First of all, you have a misconception on what is meant by "anarcho capitalism". This is not based on the belief or premise that man is good, that is false. Rather it is based on the premise that man is self-interested. A completely free market, unregulated and unhampered by the State does not require people be good. In fact abolishing government doesn't mean you won't have crime or murder.
If you want to talk about learning from history, I hope you learn that in the age of the 20th century and of total war, the State was unrelenting and now we stand on the brink of destroying humanity thanks to the State. Individuals don't commit genocides, States do, by convincing people that they must relinquish their minds to the craze of mass mindedness. Government has caused 200 millions deaths in the 20th century alone, how many have individuals caused by themselves working outside of political systems? Yet based on this you support government and say I haven't learned from history? There is no way to "harmony or ultimate good" and that is not what I said, merely something you assumed and put in my mouth. On the contrary what anarchy would mean is to lessen the amount of destruction the gradual rise of the State has done to humanity.
Politics is based on collective thinking and in any political system you believe in, you lose your ability to think for yourself, because political systems in their nature rely and operate on the collective mass mindedness in order to be successful. We all too often acknowledge that politicians lie, they cheat, they do the dirtiest things that we in our everyday lives will not do, yet we unconsciously vote for these morally depraved people to make choices for us. Another contradiction lies in the fact that the government can lie, cheat, steal, and go across to distant lands, bomb and maim and kill people, yet we do nothing about it, and in fact support and vote for these people, yet we condemn and criminalize individuals for essentially doing the same thing.
Take the democracy that we have in this country, or so we believe to have. It is premised on voting. From the beginning of political systems during the Enlightenment and what we know today as the State, in order to maintain social control, the State engages in violence and coercion to maintain social order. We covered a book in class called "Parliament of Whores: A Lone Humorist Attempts to Explain the Entire U.S. Government" by P. J. O'Rourke. O'Rourke writes:
"Authority has always attracted the lowest elements in the human race. All through history mankind has been bullied by scum. Those who lord it over their fellows and toss commands in every direction and would boss the grass in the meadow about which way to bend in the wind are the most depraved kind of prostitutes. They will submit to any indignity, perform any vile act, do anything to achieve power. The worst off-sloughings of the planet are the ingredients of sovereignty. Every government is a parliament of whores. The trouble is, in a democracy the whores are us. "
Politics is a game of telling people what to do. That is why we vote, to have an authority figure tell us what to do, to tell our neighbor what to do and make choices for us. While we acknowledge that communist, socialist, or fascist dictatorships are brutal and use illegitimate means of brute force and coercion to gain power, democracy is worse, and a far scarier concept. It gives leaders an excuse to do what they do. If a leader is elected and is a tyrant, all he has to do is show that it was the will of the people. And while there are indeed those of us who would like to vote our lives away into the hands of tyrants in a democracy, it throws everyone else who don't want to vote into the hands of the tyrant as well. So when you vote you are not only voting for yourself, but you are voting for everyone.
And once annually, almost like a holiday, we all go to the boothes to vote, to give ourselves the illusion that for one day we get to make important political decisions, that we run the state. This is why the Western governments have been so obssessed with spreading "democracy" around to the other world, not to decentralize political authority, but to make people believe they are state which they have been forced into believing. Only here to we believe that we have a "choice" between a Republican and a Democrat. The absurdity of this is proved by the fact that after 911 virtually all politicians supported Bush's policies and voting for the odious Patriot Act. No matter what, the government always gets elected. To quote Biafra of the Dead Kennedies "If Voting could change anything, it would be illegal".
As far as the free market, it was precisely the capitalist revolution which has brought all this prosperity and increased living standards that you enjoy. It was the capitalist revolution which ushered the division of labor giving individuals a chance to develop themselves and specialize. I don't see this as "evil". What is "evil" is supporting the State, making yourself just as guilty for those children in Iraq who die from U.S. cluster bombs or depleted uranium.