Jump to content

Sasun

Members
  • Posts

    5,522
  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won

    2

Everything posted by Sasun

  1. Sasun

    Buddha

    Tell me where beauty comes from and I will tell you where ugliness comes from.
  2. Sasun

    Buddha

    Shnorhakal em Janik
  3. Sasun

    Buddha

    Yeah, for example, I believe in hell as planets, you believe just one hell without specifying what it is. But we still believe that there is a hell where one can go for reasons that we both agree what they are, maybe not in all cases but largely we agree. I believe that we have three bodies, I don't know what is your point of view, but let's say you don't believe in that. Whether we have three bodies or not has no bearing on our spiritual practices, we still have faith in God and believe that we should do good just the same way. Basically our differences are like these...
  4. Sasun

    Buddha

    If I understand correctly you are talking about power of suggestion. It works sometimes, but prayer too works. For example, if we sincerely pray for others' well-being it will work even though they are not aware and therefore could not use the power of suggestion. This happens because when we pray we send healing energy, God is not directly involved in such a prayer even though we are using His healing energy. But one can also pray to God directly though this is more difficult IMO. That is why many people's prayers are left unanswered, specially when these are selfish prayers for wealth and luxuries. As to meditation, here in the West people can call all things meditation. Like Hatha Yoga, which is just bodily Yoga has become the only known form of Yoga. There are farm more superior forms of Yoga that people don't know here. The purpose of meditation is not to become calm and peaceful, but to quiet the senses and thoughts in order to get subtle vibrations of the soul. We don't know that we have souls because we are too engrossed in senses. Senses and thoughts are coarse, vilolent vibrations compared to the soul's subtle vibrations. As a result the latter are simply buried under senses and thoughts. Calmness and peace are only side effects, not the goal of meditation. This is an explanation in a nutshell, it is a whole separate science. Just wanted to clarify. P.S. By the way, there have been some interesting research and experiments on prayer pointing that prayer does work. I will post about these some other time.
  5. Sasun

    Buddha

    Sip, in that case before asking the question "What evidence do you have that God exists?" you should first ask "What is the definition of God that you use?", or "What is God?". Basically, from your point of view, you are asking me the question "What evidence do you have that X exists?". In that case I am unable to give any answer because you are giving me one equation with two unknowns. From my point of view, God means a specific thing. Until and unless you make up your mind of what God at least in theory means to you you cannot ask for evidence for that. The topic of God is objectively broad. I have many evidences that the way I understand God exists and is a living reality. This understanding of God only keeps increasing and clarifying to me. Some things that I have assumed become no longer valid, however the basic definitions of God remain alwasy valid. It is a learning process, but never a blind faith. Likewise, I have inner experiences that prayer and meditation both work, because I have evidence in my personal life. You dont' have, but you are not in a position to reject my experiences. But you are in a position to repeat spiritual practices and have your own inner experiences.
  6. Sasun

    Buddha

    Yes, but you cannot say that ugliness is the source of beauty. Ugliness makes you realize that there is a beauty, but doesn't explain where beauty comes from.
  7. Sasun

    Buddha

    I don't know what many women being witches is about, but I know for sure the word "woman" is generally not associated with being a witch. That is simply not part of the definition of the word. However, the word "God" is not arbitrarily defined. If there is God then God is good, being "good" is part of the concept of God. You cannot make up a different definition for a word that already exists in this form.
  8. Sasun

    Buddha

    Well, if my undertanding is wrong then tell me what is the source of beauty?
  9. Sasun

    Buddha

    I tried to say the above with logic, but the best way to see the connection is to concentrate on beauty, and concentrate on God. When you see that they have something in common then it will be apparent that the beauty in the flower is nothing else than a manifestation of God.
  10. Sasun

    Buddha

    It seems tautology because you are treating it mechanically. You can't define God anyway you want. There is a general understanding of God, even to the atheist the word "God" means something that generally implies that God is supposed to be good. From that understanding follows that beauty must be originated from God. Because God is good, then since beauty is also perceived as good then God is the source of the beauty in the flower. For someone who does not think God exists, I would like to know what they think the source of beauty is.
  11. Sasun

    Buddha

    Sip, why don't you try meditation? Aren't you curious what it is? I will tell what I have actually experienced: practice breathing meditation every day at the same hour. Sit straight and follow your breath for half and hour in the morning and half an hour at night. Just concentrate on your breath and follow it, don't be distracted by any thoughts. Don't try to mentally control your breath, only follow. Depending on your will power and persistence after some months you will get a glimpse of the beyond on your own. It is hard to control thoughts, but not impossible. Otherwise words are useless and this conversation is useless. P.S. Before meditation let 2 hours pass after meals, and preferably take a shower.
  12. Sasun

    Buddha

    Since when is Azat the source of beauty? You are mechanically replacing the word. God is by definition the source of beauty, intelligence, wisdom, life, etc... To understand that I am right you need to concentrate on beauty and on God.
  13. Sasun

    Buddha

    So basically you are saying you have not run experiments but you could have run and repeat what is said in publications. Methods of meditation also are clearly stated and explained. In essence my evidence and your evidence are the same because they are repeatable, and not necessarily our own. The mystic experiences too are repeatable, otherwise they could not be truthful. Repeatability consists in doing tested methods of meditation and arriving at objective truth. Call a meditation an inner experiment. You, I, everyone can have those experiences. There are tested methods of meditation that for thousands of years have proved to be right. Those who have seriously practiced meditation have come to the same realizations as others, even though they use different words. Mystics are not nearly as many as scientists, hence they are unknown and not easily understood or accepted. Other than that, I don't see any essential difference between a scientist and a spiritual scientist. They are both in search of truth, the former in the physical and the latter beyond the physical. All religious truths come from mystical realizations.
  14. Sasun

    Buddha

    Just to clarify, I was talking only about my post about three worlds. As to God it is much more significant, and I personally do not take God the same way as the post. There are actually a lot of evidences of God. For example, the beauty in a flower is evidence of God because God is the source of beauty. The fact that we have intelligence is also evidence of God because God is the source of intelligence. There are a lot of easy-to-see evidences like that. Of course, if you were looking for a videotape of God, I don't think that kind of evidence exists. God is Spirit and non-physical but He manifests through the physical. BTW, I don't know if sSeb's evidences are the same as mine.
  15. Sasun

    Buddha

    This sounds like I have said the contrary before. Is that so? Don't you have faith in science? I am sure you have not done every experiment that led to scientific discoveries that we take granted in science books. I am sure you take 99.99% of the scientific truths by faith, and the rest perhaps you have had a chance of doing experiments in a lab. I know you will say but there is tons of evidence! Yeah, there is, but not yours You personally have had absolutely no first hand knowledge of these evidences. You personally have experienced nearly ZERO of the scientific truths. You take science and scientists by faith, and so do I. As to me, I also take spiritual science and spiritual scientists by faith. So my faith is not any more blind than yours
  16. Sasun

    Buddha

    No, you cannot explain to everyone. You cannot explain to blind and deaf people anything at all, or people who cannot reason. The first because they are not familiar with your acxioms as they have not observed. The second becuase they do not have sufficient logic. In fact, I am not so sure that you will be able to present a sound reasoning for everything. No offence, but we all think that we are reasonable yet we disagree. You cannot find 2 people who agree on everything that involves reasoning.
  17. Sasun

    Buddha

    First of all, I don't read the Bible everyday. Second of all, every time I read the Bible I learn something new that I didn't understand before. Third of all, I read a lot of other things from other religions. Often that helps you understand your own religion better, because all scriptures have a common truth. So the answer is, no you don't get brainwashed when learning the truth. The only washing that takes place is the washing of false ideas when you compare it to the truth.
  18. Sasun

    Buddha

    One example that comes to my mind is the story where the three kings come to see Jesus when he is born. This story is also recorded in India. There were three Indian kings that had the yogic vision of God being incarnated, and traveled to see him. They took three types of gifts, which are exactly the types of gifts common to give to newborns in India.
  19. Sasun

    Buddha

    Sip, let's make it clear: you are saying what I have said is inconsistent. That would mean, for example, if I say ths sky is blue and also say that the sky is not blue. But from your post I can tell the following: 1) The so called inconsistencies are what you assume follows from what I say, and what you assume should have been. But it doesn't work that way, you should not assume that the conclusions you make are true and objective, or that I also make the same conclusions. In other words, if you want to show inconsistencies in what I say you should say this statement of yours contradicts to another statement that you made. 2) You are asking what evidence I have of the worlds and all that you don't believe: I don't have any evidence, and I never said I have evidence. I have presented it as a theory that I believe in. This is not an incosistency. The type of evidence that is relevant to metaphysical concepts cannot be physical which is what you are looking for. The only evidence I can give you is what I have made a mention of before: go beyond your senses and mind. There is evidence, but you should be able to see that evidence, and going beyond the material dimension of your being is necessary. I can't help you otherwise, and nobody can do. Now, I have said this before, but you didn't understand. This not magic, this is normal and everyone can do that. 3) Your argument on the number of souls is not correct, because your argument is based on your conslusion from my post. My post is not at all a comprehensive description of all that there is, it is only a brief fragment on the life beyond physical, of which I myself know very little, yet I could post a lot more (not that I am going to do so). As to the number of souls, I don't know if it increases or decreases or stays the same. From my post above it does not follow if the number of souls should be constant. However, souls evolve from mineral to plant to animal to human form, and souls can stay for any duration of time beyond the physical. So there is no way to tell what the number of human souls on earth should be. 4) As to my personal experience of these worlds, planets, etc... there is none, I didn't claim to have any, but I believe that those things can be experienced, because by meditation I have experienced things that I could not experience otherwise. But forget my experience, it doesn't matter if I had such experiences, what matters is that others have had such experiences. From your point of view, does it matter it is me or somebody else? When you want to learn physics you don't go and ask questions to your next door neighbor who has taken one course in physics. You instead go to an expert in the field, such as a physics professor. Therefore, my experience is not important, what is important is the experiences of mystics who are the experts in this field, and who also tell you how you can accomplish what they have accomplished. You are free to believe or not the mystics, however you are not in a position to reject their experiences. 5) Human knowledge is based on observation and logic. The axcioms that you mention are simply observations. The same way, the observations of mystics are axcioms of spirituality. But since you have not observed them yourself you don't believe. On the other hand, one can have faith in such things becuase faith is an intuitive knowledge of those things. And by faith I do not mean mental knowledge. 6) The ability to go beyond the senses and mind is not a gift, it is a matter of training and practice. I have never said that some people have the privilege to do it and other do not. What I have always said is everyone can do it with enough effort, including you. Some people are born with this, but it is not that they are gifted, they simply have practiced spirituality in one form or another in their previous lives. 7) THE PROOF OF THE PUDDING IS IN THE EATING. I can't say any simpler. If I said something unclear I can clarify, but I think we both agree that there is no need to go in circles.
  20. Sasun

    Buddha

    Anoushik jan, as far as I remember in the last one or two years you have never ever agreed with me on religion/spirituality (and if I am wrong in this and it can be proven then as a penalty I volunteer to split this thread, which is not an easy task to do). So I guess that is your way of appreciating BTW, you have become surprising lately, how did that happen? Anyway, joke aside I appreciate your words. I think that you are a very sincere person and as such I value your disagreements because they are sincere (even though wrong ) and come from a desire to see humankind in a better shape. Thank you indeed for your honest words
  21. Sasun

    Buddha

    I don't get it. Are you sure that a God who had created all these things would in no way care about human beings? Why is that? Can you explain how that conclusion follows? This maybe your opinion but who said that it is true? Actually by making this assumption you are lowering God to the level of undivine human beings who are arrogant not to care about people that are supposedly lower than them. Perhaps you think that this is the right thing to do for someone who has the status of God, but I could not disagree more. No wonder why you have no interest in God (to put it in mild words). I don't see how sSeb or I have said incosistent things.
  22. Sasun

    Buddha

    Sorry Anoushik, I would always be glad to answer you, as I have done many times. But it seems to me my answers have not been of use to you, therefore it does not really matter if I answer or not. But here, my answer to your question: The Bible was written by humans, correct. But these humans had various levels of divine knowledge (or such knowledge was orally told by them and somebody else wrote them down). For example, as sSeb has said, the Gospel of Mark was written by a disciple of Jesus Christ, telling about the events and sayings of Jesus. Jesus talks about God a lot, which I believe is absolutely true, therefore, it has everything to do with God. As to other books, I will not make a strong statement of the nature of the books that I have not read completely, but to the extent that I have read and understood, some things are really inspiring, and I believe there is truth in them and as such have to do with God. Other things which are not inspiring, may have truth that I don't understand, or simply are not divinely inspired and have little or nothing to do with God.
  23. Sasun

    Buddha

    Anoushik, the Bible is a big collection of books as you know. I don't know many people who have read the Bible from start to end, but many people have read some things from it. In particular, because the Christian church gives a lot heavier importance to the New Testament, for that reason many Christians follow them and only read the New Testament, or parts of it. So they know something from it. For example, someone can read one of the 66 books and find it very inspiring, and also can say that they know something from the Bible. That would not be a false statement that they have some knowledge of the Bible. Someone else may have mechanically read all 66 books from start to end and not understand anything. I would say this person has no real knowledge of the Bible. My personal standard of knowing is grasping the underlying truth rather than mechanically reading. That is me. As to me reading the Bible, like I said I have not read it all, and not even the New Testament completely. I consider the Gospels the most important books, and have read them completely (which I am doing again as Christmas is approaching). Every once in a while I will take and read from both Old and New Testaments. But to tell the truth, I don't find a lot of inspiring things outside of the Gospels. And many things are not clear to me (which explains why I am not in a hurry to read all books end to end). I prefer to read one paragraph and really understand it, rather than read a whole book mechanically. Oh, I have read the Reveletion by St. John and am convinced that this also must not be taken literally, as well as many things in the Gospels said by Jesus. This is my personal understanding. I consider the most important writings in Christianity the words of Jesus Christ as given in the Gospels, then other books. Again, this is my opinion, others may tell you otherwise.
  24. Sasun

    Buddha

    Oh, you never know, Anoushik, from your question I assumed that you didn't read the Bible In that case I would advise you to re-read
  25. Sasun

    Buddha

    Anoushik, like I said to Sip, the same goes true for you. It is puzzling how people can have strong opinion about religion, God, or what not, yet they have not read the Bible. Amazing indeed. Please take up the Bible and read it. You will learn a lot more than whatever you could ever learn from these forum debates.
×
×
  • Create New...