Jump to content

Interview With Norman Naimark


joseph parikian

Recommended Posts

Interview with Norman Naimark

 

 

Interview by Khatchig Mouradian

 

 

http://www.aztagdaily.com/interviews/interviews.htm

 

31st of December 2003

 

A senior fellow at the Hoover Institution, Norman M. Naimark is also

the Robert and Florence McDonnell Professor of East European Studies

and chairman of the Department of History at Stanford University. He

is an expert in modern East European and Russian history, Poland

since 1863, and the history of the German Democratic Republic since

World War II. His current research focuses on the Soviet occupation

of Eastern Europe after World War II and ethnic cleansing in the

twentieth century.

 

His book "Fires of Hatred: Ethnic Cleansing in Twentieth Century

Europe", published in 2001, studies "cases from twentieth-century

European history that help illuminate the process of ethnic cleansing,

its causes and effects". Aztag Daily contacted professor Naimark

requesting an interview and he gladly agreed to answer our questions

about genocide and ethnic cleansing in general, and the Armenian

genocide in particular.

 

AZTAG - Does one find any distinctive features in ethnic cleansing in

Europe in the 20th century when one compares it to ethnic cleansing

and genocide on other continents? Does the fact that Europe is the

"epicenter" of human rights and high levels of culture make such

calamities all the more shocking?

 

Norman Naimark - I think one has to consider Europe -- broadly

speaking, including Russia and the Turkey/Ottoman Empire -- the home

of ethnic cleansing. If one thinks of episodes of ethnic cleansing and

genocide outside the European continent, like the partition violence

in India in 1946-47, the Rwandan genocide, or the Cambodian genocide,

one could argue that the preconditions for these horrible events were

"exported" in some senses from Europe.

 

That Europe in the 20th Century was home to ethnic cleansing and

genocide is indeed more shocking, I think, because of the high

levels of culture and society. What could be more disorienting than

the Holocaust, for example, which saw one of the most civilized and

developed countries in Europe -- home of Goethe, Schiller, Weber,

Einstein, and Benjamin – turn on the Jews in such a vehement and

murderous fashion?

 

 

AZTAG - In "Fires of Hatred" you underline the difficulties of

differentiating ethnic cleansing from genocide, especially because

ethnic cleansing more often than not turns violent. What is the

importance of differentiating between violent incidents of ethnic

cleansing and Genocide?

 

Norman Naimark - I think intentionality is important in understand the

phenomenon of mass killing. In Bosnia, for example, or in postwar East

Central Europe, the intention of the perpetrators was to drive the

"enemy" (Bosnian Muslims and Germans) out of a concrete stretch of

territory, thus ethnic cleansing. This is not genocide; they didn't

care how they left, just as long as they left, using whatever violence

they thought was necessary to accomplish it. In the cases of genocide,

like that of the Jews or Armenians, the intent of the perpetrator is

murder, genocide. Both ethnic cleansing and genocide are crimes against

humanity. Genocide, I believe (as does international law), constitutes,

however, a higher level of criminality and it much harder to prove.

 

 

AZTAG - Is there any legal framework based on which people could be

held accountable for "ethnic cleansing" today?

 

Norman Naimark - The International Tribunal for Yugoslavia has included

ethnic cleansing among its listed crimes against humanity. Again,

it is an important crime, but not of the order of genocide. There

seems to be no special attempt to place ethnic cleansing in a separate

category. Instead it is joined with ideas of "forced deportation."

 

 

 

AZTAG - What about the moral accountability of bystanders?

 

Norman Naimark - I am not a moral philosopher and am unwilling to

judge the culpability of bystanders in this connection. Clearly,

they share some responsibility for what is going on. But I have been

much more concerned with demonstrating, historically, that ethnic

cleansing and genocide are the products of government planning and

the nationalist political elites that control those governments.

 

 

AZTAG - Do you think September 11th and the war on terror will change

the way the West responds to genocidal acts?

 

Norman Naimark - Yes, I believe the trajectory of the international

system has shifted dramatically from one that seemed increasingly

willing to deal with acts of ethnic cleansing and genocide, for

example in Kosovo, to one that is mesmerized by the "war against

terrorism." It is unclear where the "system" and its guiding star

at the moment, the U.S., will go from here. But I think it less

likely (take a look at Liberia, for example), that the U.S. and U.N.

will intervene in genocidal situations than in 1990.

 

 

 

AZTAG - How did your become interested about the Armenian genocide

and in what ways did your research on the Armenian genocide unfold?

 

Norman Naimark - I had heard about the Armenian genocide from Armenian

friends and found myself very confused by the contradictory nature

of Armenian claims on the one hand and Turkish protestations on the

other. The scholarly literature on the genocide is growing -- people

like Vahakn Dadrian, Richard Hovanissian, Taner Aksam, and Ronald

G. Suny have made important contributions -- but it is not nearly

as solid and developed as that on the Holocaust. As I consequence,

I wanted to study the documents myself, as a way to understand what

happened for myself. The older I get as an historian, the more I want

to see the documents myself in order to judge controversial problems.

 

 

AZTAG - Also in "Fires of Hatred" you say that "the concept of

Genocide does not fit the Armenian case perfectly", citing the fact

that Armenians in Constantinople and Smyrnia were left intact due to

the presence of foreign observers in the city and that some Armenians

were converted to Islam, and some Turkish officials ignored the order

etc. Some of these are, fortunately for Armenians, some "gaps" in

the plan to annihilate a whole race; do these gaps make a genocidal

act less genocidal, or less "perfect"?

 

Norman Naimark - What I tried to say in the book is that, first

of all, we are short of the kinds of documentation we have for the

Holocaust. Because intentionality is so critical for the determination

of genocide, it would be an easier case if we had more internal

Turkish documents that would demonstrate the intention of murdering the

Armenians. Also, genocide seeks to destroy all of a nation. Armenians,

as you know, could sometimes convert, escape to the mountains, stay in

certain locations, survive as Protestants or Catholics, etc. I don't

think there is a perfect or imperfect genocide. But conceptually,

the Armenian case does not fit neatly into our idea of genocide. I

believe it was genocide, as you know from my book. But it is not the

same kind of case as that of Hitler and the Jews.

 

 

AZTAG - In the book, you do not hesitate to use the "G" word when

you speak about the Armenian massacres and deportations. What were

the "pieces of information" that led you to conclude that this was,

in fact, Genocide?

 

Norman Naimark - The "G" word is important and I do believe it fits

the Armenian case. What convinced me more than anything was reading

the documentation of the various consuls and doctors and observers who

witnessed what was going on around them and reported it to Ambassador

Morgenthau back in Constantinople or to their respective governments

or bosses. Thus, there is an accumulation of first-hand eyewitness

evidence about what was being done to the Armenians that -- combined

with some other documents, the post-WW I trials of the Young Turks,

some remarks by the Young Turk triumvirate itself, and a few others --

convinced me this was intentional murder of a nation, thus genocide.

 

 

 

AZTAG - Do you consider the Armenian Genocide a template for other

genocides that followed?

 

Norman Naimark - I think the Armenian genocide was not so much a

template for genocide as an historical precursor of other genocides,

especially the murder of the Jews. We know Hitler and his circle knew

about the Armenian genocide. There is some question whether he actually

made the statement "And who remembers the Armenians now." Still,

the example of mass murder and the inability and unwillingness of the

"international community" to do anything about it -- which was clear

in the Armenian case -- certainly had some kind of influence on the

Nazi sense that one could do these sorts of things with impunity.

 

 

AZTAG - The Armenian Genocide is denied by Turkish governments, and

it is not recognized by a number of other countries, including the

USA. Naturally, without recognition and some form of reparation the

wounds would not heal. In your opinion, how can this issue be resolved?

 

Norman Naimark - You are right, there is only one way for healing

to take place, and that is for the Turkish government not only

to recognize what was done to Armenians, but to give historians

unrestricted opportunity to use Ottoman archives. I have participated

in conferences where, in a very preliminary way, Turkish historians

(usually from outside Turkey, but not only), and Armenian historians,

have discussed the genocide from their own perspectives. There IS

progress on this score. But there is much more work to be done,

including the building of a museum in Washington commemorating and

documenting the genocide. Healing will come, but it will take time

and it will take honesty. I hope soon the Turkish government will

come to this realization, as well.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is off-topic just a reference to some other old arguments that we have had in the forum about, what is Europe and where is Europe. Aside geography Europe has always drawn her borders based on cultural, religious and economical parameters. I was looking at some old German maps produced somewhere around 1830's, and then according to the author of the map Europe was very narrowly defined. The utmost south-east point of Europe was Ruschuk (today Ruse) on the Danube river. I guess this was kind of gesture of good will to the turks since some parts of the Empire were recognized as parts of Europe. Some older maps, though strictly pointed out the borders of Europe as the places not contaminated by Osmanly.
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...