Jump to content

Anonymouse

Members
  • Posts

    2,222
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Anonymouse

  1. So there I was at my favorite watering hole (most people throw penny's in the well, I throw in my empty cans). So there I was. And up comes this guy with his girlfriend who was visibly crying. He said "Hey! Is this the guy honey?" while pointing at me, and through her sobbing, she muttered a faint "yeah". The guy says to me, "I'm going to kick your ass" and I said "Ok, just one second." I proceeded to chug my last Mike's Hard Lemonade, I jammed my fingers down my throat, and sent out a perfect stream of projectile vomit with enough force to tear the paint off of an '82 Ford. With his eye's burning, I quickly made my escape, but not before stealing his shoes. http://cgi.ebay.com/ws/eBayISAPI.dll?ViewI...bayphotohosting Help put food on this poor old man's table. Thank you.
  2. Remember, I'm Darth Vader since I can freeze people in carbonite.
  3. http://www.candidcritic.com/images/dennismiller.jpg That's great coming from an adroit gregutlation that managed to disobey the forefollowings of a modern day Mr. Peanut. While you're adjusting the cramshanks on your Burger King crown, I'll be moseying over to the tremultious booth of tap dancing since you bore the bejesus out of me and if my yawn got any bigger they'd have to assign it a hurricane name.
  4. The answer to your problem, is to live outside the City. The City is a dehumanizing hell hole.
  5. ... First off, what I am arguing for is not a "theory" nor the "sameness" of "nations". No one said that, but then again in the haze of "discussions" and especially when peoples memories and emotions are embedded in their systems of thought ( nationalism ) I expect lots of uneasiness with this topic. The onus is not upon me to prove that nationalism is a recent phenomenon, for it is obvious it is, but rather upon scientific nationalists, for they have been the ones, whether German, French, or Armenian, that have tried to map ethnicity, linguistically, archaeologically, and historically, and they have all failed, resulting in constant conflicts, often in precipitating to genocidal ends, even the recent conflict with Azerbaijan was a result of two nation-States, nevermind that they look more similar to one another than they are to whatever "ancestors" they are said to descend from. When you accept any "ism" which is an already structured system of thought, such as nationalism, you are in essence identifying with that world view, anything to the contrary is wrong or a threat to your system of thought, that is why everyone is so passionate about their said "truths" regarding any of these discussions involving isms. Whether its Marxism,or Fascism, or Nationalism, etc., they all have already structured mechanisms. This is why for Marx "all history is a class struggle", this is why for Hitler all history is a "racial struggle". From the Enlightenment onward, we were introduced to "isms" and from then on, we take our respective ism, and project it into the past, and it is only a matter of will to place past events into an ism, and have it interpret a whole new meaning of the equation. This is why Marx found evidence for his thesis, and Hitler for his. You will find that I would disagree with this on the grounds that "national" or "nationalism" was simply non-existent until the 19th century as an ism and ideology, therefore HOW and WHY do we project ourselves into the past and create these national entities where there was none? Only when any people became a Nation-State, even Armenia, did they begin to adopt this method of historiography which uses the techniques of Indo European philology working in tandem with nationalism to give people claims to lands and ideas of the past. That Armenians began to create for themselves a nation state was only a ripple being felt by Europe, and it was European Enlightenment ideas that they adopted in order to undergo with this. Once the concept of nationalism was sealed, it was up to the thinkers, journalists and writers, and later educational institutions of the respective nation-states to create history and assign language and culture to people of the past assigning mythical claims to people of what language they spoke or what they adopted as their dress. We have little evidence to suggest what language, or better yet what languages, the "people" spoke, since writing and reading was not the forte of the common man and since they outnumbered the educated class in all societies, only a tiny minority "spoke" the language that we have in written evidence, even the Church elite. There were many kingdoms in the areas of "France" and "Germany" or "Lotharingia", not to mention the differeing Dutchies or Lords who were lives unto their own, not different from the nakharar houses. In fact you could find many kingdoms, rivals, speaking the same language, and many others, yet in constant feuds, or allying with other peoples not speaking their language. Trying to make the Armenian case an exception is wrong in my opinion, and I know stating this is going off on a limb within the Armenian community because it is in fact more nationally aware now, than it has ever been before, because of Genocide and constantly being projected into their minds of suffering, of fear and a people and this and that; it permeates into and forms peoples minds. If Europeans went through ethnogensis and changes and mixed, the Armenians did so too, considering the Caucasus is the cross roads of east and west. The Armenians having changed throughout, have also changed meaning and culture. It is not static. Thus the Armenians of the Yervantid Dynasty pale in comparison to who or what the Armenians are these days. In fact, the Armenians of today, look more alike with their Georgian, Turkish, and Azeri neighbors, than they would with the "Armenians" of Hellenistic times. By stating that, prior to nationalism, Armenians were a decentralized people living in many places, a linguistic and religious people, not a national one, for since it's obvious nationalism did not exist. Thus, on the grounds of nationalism, Armenians must hate all Turks, because the Turks tried to wipe out the Armenians. This is the eventual logical consequence of nationalism. That some Turks may have been Armenians before converting to Islam, or have intermarried, matters not. All Turks are Turks and they all descend from the Mongoloid peoples. This is the thinking that is implied by nationalism, since we all descend from this or that people, and have always been a people. As far as awareness, well obviously everyone was aware of what language they spoke, but more importantly what languages they spoke, or what religion they belonged to, or where they lived, no different than anyone today. One must also understand that historiography in the sense that we understand it now, in terms of "national history" is a recent phenomenon which works its way backwards, projecting itself into the past, and creating history. Even now we acknowledge nationalism was created in 19th century, yet try to give Armenians a national awareness prior to the Enlightenment, yet their behavior, as I suggested was anything but "national". And since language based claims to ethnicity are faulty by nature, since language is fungible and people spoke a variety of languages and dialects and people came and went and adopted this or that language, it is not a good measuring stick. I cannot see any evidence to this, since all I see is evidence against the idea of a national awareness or a nation, a "nation" being defined by the Random House Webster's Dictionary as "a body of people, associated with a particular territory, that is sufficiently conscious of its unity, to seek or possess a government peculiarly its own". Language based claims to ethnicity are shady since we often don't know what "peoples" spoke, and evidence suggests that peoples spoke a variety of languages, not just one "national" language. Nor does language correspond to cultural traditions such as dress, pottery, or jewelry. It was only after the rise of nationalism and nation-states that historians began to look for a correspondence between territories, regions, or kingdoms, and ethnic groups who occupied them. But you will more often than not, find people debating endlessly about this or that ism, rather than asking more pertinent questions as to how and why was that particular idea introduced at that particular time, but this particular group to that particular people? For example, how and why, was nationalism introduced in France, by the Jacobins, during the French Revolution and how and why was it so successful in spreading around the world, eventually to be adopted by people as little as the Armenians? I end this treatise.
  6. Ohhhh, I like you. I feel the same way. I have an ism, for your prism ( mind ), and if you want it, you will have it. And if you want an ism, youd lose your power to think for yourselfism. La la la la. I have an ism, for your prism. This could be a cool pop song.
  7. I don't know if I suffer from birth defects, but I certainly suffer from birth effects.
  8. I like to believe George Orwell was into beating up on animals in a farm.
  9. Well, I've given up on this thread. But on a side note, feminism might make men effeminate, but that still doesn't mean you won't crush your package when you cross your legs.
  10. Everyone is against me, so I must be wrong.
  11. My philosophy is, pick a broom, and love it. You'll see that you can learn alot from relationships by loving a broom.
  12. In order to keep people subservient and rule, you must keep them stupid and ignorant. It's really simple you see. Give them mindless sound bytes and endless Hollywood break ups and pop music, and they love it. The masses are content. They don't ask for more. The gradual growth of Leviathan, has risen exponentially with the gradual dumbing down of the masses.
  13. Women will only fool me once. Only janitors will fool me twice!
  14. Avatars can be misleading indeed. But not mine. What you see is what you get.
  15. Mostly because I can go in between the elephants big toe and make him submit. It's sort of like jiu jitsu.
  16. As a Jackass I can tell you that I can coexist with an elephant, provided he doesn't trample over me.
  17. That was in reference to those who like to create mythical tribes such as the Armen tribes, or "Armenoids". There are various theories of ethnogenesis obviously and I lumped them all together for the sake of argument, that no matter what reference point you use, you are nonetheless using a reference point, but I recognize the obvious names given to people by different groups. The graph may be arbitrary, yet it is designed to make a point. If you have a straight line of descent of any people, and state "We descended from this", you are making a gross exaggeration. Perhaps in our imaginitive minds we may descend from Hayk, but such things do not take into account the population shifts, and demographic changes and mixtures. The concept of an Armenian nationality was a result of the Russian influence and interaction with ideas from the Enlightenment. There is no escaping this, no matter how much wishful thinking one may engage in. It was under the Russian sphere of influence that the concept of national identity was being created. The thinkers were giving Armenians a sense of meaning. What were religious and linguistic people from different regions were being given this one fixed identity with common interests, nevermind that their history is anything but sticking up for the common interest of the "nation". It assumed that the interests of the "nation" was all the same, much like Marx assumed that the interests of the proletariat were all the same, or at least ought to be. If viewed, Armenians, prior to the concept of nationalism were a religious/linguistic people, and they had no sense of a "common interest". That a Muslim would convert to Christianity and speak Armenian was only indicative of the fungible nature of ethnicity. Thus the Armenians during the time of the Achaemenians referred to as "Armina" were not the same, as the Armenians during the time of the Golden Horde, for this was a different people, and with a different culture, therefore a different sense of who they were with respect to their surroundings. The Armenians of 15th century with their grapar are different from the Armenians of today with their ashkarapar. You are trying to give Armenians some sort of identity that they were group conscious or a nation, before their recognized themselves as a nation. That is not so, since there is no evidence of "national awareness" until the Enlightenment. The people were a people in other words, before they knew itself. The region of the Caucasus is one that is very diverse and has been so since as far back as we can trace its history and the many empires and conquerors that came and went through that area and have left their mark is testament to this. To assert that "Armenian" has been some sort of fixed entity that is unchanging and was conscious of itself is to ignore everything else and make history centric around the concept of Armenian. To understand the world before nationalism, one must acknowledge the existence of empires and religious communities, not national entities or nation-states. So when the nakharar houses allied with Muslim emirs against other nakharar houses, this suggests that these people didn't view each other as "national people" headed for this "common goal" into the future to someday establish an "independent Armenia". In fact, that the Armenians living under Byzantium were loyal to Byzantines, and the Armenians living in the Persian sphere were loyal to Persians, doesn't suggest a people aware of its common "nation". That is the reason why Armenians have historically not been "united", as present nationalists contend. Their actions do not reflect the will of the "people" ( a holistic entity ). What you are in essence implying throughout your whole posts, is that Europeans and everyone else didn't think of themselves as a nation, or nationalities up until the Enlightenment, but somehow Armenians are exempt from that, and the people were a people before it knew itself. Obviously they self-identified themselves as speaking Armenian, and had the religion of Christianity, just like others identified themselves as speaking Greek, and belonging to the Greek Church. This is no different than many who converted or traded sides, or even adopted Islam as their religion or Arabic, or Turkish as their language of choice. I do not see this as evidence of a national awareness that they were somehow headed for this bright future with common interests. National awareness was created in the 19th century. That is all. If you can't deal with that on its face value, you are trying too hard to believe.
  18. Enjoy. http://homepage.mac.com/webmasterkai/kaicu...onestdubya.html
  19. Well Thoth if you hadn't made people the subjects in this discussion and instead remained on subject, we wouldn't be justifying ourselves here now would we? Instead you attacked the messenger in every instance, instead of confining yourself to the message. Let's move back to the topic or face the closure of another thread.
  20. Fool me once, shame on you. Fool me twice, shame on me.
  21. Can't disagree here. Nicely thought out. Signed, sealed, delivered.
×
×
  • Create New...