Vigil
Banned-
Posts
664 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Vigil
-
Why would you bring this up? Did I ever say it was similar? I only mentioned how insignificant human life is nowadays, when it actually is not. If Kosovo actually was important to the American people than the Armenian Genocide would have already been recognized in the United States, instead a double standard has been put into place, which we all know exists. Well, yes, you might be able to "understand", but you can also "understand" the Turkish stance. The question is what are you going to do about? The United States and United Kingdom are supposidly the "world leaders", but they sure as hell do not act like it. If the U.S. or U.K. wanted to deny the unquestionably obvious evidence of the genocide than the dynamics of recorded history also change. What I mean by that is that if it lied in the past for the sake of "public relations" than it is quite possible that you may have not stoped there, right? So for these "world leaders" to place their wallet over their crediblity is a very crucial decision and for citizens of these nation to allow it means that they also lose credibility on the world stage. This underlying fact can be said about the Jewish community and organizations, who preach about how important it is to not forgot the holocaust, but yet remain silent when other autroticies are denied. This action has lead, Armenians like me, to see them as nothing more as hypocrits and their remembrance of the holocaust as nothing more as a cheap attempt to attain more funds. Understanding and actually trying to do somthing about it is two different things. You may "understand" the genocide, but its blantantly obvious that your countrymen do not give a $hit because if did they would be standing next to Armenians instead of just ignoring them. Listen, when 120 respected genocide/holocaust schalars sign a letter confirming the act as a centrelized order to exterminate I think that is enough to actually record history as it was. Instead your government and many others have regressed it to a political movement and the fuel of any political movement is propaganda. I think what your problem is that you are mixing the political movement with the actually schalarly research, which you can not use in the same context. The previous is trying to get the public awarness of the genocide out there, while the latter is thoroughly researched schalarly fact, which anyone can go read about if they are truly interested. Yes, you are right the government is somewhat corrupt, but the people are not and for you to compare the people, who actually represent the country, to the government is inconsistent. An example of how cultured Armenians are is the fact that they would rather protest the corruption peacefully instead of packing bullets and revolting, which in many parts of the world is not the case. What should Armenians learn, when in fact it is the Turkish government that need to learn a few things from their past. So for you to place Armenians as the aggressors, when in fact they are the victims, shows me that you are just another spiteful Turk that has not learned anything from the past. Last time I checked it was the perpretrator of the crime that has some growing up to do not the victim or is it diffferent in the U.K.? Again you are comparing two parts of the world that can not be compared with another. Armenia has only been a independent state for only 10 years and so far it is signficantly more democratic than its neighbors. However, what is tragic in this case is how countries, like Azerbaijan, are rewarded for corruption instead of punished just so the "western world" can get a few cents discount on its energy imports. What can you expect from the British or Americans when they basically conducted a genocide themselves. This is why they remain so silent because when ever they mention how important it is to accept the Armenian genocide, Turkey just states that "well you did it to", so, by Turkish logic 2 wrongs make a right. The Irish and Scotts are still waiting for recognition also, so maybe instead of commenting on how uncivilized the Armenains are in the way they present the subject matter, instead, try and convince your government in accepting its past and other countries as well.
-
Why even degress so far? Try to find any mention of it in the "one world" or "human race" preaching media.
-
Armenian Quarter In Jerusalem
Vigil replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
Is Turkey's relationship with Israel a "brotherly" one or could it just be described as blackmail? It seems to me that if Israel does not grow some balls it may end up being Turkey's bitch for a long time, but again that is just some observational facts. -
Armenian Quarter In Jerusalem
Vigil replied to Teutonic Knight's topic in † Armenian Apostolic Church
The Jerusalem Post Thursday, June 15 2000 A tragedy offstage no more By Leora Eren Frucht (May 11) - The decision by Education Minister Yossi Sarid to include the Armenian genocide in the national curriculum is a significant step toward counteracting Israelis' often deliberate ignorance of the atrocity, writes Leora Eren Frucht. When Hitler ordered his death units to "exterminate without mercy or pity men, women, and children belonging to the Polish-speaking race," he was confident that the world would overlook the mass murder. "After all," he asked rhetorically on the eve of the 1939 invasion of Poland, "who remembers the extermination of the Armenians?" For a moment last month it seemed as though Israel was determined to answer that question with a resounding: "We do." At a ceremony in the Armenian Quarter of Jerusalem's Old City, Education Minister Yossi Sarid bemoaned the fact that Israeli students know next to nothing about the 1915-1916 genocide - in which some 1.5 million Armenians, one-third of the Armenian people, were killed by Turks - and declared his intention to change this. "I will do everything so that Israeli pupils will study and learn about the Armenian genocide," he declared at the April 24 memorial, where he announced plans to introduce a chapter on genocide into the national history curriculum which would include references to the Armenian genocide. He also promised to try to acquaint Israeli youth with Prague-born Jewish writer Franz Werfel's The 40 Days of Moussa Dag, the 1933 novel whose graphic depiction of the Armenian plight "shaped a generation in Israel," noted Sarid, but is unfamiliar to most students today. THE SPEECH and plan marked a sharp departure from the traditional Israeli attitude toward the Armenian genocide, which has for years been downplayed and, some say, even denied by Israel, mainly because of vociferous objections by Turkey. Ankara maintains that there was no genocide - a claim leading scholars have dismissed as part of an extensive campaign of denial. "Outrageous," is how Prof. Deborah Lipstadt described the Turkish position. Lipstadt, the American historian who defeated Holocaust denier David Irving in a highly-publicized libel trial in a London court last month, said in an interview last year with The Jerusalem Post: "The Turks have managed to structure this debate so that people question whether this really happened." She was one of 150 scholars and writers who signed a Washington Post ad last year decrying the Turkish denial of the Armenian genocide. Another signatory was Prof. Yehuda Bauer, academic director of Yad Vashem and a leading authority on the Holocaust. "If you accept the UN 1948 definition of genocide - which we and many other nations have done - then there can be no argument [about calling this a genocide]," Bauer told the Post. But in Israel, the Turkish position - that there was no genocide - has prevailed for years, with the Foreign Ministry playing an active part in suppressing any mention of that dark chapter in Ottoman history. Anxious to maintain close ties with Ankara, the ministry has tried - and frequently succeeded - in canceling academic conferences, educational programs, and even TV shows mentioning the Armenian genocide. OVER THE years, the Israel Broadcasting Authority (IBA) has repeatedly canceled scheduled screenings of programs dealing with the subject - including a British documentary, Passage to Ararat, and a seemingly innocuous film on the Armenians living in Jerusalem's Old City. Years after one such incident, Yosef (Tommy) Lapid, now Shinui party leader and MK, admitted that as IBA director-general he had canceled a documentary on the Armenians under pressure from then-Foreign Ministry director-general David Kimche, who warned him that angering Ankara could harm efforts to help Syrian Jews escape via Turkey. Prof. Israel Charny, founder and executive director of the Jerusalem-based Institute on Holocaust and Genocide, said that in 1982 he resisted Foreign Ministry pressure to cancel what was to be the first Conference on the Holocaust and Genocide, and was to include a session devoted to the Armenian case. More than half the scheduled participants withdrew, among them Nobel laureate Elie Wiesel, who was to have been president of the conference. (Wiesel rejected a Foreign Ministry demand to cancel the Armenian session, but withdrew from the conference when Charny turned down a ministry request to move the venue from Jerusalem to Europe, a compromise Wiesel supported.) Bauer said he never experienced pressure but was "advised" by the Foreign Ministry to keep the Armenian issue out of the public eye - advice which left him feeling "uncomfortable." In 1989, the Israeli Embassy in Washington actively lobbied to block a US congressional measure to commemorate the Armenian genocide. In that instance, the Foreign Ministry chided embassy officials for their excessive involvement in an issue that embarrassed Jerusalem. ISRAEL'S official, though unspoken, policy on Armenia has also kept government representatives away from the Armenians' commemoration of the genocide, held every April 24 - the day in 1915 on which 300 Armenian leaders were rounded up, deported, and killed in Turkey, setting off the beginning of an 18-month campaign of deportation and mass murder. With the exception of former absorption minister Yair Tzaban, who attended the ceremony in 1995, Sarid is the only minister to participate in the memorial. Not surprisingly, Sarid's speech prompted an outcry in Turkey that included a protest to Israel's charg* d'affaires in Ankara. In response, a Foreign Ministry source was quoted as saying "it's a pity that Sarid made a decision on such as sensitive topic without consulting us first and without raising the subject in any government forum." The pragmatic reasons for Israel's position are clear. Turkey is one of Israel's most important and strategically positioned allies in the region, a Moslem ally with which Israel has growing military ties. When France adopted a bill in 1998 recognizing the Armenian genocide, Turkey promptly suspended the signing of a $145 million defense contract. BUT realpolitik has its price. In siding with Turkey, Israel has placed itself in the uncomfortable - and bitterly ironic - position of colluding with a denier of genocide. "There has been a tendency here to ignore the subject [of the Armenian genocide]," said Bauer. "And on the part of some Israelis there is even support for denial," added the Holocaust expert, who praised Sarid's decision. "Israel's attitude has very definitely constituted denial," asserted Charny. The Lipstadt-Irving trial showed the world that denial of genocide can be done in sophisticated and indirect ways, added Charny, citing similarities between Irving's claims and the type of arguments made by deniers of the Armenian genocide. "In the wake of that trial, it becomes much more difficult to engage in double-talk about the Armenian genocide - the kind of double-talk we Israelis have been guilty of. We are left with a choice: Are we going to allow people to distort a genocide the way Irving does?" THERE IS another reason why Israelis have preferred not to confront the Armenian genocide, one that has nothing to do with Turkey. Few will say it aloud, but many fear that acknowledging the Armenian genocide will call into question the uniqueness of the Holocaust and somehow diminish its weight. "For years it was a sin to mention genocide of other people," said Charny. "If you did, you were viewed as disloyal and a traitor to the Jewish people. This attitude of 'we're not gonna talk about the goyim's suffering' is a sad phase of immaturity and a betrayal of our ethics." "As Jews and as human beings we should care very deeply about other people who were victims of genocide. And we should realize that doing so does not diminish the enormity of the Holocaust," said Charny, who edited the recently published Encyclopedia of Genocide. In response to Sarid's decision, Yad Vashem, the Holocaust Martyrs' and Heroes Remembrance Authority, issued a press release saying it "supports the teaching of the subject of the Armenian genocide in schools and does not think that this will harm the study of the Holocaust, and that, if anything, the opposite is probably true." "The way to establish the uniqueness of the Holocaust is by comparison," explained Bauer of Yad Vashem. "The Holocaust was unprecedented. In order to establish that there was no precedent, you've got to compare it with other genocides. So I am very much in favor of teaching the Armenian genocide." In fact, without putting the Holocaust into perspective, words like "unique" and "unprecedented" are fast becoming empty slogans for many Israeli students, said one educator who is deeply involved in the subject. THE HANDFUL of educators who have exposed their students to the Armenian genocide - which is not part of the school curriculum - have seen surprising results. Since 1995, Orit Shimoni, a teacher at Ramot Hefer High School in the Sharon region, has taught the subject to her 11th-grade history students. Interestingly, she said, the students emerged with a much deeper awareness of the Holocaust. "They told me that learning about the Armenian genocide had shown them how easy it is to simply forget and ultimately deny a genocide. They were shocked and shaken by this," said Shimoni. "They felt it was more important than ever to read and talk about the Holocaust constantly in order to ensure that it is never forgotten." The study module used by Shimoni was developed by Dr. Yair Auron of the Seminar Hakibbutzim State Teachers' College and was initially slated for use in a country-wide pilot program for 11th-grade history students. Called "Sensitivity to the Suffering of the World: Genocide in the 20th Century," the program was written by Auron in 1994, following a decision by then education minister Amnon Rubinstein to introduce the study of the Armenian genocide into the school curriculum. The program - separate from the study of the Holocaust - was to have looked at genocide in general, focusing mainly but not exclusively on the Armenian and Gypsy examples. But Auron's study program was rejected by an Education Ministry committee which called it unbalanced. Proponents of the program suspect that Turkish pressure may have been the real reason for its rejection - a charge denied by the Education Ministry. WHATEVER the reason, the result is not open to debate. Rubinstein's decision was not implemented and, with the exception of a few classrooms in the country like Shimoni's, the vast majority of Israeli high-school students do not study the subject of genocide - with the obvious exception of the Holocaust - from a broad perspective. Auron, whose book on the Armenian genocide, The Banality of Indifference, was published in the US last month, applauded Sarid's decision to teach the topic. He said that surveys he has conducted on college and university students show that some 85 percent know very little or nothing about the Armenian genocide, a fact Sarid referred to in his speech last month. It's not clear whether Auron's original program on genocide is to be revived. "I don't care whether it's my program that is used or another one - as long as the subject is taught," said the historian, who now teaches a similar course to college students at Seminar Hakibbutzim and is developing one for Tel Aviv's Open University. If the Armenian genocide is taught, as Sarid promised, it will be as part of an elective course on genocide, probably one of some 20 or so topics that high-school students specializing in history can choose from. That's not quite a revolution, but it's still a sharp policy change for Israel - and a first step in breaking a national taboo. But if, as appears increasingly likely, Sarid carries out his threat to resign over the transfer of funds to Shas's educational system, then for most Israeli students, the Armenian genocide will most likely revert to the dustbin of forgotten history. -
I have nothing against anyone on this forum even TB, but when people state some things that are insulting and inaccurate I call it how it is. I am sorry if this "offends" you, but I have learned the only thing you leave the world with is your dignity and because of that I can not allow false accusation to discredit my good nature. But yes, if I did argue for the sake of argument I would agree with you and would not FEEL LESS OF MAN by stating that I am sorry, but that is not the case here. I have also never attacked TB personally and who knows maybe if I meet him in real life we would have a more pleasent debate.
-
So are you saying than that I would still be considered a citizen of the United States if I were not to follow the RULES and REGULATIONS implemented by it's governing body? God has no reason to accept the unfaithful, while the same can not be said of the devil. The devil just wants to increase his armies man power in order to invade heaven. This is the underlying motive behind Satan, so by stating that God does not have a way to measure "goodness" is actually inaccurate because he has to in order to pick and choose the most deserving inhariters of paradise. But again I am agnostic (I have no faith, but believe in somthing beyond my existence), so what do I know? Anyways this is drifting away from the subject matter so if you would like to split go ahead.
-
First of all I would like to add that I am not TAP, however, I strongly agree with his views, which in my opinion has a lot more relavence to the subject matter than what you have written. For somone like you to state that the debate has failed is really hypocritical when in fact it is blatently obvious your side has actually failed in proving what you are out to prove, which incidently is the whole reason to debate is it not? So by stating that TAP has failed, when in fact he has written pages upon pages of relavent subject matter and has gone as far as countering any point you have made goes to show that you are wrong. Stop with the "holier than thou" bull$hit and actually write somthing that has some substance. Its like me telling you your wrong, but never saying why? If your argument is so "strong" put your money where your mouth is and begin writing other than that I think the above statement just means that you have nothing to reply with. At least you can admit you are wrong, but stating that "yeah, I am right" without any reasons as to why you are right just proves to me that you are the intellectual failure. I call bull$hit again! Is it me or does this not sound hypocritical? Just scroll back to your previous posts and read what you have written. You will notice that no one other than you and your side has actually been the ones that have made no attempt to muster "good-faith" or "effort". Like I have said maybe "one liners" can be considered a "rebutal" to someone of your "intellegence", but to me it is just trash. I find this again very hypocritical due to obvious reasons stated above, but again I will truly be patient and put you on the spot by asking how is it "simple-minded"? I can tell you that the world is flat, but wouldn't I have to prove it? I would also like to add that at this point you are again resorting to personal attacks instead of actually writing somthing that will place your argument above the rest. I think TAP already addressed the issue of trying to use personal life information to state that your word is more valued than mine. So by your logic if I were to state that I have a Ph.D. from Harvard than my argument is automatically more accurate than yours? How do you know how old I am in real life? I could be 75 years old could I not and if I was would'nt that mean by your standards I would know twice as much as you because I would be twice as old as you, right? Wrong! Your again trying to bring assumptions about a person's personal life into a debate, which as much as you state you know about fail to realize that to prove the opposite debaters argument wrong is the underlying essence of a debate. Any "educated" person such as yourself should have learned this in your introductory writing course, but again on these boards everyone thinks they are "intellectuals", when in fact can not grasp the concept of it. Oh Gurgen by the way I have never "dissed" anyone on these forums and people that know me on these boards will tell you the same. What ever I haved posted has never had any personal co-notation attached with it so do not bring me down to their level.
-
If there was a God the answer to your question would be definitly be no because God does not need to trick people in order for his agenda to move forward. Nevetheless, God does have the ruthless working for him like Micheal his archangel, who even though is a angel still conducts immoral acts for the greater good of God. In fact he replaced Gabriel because maybe God saw in him a more ruthless individual, which goes to show that even evil can be used as a weapon of God. However, the devil has much to gain if people were to all of sudden think he did not exist because they would have no reason to fear any sort of retribution for their sins due to the underlying fact that they would be tricked into thinking hell did not exist. So you see somtimes what you think is obviously a good thing actually is a bad and somtimes a bad thing is actually good. It just takes a good observer to understand which of the two sides it falls under because nothing is truly bad and nothing is truly good, but rather a bit of both. Lets hope it is, but I know only a few people that actually understand the significance of it. Most people are pretty occupied by other things to actually give a $hit anymore. I mean when is the last time anyone besides a Armenian actually talked about Rawanda or Kosovo? Kosovo was what like not more than 5 years ago? Most Armenians feel alienated talking about it when they should not be, which is due to the way American Government and meida alienates them by constantly placing 2 sides. What I mean by that is that it is very difficult to make "otars" understand how important this event is not just for Armenians, but the rest of the world when the sources that they presume are "reliable" flat out lie to them like the New York Times, Los Angeles TImes and etc... Isn't it tragic that our generation had to bare witness to 2 genocides within the last what 10 to 15 years? I mean how many more people must die for "otars" to understand that eventually they to can be potential victims if the issue if it is not addressed and solved. With that being said... MAKE NO MISTAKE EVERY ETHNICITY, NATIONALITY, AND RACE ARE POTENTIAL TARGETS OF GENOCIDE AT ONE POINT OR ANOTHER IN THE FUTURE AND IT IS OUR DUTY AS THE NEXT GENERATION TO PREVENT THAT FROM HAPPENING AGAIN BY ADDRESSING A SOLUTION AND MAKING IT KNOWN THAT NO ONE CAN GET AWAY WITH IT. BUT again this has no relavence nowadays. People are so desentized and brainwashed that any approach to bridge the communication gap is meet with the underlying notion that the person addressing any issue is a radical thinker instead of critcal one. So basically any time you go up to people and talk to them about anything besides what the next episode of "Friends" you are meet with hostility or labeled a "terrorist". Its funny and at the same time scary how 300 years ago you could label the actions of the American forefathers as terrorist acts by contemporary standards, which is why the lines that seperate a rebel from a terrorist should never be erased. They are similar to one another in that both are forced to take matters into their own hands, but equally are different in the manner of which they take action. The power to rebel or STAND UP FOR WHAT YOU BELIEVE IN should not be mistaken as terrorism. I think this attempt by the NYTimes should be looked at very carfully because for them to this all of sudden make drastic changes after so many years of publishing bogous articles against Armenians that constantly slander us means that the agenda of the "higher ups" are shifting towards pro Armenians, but again I may be reading too much into it.
-
The phrase "I rest my case" -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Posted by ?????? on January 30, 2003 at 12:22:36: In Reply to: The phrase "I rest my case" posted by ??????? on January 30, 2003 at 12:04:33: : I think I have used the phrase "I rest my case" quite erronously. I tried to look it up in the phrase thesaurus, but could not find it. Does anyone know its origin and correct use? : ?????? It's of legal origin, with "case" meaning argument or claim - as in the case against legalising soft drugs, for example. To this day in British courtrooms (and probably elsewhere in the English-speaking world), when the Prosecution (or the Defence) has finished calling all its witnesses and introducing into evidence all the items that it feels beneficial, its lawyer will tell the court that "the Prosecution rests". Of course the right of cross-examination of any witnesses introduced by the other side still remains. To say "I rest my case" means therefore that, as far as you are concerned, you've done more than enough to prove your point, and need say no more. It's often used in an ironic manner, to highlight when someone inadvertently says something that supports the claim you are making, as in the follwing example:- John: "You know your problem, Bill? You're far too quick to descend to insulting people who disagree with you." Bill: "Don't be ridiculous! That's the sort of thing only a complete idiot would say." John: "I rest my case..."
-
In my OPINION it would be an insult to Armenians that currently RESIDE in Armenia if citizenship was made accessible to the Diaspora without any restrictions. Citizenship standards should remain high for the Diaspora due to the fact that they do not make an effort to eventually relocate to Armenia so granting them citizenship would not solve the problem. In the case of "otars" they should not yet be granted citizenship and only be given work privileges. Nevertheless, this could change if there was a major migration of "otars" to Armenia. In this case the dynamics of the situation are different, but than citizenship should be only granted to these groups only if they are willing to lobby to be recognized as citizens of Armenia because it would be really premature for Armenia to grant such privileges when our borders are not yet secure. What I mean by that is that citizenship is a crucial factor at this point due to fact that there is a rising Kurdish population and 70 million strong Turkish nation next door that might I remind you people has not had a good relations with Armenia for some time now. What do you think would happen when Armenia becomes the economic leader of that region? Do you think Turks would not be willing to move to Armenia to find jobs? What would happen if Turks out number Armenians? Just in Germany there are already millions of Turks that incidently breed like rabbits. I would like to add that before some of you go ahead and state "well the United States is open minded" I would like to point out that the United States has been in existence for only 300 years, which is not a sufficient amount of time to see if the concept of democracy and equal rights will actually remain. Also the U.S. does not share borders with nations that still have ambitions of touching two coasts. Keep in mind that the population of the U.S. is not comprised of the indigenous population that use to live on this continent prior to it becoming an English colony. Again it would be very premature to compare the U.S. to Armenia or to any nation that has a purely homogenous identity. However, TAP's suggestion of “Cumulative Visit Time Accumulation” (CVTA) would be a great solution to the problem. It would allow the part of the Diaspora that actually give a rats a$$ about Armenia to prove that they are willing to take steps towards its sovereignty and salvation as a nation. I have said it before if you are one of those individuals that are not willing to die for any belief or commonality than you do not deserve the privilege of associating with that particular group or any for that matter. Before some you state that "I am not willing to die for any country" I would like to point that this concept does not apply to just being involved in the defense of nation, but rather the survival of one. Any amount of time set aside for the well being of Armenia should account towards achieving citizenship, however, only if you are at least 1/2, not 1/4, 1/8, or 1/16, but at least 1/2 Armenian. I would like to point out that a good example of this model is Proud EXPAT and I am sure he would feel really insulted if citizenship was reduced to owning just a peice of paper because clearly it means more than that. Excuse the grammer and etc.
-
We mourn the dead, collect restitutions, and try to put the past behind us. ANC is the second biggest lobby in America, with that much influence I think we can accomplish more goals together after the genocide denialists are converted to the light. The only reason this cruel joke has gone on for so long is not because of us, but rather due to Turkish fears of giving back what they stole from us. By the what is so wrong with having the Genocide ingrained into our identity? The Jewish community remembers the holocaust like the Chinese remember the rape of Nanking, and like them the Armenians have to remember the events of 1915 because it is part of the mosaic that comes together to form our identity today. Again the power of the individual prevails...
-
How is this a battle a pessimist vs. optimists one? TAP has clearly demonstrated a clear cut solution, which I strongly agree with and have stated numerous times, as to why our youth are not interacting with one another which is leading more and more hye females or males to embrace otars more often than their own kind. This in time will lead us to lose our identity, motherland, and everything else that any race, ethnicity, and nationality has a claim to. I just do not buy your pessimistic views due to the fact that I face them everyday as I struggle to earn my diploma. Everday I encounter pessimists like yourself, who all they do is just bring everyone else's morale down. Maybe if I were to elaborate...I am a accounting major and attend one of the top 3 accounting programs in the nation if not the best. The drop rate for a accounting major at my school is estimated roughly at 75%. Knowing this, by your logic, because the drop rate is so high I should just say "screw it let me drop out now" because it's inevitable just so I can "face reality"? Your argument is just bull$hit by my standards because everyday that I attend school I am disproving you by going against the odds. Everyday your argument weakens because at this point I am an INDIVIDUAL and I am CHANGING the world around me. Actually I think everything that you have stated can be thrown out the window at this point, and you can keep your bad kharma to yourself because Armenians sure as hell do not need it. Now as to who was the one who brought the whole pessimists vs. optimists debate...weren't you the one who intially stated the first pessimistic ideology, or as TAP referred to in a more accurate manner, sloth like ideology? Yes, you were. You're basically stating that anything we do to overcome this roadblock is useless? You're wrong. If its so useless than how come you're here as TAP stated "if its all going to shit anyways"? I think at this point you people are arguing for the sake of arguing just to save face and it is time to stop because your whole argument offers no solution or anything else for that matter. TAP has provided more than enough reasons and I sincerly believe any man or woman who writes with so much passion, charisma, observational logic, and common sense deserves our recognition instead of persecution, especially from someone that thinks that no matter what we do as Armenian youth we're doomed. Please tell me you're not serious? Basically TAP has countered every point you have made up until now and this is the best thing you can come with? How did the debate fail because we all sure as hell know that TAP did not regress this progressive debate into another failed attempt like you so eloquently stated, you're in denial, because TAP schooled you in every one of his posts. THANK GOD there are people like TAP that are willing to take charge and as he stated before in a more different manner if it was up to Armenians like yourselves we would have already gone extinct a long time ago. Quit using logical fallicies and at least offer some substance instead of "one liners" because "one liners" sure as hell will never counter pages worth of logical debate and observational facts. TAP has never placed himself above us and instead has taken his own time to offer solutions unlike some people on these boards who roar like lions, but when push comes to shove to take action or responsiblity, they purr like kittens. Yes, he does write extremely well and that may be the only thing you and I see eye to eye on. What TAP and many others have stated is not a ideal, but rather what you say is the actually "idealism" in this thread. TAP is right, we do not live in a utopia so why continue living in a illusion of paradise? If everyone is out to take what you have why let it continue? This is the same reason why 1.5 million have died and yet these same people who preach "one world" and "one human race" are the same who deny the very obvious perpretation of the crime. That is exactly one of the things TAP has been saying all along, maybe if you read what has written more carfully instead of trying to argue for arguments sake or to save face, you would known this already. You basically have just rewritten what TAP has been saying all this time about preserving Armenianism in diasporians than using their resources, experience, and spirit to strengthen Armenia. You do not want to admit you're wrong in what you have written previously so you just jumped over to the other side of the fence by rewritting what TAP has been saying all along. Both of you were all about inevitability, but now you're changing your tune. Besides that you do not want to offer a solution to diasporan problems beyond simply just saying "we're screwed". Basically you two, who are the most negative sloth like Armenians I have ever encountered, actually have the nerve to come now and state that "we need to preserve Armenia or else" after TAP has already said that in order to make Armenia stronger wer need to make efforts towards the preservation of the Diaspora. I cleary see a contridiction and hypocrisy in how both of you all of a sudden have changed your stances, but again I am not going to antagonize you two because I believe in what TAP has written and antagonizing any Armenian, even those that disagree with me is wrong because it only creates further seperation among Armenians. Oh by the way tomorrow I was thinking of going to Barnes & Noble and buying books so that I can learn the japanese language, history, and culture. After that I am going to change my name to "Otaka" and marry a Japenese woman. I think after I do this I will truly become Japanese because we all know that we can become any race, ethnicity, or nationality overnight by reading books, learning language, and knowing historical facts, right? WRONG! Bottom line if anyone on these forums wants to do nothing and yet wants to state that we are all doomed let them follow the pessimists into the pit, so be it, but do not come here and strap a bomb to yourself to try and take others down with you simply because you do not have the courage to take the plunge by yourself. Also just a side note my stat professor (he use to teach at MIT and the government calls him in to analize scenarios for defense, eduaction, and economics) constantly tells us that most of the math behind statistics is bullshit because the SAMPLE NEVER FULLY REPRESENTS THE POPULATION 100% of the time outside of the lab model, due to the fact that there is always that lovely margin of error that can never be corrected for when real world variables are brought in. This is the same reason why the experts that are getting paid six figures because they have degrees from Harvard, Stanford, and any other top school, are eating $hit right now due to the fact that they have to explain to the Bush Administration and to the American people as to why the progress in Iraq is not going as planned. Anyways, anything after this stated by the sloth like individuals that is going to only be a waste of time I am not going to reply to. So if you are going to say that "you obviously can not see the reality of the situation" I am going to have to call bull$hit beforehand because like I have said before your argument holds no weight and clearly your credibility as a debater has already diminished because you personally like to attack people when you have no valid counter points, and its obvious that you had very few counter points to what TAP had written. I am looking forward to read more about TAP's ideas, your's are just too hollow, hopeless, and culturally degenerative for my taste.
-
I think you should ask yourself this questions because I clearly understand your viewpoint and do not buy it, however, I do not go about insulting you personally simply because I do not agree with you. The same can not be said of you on these boards. And I am not going to turn this productive thread into a "flame fest". So if you think insulting others that do not agree with you helps your argument so be it.
-
TB your entire argument has lost its credibilty a while ago because all you do is personally insult people that do not agree with you. You did it to TAP, Axel, MX5, and pretty anyone else that does not agree with you, give it a rest. By the way TAP you had me at "hello"... Good stuff!
-
The only thing that relates us is the similar ideas we share on this forum.
-
IP's could resemble one another but the man behind that statement is not me and you should listen to his view was well as mine.
-
I agree with TheArmenianPirate. We need more individual thinkers like him rather then intellectuals off a assembly line and I agree with everything said by him.
-
Then explain to me what black culture is? What is your definition of black culture? In fact explain to me what black culture is not. Is there black culture in America? Do you consider Hip-Hop as part of black culture? Define the borders for me and maybe I will listen I am assuming you will finance the venture. Doesn't it make you wonder as to why we do not think about full blooded Armenains like this as opposed to half breeds? Does it not bug you? There are some full blooded Armenians that do not know anything about Armenia, but yet we are more concerned about how to satisfy the needs of the "oders" as opposed to our own kin.
-
We will discuss this age old question in a couple years from now, but judging from the sample of the population I am placing my chips on extinction. Well said, but that was never my intention and I hope he does not think that I wanted to drive him away. Anyone has a right to learn about Armenia, but we must be carful as to how far we extend the boundries that define a Armenian.
-
Look eventually one of the identities will be the more dominant one don't you agree? Either your lineage will be Armenian or African, but it can never be both. I personally am not against you, but rather am trying to keep us from going extinct. You can be open-minding and accepting, but that still does justify me marrying a black woman for the sake proving my liberalism. So by your logic if a Armenian woman were to reject a black man she is racist? Do you think what makes me a Armenian is because I can speak the language? Yes, to a certain extent language is important in defining a identity, but that is not what made me the Armenian I am today. Ok let me ask you this what culture will the child learn other than the Armenian? What idenity will the child inharit from your side of the family? Is he or she going to learn to be Carribian? African? Spanish? English? Dutch? Which one of the 5 identities are you going to emphesize? I am not jesus and that is why I do not want to get persecuted for my beleifs, which others apparently don't share. How is it text book and how have you rebuttaled my point? I live in Los Angeles in near USC, which I attend and has a strong black community around it, I know perfectly well what black culture is about. However, I agree with you that everyone has a right to love anyone they desire. It is not my life and like I said before I can not create Armenians in my own image. As much as you have a right to keep your identity I have I right to keep mine, right? If people continually jump ship what happens to Armenians? What remains? So is that suppose to make you expert? My friend has a 4 year degree from UC San Diago and teaches "engrish" in Japan. So by your logic my point would be more valued if I were to say that I am a physicist? If you must know I attend one of the best Accounting programs in the nation and if not the world. Yes, exactly you have proven my point. At the very end your line becomes black, which is nothing bad, but it signals the death of what ever was Armenian. Sev-Mard its not a personal attack towards you or African-Americans. I have many African-American friends and enjoy there company. Again your logic amazes me. So if I want to continue being Armenian and do not want to ethnically soujourn I am missing out on life? How many Armenians are there in the world? About 6 million? How many Africans? like a few hundred million, right? The only reason I am so hard on them is because I do not want us to go extinct, which tragically is happening. We are not like Jewish people and can not convert "odars". Everyday we decrease in number, while other minorities increase in number. How am I spouting rhetoric? I only ask questions that need to be answered. Yes, I am sure if I did know you we could be great friends, but unfourtunitly we have not met. When I have said it was about you? When have I said it was about Afrian-Americans? Why do you automatically assume I am trying to be a bigot? I could have targeted any other minority and it would still contain my argument. Listen, I have said it in my previous post that in any situation their is circumstances. Are Armenians going to marry "odars"? Yes, they are and historically they have, but do I want to increase? No... Why? Because at a certain point we will go extinct. My point is about survival and not racial supremacy.
-
I bet the American male you want to become also historically has thought like you. I wonder what America would become if they had citizens like you in 1776, WW1, WW2, or any of the other defining moments of this nation. Please explain to me what I have said that has offended him? I never have nor ever will insult you so I ask of you to give me the same respect. Your comments just proves my point as to how quick Armenians would sell out their own kind just to win the appeasment of "oders". Domino you have lost a strong supporter of your work, but have gained nothing in return. I presume that you think this Sev-Mard has actually read your material and understands the plight of Armenians as well as I have? You can write volumes about the history of Armenians, but if their are none to preserve it left what use is it? Like I have said you can have the black man for the Armenian. Sorry, my decision is final. I am not going to spend my time communicating with people that make comments like the ones above.
-
Moderator's note: this post was not originally the starting post of the thread. A new topic originated in the middle of another thread which was split. The quotes are from there. Yes, continue to be the idealist like many others on this forum. So are you telling me that when Turks and Azeri's invade Armenia this "African-Armenian" or Sev-Mard would actually be enough of a patriot to go and fight on behalf of his fellow Armenians? Are you also saying that he will know the history and folk stories passed down from father to son? What about the language? Culture? Traditions? You already lose the point of being part of a ethnic group when you trade the old for the new. I presume in a couple more generations when his family is forced to migrate out of America due to social unrest he will quickly betray his American roots like his ancestors betrayed the Armenian. If you are not willing to die for your beleifs than you have no right to claim them as your own. Most of the so-called "intellectuals" on this forum can roar like a lion when they degrade Armenians, but when the call of action is heard they purr like a kitten. Why do you assume I am being racist? I already stated many times that I am not being a bigot, but again you are entitiled to your own opinions. This is typical whenever race is brought up. The only rebuttal is pulling out the race card like many others have done in the past. If you agree with me then be brave enough to stand behind your words instead of hiding behind a false ideal. Beleive me their is nothing in common between us. You conceive the truth from the very groups that are trying to destroy your kind, but you are ignorant to it because you assume this is the "norm", which it is not. Like I have said you there are two individuals in America, the colonized and the colonizer, where the first is exploited to meet the needs of the later. Anyways I just wanted to address these few comments before I left, chow!
-
“It is about time that we loudly repudiate the romantic conceit that ‘My pen is my gun.’ Pens are pens and guns are guns. There are more than enough ‘intellectuals’ in the diaspora. What we need are fighters, soldiers, fedaiis.” --“A Critique of Past Notions,” The Right to Struggle, p. 194.
-
Why is it naive? Why do you assume I am trying to insult African-Americans? That is why in the recent U.S. Census almost 25% of African-Americans were in poverty? Why is then that African-Americans are one of the largest if not the largest minorities in America, but yet their has never been a black president while their is roughly about 6 million Americans of Jewish decent that have already tried to push for a Jewish president in this years democratic primary? In your opinion what is American? Do you consider your fellow Mexican or Armenian a American? What about Asians? Irish? Jews? The only American, who is a true native of this continent, is the Native American. My comment has nothing to do with race so please do not pull out the race card. I just do not want Armenians to lose their identity like African-Americans and have to be forced into accepting a fake nationalism. In America there is only the colonizer and the colonized. How am I making it complex? Africans were brought here, used, raped, and sold. Do you consider "P-Diddy", "Russel Simmons", or anyone of those hip-hop moguls part of this diaspora? I certainly do not mainly because they expliot their own kind for quick bucks. How many times do you hear the word "nigga" in their lyrics? I have never seen anyone of these so-called "gangstas" ever go back to the hood they come from and I presume it is because they are above that now? Why is the concept such a hard one to acheive? My original point was that lets not become like African-Americans because if we do it is obvious we will lose our identity outside our homeland. You do know the quote that I used above was explaining the relationship between black men and women during the height of the civil rights movement? Black men instead of embracing their own kind and moving up on the social ladder instead craved white women to point of calling the white women involved in the civil rights movement racist if they refused to have sexual intercourse with them. With that said my only point again is that I do not want the same sitution to arise in my community. As much as Armenians or the white race tries to be black today blacks historically have always tried to be white. Black men felt that it was a prize to be with a white women and white women thought black men were exotic. That is why some of lynchings in the south were conducted. White men thought that their wives were having affairs wth black men, which in most cases was true. Do I think that anyone, outside of African-Americans, that dress like a hip-hop star are silly? Yes, but I also think it is equally worse if not more tragic when these so called "gangsta rappers" make money by exploiting their fellow "brothas". I never called Africans "stupid" and perhaps you misunderstood me. Do I think that some races or ethnicities are better then others? No, ofcourse not, however, I feel that people, who come from a similar background that work together, acheive more in a group rather than individually. This is evident in the acheivements of the Armenian lobby, who is underfunded, understaffed, and is a non-profit orgnationation, but yet is the second biggest lobby in America. Listen, every nation today has its share of problems. Just recently there was a BBC article on the massive increase in the difference between the upper and lower income brackets. Armenia for being a nation comprised of 3 million and being 10 years old is fareing much better than older developing nations. You can not compare Armenias situation to any other country because it is a sensitive case. Armenia is landlocked, has no resources, and was not given its rightful share during the break up of Soviet Union. Many of the other countries would be much worse if they were in Armenians position, but yet Armenians survive because we historically have worked together and it is not until the recent 2 or 3 years that the diaspora has become a bit less invovled. The prostitution in Armenian is expected like in many other countries. In America there is prostitution is there not? Tell me one country that is whore free? About you stating that it is forced is kind of a low blow and offending because any type of prostitution is forced upon men and women due to economic conditions. So let me get this straight you think in America the pimp is around the prostitute to protect her, rather than beat her? It is a weak argument to use as a rebuttal due to the fact that historically prostitution has and always will exist. An example is the forced prostitution of Asians and Europeans captured by the Japanese during WW2. In fact the Japanese created a hierarchy in which Europeans were reserved as a prize for commanding officers, while Koreans were kept for feild soilders. Rather what is tragic is the men that exploit these women. It is one thing to be born into a lifestyle of a prostitute, but it is another thing to actually be the exploiter. An example is the present U.S. Military Bases abroad. All of these bases have a prositution network set up to service the "good old boys". Another example is Europeans that go to Bangkok or Cambodia to satisfy their sexual fetish of screwing 8 year olds. Lets not forget the good old Turkish, who abuse and sleep with Russian prostitutes more than their wives. It is men like yourself that give men like me a bad name. Women through out time have been used as psychological weapons. During any war women are raped as a symbol of domination over the enemy and prostitution is no exception. Prostitution is neither bad nor good, but rather is a tragic lifestyle that some must experience. Also for those of you who did not have the self respect to defend Armenian women from such a devestating attack due to your own insecurities and the fear that your own "reputation" would be at stake is tragic. I made it clear in my post that this was not about racial supremacy, but rather the Armenian community not becoming part of the colonized. Yes, at some point race is soically constructed, but to a certain what defines you is your outer characteristic. This is evident in the fact that you can never call a black man asian and a asian man black.
