Men who abuse, women that stay
What you should know about domestic violence
By Mark Servis, M.D. -- UC Davis Medical Center
Published 5:30 a.m. PDT Friday, April 19, 2002
We live in a society in which anger and rage are increasing. People show their anger on the road, in the workplace, at school, and at home. While expressing anger verbally can be healthy if it is done appropriately, expressing anger by physically harming another person is never justified. Yet nearly 1.5 million women are physically abused by their husband or live-in-partner each year.
If you or someone you know is in an abusive relationship, understanding the dynamics of the situation can help you or your friend find the courage to escape.
Abuse is never the woman's fault
The first thing that a woman in an abusive relationship needs to realize is that she is not to blame for the abuse. No woman ever deserves to be hit, punched, kicked, or otherwise physically harmed. Men who tell women that violence is their fault are trying to excuse their own inability to handle their anger appropriately. Violence comes from the man, it is his fault, and it is always inexcusable.
Although women are never to blame for being abused, women who get into abusive relationships often do so repeatedly, and such women have certain shared characteristics. Think about your relationship patterns. If you have been in more than one abusive relationship, you may subconsciously seek out men who will be abusive. Women who repeatedly get into abusive relationships were often abused by a parent or another significant person early in life or witnessed parental abuse. Because of early exposure to abuse, these women equate love with abuse and think that it is a normal part of love. This belief is often subconscious, and women may have difficulty recognizing the relationship pattern in themselves.
A woman's tendency to repeatedly become involved in abusive relationships does not mean that she is responsible for the abuse. The responsibility always lies with the perpetrator. However, women who are vulnerable to getting into abusive relationships can benefit from counseling to help them recognize and seek out healthy, non-abusive partnerships.
What are the characteristics of abusive men?
A woman who has been in an abusive relationship in the past is at risk for being in one again. By recognizing this risk, a woman can be alert for certain warning signs in a man that might indicate abusive tendencies. When trying to determine if a man might be prone to violence, it is important to realize that physical abuse typically does not begin until a couple becomes intimate. In the early stages of dating, if physical intimacy is limited and the couple do not spend nights together, abuse is not likely to occur. Once the couple begin living together or spending lots of time together, abusive tendencies may surface.
Past behavior is generally a good indicator of future behavior. If you know that a man has been abusive to women in the past, you should stay away from him. Do not assume that you can "cure" him or that if you just love him "enough" he will not be abusive. The problem is within him, and unless he seeks professional help in controlling his anger, he will continue the pattern of abuse.
Additionally, abusive men usually have a combination of personality traits. While the presence of these traits doesn't always mean that a man will be abusive, they can serve as warning signs. The traits include:
•Excessive need to control others, particularly the woman
•Frequent and inappropriate jealousy
•Paranoid tendencies; being overly vigilant about certain activities
•Being overly suspicious of others
•Being possessive of the woman and overly vigilant about her activities
•Alcohol or drug abuse
Since you cannot always be objective about the man you are dating, you might want to ask a friend's opinion. Invite your new boyfriend to dinner with a best friend or take him to a family event. Have him meet and interact with friends and family and let them see how he behaves. Then ask for their insights. They may see warning signs of abuse that you cannot recognize. While your may see his attentiveness as loving and caring, your friends may recognize it as being overly possessive. If your friends think the man might be abusive and you have been in an abusive relationship before, trust their opinion and end the relationship.
If the man you are dating repeatedly refuses to meet your friends or family, that in itself is a warning sign. Abusive men often do not want to meet their partner's family or friends because they want to maintain an exclusive relationship with the woman. Abusive men with a history of violence may fear exposing their relationship to scrutiny from others who will hold them accountable for their violent behavior.
How should women handle violence?
Physical violence usually doesn't come out of nowhere. Typically, it begins with yelling and extreme agitation. Then it escalates to the point where the violence begins. Women need to heed the warnings and physically remove themselves (and their children) before the situation gets violent. If there is any indication that a man is about to become violent -- especially if he is angry and intoxicated -- you should get away from him. Don't try to calm him down or reason with him when he is angry and violence seems likely.
Recognizing the pattern of abuse
After a man physically abuses a woman, he usually apologizes and promises never to do it again. He may "blame" her and tell her that if she just did what he wanted, it would not have happened. Women need to understand that this is simply not true. He is responsible for his actions and you should never blame yourself or apologize for whatever led to the violence. Don't think that if you just try "harder" to give him what he needs, he won't hit you. Although you may have done something that upset him, he is never justified in harming you physically and you never "deserve" it.
When a woman loves a man and wants the relationship to work, she may excuse or minimize the behavior. She may think that the abuse will go away when "things get better" (He gets a job, they get their own house, they get married). But if he has abused once, he will abuse again. Once a man has crossed the threshold into violence, it will be easy for him to regress.
Can abusers be treated?
Since abuse is not the woman's fault, she needs to realize she cannot do or say anything to get the man to stop. The abuse is coming from inside him and until he deals with his own patterns of behavior, he will be unable to stop. Even if the man apologizes and promises to get help, he is unlikely to do so. It is extremely rare in the context of an ongoing abusive relationship for a man to genuinely seek help and stop the abuse.
If a woman truly desires to help a man deal with his abusive tendencies, she needs to take a tough love, non-enabling approach. This means she must leave the man and tell him that he has to get help in order for the relationship to resume. He needs to prove that he means it when he says, "I'm sorry." The woman must set clear boundaries that include specific steps that the man needs to take, including:
•Ongoing professional counseling that addresses why he is abusive and that helps him find appropriate ways to deal with anger
•Evidence that he is committed to changing (keeping the counseling appointments)
•Evidence that he is changing (less possessiveness and jealousy and the ability to get angry without being violent)
•Couples' counseling before the two reconcile
Once a man begins to take these steps, the woman needs to be patient. She should not move back with the man simply because he is getting help.
Sometimes, the only thing that will motivate a man to get help is if the woman leaves him.If he genuinely recognizes that the problem is his, he will seek help. But a woman should not expect an abusive man to meet her ultimatum. In many instances, he will allow her to leave, he will find another relationship, and his violence will continue.
Where can women get help?
Women often stay in abusive relationships because they feel financially trapped. Many communities have organizations that help women leave abusive relationships. In Sacramento, WEAVE (Women Escaping a Violent Environment) offers emergency shelter and counseling to abused women and their children. Religious organizations and family and friends are also sources of help. Don't be afraid to reach out and admit that you need help.
Once you leave an abusive relationship, take some time to understand yourself and how you got into the situation. Get individual counseling or join a support groups with women who have had similar experiences. Find people to hold you accountable so that you won't get into the same situation again.
Breaking the cycle of abuse
Abuse has a devastating effect on children, and through children, abuse is perpetuated. Even if children are not physically abused, they suffer serious emotional damage from being in a home where abuse occurs. Boys who grow up in abusive homes are likely to become abusers; girls are likely to become victims.
Girls who witness their mother being abused, may unconsciously seek out boys who treat them the same way. Women who have been in abusive relationships and are doing their best to free themselves from that pattern should sit down with their daughters, acknowledge the problem, and let the daughter know that such behavior from a man is wrong.
If you suspect that your teenage daughter is in an abusive relationship, try to have a close friend, a trusted female teacher, or another female relative talk to her about it. Help her to see that you understand what she is going through and that she needs to get out of the relationship.
Remember that the best way to protect your children from the physical and psychological effects of domestic violence is to take care of yourself. Recognize the long-term impact that your being abused is having on your children. Take action now to get out and find safety.