Jump to content

Sasun

Members
  • Posts

    5,522
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by Sasun

  1. Good idea Gurgen, I was thinking to put this stuff where wolfie opens his philosophy thread, but maybe we should keep individual philosophers in separate threads.
  2. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Is this what you disagree with? By the way, I can have a (personal) philosophy, but here I am not (yet) trying to bring any philosophy, just simple thoughts.
  3. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Eh Serge (can i call you wofie? )... what do you disagree with? With my philosophy? but I am not developing any philosophy, I tried to be as simple as possible by stating simple facts and a simple logical conclusion... what the hell are you talking about, cultures? did I mention any cultures? .... ....damn these philosophers.... .... OK pal, I am just kidding, don't worry, in time we will get there :lol: good night for now
  4. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Its OK Den_wolf... seems like we are both confused. I have been educated in Soviet Union so I was taught atheism, and I have been an atheist. Becoming a believer for me perhaps means the same thing as for you moving from religious education to atheism (or agnosticism, I am not sure where you belong to in this regard). At any rate, here is what I was trying to say. Case A Fact 1. The earth was believed to be flat by many in the past. Fact 2. The earth has been discovered and proven to be round as of present. Case B Fact 1. God was believed to exist by many in the past. Fact 2. God is believed to exist by many at present. Fact 3. There has not been proof that God exists. Fact 4. There has not been proof that God doesn't exist. Conclusion: Case A is different from Case B. If you agree with these simple facts and my conclusion then we can move further debating. If not, then we should make a stop and clarify before we indulge ourselves in off-topic ideas
  5. Domino, I fail to see how multiple universe theory is relevant to discuss with the evolution theory. I am not talking about possible evolution of universes. Darwinism is about the planet Earth, correct? So why are we talking about multiple universes? I can understand the attractiveness of multiple universes, however I don't see how that should matter for processes on earth. But suppose it does, then evolution theory is not the only thing affected by it. In that case every big or small processes on earth must be considered having the Multi-univ. theory in mind. Or am I misunderstanding something? For once, I would like to know what the hell this theory has to do with evolution and lets not get too hypothetical. Very simple Domino, because they are not fit and by far not the fittest. Well, the reason I asked this question is because life forms replicate and carry forward the existing 'program' already and the rest is done by evolution on selected individuals of the population. Unlike life forms, molecular structures don't replicate, there is no population. So suppose a single molecular structure was accidentally formed that was pretty close to be called a life form but not there yet. That would be the end of it since it is not a life form to replicate many many similar copies in order to form a statistically significant pool that would allow an evolutionary change. In other words, there is no chance of a gradual change and a jump is necessary for a non-life structure to become a life-form. By the way, has there ever been any artificially created cell? I never heard of it. I am not talking about cloning and stuff like that. I mean, a fully functional biological cell (let it be one of the simplest) created in a lab from scratch mimicking a possible natural process described by Domino. The upwards direction is more favored it seems. In other words, it looks like a stochastic process with an upwards trend. I wonder why? I don't mind a separate discussion but since humans are part of the evolution then I don't understand why the emergence of intellect in our species is irrelevant. I am surprised you think that way. Domino, this is physics we are talking about, things have a reason. If the universe originated from nothingness, then there was a dot right? Then this dot expanded and became a universe. Now, the question is why one dimension is less favoured than 2 other dimensions? I am quite convinced that there is a reason Domino. The planets, stars are more or less spheric and we are not surprised since all dimension are equal. But why is the unviverse on the whole flat? Don't you ever wonder?
  6. Yes den_wolf, I read that book. At the time I was extremely fascinated. However, now I have a problem with his philosophy. Btw, he keeps repeating the same thing from different angles in all his works (that I have read). His idea of the Superman is a false concept.
  7. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Its no clear to me. Do you have questions to me?
  8. Sasun

    Spinoza

    OK, now I don't know what you mean. Until a certain point in time it was assumed that the earth was flat. Then it was discovered that the earth was round. Is there any contradiction here?
  9. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Oh, I posted before you added this part. The earth was proven to be round, therefore the assumption that it was flat proved to be false. God has not been proven to not exist, so this cannot be a good example of "it was widely thought to be X, yet it was wrong"
  10. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Yeah Den_wolf, I think I am in agreement with your last post. I agree that there are absolute truths, and by cultural aceptance I meant both premises and conclusions. BTW, did I mention that I am not catching up with your questions? I am trying to formulate more or less satisfying answers to your questions. As far as the concept of God and philosophy pertaining to it are concerned, to give you a heads up I am a believer of soul reincarnation, the immortality of soul, that everything that there is is a manifestation of God while God himself is a transcendental being, and similar concepts. There is more to that but I thought to tell you this much so you have a better idea of what I am arguing about
  11. Sasun

    Spinoza

    I will post an answer later, but I wanted to say that in my thinking the degree of cultural acceptance of any line of thought has nothing to do with its validity. One example - at some point the earth was widely thought to be flat, yet it was wrong. There are so many other examples.
  12. Sasun

    Spinoza

    And so that to say something ON topic, I find Spinoza's language hard to read (or maybe it is the translation)
  13. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Well, I have to defend my point, don't I? OK, it doesn't matter really.
  14. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Is there a universal law or some kind of a mathematical rule to guide us what can be taken as premise and what cannot? I don't think there is, so premises are somewhat arbitrary and subjective. Likewise, God's existence can be taken as premise and a solid philosophy can be made based on that. I don't see it less valid as other philosophies since they are all based on certain premises without proof. That's my point.
  15. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Well, this is something you are assuming I did. I didn't try to prove that God exists, and I didn't try to use A=A as analogy - that's something you brought into debate.
  16. Sasun

    Spinoza

    You just confirmed my point p.s. I will address your other questions later on.
  17. I think it all depends on our motives. If we are helping only because we think that's the right thing to do and not with any other motives then I think it is not selfish. I guess you could call it soothing the soul but the soul is never selfish. It will urge you do things out of compassion and love. It is a spontaneous feeling of good, there are no calculations or desire. But it could be that we know helping others is the right thing to do but also it will bring us name or fame, or perhaps we expect to be helped in exchange, in that case we are being selfish. In other words there is some expectation for yourself. I guess this could happen also on the subconcious level. At any event, one doesn't get a full satisfaction out of a selfish act. There is always something lacking to feel satisfied. You are right, it is based on faith. But what is faith really? It is the soul's knowledge which Nietzshe was lacking I think. All that he has said came from his limited and imperfect mind. He proclaimed that God is dead - a typical gigantic arrogant remark by him. This is also a sort of faith created by the misguinding ego. Well, that's how I personally feel
  18. I used to travel with a few books always with me, one of them was by Nitzshe. We act to find some kind of satisfaction. In my understanding, there are 2 types of satisfaction, selfish satisfaction and self-less satisfaction. The first one is for the lower self, the Ego, and the second one is for the universal, higher Self, the Soul. The way I understand, Nietzshe doesn't differentiate between the these two.
  19. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Yeah, you are right, that was not really a proof ( I think by "proof" you understand someting else than I do). I mean, it wouldn't do good in mathetmatics I am not sure about philosophy. It's a definition, one of the fundaments in math, we assume that A=A and that's it. Call it a premise if you wish, the word doesn't really matter, but there is no proof. However, nearly every theorem im math is proven using this truth. Yet, the truth itself was never proven. For the same reason there are no proofs for axioms. Axioms are truths that have been observed without fail. But they were never proven. What I want to say, one should not always ask for proofs because it is impossible to prove everything. There are things that we take granted. The same goes for the idea of God. It means different things to different people. One aspect of God is omnipresence. All existence has to do with the existence of God. So if we exist then God undoubtedly exists - by definition, since the part cannot existe without the existence of the whole.
  20. Sure, the falsehood is human Ego and its much undeserved glorification.
  21. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Please prove it
  22. Sasun

    Spinoza

    I think in philosophy (and in all other disciplines) there are certain assuptions that we usually take as truths and never try to prove. For instance, why should we prove things? Has it ever been proven that proofs must be made in order to take something as truthful? Is truth really provable? Is logical thinking really truthful? There are many assumptions without which all science would fall apart for lack of proof yet they have been accepted for whatever reason. Take math - the king of all science: why are there axioms? All proofs in mathematics are based on axioms. Beyond axioms there is no proof, those are simply accepted because they seem so truthful and they are indeed beliebed to be truthful. I can come up with other examples.
×
×
  • Create New...