-
Posts
5,522 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
2
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Sasun
-
Hmm... I don't understand what you don't understand Well, you are minsunderstanding religion just like many religious people do. One must not act in certain ways because of promised reward, or out of fear of punishment. The role of religion in morality is to establish what is right and what is wrong. Once you know what is right and believe in it, you as a true religious person do the right things. Such moral actions are unselfish actions. That means one has to put his self after other things, duties, poor people, etc... so how is it selfish I don't understand? Axel has made a very good post above. Why do devoted religious people follow Christ's teachings? Not out of fear, and not because of a promised reward. They don't really think about such things. Their only motivation is pure, selfless Love for God, love for Jesus. There is no reason, no expectation from this love. It is just love for the sake of love. Unless you understand it I am afraid you will always misunderstand what really religion is about. Let me tell you that you could not be more wrong. Just study a little the history of religions, all morality that existed in all societies came from religions. Very often relision and morality were identical. Even what you call a humanistic morality came from religious teachings. It was not taken directly but rather indirectly. (And as far as I can see, we have already established that such morality did not come from rational thinking.) Non-religious people consciously or uncosciously have taken some elements and given their own flavor and call it "rational" humanistic morality. I don't know what exactly you mean. I didn't say that God has given us specific instructions. God has given us various guidlines which we know as religions and spiritual practices that are advisable (and very important) to follow, and has given us free will to follow or not.
-
There are various ways one can say, depending on religion, and all of them have to do with God. (I am not sure about Buddhism though). My answer is, humanity must survive because it is God's intention that His Kingdom must come to the earth. Every human being should realize God and manifest God on earth, each one of us has a purpose which we have forgotten. That is the ultimate goal of humanity that each human being knows himself/herself and manifest God. We are divine beings having human experiences on earth but we don't realize that. Once we realize it we will have conscious onenness with God. Before we realize it we will have a lot of confusion like we do now, and a lot of suffering. Many things could be said on the subject, but I think you get the point now.
-
Anoushik, indeed you didn't prove that morality is rationally achieved. I don't believe anyone can prove. One stops at the red light for different reasons, reasons could be not to get a ticket, not to be struck by another car and injured, as well as not to run over a pedestrian. There are different reasons and motivations in the society, both selfish and unselfish. Rules that are selfish cannot be morality, rules that are unselfish can be morality. The red light cannot be considered as morality since it does not necessarily imply selfless act on part of drivers. What you are saying is that the society must have rules so everyone can be happy because they are interdependent. This is a perfect case of selfish thinking. If the ultimate goal is the individual's selfish happiness then there is every reason for everyone to get rid of everyone else in the society who happens to compete with them. And what about other societies? Is it allowed to bomb another society which is geographically far away to benefit your own society? Let's say the good of that other society is never the good of your own, so you are interested that they die as soon as possible leaving their wealth and land to your society. You will never receive any benefit from them. So tell me please, should your society wage a war against this other society and defeat them? And as rational people the first society will surely think that they would be better off not killing the enemy but making them slaves so they could produce more benefits for their society.
-
I have yet to see a logical and thoughtful arrival at morality. All I have seen so far is claims. Please enlighten, if not then I will call it a baseless claim
-
Here are Buddhist outlook and 'commandments' in a nutshell. The main point being, there is no salvation without morality, and the morality is defined as a set of rules that must be followed in order to be moral. The Four Noble Truths Life is suffering. Suffering is caused by attachment to desires. Suffering can be ended by overcoming attachment to desires. The way to end suffering is the Noble Eightfold Path. The Noble Eightfold Path Right view Right thought Right speech Right action Right livelihood Right effort Right mindfulness Right contemplation Steps 1 through 5 concern ethics and morality. Steps 6, 7 & 8 are more advanced and concern practice of meditation and going to higher levels of consciousness through practice, and ultimately to Nirvana (or Kindgom of Heaven if you wish to call it that way). Without morality one cannot go anywhere. This is a tested and proven path to salvation, waiting for the taker.
-
Well, Domino, I went after OEM printer inks and caused my printer's demise. It refuses to print no matter what I try. So I would not recommend printer refills, as they are even worse than cheap ink cartridges. Well, I better go for shopping a new printer, no more Epson, this time its gonna be a Canon I think.
-
Armat, instead of playing chess and gardening, you should post more often this type of stuff Seriously, I admire Buddha's teachings and would like to learn more
-
That's true, but please explain, why are you not bad? Why must you be good?
-
I will be looking forward to your answer. Please also think about the question "why must we be good?" according to humanism. P.S. As far as the self-proclaimed "god" Thoth, since you are asking I will answer: he is simply not worth my time.
-
Anoushik, why don't you show that humanism is rational? You are just making a claim. Please explain how humanism is rational? Who said that without humanism the humanity or part of it will not survive? And who said that humanity must survive? How is it rationally explained? Can't you live for yourself and be happy even if after you there was a flood. I won't take anything granted from a rational thinker, I need a clear reasoning and solid logic. If not then I will call you irrational
-
Domino, how can science have anything that is not rational? So what quantum mechanics is counter-intiuitive? It is still rational. Domino, why do you always think that religion is supposed to explain things? That's not what religion is about. Religion is only a step in spiritual development. It cannot explain the universe and generally does not try. For more advanced development there is yoga which can and does explain everything metaphysical that science and religion can never explain. Religion is like a kindergarten level of education. You will have to provide a lot of evidence for this
-
Thanks for the time to find a good answer Anoushik. My question was more rhetoric though. The point I am trying to make is, humanists and religion agree that we must do good, but humanists fail to explain why, while religion will say because God tells us to do so, for example. I believe that humanists share many of the same views with religions, but the scope is limited because they chose to be limited. And again, humanism is not rational. Humanism has COMMANDMENTS, just like religion that must be followed to be qualified as a humanist
-
I agree that we are both rational and irrational, and there is nothing wrong with that. We must be rational and moral at the same time.
-
Hmm... I don't think it is possible. There is never a logical answer to questions like "why must we be good?", "why must we care for others?", etc... these questions cannot be answered through logic and reasoning.
-
But I am not talking about Buddhism, am I?
-
Well, that's not a paradox Domino And I am not patching, what you call "an asian belief system" is as good a theism as any other theism. Just keep in mind, God is not a thing but it is something immaterial/non-physical behind everything, there is no paradox really. It would be a paradox if it said there was a physical being that created all other physical things, and it needed to be created too.
-
OK, I can see your reasoning but I cannot agree in principle with your last sentence. True, religion is a guidance and it may imply a strict discipline for the follower. However, it is not about thinking. No matter how good a thinker one is, there is still something beyond reasoning, that thing is morality which is largely irrational. If one picks morality it doesn't mean he/she cannot or should not think. This is about the sense of right and wrong. Religion says you must do the right thing. It is morality, and it is a guidance that cannot be replaced by any thinking, it is a moral choice. One still needs to do a great deal of thinking. But one thing is clear, one cannot come to morality by thinking.
-
Are you saying that religious people cannot think for themselves? It seems to me that you are saying, whatever people could not answer they just invented God and that was the explanation. Well, it maybe your opinion but there is no truth in it. In all major religions there were direct experiences with God, and that is how people came to learn of God, and that is how religions originated. Now if you want to believe that its not the case and people just invented God you will not be able to support with the history of religions. What you are saying maybe true for some people who don't know much, and when asked about things they will simply refer to God. But that doesn't prove anything.
-
I may have missed it or forgotten, Domino can you tell me what the Theist Paradox is?
-
Not really Sip, that's not what religion is about. In most cases religions are not concerned about understanding things or explaining things.
-
Well, one maybe not religious in this life but religious in subsequent lives. There are many-many opportunities for each soul to take advantage of spiritual practices and evolve towards liberation, if not in this life, then in next, if not in next then the one after, etc...
-
What is secular humanism? Where does it come from?
-
Some don't want to be changed, some want to be changed but have no faith in themselves, some want to be changed and have faith in themselves but are lazy to work. Deep inside everyone wants to be happy and satisfied with life, this change is the only thing that can make one truly happy and satisfied. This is what those who have gone through this path will say with absolute confidence. Everyone has a degree of goodness, it is not possible to find somone who has no virtue at all. So everyone can use religion to be good and better if they choose so. If you agree that people should be good, and if you agree that if people follow religion they will benefit from it, then I don't see what the problem is. These select few are said to carry the humanity forward, while the rest of people live for themselves. Knives can be properly used for the benefit of the kitchen, and knives can be misused to hurt people. Should we conclude that knives are dangerous? If religion can be misused, it is not the problem of religion but the problem of misuse. If we agree that religion properly used is beneficial for the humanity then it is unfair to call it dangerous. Dangerous are people who are willing to misuse it for selfish needs. Religion is not to be blamed. If there was no religion these people would find something else to misuse. I must make a note, when I refer to religion I have in mind the pure, intended meaning of it, not the religious structures, hierarchies, authorities, etc. I hope this makes my point clearer. We find that many religious people are misusers rather than sincere practicioners working to transform their nature. Nevertheless, religion in the sense of spiritual discipline and growth is our only hope.
-
Armat jan, if you remember Armenia produced and still produces crappy vans called Yeraz, hence that name is used for Azeris who came out of Armenia. Probably it has a derogatory tone and they would not call themselves Yeraz. Supposedly Yeraz Azeris are more nationalistic because they were discriminated against while in Armenia, and probably because they were eventually driven out. Before seeing this article I thought that rivalry existed between Baku Azeris and Armenia/Nakhijevan Azeris.
-
Chill down Arpa, I am sure Raegan is quite peaceful. People are talking about him as a politician, nobody is gossiping about him as a person while being guests in his house. Hospitality has nothing to do with criticizing a politician or politics. I am a guest in this country but I have no problem criticizing its aggression against another country or other wrongdoings. As far as my obligations to the "host", I pay taxes.
