Jump to content

Sasun

Members
  • Posts

    5,522
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by Sasun

  1. Sasun

    Spinoza

    I took you more seriously than I should have. At least I expect you to read carefully and think before you answer. Instead you are trying to impress with your 'knowledge' and typing irrelevant things. You think I am confused??? Is that your argument? Well I think you don't understand things that are not simple. But in such a case you should ask instead of arrogantly claiming that I am confused.
  2. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Well I brought new points but you didn't address but are only saying that you disagree. BTW, why was this new argument of yours on divine commandment relevant? I would appreciate if you instead focused on my questions rather than deviate from the subject and overlook my replies
  3. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Suppose there is something I can observe and you cannot. Since at least one person can observe we can call it observable. Is this thing truth?
  4. Sasun

    Spinoza

    It is superficial because it assumes that something can exist independently of God. God is not an old man with grey beard who is sitting in the clouds and giving commands. All that exists is part of God, nothing can exist without God - this is an AXIOM Anything that contradicts to this is wrong. The argument obviously contradicts to this axiom because it is assuming that God can be separated from good - it is a nonsense because good (in the sense of right action, righousness) is an aspect of God. God's commandment (which is actually a kind advice at least and not a command) is by definition right. Right means God's word and God's word means right. It is not arbitrary because there is no other choice. It is like A=A. It is not more arbitrary than the creation of the world. In fact the use of the word 'arbitrary' referring to God is a fallacy with the same roots as the whole argument. The confusion comes from lack of spiritual knowledge. Socrates' argument is using 'gods' and is valid in conclusion ( b ) while this argument foolishly replaces 'gods' with 'God'. That is a big mistake coming from superficial understanding of God.
  5. Sasun

    Spinoza

    This argument is based on a superficial idea of God and has no truth, that's why it comes to a false conclusion Blind faith is not true faith. Philosophy and faith can very well go together but philosophy is not necessary for someone to have faith. Wolfie, are you going to tell me if you agree with my previous post or not? I am curious
  6. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Proof then is not the goal but the means to achieve it where the goal is the truth. If you can get to the goal then the choice of the means is not so important. Wolfie, I don't know if you accepted my assertion that every process of proof is based on self-evident truths. If you don't accept then I can't convince you, however I think that you are wrong. If you do accept then you should see that favoring proof over self-evident truths is arbitrary and subjective. There are so many things that can be questioned in every proof, those are elements of logical reasoning that are accepted as truth. Thus proofs are really universally accepted convictions. Why are they universally acceptable? Because the building blocks - basic self-evident truths are easily observable and not questioned. But what about truths that are not easily observable? Of course such truths are not used in proofs. That is the problem with proofs, or rather not a problem but limitation. For everything else proof has no real advantage over not so obvious and unprovable truths. In the end, what matters is the truth, not how you arrive at it. Proof is one method of arriving at truth, but not the only method. If you limit yourself to proofs you will have limited knowledge. Axel has made some valid points. Let me add something: faith is very important for attaining knowledge. It allows you to transcend the limits of proofs and the domain of provability. Wowever, faith itself is not knowledge, it must be accompanied with aspiration to become knowledge. One should not confuse faith with universal knowledge, something that agnostics and atheists often criticize the belivers for. It is a trivial mistake to say that faith is a fantasy. Of course, there is also mental fantasy which is not faith. True faith is the awareness of the knowledge of the beyond, and aspiration through spiritual discipline is the means to achieve that knowledge. All one needs is courage to recognize it rather than stick to proofs which are good for many things but in reality give incomplete knowledge and a false sense of security.
  7. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Just because Plato said doesn't mean it is the truth. Not that I am arguing against it. Here is my version (not my invention but that's beside the point): all that there exists in this universe is a mainfestation of an inherent underlying absolute consciousness (read "idea" to draw the parallel with Plato thinking that you are describing). The manifestation is readily observable and experienced as we experience the material world, while the transcendental consciousness is not observable. Nonetheless, it is possible to fully realize the transcendental consciousness. Both the manifestation and the concsiousness are real, very real. We must go back to the beginning of things to fully understand. It would be more correct if we say: the root of all proofs are things that we assume to be true because they are self-evident truths. It is beyond the reach of proofs and methodology, at this basic level there is no other way to pick what is true and what is false. The line is drawn, we just have to see it. There are 2 things only - truth and falsehood. Truth is self-evident, if something is not true then it is false. We are unable to see it without expanding our own consciousness. I am arguing that our knowledge consists of self-evident basic truths and huge constructions developed on that ground. Some truths are easier to be convinced of than others. There is no proof that doesn't use self-evident truths. These self-evident truths in turn are aspects of the single absolute truth. I never doubted our existence or tried to prove it. I don't understand the reason of your argument about our existence. We cannot prove our existence, it is also self-evident. Agreed, our existence is the basis of all that we do and represent. If we do not exist we cannot think and do things. If God doesn't exist then God cannot do anything. But the fact that atheists exist doesn't mean that God doesn't exist. I don't understand your argument. We all exist due to God, God doesn't make a distinction between atheists and theists when granting and sustaining life.
  8. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Wolfie, you keep telling me what and how things should be proven, and I keep telling you that I am not trying to prove anything. You believe in the absolute truth. Have you ever observed it? Have you any proof that there is absolute truth? I don't think so. Then why do you try to prove things using the EXISTENCE of the absolute truth (implicitly or explicitly)? Should I also point out that ALL sciences, all logical reasoning assume that the absolute truth exists and they are all after it. In every proof, every little step a scientist makes to prove something it is assumed that there is absolute truth according to which a smaller truth - the objective of the proof - can be achieved. Yet 'absolute truth' is a concept, nothing to see and touch, in other words an unobservable thing. What you call the TRUTH I call God and believe that it exists. It is self-evident and cannot be proven. All smaller truths are proven and measured their degree of truthfullness in comparison to the absolute truth. All proofs are made based on the implied absolute truth. Do you see that there is no objective difference between your premises and God as premise in arguments? I suggest you think before you answer - not that you don't think but you have repeated things that could be avoided
  9. Dude relax, I moved the thread, all he did is post an off-topic thread in the genocide section
  10. America-Hye, care to elaborate? I don't know anything about their pro-Armenianness and would like to know specificst if you have such info.
  11. Interesting articles, keep them coming
  12. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Wolfie, do you think all existence is observable?
  13. Oh BTW, I have removed a lot of off-topic posts from this thread. Some were not nice but most were simply off-topic so folks please try to not divert too far away from the subject, and don't get offended when your nice and harmless (yet irrelevant) post is gone
  14. Yeah, I am against any foreing intervention of any type particularly military if it was not asked for by the country who is supposedly being helped. In case of Liberia, they are asking for help - I see nothing wrong with foreign troops going there to help them out of chaos. If fact it is a great thing that militaries are sometimes doing good things. So, my choice is not a flat rejection of any foreign deployment of troops.
  15. Anonymouse, I understand your point - people may vote for a nice guy such as "B" and after a few years he may turn out to be a fascist pig like Hitler. Quite a valid point having the record of Hitler's political track as you portraied above. However, it is not likely to happen very often. I don't think Hitler's rheatoric, political skills and personality alone played a significant role in his rise. It was rather the political circumstances at the time that led to Hitlers rise. It is because of the people who supported him and allowed his agenda to be realized, because of business elites who benefited from his agenda, and because of public at large that he was allowed and welcomed as a leader (or rather a chief). So simply voting for a few campaign lines does not really make it. Had Hitler (or Mr. B ) been in a different society under different circumstances the same campaign lines might get him elected to be a totally different type of leader.
  16. I like classical music very much - Bach is my most favorite. I like opera as well but less than symphony and other classical. Nowadays the only opportunity to listen to opera is on the radio. But I don't remember to ever have listened to opera from start to end.
  17. Sasun

    Spinoza

    What do you mean by "observed"?
  18. Sasun

    Spinoza

    I like to avoid loops (philosophical or otherwise) them
  19. Sasun

    Spinoza

    Wolfie, when I brought Case A and Case B I was merely restating what I had said before. I was not going to use Case B in any proof. I have said that I am not going to prove that God exists. I don't believe anyone can prove it to the satisfaction of everyone. And it is the truth that many people believed in flat earth. When I said "Fact 1" I didn't mean that the earth was flat, but that there was such a belief. I don't know why you brought cultures into debate - I don't really care about cultural perceptions or beliefs. What I care is the truth. So now am I to understand that you believe in absolute TRUTH?
  20. Now I am hesitating to vote - I would like to ask "B" what he means. Sending troops as in Liberia, or as in Iraq? If the second then it is more like Bush and I am not voting for him, if the first then it is OK. "A" is not my candidate at any event.
  21. Sasun

    Spinoza

    I disagree with your disagreeing my process But - what process are you talking about? I am not aware of any process of mine.
  22. Sasun

    Childhood

    I mostly liked my childhood, some things I hated, things like having to wear a pioneer's red tie, having to go to school early, etc. One thing that pissed me off much was that I was not allowed to grow my hair. The most enjoyable parts were in summer when I stayed with my grandparents. That was a blast, I had so many adventures. Parents were somehow strict and boring, my grandma was such a great grandma - no matter what I did she always forgave me, there was never a punishment of any sort, and I should add I have done many bad things like breaking windows, breaking radios and other equipment in an attempt to "fix" them, chasing cats and dogs and kicking them, coming home very late, punching tires, stealing potatos, cutting trees, once we even stole a chicken with friends - it was delicious, many other crazy and stupid things I had some very special childhood friends where my grandparents lived. But I had many problems with my classmates. In fact, there was no single boy in my class with whom I didn't have a fist-fight of some sort. By the time we grew up I was friends with everyone, after fighting they became very friendly. There were less adventures when I was 13-14 and onwards as I liked to stay home and read, but that's also very useful and I don't regret a bit for not wasting my time doing silly things...
  23. Anon I fail to see why candidate "B" is necessarily Hitler (or someone like him). I came too late to vote but I would vote for "B".
×
×
  • Create New...