-
Posts
5,522 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Sasun
-
Hey Gevo, I wonder if you ever carry stuff in your truck Isn't it the purpose of having the area in the back? OK, I know it's good for offroading. But still, why a truck?
-
.. and another thing Domino - we should not dwell on such frustrations. Just learn, remember and move on, otherwise we might go crazy like Komitas.
-
Domino, I completely understand your frustrations with the Turks. I am convinced that this is a part of the Turkish national character. As individuals they maybe OK, not much different in personal relationships from non-Turks. However, when it comes to nationality they are "programmed" to behave like sub-human scumbags (lying, cheating, falsely accusing, slandering, and other lowly ways of behavior). Of course, when it comes to vilolence Turks are sub-human, bloodthirsty savages who not only kill mercilessly but also humiliate the opponent's human nature in the lowest possible way. Dignity and virtue have no place in the Turkish national character. Truth and honesty are among Turks' enemies. In peace individual Turks are normal people and can even be good friends, national character plays little role in their behavior. You wouldn' think that they are savages. Perhaps this dichotomy of Turkish personal vs. national character is largely responsible that our ancestors trusted the Turk. Well, now we know that they made a mistake and we shouldn't trust them. On the other hand, we should never drop to their low level. Not that the Armenian national character is perfect. Far from it, we have plenty of flaws. However, we are not savages.
-
Just something http://s93760412.onlinehome.us/pics/mouse_and_duck.JPG
-
Yes, if you add two infinites you will get another infinite. All infinites are infinites, this is a very trivial observation. However, this has no quantitative meaning (I think this is why Gevo objected using infinity in 'calculations' which we don't acutally do). As we all agree the best way to understand infinity is limits. What seems contradictory is when you try to get the limit there is a qualitative change. Namely, 2 times the same non-zero should not be equal to itself. However, as we take the limit this requirement is no longer true. I have another question regarding the proof of the lines. Cantor has proven that real numbers cannot be counted (the validity of this proof is actually debated in the article Domino posted, but that's another issue). The points on the lines represent real numbers. If we cannot count the points principally then how can we even consider this method of drawing mapping lines in the proof? I mean, we should first be able to count/identify every point in order to draw lines.
-
Congratulations Armat jan, that's great!!!
-
Domino, thanks for the links! I have been reading and thinking (and getting nostalgic) I am still digesting parts of the links (I have only read parts) - it is not that easy to understand all these materials. Please do draw and post the visual demonstration of Cantor's proof. I thought that it was clear already but maybe not. All I can see is a paradox, a contradiction. I showed above the contradiction unless I was wrong and am not aware of it. I have thought of another way to show the contradiction, I am still working on it. I tried to understand Cantor's Paradox but I am not quite sure what it means. I know very little of set theory. http://mathworld.wolfram.com/CantorsParadox.html http://planetmath.org/encyclopedia/CantorsParadox.html Can you tell me in human words what part is paradoxical? Perhaps in that case I will understand why you mentioned it.
-
Domino, I don't think the international community cares.
-
There is Oprah in Holland???
-
Azat, when you saw us talking about infinity, I wonder if you thought about that Infinity car you had among your choices, and thought something like this "Hahahaha... look at those geeks and me, I am thinking of getting this shiny Infinity and driving to ladies to sweet-talk, and what the hell are those geeks thinking about! "
-
That's OK Domino, you can post when you have a chance. And good thinking on choosing the article
-
Eh Gevo, I am not sure what you want me to answer. I think we all agree that we cannot have a good understanding of the "infinity" concept. Tell me what "infinity" is and I will tell you what 5*infinity equals
-
OK, I will not search on Google, you do the job and let us know I am surprised you put this link I will try to read it.
-
Gevo, that's the definition in math (to my knowledge), it doesn't matter high school or no. What is the definition that you know? "N" is just a notation, we are defining something, we are not saying it is finite. Before you take the limit you need a definition of infinity. And what I gave is the definition.
-
What? that the point p is not arbitrary, and how to find that point?
-
Cool illustration Sip, I like the graphical proof, now I remembered something like that I have know. It is in fact equivalent to my "stretching" argument above. But still there is something missing. How do you explain the difference C?
-
In mathematics, infinity is defined like this: number N is said to be infinitely large if no matter what number x we choose N>x always holds true. Now, you make up your mind to see if there is such a thing as infinite number or not To claim that A, B and C have the same number of points implies that we know how many points each have. All we know is that each has an unknown number of points. We cannot compare unknown numbers. The only certainty is that no matter how large a number we think of, the number of points on each of the lines (A, B and C) is larger than that number. However, 2 arguments. One could argue that in order to get from B to A we do have to add more points. One could also argue that in order to get from B to A we do not need to add points but only "stretch" B without adding more points.
-
But but... have you ever considered the same Azat the way he is, plus he can prove a theorem
-
Hahahaha, Azat we do all the hard work, and you do the sweet talk? That's not fair. I think you should prove a theorem or two before you go to ladies I think ladies will agree with me on this
-
Edo jan, what about the other points between the 2 endpoints
-
Actually I am not quite sure that those two lines have exactly the same number of points. Let's say line A is the longer line, and line B is the shorter one. Let's say A has N(A) number of points, and B has N(B ) number of points. Let's assume that as Sip and Domino claim N(A)=N(B ). A ________________________________________ B ______________________________ C __________ There is a third line, C which is the difference of A and B. Lenght(A)-length(B )=lenght©. Now, according to the same assumption, C has the same number of points as A, N(C )=N(A). Under normal assumptions lenght and number of points would be proportional - the more point you add to the line, the longer it is. So it follows that since length(B )+length(C )=length(A) then N(B )+N(C )=N(A). Since we assumed that N(B )=N(A) and N(C )=N(A), then we can substitute in the former equation and get N(A)+N(A)=N(A). Now, this is not true with finite numbers. Could this be true with infinite numbers? I would say that the answer is either no or undetermined. For all practical purposes the answer is yes. BUT...
-
I feel like you have some explaining to do here
-
Sip do you mean the line? Actually, we never see infinity, we only see a limited object (in this case a drawn line) and imagine a collection of very-very large number of very-very tiny dots. We never see infinity but we can try to get infinitely closer and closer to it.
-
Nairi jan, something tells me you never were a big fan of math
-
Gevo, you are raising an interesting question. But the fact that we cannot mathematically fathom infinity is not due to limitations or flaws of mathematics but limitations in our comprehension and perception of reality. Being limited on the physical plane we are only used to limited reality. For that reason we cannot imagine infinity. As to your question, I think what you are asking is "what is the closest number to 5 other than 5?" In that case both your questions are of the same nature, and the answer is undeterministic. As to Domino's answer, I believe he is more confusing you than clarifying things
