at this spring, pitching their goats-hair tents in the recesses of these lonely rocks, chanting their wildly pathetic airs with neither a past to remember nor a future to plan for. Perhaps the most distinguishing characteristic of the Kurds is great devotion among the members of families. This is exemplified in the following incident. A chief from the mountains of Kurdistan descended into the plains of Urumiah and there engaged in plundering, the property of the citizens of the state of Azerbaijan. The militia was ordered to trap the culprits. The chief was subdued. They were brought into the city, and all were sentenced to death except the chief, who was spared for his gray hairs. Among them was a youth of twenty, strong and healthy; his rugged appearance made an instant appeal to every spectator, and the cry rose, "Save him, save him!" Immediately the old chieftain, whom the Governor had forgiven on account of his age rushed forward and demanded, before they proceeded with the execution, to speak to the Governor. After the poor old man had experienced much rough treatment was granted. In true Oriental fashion, he thus addressed the Governor: O, eye of my home and of my family. We did come from the mountains to carry some food to our families and to our herds. We admit that we have done harm to your law-abiding citizens. You have sworn that the guilty men should die, and it is just, but I, who am pardoned on account of my age, come here to demand a favor of my lord. The youngest of my family is with me; he came here because I asked him. This is his first offense. He is young, and has hardly tasted the sweets of life; is just betrothed. I am here to die in his stead. Inshallah, inshallah (in the name of God) let a worn-out old man perish, and spare a youth, who may long he useful to his family, to feed the flocks and tend the sheep. Let him live to drink of the waters flowing from the fountains and silvery streams of Kurdistan, and to till the ground of his ancestors. The Governor was greatly moved by the old man's appeal. He granted the chief's wishes, and the old man went to meet his fate, while the youth cried wildly and became distracted with grief because the Governor reversed his decree and took the more valuable life of the aged chief. This is characteristic of a system which bears today more clearly than any other traces of the patriarchal government. [1 There are no means by which we can obtain with accuracy the exact population of Kurds, for neither in Persia nor in Turkey has a government census been established.] [2 The word "ulderam" is Turkish in origin, as the Kurdish language is largely intermingled with the Turkish and Persian languages.] p. 130 Photograph by Underwood & Underwood, New York KURDISH TROOPS IN THE TURKISH ARMY p. 131 YOUNG KURDISH WOMEN AT COTNI, MUSH PLAIN American Review
  11. BRYCE TRUST AMERICA FEBRUARY 23, 1916 PARIS, Feb. 22.--Lord Bryce, who heads the British delegation to the Anglo-French Parliamentary conference, has given an interview to The Paris Journal. "The situation in the United States is much too complicated and changes too quickly from day to day," he said, "for me to be able to form any conjectures as to the manner in which events concerning the Washington Government are liable to develop. There is, however, one thing which should be known, ad it is that the sympathies of the great majority of the American people go out clearly and indisputably to the Allies. I never had the slightest fear of real difficulties arising between the United States and the Allies, because it is hardly necessary for me to say that there are historical reasons why a genuine friendship should be felt in the United States for France and Great Britain." Lord Bryce expressed his satisfaction at the fall of Erzerum. He said: "The cause of the Armenians is especially dear to me. There is no people in the world which has suffered more. It has been a victim not of religious fanaticism, but of cold-blooded, premeditated hatred on the part of the brigands who term themselves the Turkish Government and who do not intend to permit the existence of any national vitality except in their own element." Although he had just got in touch with the members of the French Senate conferences, Lord Bryce said he already felt that the meetings and the exchanges of views would be of the greatest benefit both during and after the war. "The great problem which the allied Governments will have to face at the end of hostilities." he said. "will be the creation of some instrument able for all time to prevent a conflagration such as now plunges Europe in desolation." New York Times
  12. Promising to Hang Some Turks TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 22, 1916 Included in the dispatches about the fall of Erzerum is the statement that t he victorious Russians intend to hold the Turkish officials, civil and military, personally responsible for their atrocious treatment of the Armenian population, and that there are to be many trials for murder, the inevitable end of which will be the hanging in large numbers of those who ordered or permitted the massacres. It is hard--for most, probably impossible--not to receive this news with satisfaction and to hope that it may turn out to be true. Of course, on general principles, the amount of killing in progress over a considerable portion of the earth's surface is already somewhat more than sufficiently great, and its increase in not desirable, but there really seems to be no way to convince the Turks that some of their policies are intolerable, even in such a world as this has come to be, except by arguing with the men who devise and execute those policies in he one way they understand. How far, if at all, below the Sultan himself and his chosen or self-selected Ministers, the line of direct, personal responsibility and direct, personal punishment should be direct, personal punishment should be drawn is a question to which the Russians can probably be trusted to find an answer in the number and importance of the prisoners' they are able to take. They are not a squeamish lot, the Russians, and they would do the job well if they set about it. Their own record in the treatment of helpless peoples whose existence they found obnoxious or inconvenient can be held, according to the point of view, either for or against their right to reprehend the Turks for slaughtering Armenians. On the one hand, one might say that it little became the Russians to find fault with any peculiarities of Turkish politics, but on the other, their competence is indubitable for the exercise of deserved as well as of unearned severity. Again, we are often told that the Russia of today is a new Russia, with new habits and ambitions. That, if true, makes it unnecessary and injudicious too industriously to take up old grievances against her. At any rate, she is keeping excellent company, nowadays, and it is only fair to credit nations as well as individuals with sharing the virtues of their associates. New York Times
  13. APPEALS FOR ARMENIANS FEBRUARY 18, 1916 Dr. William A. Shedd, an American missionary of the Presbyterian Board, who has been engaged in active work for twenty years in Persia and who returned recently to this country, has written Secretary of State Lanshing regarding the Armenian atrocities. In his communication he says: There is absolutely no question as to the effects of the outrages suffered by the Armenians nor as to the responsibility of the Turkish Government for these outrages. Precisely similar outrages took place a year ago on Persian soil during the period of Turkish occupancy and in part perpetrated directly by Turkish officers and those who were under Turkish orders. In the course of these outrages helpless men and women were killed, women suffered outrage and women and girls were taken captives, while as a result of the conditions of life several thousand died from epidemics. "I am sure there are a great many thoughtful Americans who, like myself, feel that silence on the part of our Government to make no public protest against a crime of such magnitude perpetrated by a Government on noncombatants, the great majority of them helpless women and children, is to miss an unusual opportunity to serve humanity, if not to risk grave danger of dishonor on the name of America and of lessening our right to speak for humanity and justice. I am aware, of course, that it may seem presumptuous to suggest procedure in matters of diplomacy; but the need of these multitudes of people suffering in Turkey is desperate, and the only hope of influence is in the Government of the United States." New York Times
  14. RANSOMS ARMENIAN GIRLS FEBRUARY 13,1916 The American Committee for Armenian and Syrian Relief, among the members of which are Cardinal Gibbons, Oscar S. Straus, Bishop Greer, Charles R. Crane, and many other prominent Americans, announced yesterday that it had undertaken the work of reclaiming Armenian women and girls who were in the hands of the Turks, and also the paying of ransom, when necessary, to recover the captives. "From information furnished this committee," the statement said, "it is authoritatively estimated that there are hundreds of these young girls and women who today are in the hands of the Turks and Kurds. A great many of them have been reclaimed, but many more remain to be saved. Upon authentic authority it is asserted that there as on an average of one out of every twelve of these young women who is returned to her family by those who were her captors. It is principally from personal influence that the way is opened for this work of reclamation. The Turkish officers for so much money will give information as to where these young women may be found. Further payments will cause them to be brought to some appointed place, and then it is a matter of how much money will be paid for their release. "So far as the payment of ransom money is concerned, no estimate as to the average amount is possible. An instance cited is that of a Russian orthodox priest who was a Persian by birth. The Kurds demanded $15,000 ransom for his release, but when $5,000 was offered they accepted it. "It is for this work that urgent appeals are being made by the American Committee for Armenian and Syrian Relief. Contributions may be sent to Avenue, New York." New York Times
  15. AMERICAN BURNED ALIVE BY TURKS FEBRUARY 8, 1916 PETROGRAD, Jan 12, (Correspondence of The Associated Press.)--Dr. Jacob Sargis, an American Methodist medical missionary, who has arrived in Petrograd after narrowly escaping death at the hands of the Turks and Kurds in Urumiah. Persian Armenia, asserts that among the outrages committed against the Christian refugees was the burning to death of an American doctor named Simon or Shimmun, as he was known there. His identity was not established further, but the story of the outrage, as told by Dr. Sargis, was as follows: "Dr. Shimmun was in the village of Supurghan when the Turks attacked that place. He was among those who took refuge on a mountain near the lakes. He was captured and told that since he had been a good doctor and had helped the wounded, they would not kill him, but that he must accept the Mohammedan faith. He refused, as almost all Christians did. They poured oil on him, and, before applying the torah, gave him another chance to forsake his religion. Again he refused and they get his clothes afire. While fleeing in agony due to the flames the Turks shot him several times. After he fell to the ground unconscious they hacked his head off. Mr. Allen, an American missionary, who went from village to village burying the victims of this butchery, found the body of Shimmun half eaten by his doers. The Catholic mission there took 150 Christians of all sets and kept them in a small room and tried to save them, but at least forty-nine of them, among them one Bishop Dinkha of the Episcopal mission, were bound together one night, taken to Gagin Mountain, and there shot down." Dr. Sargis was born in Persia, but went to America in 1883, and was educated there by assistance of Dr, W. F. Oldham, and former Bishop of India. He is a graduate of Ohio Wesleyan and Ohio Medical Universities, and was for a time resident physician of the Protestant Hospital at Columbus, Ohio. He was doing relief work in Urumiah on Jan. 1 last year when the Russian Army retired from Urumiah and a hundred surrounding villages. There were still left in Urumiah and the villages 45,000 persons, chiefly Armenian refugees, when the Turks and Kurds entered. The latter at once began the work of extermination of the Christian population. In one town alone, Gulfarchin, in one night, according to Dr. Sargis, seventy-nine men and boys were tied hand to hand, taken to a hill outside the village and shot. Their wives and daughters were distributed among the Turks, Kurds, and Persian Mohammedans. "On the second day after the Turkish officers came, " continued Dr. Sargis. Dr. Sargis turned the tables on the Arab doctor by alleging that he was insane and having him put under guard and on a milk diet, notwithstanding he was a doctor in Khalil Bey's army. "Soon after the Russians left Urumiah a German machinist, Neumann, who came in with the Turks, announced himself as German Consul. By his orders a Christian by the name of Mushi was hanged. Eighty-five hundred persons died in the vicinity of Urumiah in five months; 1,500 were killed and the rest died of cold and hunger. "They had a good many wounded and sick. As soon as they heard that I was an able physician, they took me, gave me a bodyguard, and put me in charge of Urumiah Hospital. That was how I came to learn most of their secrets; I helped their wounded and sick. One day there were sixty men brought from Bashkal, all well-to-do citizens, some of them noted men of that place. They were used as heists of burden, forced to carry rolls of barbed wire into Urumiah. The next day they were all taken to the Castle of Ismayil and every one was shot or hacked to death. "About that time Nuri, the Governor of Garv, told me that he had received word from the Turkish commander to kill all the Armenian soldiers in the Turkish army. He said that for my sake he would not do it, but that somebody, else would. Twenty-nine were killed about fifteen miles from Urumiah, at Karmad. We had eight of them in the city, fine fellows, some of them educated in Beirut. They had been disarmed, and one night the Turks took them to the suburbs and shot them. But one of them named Aslam escaped. He dropped with the others, but was not hit. After the butchers left he made his way to the Presbyterian mission college. I was notified and asked to take care of him. I kept him until the Russian Army came. He joined and is now fighting with them. "In the First Turkish Corps, commanded by Khalil Bey, There were about 400 Armenians. One of them, Gubankyan, a graduate of Beirut, told me that they were all doomed to be butchered. When they appointed me head physician of the hospital they gave me plenty of helpers, including seven Christian nurses, six Arabs, and one Greek, Gubankyan told me that if I did not help them they would be killed. "An Arab physician, Bahadin Effendi, was appointed to work under my direction. My Greek nurse warned me that Bahadin had already killed more than fifty Armenian Christians and cautioned me to watch him. One night about 10 o'clock Bahadin sent for me, saying that he was sick. Fortunately for me, the Greek and two Armenian nurses went with me. When I reached the hospital I found that Bahadin was not sick at all. He said to me: "What business have you to disturb me at this time of the night? Your coming shows that you have some design upon my life. I told him that it was a mistake, that the overtaken by an officer, who said that the doctor was not done with me. I protested, but was ordered to go back. So I put my trust in the Lord and went. "The doctor greeted me with the question: 'Who gave you permission to leave the room? and continued: 'You are a prisoner and you will never seethe light of tomorrow's sun.' I told him that I was helping the wounded for the sake of humanity. He cut me off by saying: 'This is wartime. The top of your hat is green. That means that you are a descendant of the prophet, and it will give me pleasure to destroy your life tonight. I must think how I shall kill you. I could throw you out of the window, but that would be too quick. I could shoot you, but that also is too good for you. I shall have to use my sword. You sit down there in that corner and these Turkish nurses will sing your, funeral before I begin to cut you up.' "The Turks began to sing a droning chant, and had no choice but to sit and listen. My bodyguard, the Greek nurse Theodore and two Armenian soldiers, the latter my servants, stood outside the door and when they heard the chanting they thought it was all over with me. The Greek, who was a shrewd fellow, told my bodyguard to enter, and if he say me, to say that the patients wanted to see the doctor. All of a sudden I saw him enter with a lantern. He saluted the Effendi and said: 'The patients want the doctor.' I didn't save Bahadin a chance to say a word. I was up stop me, but they were too late. My bodyguard and the Armenians and the Greek followed close behind me and I got away. I reached home at midnight. My wife and children thought I was already dead." New York Times
  16. TELLS OF GREAT PLAIN BLACK WITH REFUGEES FEBRUARY 7, 1916 A letter written by Dr. Richard Hill a member of the American commission that went into the Caucasus to investigate conditions among the Armenian refugees who fled into Russia to escape the Turks, has been received by Dr. Samuel T. Dutton of the Americans Committee, under whose auspices the commission is working. Dr. Hill writes: "I dined with a gentleman who had come up out of Persia about the time the last great exodus took place. He relates that he saw the great Erivan Plain black with a slow moving mass of humanity that seemed to fill and overflow the horizon. They must have numbered close to 230,000 and they were aimlessly, listlessly wandering in the torrid heat. "Children, were dying by the hundreds, sometimes the frenzied mothers would in their helpless mad grief, fling their children from them over the roadside into the fields, so their emaciated and starved babies. Old women and men were dropping out by the roadside, too far gone to go another step. Epidemics had already appeared and were claiming their victims by the hundreds. From that throng he said there went up such an unutterable wall of woe and misery that he was compelled to close the window in his railway compartment to try to shut out the sound of that concentration of agony and pain. "They had been on the march constantly for weeks. Children had lost their parents, parents their children. Out of hundreds of stories that are daily coming to band it is bard to make a choice, for all alike are most touching. We hear, for instance, of Cossack transports picking up scores of little children left by the roadside to die and of their bringing these in on their wagons, sharing their frugal meals with them; of women found dead by the roadside and a baby trying to waken the mother by pulling at her face and demanding food. Of new-born babies left just as they were born, carelessly flung aside the mother often dying shortly afterwards, or of a Russian officer out at the front sitting crouched over a little fire that he had made out of a few sticks, and of a little girl stiff with he cold and hungry, slipping into the circle of heat of the fire and without apology snuggling up to him and going fast asleep in a moment in the kindly warmth of the fire and of that officer sitting cramped for hours in order to let the little wolf sleep in the folds of his big army coat. "I have looked into the faces of hunted, haunted children prematurely old though the children prematurely old through the months of horrors that they have gone though; into the eyes of young women and girls, alas, too apparent the condition they are in. Hateful outrage and nightmare being them more and worse facing them, after a month or two." New York Times
  17. SAW ARMENIANS GO STARVING TO EXILE FEBRUARY 6, 1916 The story of a journey through Turkey, from a port on the Mediterranean to Constantinople, is told in the January bulletin of the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions by a member of the party who recently arrived in this country. The trustworthiness of the narrator is vouched for by the board. The journey to Constantinople began on a Monday morning, a few weeks ago. The first stop was a little village where the party had to remain three hours. While there the travelers went to the home of a young Armenian woman, the wife of an Armenian physician who had a year before gone to the front as a member of the Medical Corps of the Turkish Army. The fact that her husband was at the front for Turkey and ministering to Turkish wounded and sick did not little children from exportation by the Turks came, ordered her and the children to leave, and then plundered the house. "It was one of the saddest hours I ever lived through," says the person who tells this story, "and we knew that in hundreds of other homes in that very town the same heartrending scenes might be witnessed. The courage of that little woman who knew she must take her two babies and faces starvation and death with them! Her smile was like a beacon in that mud village, where hundreds were-doomed. Her husband was far away, ministering to those who were sending her and her babies to destruction. " 'It is the slow massacre of our entire race," said one woman. 'It is worse than massacres, replied a man. "The town crier went through all the streets of the village, crying out that any one who helped the Armenians in any way, gave them food, money, or anything would be beaten and cast into prison. To help them we could do nothing; we were powerless to save their lives. "Already the Turks had taken the American school and church, and after a procession through the streets had consecrated the church into a mosque and made the school a Turkish school. They had taken down the cross and put up the crescent. Some weeks before they had exiled the faithful Armenian pastor, who for a great many years had toiled there, as he said, 'to make a little oasis in the desert.' "Hardly had we left the town when we began to meet one train after another, crowded, jammed with these poor people being carried away to some spot where no food could be obtained. At every station we stopped we came side by side with one of these trains. It was made up of cattle cars, and the faces of little children were looking out from behind the barred windows of each car. The side doors were open, and one could plainly see old men and old women, young mothers with tiny babies, men, women, and children all huddled together--human beings treated worse than cattle are treated. "About 8 o'clock that evening we came to a station where stood one of these trains. The Armenians told us that they had been in the station for three days, with no food. They said the Turks forbade their buying food. At the end of each train was a car of Turkish soldiers, ready to drive the poor people on when then they reached the desert, or to whatever place they were being taken. "They told us that twenty babies had been thrown into a river as a train crossed, thrown by the mothers themselves, who could not bear to hear their little ones crying for food when there was no food to give them. One woman gave birth to twins in one of those crowded cars, and crossing a river she threw both her here babies and then herself into the water. Those who could not pay to ride in these cattle cars were forced to walk. All along the road, as our train passed, we saw them walking slowly and sadly along driven from their homes like sheep to the slaughter. "A German officer was on the train with us, and I asked him if Germany had anything to do with this exile, for I thought it was the most brutal thing that had ever happened. He said, "You can't object to exiling a race; it's only the way the Turks are doing it which is bad." He said he had just come from the interior himself and had seen the most terrible sights he ever saw in his life. Hundreds of people were walking over the mountains, driven by soldiers. Many were dead and dying by the roadside. Old women and dying by the roadside. Old women and little children too feeble to walk were strapped to the sides of donkeys Babies lay dead in the road. Human life thrown away everywhere." "Another man on the train said that in one train he was in the mothers bagged him to take their children, to save them from such a death. He said that an Armenian, a leading business man in ------, told him that he would rather kill his four daughters with his own hand than see the Turks take them from him. This Armenian was made to leave his home, his business and all he had, and started off with his family to weak to whatever place the Turks desired to exile him. "When we reached a station near Constantinople we met a long train of Armenians that had just been exiled. Some of our party talked with one of the native teachers from the American school. Among other things he said that an old man was walking the street when the order came to leave. The old man was deaf and did not understand. Because he made no move to leave the soldiers shot him down in the street. "On every train we met we heard the heartrending cries of little children." New York Times
  18. THE LIVING AGE THE MURDER OF ARMENIA February 5, 1916 Not the least service performed by Lord Bryce and Mr. Toynbee in their pamphlet on "Armenian Atrocities" (Hodder & Stoughton), is that they have told the truth in carefully chosen words of moderation; that they have rejected all "coffee-house gossip" and unsubstantial rumor; that they have expressed themselves with almost as much detachment as if they were telling a tale of deeds done "long ago, and ill-done, too." Any expression of violence and deep anger, even of a desire for vengeance, is absent from this truthful and detached record of what is perhaps the most horrible story of the world. The tale is in each the same. It comes from forty or fifty centers - populous towns, each linked by telegraph to Constantinople and Berlin. On a given date, all the male adult Christian population are led away from the city and massacred in some neighboring valley. In some cities as at Trebizond or some coast or river town, the nuisance of shooting or hacking these populations to death is averted by taking them out to sea and sinking the there - a clean, expeditions job, whereby thousands can be destroyed in a few minutes. If that were all that were done - and this at the most is all that could be regarded as necessary by some Eastern conqueror or potentate of the Dark Age - a deed would have been accomplished, frightful but not unparalleled. But what followed is unprecedented - an action committed not in the heat of battle or lust, or animated by fanatic religious fervor, but an action such as might be undertaken by skillful, efficient insects, who hated not or loved not, but just had chosen so. From every town the Christians women and girls and old men and women were assembled in great companies. All their houses and household goods had already been seized by the Turks of the town. Under the charge of some of the lowest ruffians of each city, they were dispatched to their allotted destination, some hundreds of miles away. These caravans traversed the mountains and burning desert, oppressed with hunger and thirst. Their tracks could be marked by those who fell out by the way, and were left to die. The girls had largely been trained at the German and American Mission Schools - some of the women in Europe - even on Germany. Many could speak European languages, and would have passed as Europeans. They were driven forward by the blows and whips of their intolerable escort. Many of them had had their clothes torn from them, and were toiling naked over the desert sands. Pregnant women gave birth to children on the way, and were driven forward with the rest, and died. At every village up and down the prettiest girls were sold to the local Governors or rich Turks to do with them as they pleased, or for the brothels of Anatolia or Constantinople. At night their escorts or the neighboring Kurds inflicted upon the remainder every element of bestiality or lust - under the sanction of the Governors, that "they could do with them what they pleased." We read f their arrival at various Turkish towns, but of no attempt of the Turks to succor them, and of any attempt to do so by native Christians who remained being sternly forbidden. When all the young and pretty women had gone, their escorts, tired of the work, would kill the remainder; literally, as in the Scriptural text, seeking the blessing that accompanies those who "take thy children and dasheth them against the stones." Gradually, under the subjugation of this process, the very elements of humanity seem to have been beaten out of them. They had no men except the oldest, no priest to preach the religion which has sustained them against the Turk for five centuries. "Many began to doubt the existence of God," says on witness. "Don't you see what has happened? God has gone mad," was the cry of another. "The Armenians on their arrival in a Turkish town," says one, "could not be recognized, as the result of their twelve days' march. Even in this deplorable state, rapes and violent acts are of everyday occurrence." Some women carried poison with them, others pocks and shovels to bury the dead. The later caravans on the road came upon the remains of the former, "women, husbands, and sons killed; old people and infants still alive, but in pitiful condition, having shouted their voices away." Those who were too weak to keep up were bayoneted and thrown into the river, "and their bodies floated down to the sea, or lodged in the shallow river on rocks, where they remained for ten or twelve days and putrefied." They were not allowed to sleep in the village, but lay down outside. "Under cover of the night, indescribable deeds were committed by the gendarmes, brigands, and villagers." The people found themselves in the necessity of eating grass. When this particular party reached the Euphrates, "the worst and most unimaginable horrors were reserved for us. The mutilated bodies of women, girls, and little children (those who had gone before) made everyone shudder. The brigands were doing all sorts of evil deeds to the women and girls that were with us, whose cries went up to heaven. All the remaining children under fifteen were flung into the river." In other testimonies (these are, in the main, American Consuls, German or Swiss missionaries), "the caravans are exposed in front of the Government buildings in every town or village where they pass, in order that the Moslems may take their choice." The journey's end, as Mr.Toynbee remarks, is an exact copy of the scheme by which the Young Turks settled the problem of the pariah dogs of Constantinople. The survivors were finally deposited, mainly at the "agricultural colonies" - one southeast of Aleppo, which was uninhabited, owing to the fever of the marshes: the other in the burning desert beyond Der-el-Zor, on the banks of the Euphrates. A visitor sees the first party herded through Aleppo (where the German Consul is all powerful), creatures scarcely human, and deposited in the swamps, where all perished. The remainder were driven on to Der-el-Zor, given up on the way to the Kurds and the Bedouin. A Swiss missionary, Fraulein Beatrice Rohner, describes from personal observation this last scene: "It was evident from their clothing that they had been well-to-do. It was a daily occurrence for five or six children to die by the roadside. ' Why do they not kill us at once?' they cried to her. 'For days we have had no water to drink, and our children are crying for water. At night the Arabs attack; they steal the clothes we have been able to get together; they carry away by force our girls, and outrage our women. If any of us are unable to walk, the convoy of gendarmes beat us. Some of our women threw themselves down from the rocks into the Euphrates in order to save their honor - some of these with their infants in their arms.' " This evidence dates from months ago. Death by now has provided a merciful release. The remains of the Armenian nation have fl into Trans-Caucasus, over the mountains, under every circumstance of cold and hunger; but with hope instead of utter despair for guiding star. Attempts are being made by American and English friends to succor them, but they are dying like flies from privation and disease. More subscriptions for the Lord Mayor's Fund might save a few. But over the greater part of Asia Minor "Delenda est Armenia" waves over the bones of a murdered nation. Christianity in the East is dead - and the certificate of its destruction can be truthfully given by the "Young Turks," the "Committee of Union and Social Progress," when they welcome the German Emperor to the capital of his coveted "place in the sun." What can be said of German complicity? This: (1) That from May to October, 1915, when the vast tragedy was being accomplished, there were German Consuls, all powerful, at every town, who could have telegraphed the facts to their Ambassador at Constantinople, and in an hour from there to Berlin; (2) that all demands made by the American Consuls to the German Consuls to appeal for stoppage or amelioration of these horrors were refused; (3) that the record of the Belgian atrocities differed in degree only, but not in kind, from the German; (4) that Enver ***** had been educated at Berlin, decorated with German Orders, and would undoubtedly have followed any advice given him by his Royal ally; and (5) that the Turks in Anatolia being incredibly stupid and unreachable, the whole apparatus of trade, commerce and culture had fallen into the hands of the Armenians, and the elimination of a million of them would leave a gap specially suited to the kind of German immigration which most feels the pressure of population for expansion abroad. More than this at present we cannot say. But no German emigrants will go to a protected Anatolia. No German Empire will stretch from Berlin to Baghdad: and a bankrupt, decimated, limited race, bound in between secure boundaries, will learn, at length, that God exists, and His wheels grind exceedingly small. I remember following Mr. George Eussell in resigning my position on the Balkan Committee, when Enver and Talaat and other "Young Turks" were feted in London, and quoted glibly passages from Herbert Spencer and John Stuart Mill, and concealed successfully the eternal ferocity of the Turk. I am glad today that I was not deceived by that "gang of ruffians," as Lord Bryce calls them, who have successfully combined the vices of the East and the West. We cannot reverse the vast holocaust of misery and outrage which for six months has cried to Heaven for vengeance and cried in vain. But we can swear an oath and keep it with an equal mind that the sword shall not be sheathed until Turkey-in-Asia is rent in pieces; that no Christian, or people of other race, shall henceforth be ruled by the Turk; and that the Turks shall obtain no advantage - nor the Germans either - from the lands they have depopulated and the people they have destroyed. If that can be accomplished this war will not altogether be fought in vain, or our dead sacrificed without a purpose. We cannot forget our own past guiltiness in the matter. John Bright appealed to posterity for vindication against a cynical Parliament and an absurd coalition in opposing the Crimean War. We were told later on by a Tory statesman that we had then put our money on the wrong horse. We had not put it on a "horse" at all, but on a ravening, half-maniacal wild beast, thirsting always for blood and outrage. A generation afterwards, J.R. Green saw England, under Disraeli, "drifting into war - into war on the side of the Devil and in the cause of Hell." The result was the destruction of the San Stefano treaty and the substitution for it of the Treaty of Berlin - from which most of modern European tragedies, including this war, have directly arisen. Today, the amateur diplomatist blames Sir Edward Grey for not having made an alliance with Turkey instead of finding himself openly at war with her, and she the Kaiser's friend. We can congratulate him and his people on that friendship: a live nation cemented to a corpse, for whose misdeeds he is responsible, and who, in the fullness of time, even perhaps through this desperate sortie to the East in which he is engaging, will drag him down into the same destruction as she is destined inevitably to endure. C.F.G.Masterman. The Living Age
  19. THE AMERICAN REVIEW OF REVIEWS THE FATE OF THE ARMENIANS FEBRUARY, 1916 ONE of the few results that may be looked for from the War of Nations is the erection of an autonomous, or partly autonomous Armenians state in Asia Minor, although here, as with Poland, there is little likelihood that all the fractions of this unhappy race can ever be united under a single government, for at present the Armenians are divided among three different nations, Russia, Turkey, and Persia, their political lot closely resembling that of the Poles in this respect. Some aspects of the Armenians situation are presented in an article in Nuova Antologia (Rome), by a member of the Italian Chamber of Deputies, Signor Filippo Media. At the outset he notes that but for Disraeli's opposition, the Armenian question might have been settled at the Congress of Berlin, in 18878, by constituting an Armenian dependency under the nominal suzerainty of Turkey. A petition signed by 200,000 Armenians had been presented, and several of the delegates were inclined to support the project, but Disraeli and his assistant, Salisbury, opposed it inflexibly. The chief cause of this opposition was the fear that the new Armenian state would follow the example of the Balkan states and gravitate toward Russia, and would thus render Turkey more vulnerable in case of a Russia attack in Asia Minor. The same indifference to the fate of the Armenians, dictated by considerations of political expediency, prevented any attempt to enforce the article of the Berlin Treaty requiring the Turkish Government to reform the local abuses in Armenia, under the general supervision of the powers. As is well known, this article has always remained a dead letter, and not even the impression caused by the terrible happenings of 1895 and 1896 could induce the powers to interfere. The French Minister of Foreign Affairs, Bourgeois, replied to an interpellation in the Chamber of Deputies, that in view of " the delicacy of the subject," his answer would have to be given personally and in writing, and in the very midst of the massacres, the Czar sent an autograph letter to the Sultan, Abdul Hamid accompanied by valuable gifts. To make the balance between the Allies and the Central Powers even, we are reminded that about the same time the German Emperor sent his photograph, with a friendly inscription, to the Sultan. While this Italian writer is evidently a decided pro-Armenian, the general exactness of his presentment can scarcely be questioned. The recent revival of the Armenian persecutions in the most aggressive form is matter of recent history, and we must feel all the greater satisfaction that at last some apparently effective steps have been taken by a neutral whose power and influence are due, not to temporal, but to spiritual force. Of this, Signor Meda writes as follows: The efforts of Monsignor Dolci, the Apostolic Delegate at Constantinople, though whom Benedict XV has transmitted his remonstrances and solicitude to the Sublime Porte, have been crowned with a considerable measure of success. In fact, the Turkish Minister of the Interior was induced, last September, to send a circular to the governors of the Empire, in which it is stated that the object of the measures taken in regard to the Armenians was only to check the rebellious activity of that nationality and its aspirations for the formation of an autonomous state, and not to massacre the Armenians. In accordance with this, orders were given to suspend their expatriation, to protect those who had already been expatriated, on their way to the new districts assigned to them, and to provide them with requisites for the establishment of new abodes. All who should attack them on the way, or who should commit any acts of brigandage, were threatened with heavy penalties, and, finally, it was ordained that all failing to conform to these instructions should be denounced. It appears that the Turkish authorities did not confine themselves to this circular, as information secured from the Apostolic Delegate is said to confirm the report that certain officials were punished, and that in many places the persecution had ceased. The warmest thanks were sent to the Holy See by the Armenian patriarch, with the earnest wish that the Armenian blood that had been shed, both of Roman Catholics and Gregorians, might serve a union between the two churches. Of course, at best, this is only a step in the right direction, and any real a improvement of conditions can only come when the Turks are brought under the control either of the Allies or of the Central Powers, as will inevitably happen, whatever may be the result of the war. American Review
  20. BRYCE ASKS AMERICA TO SUCCOR ARMENIANS JANUARY 26, 1916 Special Cable to THE NEW YORK TIMES. LONDON, Jan 25.--Viscount Bryce called upon Ambassador Page today to urge America to interpose in aid of the Armenians who, driven out of their homes by the Turks, sought refuge in the wilds of Syria. Lord Bryce told Mr. Page that the predicament of the Armenians was becoming even worse than when the Turks started the slaughter, and said that the need of help was imperative. He informed the Ambassador that he had called as the representative of Armenians but were unable to do anything. Unless America was able to afford aid, he said, the Armenians eventually would starve to death on the barren plains of Syria. Lord Bryce urged Mr. Page to acquaint the American Government with the facts so that speedy relief might be afforded. Mr. Page assured Lord Bryce that he would at once inform Washington. New York Times
  21. SUBMARINES AND ARMENIA JANUARY 26, 1916 To the Editor of the New York Times: There is method in Turko-Teunic madness if Turkey admits the responsibility for the sinking of the Persia. It is a well-known fact that at the beginning of the world war Turkey did not possess any submarines worth the name. She may have later constracteristic Turkish slothfulness would render it well night impossible. Let us grant, however, that Turkey has since constructed some submarines. But where could she procure the crews to man them? It has often been asserted that it is easier to construct submarines than to train officers for them. German submarine officers might be Turkofied by wearing red fezzes of their heads, or bearing on their arms red bands with the inscription, "Mohammed is the prophet of God," yet they would not cease to be Germans. If the United States is deceived by this latest Teutonic trick, Germany will accomplish two things: first, she will be in position to continue her barbarous submarine warfare in the Mediterranean under the Turkish flag, as she will undoubtedly advise Turkey not to accede to any American demands for reparation; and secondly, by a severance of diplomatic relations between the United states and Turkey, which may result from the Persia dispute, the despicable German plan for exterminating the Armenians will be consummated. That the German Government has been the instigator of the worse-than-massacre deportation of the Armenians has often been intimated, even by Turkish officials and priests. And taking into consideration the German control of the Turkish Government in Constantinople, it is obvious that the Kaiser could have instantly terminated those Turkish atrocities had he so desired. M. Victor Bernard, the eminent French publicist, whose impassioned appeal to President Wilson in behalf of the Armenians will be published in The New Armenian not only directly accuses the German Government but reveals also its motive, saying: So long as the influence of liberal powers was paramount in Constantinople, the Turkish Government viewed in a friendly spirit the educational endeavors of the American and French missionaries, and acknowledged that their work promoted the growth of wealth throughout the entire Ottoman Empire. And the Sublime Porte wants to declare with pleasure that the Armenian pupils, were the Millet-l-Sadik, (faithful nation,) to whom the Sultan entrusted the highest and most important posts of his civil administration. But when German influence came to predominate over the Sultans and their camarilla, the Armenians were persecuted tortured, and massacred by the hundred thousands. After the massacred by the hundred thousands. After the massacres of 1896 and 1909, perpetrated by the order of Abdul Hamid, the Yong Turks undertook to extirpate systematically the Armenian nation, and the work of extirpation is being executed in those provinces where one day the Baghdad Railway is expected to transport the German colonies. Accordingly, if the Armenians are not extirpated the prospects of German colonization in the fertile Armenian provinces will become nil. Thus far the only obstacle that has prevented the consummation of the Kaiser's plan for the total destruction of the Armenians has been the American financial assistance rendered the persecuted Armenians through the United States Ambassador Consular agents, and the American missionaries. Should America be caught in the Teutonic snare by regarding Turkey as responsible for the Persia slaughter and should the next step be the severance of diplomatic relations between the United States and Turkey, the hope of saving the remnants of the noble Armenian race will vanish, and there will be assured for the Germans "a place in the sun" on the graves of a martyred nation ARSHAG MAHDESIAN. New York, Jan 24, 1916 New York Times
  22. SAVED BY AMERICAN CONSUL JANUARY18, 1916 GENEVA, Jan 17, (via London.).-- Thirty Armenian refugees, some of them formerly wealthy, have arrived here by way of Egypt and Italy, and others are to follow them. The Armenians say that it was solely??? owing to the energetic action of the American Consul at Aleppo, who adopted a strong attitude with the Turkish military authorities, that thousands of Armenian lives at Aleppo and in the surrounding regions were saved. They assert that the German Consul, Herr Roesseler, took no action to stay the Turks. One of the Armenians, a man eighty years of age, said: "America saved us from death, but there are many thousands in our country who are waiting to be saved from slavery. Only America can help us. Thousands of Armenians have crosses the frontier into Russia, but the Armenian national has virtually been annihilated by the Turks." New York Times
  23. 500 ARMENIANS SLAIN UNDER TURKISH ORDER JANUARY 15, 1916 LONDON,Jan.14.--Armenian refugees arrived at Erivan, Russian Trascaucasia, state that 500 Sasun Armenians who were forced by cold and famine to surrender to the Turks under the Government amnesty, were killed by order of the Governor of Mush. The men were massacred and the women and children drowned in the Euphrates River. This news was telegraphed to Viscount Bryce by an Armenian refugee worker. Commenting on the telegram to Viscount Bryce from the frontier of Russian Transcaucasia and Asiatic Turkey, the Armenian Refugees Committee in London says: "This seems to indicate the final destruction of the unfortunate Armenian peasantry who fled to the mountains to escape massacre. They were the most manly part of the Armenian nation, leading a quiet life in the remote valleys of the Euphrates." New York Times
  24. Turkey's Past and Future JANUARY 3, 1916 To the Editor of The New York Times: In the columns of your last Sunday's issue I read a letter by Djevad Eyoub, under the title "New Turkish Power," in which he states that just as Ertogrul, 631 years ago, with his 400 warriors helped the weaker of the two fighting armies and came out victorious, thus causing the rise of the military power of the house of Osman, so a descendant of the same house (Enver *****) views this gigantic conflict and decides to throw his lot with what seems the weaker (Tsutonic) side, and this is going to mean not only rise in military power to Turkey, but in Kulture also history repeated itself. In 1803 a general massacre of the Armenians by the famous descendants of Ertogrul, whom Djevad Eyoub calls the defender of the weak and helpless, sent 250,000 weak and helpless men, women, and children to their graves. Again, in 1908, a carefully planned massacre wiped out in the State of Adana 30,000 weak and helpless Armenians. History repeats itself. And even in 1915 which according to Djevad Eyoub, dates the rise of Turkey in power and Kultur, 950,000 Armenians met their deaths either by massacre or by starvation in the desert. Is it possible that a nation can rise in power again when that power was secured with the sword alone? As for her army, Turkey has to thank the Kaiser for it German coin, German brains, German guns and the German submarines are working behind the Turkish forces. Removed all these Germanic factors and the Turkish Army is no more. S. S. KAISH. Syracuse University, Dec. 30, 1915 New York Times
  25. BULGARS AND ARMENIANS December 23, 1915 To the Editor of the New York Times A telegram from London, dated Dec.21, which appeared in the columns of The Times and of some other papers, purports to give the contents of a dispatch to The London Times to the effect that "all Armenians in Adrianople have either been massacred or deported by the Bulgarians, 1600 men being deported to Asia Minor," and that "many were placed on fishing vessels bound for Asia Minor." Unless we suppose that in the transmission of the above dispatch the word "Bulgarians was by mistake substituted for "Turks," the whole story is sheer nonsense. In the first place, Adrianople is not in Bulgaria or under Bulgarian rule. In the second place, the deported could not have been sent to Asia Minor " on sailing vessels," because Adrianople is an inland town at least 150 miles from the sea, and all the intermediate territory between is and the sea is under Turkish rule. But the strangest part of the dispatch is that the first half of it asserts is contradicted by the second half, namely, that a memorial had been presented (by Armenians, of course,) to the Bulgarian Government "invoking interference in behalf of the persecuted Armenians" and giving "a frightful picture of their sufferings in Asia Minor at the hands of the Turkish authorities." Every sensible man will see that the Armenians could not very well ask the Bulgarian Government to interfere against its own doings or its own authorities. The whole dispatch is evidently an intentional or unintentional muddle. The truth of the matter is that of all the peoples in the Near East the Armenians and the Bulgarians have invariably maintained most kindly and friendly relations with each other. At the time of the massacres in 1896, when Greece and Rumania refused them any asylum, thousands of Armenians fled for refuge to Bulgaria, where they were kindly received and treated. A large number of them have permanently established themselves in the country, and during the Balkan wars many of them fought in the Bulgarian ranks. During the recent persecutions, also, hundreds of Armenians who succeeded in making their escape from Constantinople or other places found safety in Bulgaria. A memorial presented by an Armenian deputation, last August, to the Bulgarian Prime Minister, begging for Bulgaria's interference in the behalf of the Armenians, was officially forwarded to the Turkish Government , while the Bulgarian press unanimously look up their defense and urged upon Turkey their better treatment. A BULGARIAN New York, Dec.22, 1915 New York Times
×
×
  • Create New...