Armen
Members-
Posts
3,439 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Armen
-
Thank you, I will take that as a compliment. You placed yourself on the pedestal of victimhood again. You just can’t help, can you? Germans are a worthy nation and I commend them for their high morals. First of all I don’t pretend to speak with expertise. I don’t speak with expertise at all. I am just exchanging ideas and opinions and I am free to use approximate notions as much as I want. Do not make ridiculous assumptions based on your own conduct. If you are that interested in my postings feel free to proofread them. Your empirical observation that “countries will go to war over a stupid bunch of rocks” is wrong. Those “stupid rocks” always have strategic value because they either provide access to resources or sea lines (Darfur/oil, Spratley Islands/gas, fisheries, Paracel Islands/sealines). So it is not the rocks that countries go to war for. You are wrong in your observation of the real reasons for conflicts. Many other conflicts (Karabagh, Taiwan, Abkhazia, Osetia, Transdnestria, Kashmir) have the status quo maintained over a considerable time span. This means that those who (according to your logic) should potentially go to war because of these territories value them less than something else. In many case that “something else” is economic stability. This means that economic stability is valued increasingly more than territory, which decreases the value of territory. If your assumption that “territory has an infinite value” was true than all these wars would be in active phase at present and they are clearly not. Indonesia gave up East Timor recently (following the Asian financial crisis). In case of our neighborhood, any territory than countries in the region have an eye on has concrete economic value. Akhalqalak - for transportation routes (oil, rail etc), Nakhichevan – transportation routes. Actually, Azerbaijan was willing to negotiate the access to Nakhichevan though Meghri. Moreover, as the processes of globalization, regional intergration and urbanisation continue (and this seems to be the course for the forseeable future) territory/land will lose value more. The only thing that can reverse this process is a global cataclism.
-
HOB, hima na nman e mi knoj, vori barak vzin mi mets ber en drel. Hiravi Hayere chen karogh sut asel, angam ashkhari qartezi vra. Inch vor meke patkerum e es zhoghovrdi zgacmunqnere ev aroryan.
-
Medya, this is not nice. Although I was not one of them, I think those who did not welcome you had at least some reasons, don't you think?
-
And I was thinking, where is Sip these days? Now I know.
-
It will cost too much to develop that area into something acceptable for living. There are better ways to invest and get something back in terms of societal development. Even Turkey could not develop those regions with all the money it got from international organisation. With intensification of urbanisation it will be very hard to populate those areas with farmers. Moreover, I don't think any emmigrants from dispora would wish to live in village type areas. They will clearly prefer cities. Also, what is going to happen to the population of those lands? Are they going to be driven away or assimilated? Don't know. It is too complicated. Right now, developing what we have and concentrating our effors in that direction seems more efficient. Surly, we can keep the "claims" as a political tool but at present it seems to be a burden.
-
What do you want TB?
-
Don't play with words TB, like you don't know what I mean. Clearly I did not mean to say that the present territory of Armenia can be given away because it has lost value. Territory has lost it value. Resources didn't however. Resources acquired more value because industry is becoming more important than agriculture. Countries keep armies to gain resources and protect them. No-one sends armies to Antartica or Sahara. They do it in case of Mosul, Basra etc. So your experiment hit the wrong target. Kars and Artahan (which are the first thing we can get) do not have anything except for the most severe climate in the whole region. Karabagh however, is the paradize spot. Armenia and Karabagh together could host (easily) a 8 mln modern nation (that is if the whole Armenian nation returns home overnight). The only territorial expansion worth is gaining an access to a sea, which is impossible. So, the way to go is careful diplomacy and development. Yes, and TB, either save your pointless hints and stuff or go to hell ...
-
TMNT, the US involvement in Iraq has changes the significance of "Pan-Turkism" idea. If the reigmes in Syrian and Iran change one day it the importance of "Pan-Turkism" for the West will go to 0. As Pan-Turkism can develop only in case it is relevant to the West I see that the reverse process is happening currently. A intergrated Turkish element was necessary only in case US and EU needed it to gain access to the Central Asian energy resources. This scenario is not there anymore and you could even see this from the passive position of Turkey regarding its relations with the Central Asian republics. Turley simply cannot concentrate on its EU accession and built Turkish union. Theu have to chose. Armenia is in no way a roadblock. It is a n illusion. By the way my position which you call a "humanitarian gesture" is based on rational distribution of our efforts to become a normal country. AT ITS BEST we can get back Kars and Ardahan. Now what are these lands? Basically, the same like the Gumri area - not fit for any kind of development except for livestock. If Armenia has a developed economy with some 5-6 mln population we could easily feed that amount of people by developing a modern livestock industry. Territory has lost its value in modern times. The only values that we can get back are Ararat and Ani. I don't know. In moder societies land is loosing its value especially if you're not going to be an agricultural country. Armenia's agricultre is mainly grapes and fruits. And these good are already produces more than we need.
-
Gams, there is one thing that I value in Baliozian's writings. He has a message in between the lines that the "Turk" is gone. That image of nomadic worrior that commited the Genocide of centuries and basically "formed" the Armenian nation with this act is gone. It is a phantom actually. We are fighting with ourselves now. And this is the most serious battle because we have to struggle with our consciousness, while the enemy is not there. Sometimes Turkey shows its "Turkish" face by assisting Azerbiajan in Karabagh or the Chechens but I think they are torn appart between the Balkans, the Caucasus and the Middle East. And as this regions all are moveing towards regional intgration of this or that level Turkey has to chose something (this is the Wlisonian trick, right? ). I just think that we have to take it kind of easy. Not make this much fuss about it. Turkey is in a very difficult situation itself. By making fuss we are promoting a policy that is not in our interest THAT MUCH.
-
Maybe Edward, but I don't think it is going to make us feel any better.
-
What's the rational then, Gams? Are you going to feel satisfied? The only way we will feel satisfied (the is get "even" proportionally) is by killing and raping 30 mln Turks. Cause I don't think that is possible nighter technically nor morally the only way is to create something realy good out of what we have now. And by "something realy good" I mean a society that others will feel jealous of.
-
I think we should forgive them. Not because we are Christian (lot of people among us are not) but because in long term any claims from our side are not going to advance our nation as a whole. It is a rational choice on our side. 1. If we demand land we cannot populate it 2. If we (Armenia) get money we cannot utilize it properly. At present it will only hurt. Individuals, however, might apply to get some compensation if they feel like it is appropriate.
-
I don't realy understand why are we investing this much effort into something (recognition) that goes on according to its own logic.
-
I agree with this observation Azat. And this is why I think the assimilation of Armenians should not be stopped. We should assimilate in diaspora. This does not mean, however, that we should not create possibilities for staying Armenian. But this process should be kind of "easy" or "light". A matter of choice rather than a destiny. Armenia should be the factor that makes Armenians to want to be Armenian. Otherwise your observation will happen.
-
Sasun, I think AG is an essencial part of regional geopolitical architecture. It was ment to be that way, in my opinion. It is interesting to see how perfect is the development of some regional processes simlutaneously with the AG recognition process, developments in Iraq etc. Sometimes it seems that all these factors are notes in front of a modern orchestra director who is performing a simphony written a century ago by a genius composer.
-
Turkey Approves US Demand for Incirlik Base By Suleyman Kurt Published: Thursday 21, 2005 zaman.com Turkey has approved a US demand to use the Incirlik Air Base as a "logistic hub" for humanitarian operations. A decree responding to the US demand will signed by the Turkish Cabinet Council to extend the period of a "secret" decree dated 23 June 2003 for one more year for the second time. It will not be published in the Official Gazette like the former decision. Opponents of the secret decree claimed that it was illegal. If the Cabinet approves it, the US will use the Incirlik Base as the logistic hub for operations in Iraq and Afghanistan. Turkish Foreign Minister Abdullah Gul, in a speech at Esenboga Airport before his departure for Lithuania yesterday (April 20) said that the process is underway: "In fact there is nothing new. What we have done is to make things more regular. It will be adopted as the extension of former decrees as there are no new dimensions to be considered. I think that the process will be completed soon." Although both Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Gul have explicitly expressed that there was no link between the Armenian genocide allegations and the Incirlik Base decision, it has drawn attention that the decree has been approved before April 24. The US asked Turkey to use the Incirlik Base comprehensively in May 2004 with demands beyond those in the recently approved framework. The previous demands were to use the base for other regional countries beside Iraq and Afghanistan and for military purposes. The agreement reached today was gained after months of negotiations between the two countries.
-
Diaspora Philanthropists George Najarian Disillusioned With Armenia
Armen replied to MosJan's topic in Republic of Armenia
Mersi Movses jan, This is good, realy good. I felt so much sympathy towards that woman and her cause. Everything about her is so right, that it would be a horrible act of injustice to treat her like that. -
See Azat, I told you you're going there two days ago. And some say I don't have abilities to predict stuff... I am coming with you. We're gonna make that city Mon-unreal
-
Azeries always say "turuba~" instead or "truba". Actually their accent when speaking Russian always makes me laugh like crazy. And I can imitate it pretty good
-
Edward jan, his being 1/2 Armenian is enough reason to spare him from criticism as a "fellow Armenian" as Armat says. Am I not right? I think he is very rightly criticised in Russia. Although that incident with someone hitting him with chessboard is stupid (and I am sure the Russian government has nothing to do with it), he latest articles in WSJ were so hysterical and biased that he lost the credit for any political viewpoints in my eyes.
-
Armat, I don't think Kasparov has the brains to express opinions on politics. He is the greatest chess player but that's it. Also, I don't view him as Armenian. I am not even sure that he views himslef as Armenian.
-
Oh he did? What a great man. The state of Uruguai did it a decade before him.
-
Isk inchi es du kartsum vor du iravunq unes indz het ayspes khosalu? Et inche vor du indzanic etqan shat gites? Im kartsiqov Pape endhanrapes Qristoneutyan het voch mi arnchutyun chuni. Aynpes vor es Qristoneanerin "bash" chem anum. Es qnnadatum em Vatikan (qaghaqakan) petutyan ghekavarin.
-
I didn't quite get it. What is liberal propaganda exactly?
-
Armat, I don't think he is moved by some principles. When during Eltsin the oligarchs were robbing the country and killing dosens of realy brilliant people (like journalist Vlad Listiev etc) Kasparov did not utter a word. And why is that? Because that "orgy during plague" that Eltsin organised in Russia was in the interest of West, which was calling it a "democracy"? Where was his courage then? Why wasen't he criticising Eltsin for inefficiency in Chechnia? His main target is "Yukos". That his motivation and reason. The rest if very understandable. Also, I would refrain from calling Russia a dictatorship. It is a cheap WSJ cliche.
