gamavor Posted November 19, 2011 Report Share Posted November 19, 2011 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted November 19, 2011 Report Share Posted November 19, 2011 WHAT "HAYASTAN" ALL-ARMENIAN FUND DOES NOT WANT YOU TO KNOWBy Ara K. Manoogian http://www.thetruthmustbetold.com/2011/11/18/haaf-summary/?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=rss&utm_campaign=haaf-summaryNovember 18, 2011 It has been a year since Sarkis Kotanjian, Executive Director of"Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund (HAAF) Western U.S. region, gave aTVinterview, during which he made so many untrue statements about theFund that I could no longer put up with the lies. I started workingon a detailed report about the true face of the Fund, based on bothmy personal experience and ample evidence from eyewitness accounts andpress. The white paper was titled "To Donate Or Not to Donate?"(Clickhere for the Armenian version), which covered a wide range of issuesrelated to the HAAF and the Armenian government. I had a meeting with Sarkis Kotanjian shortly after the interviewto understand why he was drawing such an inaccurate picture of theFund on TV. It became obvious that he was misleading thousands ofviewers knowingly. The ultimate goal of the white paper was to raise awareness amongthe Armenian donors about the reality behind the veil of deceptivepropaganda and to present viable solutions for those ills, which plaguethe fund. The research was also intended to spread the word about thenegative impact of charitable activities on the overall developmentof Armenia and Artsakh, based on various international studies. The first part of the white paper was published at The Truth Must BeTold, about a month after Kotanjian's infamous interview, on December17, 2010. The first professional Armenian news outlet to pick up thereport was Hraparak Daily, based in Yerevan, after the release of PartII in January 5, 2011. Hraparak Daily reprinted both parts on the sameday, January 6, 2011. And this republication marked the beginning ofa long journey of the white paper on HAAF through Armenia, Artsakh,and the Diaspora. When an enthusiastic young man voluntarily translated the reportinto French and posted it piece by piece on the forum of Nouvellesd'Armenie, the thread immediately became the hottest topic in theforum. The forum users were discussing every aspect of the report. They eventually demanded that Bedros Terzian, President of the Fund inFrance, respond to all the arguments made in the white paper. Instead,Bedros Terzian ordered the editorship of the French-Armenian journalto delete the entire thread. Unfortunately for him, I had been ableto save it and repost it at my media blog. Terzian then publishedan article, "Pour le Fonds Armenien, par Bedros Terzian," denyingall the facts and allegations in the white paper with emotionalpatriotic statements. While Nouvelles d'Armenie gave in to the pressure of the HAAF andlimited the lively debate on the activities of the Fund, anotherFrance-based Armenian newspaper, Nor Haratch, sided with objectivejournalism. This Armenian language newspaper covered the report infour consecutive issues in March of 2011. Betros Terzian attackedthis newspaper for disseminating the content of the white paper, bypublishing "CORRECTION: About "Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund" in thesame newspaper. Nor Haratch responded to the libelous attack with"Armenian Journalism Targeted: Response to 'Correction'." And Iresponded with "Bedros Terzian Saw the Elephant." Soon the growing noise around the HAAF became too loud for theexecutive leadership of the HAAF to continue keeping silent. It wasthe publication of Part III that broke the silence of Ara Vardanyan,Executive Director of the HAAF in Armenia. He left a comment underPart III, denying every single point made in the entire report. TheArmenian and English versions of Part III, combined, generated aheated discussion in the form of about ninety comments. The only person to take Vardanyan's side in the discussions was amysterious user, who chose to present himself with the nom-de-plumePahakazor. He presented himself as an average Diaspora Armenian who isa staunch supporter of the Fund and all of its projects. 'Pahakazor'also spoke with admiration about Sarkis Kotanjian, whose interview wasthe target in the first two parts of the report. It later turned outthat 'Pahakazor' was none other than Sarkis Kotanjan himself. Basedon irrefutable evidence that I was able to collect, I published anarticle "'Hayastan' All-Armenian Fund Cover-Up Foiled," which debunksSarkis Kotanjian and his dishonorable strategy in an effort to save hisand the Fund's face and smear mine: Thus, assuming a fake identity,Sarkis Kotanjian was praising and promoting the Fund by giving falsetestimony. By claiming to be a diligent donor, who has checked andis now completely satisfied with the way his money translates intoprojects, Sarkis Kotanjian misleads people into trusting and donatingto an organization he works for. On March 2, 2011, Ara Vardanyan made the following statement in acomment to Part III of the white paper: "Both I and Sarkis Kotanjianare ready at any time to sit with you on one of the ArmenianTelevisions and talk about all these things live. Lets see what istrue and what is not" (sic). I accepted the challenge and sent apress release, "Ara Vardanyan, "Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund ExecutiveDirector, To Debate Fund Activities Live on TV" to all major Armeniannews outlets announcing the upcoming live TV debate. I sent both Ara Vardanyan and Sarkis Kotanjian a private email,on July 15, 2011, suggesting that we decide the date of the live TVdebate any day between August and October. However, I received noresponse from either of them. After the leaders of the Fund broketheir promise and dropped the ball on me, I had to publish an articleregarding their irresponsibility, "To Debate Or Not to Debate About"Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund?" A couple of weeks following the publication of this article, I emailedAra Aghishian, President and Chairman of the Board of "Hayastan"All-Armenian Fund's U.S. Western Region affiliate, asking for ameeting. I received a call from his secretary two months later, onOctober 11, 2011, acknowledging that my email had been received andthat Aghishian was going to contact me. He has not until now. Nevertheless, before and after my attempt to meet with Ara Aghishian,I have been able to meet with a few members of the Board of Trusteesof the Fund's U.S. Western region affiliate. But it has turned outthat they were not as actively involved in the life of the Fund asone would expect a board member should be. They were uninformed aboutthe issues that I presented, quoting the white paper. The Fund has not only declined to face the criticism but has continuedtaking irresponsible steps. The latest major blunder is their newproject, the launch of which was announced in the summer of 2011:the renovation of the retirement home in Stepanakert. I conductedresearch regarding the project, and the evidence I was able to collectindicated the redundancy of this initiative. The most obvious deceptionwas in the Fund's statement that the building had not undergonemajor renovation since 1988, whereas I established the fact thatthe retirement complex was renovated in 1999 with the sponsorship ofLouise Manoogian Simone. This and other glaring inconsistencies arepresented in a report, "How to Renovate Already Renovated RetirementHome," which I completed in October 2011. It is now obvious that Ara Vardanyan had offered the bold challengeof the live TV debate with the expectation of scaring me. But thiswas a grave miscalculation. My decision to take up the gauntletforced the Fund to back up and rehabilitate its initial strategy ofsilencing the criticism by ignoring it. This explains why the executiveleaders of the Fund did not react to the release of the final partof the white paper on June 21, 2011, despite the presence therein ofserious accusations, such as the evidence of the Fund having abusedits tax-exempt status for the benefit of the oligarchs, who dominatethe Armenian economy. Throughout the entire year, I have tried to raise awareness aboutthe problems associated with the Fund's activities and its role inArmenia's development. I have also tried to generate public debateabout the pros and cons of charity for Armenia today. I am deeplyconcerned with the consequences of humanitarian aid, which has beenpromoting dependency among the Armenian population on charitablehandouts and laziness of the government to carry out its duties. Though the white paper built a sizable audience in the ArmenianDiaspora and stirred debate in the U.S. and across the Atlantic,it is sad that the Fund preferred a policy of denialism over dialogue. Today on the threshold of the consecutive phonethons and telethonstaking place in different communities of the Diaspora, it is importantfor the Armenian donor to think twice before making a decision todonate. Remember, not all that glitters is gold. It is importantto differentiate between short-sighted benevolence and long-termsustainability. We should look a few steps ahead and understand theneed to amend the agenda. The leadership of "Hayastan" All-ArmenianFund is infested with the authorities who have failed the Armenianpeople in so many ways that the only support they need is a helpinghand to get rid of their yoke. Diaspora needs to form a new generationof organizations that demand government accountability, rather thanfix and cover up a few of the countless consequences of governmentcorruption. Ara K. Manoogian is a human rights activist representing theShahan Natalie Family Foundation in Artsakh and Armenia; a Fellowof the Washington-based Policy Forum Armenia (PFA); creatorofwww.thetruthmustbetold.com and author of the white paper "ToDonate Or Not To Donate", an in depth study on the activities of the"Hayastan" All-Armenia Fund. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted November 26, 2011 Report Share Posted November 26, 2011 THE DIGNITY OF KARABAKH PEOPLENaira Hayrumyan Story from Lragir.am News:http://www.lragir.am/engsrc/society24329.htmlPublished: 11:33:39 - 26/11/2011 Armenia Fund must restore dignity which it has replaced by beggary,fake patriotism and compassion. The people in Karabakh who watch thetelethon videos about their own life say it is not quite pleasant towatch them. Yes, there is a problem of water supply in Karabakh but whyshould it necessarily be presented as if they have never seen water,they take a shower once a month, and the lands are dry and infertile,and Karabakh is unable to sustain itself? Do the organizers of the telethon care about the opinion of Karabakhon these videos? Do the people of Karabakh agree to be introducedto the world in this way, with their hand stretched out, unwashedand uncombed? Hardly so! I know a lot of people in Karabakh who areashamed of these videos and hurry switch the TV channel. Karabakh really needs water supply, in Stepanakert the citizens haveonly 2 hours of running water but people do take care of their hygiene,and their city is one of the cleanest cities in the world. Water is a more urgent problem in villages, and instead of showingpeople who are surprised to see water running from the faucet itwould be better to see a young entrepreneur who worked his land withthe help of the fund, sold the crops he harvested and renovated hishouse and road with that money. The people of Karabakh are proud people, they never beg for anything,they live on their own income, small or big, and they never complain. However, thanks to the "policy" of the recent years, the image of abegging person is publicized in the Armenian world, who is deprivedof dignity and whom you do not even want to help because he takes abath only once a week. The problem of water supply could be solved should the money be spenton actual work rather than unnecessary universal events. For instance,if the water was not used to irrigate the lands of people whose namesare known to everyone in Karabakh. Most importantly, dignity may become a convertible category. Thepeople of Karabakh may announce that they disagree to being shownin this light and they can feed themselves but there are problemswhich require major investments. And the people of Karabakh will behappy if the Diaspora makes these investments with the expectationof getting profit. In that case, instead of the feeling of pity the Diaspora will becomea partner and will preserve both its honor and the dignity of thepeople of Karabakh. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted November 29, 2011 Author Report Share Posted November 29, 2011 I don’t now Yervant what you meant by posting this article by baron Ara Manoogian, but to me it is the usual Armenian BS. On a full page he explains his dissatisfaction with the operation of the fund for unknown reasons. From his article you can find out which newspaper is objective and which is not ( no explanation why) and how counterproductive generosity can be! I really don’t get it. If someone is not happy with certain cause simply do not support it. Simple as that. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted November 30, 2011 Report Share Posted November 30, 2011 I don’t now Yervant what you meant by posting this article by baron Ara Manoogian, but to me it is the usual Armenian BS. On a full page he explains his dissatisfaction with the operation of the fund for unknown reasons. From his article you can find out which newspaper is objective and which is not ( no explanation why) and how counterproductive generosity can be! I really don’t get it. If someone is not happy with certain cause simply do not support it. Simple as that.Gamavor Jan, whenever I post an article and have an opinion I put it on top of it. Because I didn't have an opinion one way or another I posted it in order to start a debate so that members who know something about this to come forward and enlighten us, if there is any abuse or not. Therefore if you have any information about this, please share with us because calling it merely an Armenian BS didn't help me. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Arpa Posted December 1, 2011 Report Share Posted December 1, 2011 (edited) ԾՈՒՌ ՆՍՏԻՆՔ ՇԻՏԱԿ ԽՕՍԻՆՔ, or is it ՇԻՏԱԿ ՆՍՏԻՆՔ ԾՈՒՌ ԽՕՍԻՆՔ?Sit crooked and speak straight, -or is it- Sit straight and speak crooked? I kind of tend to agree with above authors Ara M and Naira H.Seems like the era of “telethons” has become obsolete. Even the original ones like the one by Jerry Lewis’ MD shows have become a little stale. Is the ERA of Punchuni-s over?It is reminiscent and redundant of this by Erwand Otian , Մի Քիչ Փող Ուղարկէ-Send Some Money for this or that Punchuni is coming up with yet another harebrained project and… SEND SOME MONEY, SEND SOME MORE MONEY!WHERE IS THE ACCOUNTABILTY?Be they water project, highway project… this project, that project….*** http://hyeforum.com/index.php?showtopic=18808&st=0&p=250937&hl=send&fromsearch=1entry250937I did not see the actual telethon , my local TV did not air it, neither could I see it on the internet. Is it because the whole of telethons have had better days?** It is reported that this year 12.xxx million dollars were raised. How many of those pledges are real money, and how much just emotional and օղի/oghi/խորուած/khorwats inspired idle promise that will never be delivered?----What will the next theme of the telethon be? Raise funds to buy new and improved BMWs for the privileged? We have yet to see the results of all those projects and have an x-ray of the pockets of the handlers, an account of the distribution of the funds. Why is that the natives of Yerevan and Stepanakert, however many of them are left build their own country, schools, hospitals, highways and waterways? How long must the Diaspora grease the palms and fill the pockets of a few chosen “oligarchs” who drive the latest models of Mercedes and BMW while many diasporans cant‘ even afford a 20 year old Chevrolet klunker?See how many fatal auto accidents in Yerevan involve BMWs and Humvees. Who issues them drivers licenses when they can’t even distinguish between a traffic green light and a red light or read a STOP sign.This is a whole separate topic when in America with a billion cars on the streets and highways there are far less fatal accidents than in Yerevan with a couple of thousand cars? **Speaking of the deja-vu of the telethons. See how the concept of “FORUMS” including this one has had better days. General ennui/fatigue?Deep coma/Խոր Մահաքուն? Has everyone said what they have itching to say for many years? Hs everyone said how they hate tews and jurks?**** Are all issues been resolved? Are there no other issues left? Oh yes! We know the Big G has become a matter of definition. The what?***This is reminiscent of the early 20th century slogan when American parents would deny “luxuries” to their children who would not eat their spinach saying “Remember the Starving Armenians”.**** Will these wretched souls see even 12 luma-s out of those 12+ million dollars? See these pictorials and weephttp://hetq.am/eng/multimedia/slideshows/18/http://hetq.am/eng/multimedia/slideshows/29/ Edited December 2, 2011 by Arpa Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
gamavor Posted November 20, 2012 Author Report Share Posted November 20, 2012 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
MosJan Posted November 21, 2012 Report Share Posted November 21, 2012 չկարողանալով վորոշել թե ինչ անել. վորոշեծինք գումարը տալ AGBU. իրենք ավելի լավ գիտեն թե ինչ անեն և ուր ինչպես ծախսեն Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Arpa Posted November 30, 2013 Report Share Posted November 30, 2013 TELETHON MELETHONHas boredom, ennui and disenchantment set in ?Where is Baronian to write about The Hororable Beggars ?Մեծապատիւ ՄուրացկաններWhen I came back from my Thanksgiving Day Holiday I was surprised to not see any talk about the latest telethon. Now I understand that they had a promise of 22+ million.**This year we gathered at my daughter’s, for a sumptuous dinner. Both she and her husband are excellent cooks.The TV was on, from one channel of football and another to the Telethon. Very few, if any were watching the latter. To not forget that there also were children wanting to watch their favorite childrens’ programs. I expressed my dim view of the whole project that I have had for quote sometime, when my host said ” You must have talking to my brother Aram”.I was not totally surprised. Aram is a highly educated (PHD) and highly intellectually opinionated , a very loyal Armenian patriot, yet he shared my critical opinion about this telethon-melethon fiascos, that the proceeds go to line the pockets of the handlers, mainly the so called recipients.*** Even more revealing was one of the guests, a recent arrival from Yerevan, a highly educated lady in her own right, a university professor , shared our view of the whole shameful affair. Besides, she being in high places and knowing the inner shenanigans, knew how the funds were distributed.Need I say more? I can, Shut me up!Now let’s hear your opinions.**How much of those promises, over a glass or two of oghi-s are actually delivered?*** I read somewhere that North South Highway is already crumbling, much reminiscent of those houses of cardboard an sand in Gumri and Spitak, I don’t forget that when I visited that New Cathedral in Yerevan I was amazed to see that the walk up from Tigran Mets avenue was already crumbling with all the tiles peeling off. This was less than 4 four years after construction. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Arpa Posted December 1, 2013 Report Share Posted December 1, 2013 (edited) This year we gathered at my daughter’s, for a sumptuous dinner. Both she and her husband are excellent cooks.Did I say what a kitchen klutz I am? Maybe not. I hate going into the kitchen. I even burn water. We were taught that the man never enters the kitchen, he only cooks outside on a manghal.We were never let inside the kitchen. Our mothers would tell us to get out, lest your thingy would fall off.Therefore ,here is me .in the “boys’ kitchen”http://www.armeniapedia.org/images/c/c2/Khorovats-gandzak-dcp0206.jpgAnd another picture of me.http://www.neilingram.co.uk/flow/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/article-1341983-0029B06C00000258-691_468x313.jpg Edited December 1, 2013 by Arpa Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted December 14, 2013 Report Share Posted December 14, 2013 AFTER TELETHON KARABAKH GOVERNMENT BUYS EXPENSIVE CARS FOR OFFICIALSFacebook groups of Karabakh are discussing the rumors that the NKRgovernment has decided to allocate 250,000 dollars to update the carfleet after the telethon for the reconstruction of Karvachar-Sotkroad. Rumors came that Bako Sahakyan already has a car, and expensivecars have been ordered for other government officials.Karen Ohanjanyan, a human rights activist of Karabakh, wrote an angrypost that this process of polarization leads to chaos. Many peopleagree with him in Karabakh where the quality of life has dropped,while people owe more money to banks. It will eventually blast.In fact, the government of Karabakh has a habit of spending "savings"at the end of the year not to roll over the next year. They usuallyspend the money on cars and other objects of comfort. Or repay somepeople's debts to banks at the expense of the state.23:30 11/12/2013 Story from Lragir.am News:http://www.lragir.am/index/eng/0/country/view/31531 Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Arpa Posted December 14, 2013 Report Share Posted December 14, 2013 So. How long will this farce of telethon-melethon last? Buying luxury cars? Is it like me still driving a 1950 Chevrolet clunker? Besides. How many of those dollars are used to buy one way airline tickets to get the hell out? Here is my car. http://jims59.com/60Chevys/images/1960_Chevrolet_Impala_Flat_top_Lt_Rear.jpg Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Boghos Posted December 15, 2013 Report Share Posted December 15, 2013 Nice car Arpa jan! Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted December 21, 2013 Report Share Posted December 21, 2013 "HAYASTAN" ALL-ARMENIAN FUND U.S. WESTERN REGION SPONSORS AUDIT TRIPSource: http://www.thetruthmustbetold.com/audit-trip/Burbank, CA - For the sake of transparency and accountability,The Truth Must Be Told, a Los Angeles-based civil initiative, isorganizing an audit trip to Armenia and Artsakh to examine the qualityof the work carried out by "Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund, in June of2014. The airfare will be covered by Antranig Baghdasarian, Chairmanof the Board of Directors of "Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund, U.S.Western Region."Anyone who doesn't believe, I will pay for their plane ticket, so thatthey can go and see with their own eyes," said Mr. Baghdassarian duringthe Telethon of the "Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund, in Burbank, CA,on November 28, 2013 (watch the video at http://youtu.be/z7PKEen2E3s)."If so they wish, let them bring an expert along, take a sample fromthe cement and examine it and see how strong that cement is," he added.Ara K. Manoogian, founder of The Truth Must Be Told and the authorof "To Donate Or Not to Donate?", a white paper on "Hayastan"All-Armenian Fund, documenting its 22-year history, welcomes AntranigBaghdassarian's offer."I welcome Mr. Baghdassarian's generous offer, which gives me hope that"Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund is ready to face the shortfalls that maybe detected during the independent audit and will make correspondingreforms to address the possible issues," Manoogian said referringto the initiative of The Truth Must Be Told to recruit a group ofindividuals concerned with the quality of work done by "Hayastan"All-Armenian Fund in Armenia and Artsakh.The Truth Must Be Told will limit the number of participants to 50people, but encourages others to organize independent auditing groups,since the Chairman of the "Hayastan" All-Armenian Fund, U.S. WesternRegion, did not place a limit on how many people may accept his offer.The ground transportation, lodging and other related expenses willbe the responsibility of the participants. Persons interestedin participating should email their contact informationto:auditHAAF@thetruthmustbetold.com.Ara K. Manoogian is a human rights activist representing the ShahanNatalie Family Foundation, Inc. in Artsakh and Armenia; a Fellow ofthe Washington, D.C.-based Policy Forum Armenia (PFA); creator ofhttp://www.thetruthmustbetold.com/. Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Arpa Posted December 21, 2013 Report Share Posted December 21, 2013 (edited) All this is horse feathers.Dear Mr. Baghdassarian, please tell us how much of that 22 million is already in your pocket.22 million for a one lane highway of less than 50 miles?That kind of money will be enough to construct a 4 lane highway from here to Glendale.Besides.Who guarantees that those so called “occupied territories” will permanently stay “LIBERATED”?Those less than 2 million citizen of the Yerevan Province, who like rats are still abandoning the ship. Edited December 21, 2013 by Arpa Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Arpa Posted December 21, 2013 Report Share Posted December 21, 2013 (edited) Also. Can we see pictures of that so called North-South Highway that we paid for a few telethons ago?Is this it? Can we see someone driving there?http://www.colourbox.com/preview/3561494-273346-road-under-construction.jpghttp://www.colourbox.com/preview/3561494-273346-road-under-construction.jpghttp://www.armeniafundusa.org/projects/north-south.htmWhy do everyone from Glendale to Gavar think we are fools?What kind of fools do they take us for?What kind of fools are we? Songwriters: ANTHONY NEWLEY, LESLIE BRICUSSEWhat kind of fool am IWho never fell in loveIt seems that I'm the only oneThat I have been thinking ofWhat kind of man is thisAn empty shellA lonely cell in whichAn empty heart must dwellWhat kind of lips are theseThat lied with every kissThat whispered empty words of loveThat left me alone like thisWhy can't I fall in loveLike any other manAnd maybe then I'll knowWhat kind of fool I amWhat kind of clown am IWhat do I know of lifeWhy can't I cast awayThis mask of playAnd live my lifeWhy can't I fall in loveTill I don't give a damnAnd maybe then I'll knowWhat kind of fool I am Edited December 21, 2013 by Arpa Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Yervant1 Posted December 10, 2014 Report Share Posted December 10, 2014 DIASPORA IS DISSATISFIED WITH THE ARMENIAN AUTHORITIESVestnik Kavkaza, RussiaDec 9 20149 December 2014 - 11:57amSusanna Petrosian, Yerevan. Exclusively to Vestnik KavkazaIn late November in the state of California another telethon ofArmenian Fund "Hayastan" (Pan-Armenian Fund) took place and collectedabout $12,399,550 in donations that are planned to be directed forthe implementation of a number of special development programs forArmenia and Nagorno-Karabakh. The telethon in California was precededby the 15th Pan-European Fundraiser of the Pan-Armenan Fund, that wasattended by Armenians in France, Germany, Belgium, Greece and othercountries, who donated about 1.37 million euros.Headed by the President of Armenia, the Pan-Armenian Fund wasestablished in 1992 for implementation of national projectsof development of infrastructure and the cities of Armenia andNagorno-Karabakh. Since 1996, the Fund has annually held 12-hourtelethons in November in Los-Angeles, which aim to raise funds, andmost importantly - an ambitious program that aims to unite Armeniansaround a single idea. During this period many roads were built andrepaired, the water supply system improved in a number of settlements,new sports and cultural centers were constructed, over 150 educational,cultural and scientific programs were realized.Meanwhile, compared with previous years, this year much fewerdonations were collected. Thus, the amount of donations at the endof the telethon in 2013 reached 22,661372 dollars. This obstacle hasled a number of experts in Armenia and some members of the Diasporato start thinking.One of the indicators of the possible new trend has become a protest inLos Angeles on the eve of the telethon. A group of activists wearingT-shirts reading "We are boycotting the Armenian Fund, collect taxes,not donations" distributed to the participants of the charity dinnerwhich usually precedes the telethon leaflets urging people not tomake donations in any case."We are against this fundraising, it would be better if the Armeniangovernment properly collected taxes from oligarchs, not organizea fundraiser. The amount of unpaid taxes is much bigger than whatis collected through donations. Armenia does not need donations,but normal leadership," one of the protesters Ara Manukian said. Hebelieves that construction of roads, the school repairing processand other programs that are implemented with the money collected bythe fund, are the responsibility of the government of Armenia andNagorno-Karabakh, which must solve these issues through the collectionof taxes.The Member of the Central Board of the Social Democratic Party"Hunchak", Ambiq Sarafian, assumes that every year in the diasporafrustration increases and the enthusiasm with which donations aremade decreases. In his opinion, an important role in this situation isplayed by the lack of confidence in the Armenian leaders, the internalpolitical situation, the poor social situation of the majority ofthe population in Armenia and the reigning atmosphere of impunityand injustice, that is reflected in the dominance of monopolies,the enormous influence of the oligarchs, and most importantly -in the complete indifference of the authorities."Annually collected by the fund, the amount of money that is inthe range of between 20-30 million dollars is nothing by itself,considering inflation and other social and economic factors inArmenia," the representative of the Armenian community in the US said.Of course, it is necessary to say that such moods in the Diaspora arenot widespread. The largest and most influential Armenian organizationsin the USA, including the Armenian Church in the United States,the Armenian Charity Foundation, the public organization "ArmenianAssembly of America" and "The Armenian National Committee of America"do not oppose the collected donations or the policy of the Armenianauthorities.Despite the position of these influential organizations in the behaviorof certain circles of the Diaspora, a trend based on sharp criticismof the policy of the Yerevan authorities and distrust of the leadersof Armenia is beginning to appear. Certain circles in the Diasporabelieve that the funds raised by the Pan-Armenian Fund are not spenttransparently. It is also important that such moods as evidenced bythe protest in Los Angeles have never occurred before.It is possible that the proportion of people in the Diaspora who leftArmenia relatively recently -10-20 years ago - plays a role in theappearance of the new trend. Secondly, which is very important, themeans of communication have changed. That is, today, unlike the 80sor 90s, you can see mass rallies in Yerevan on the internet. Peoplein the Diaspora have become better informed about the situation inArmenia, that is not unique to the authorities.http://vestnikkavkaza.net/analysis/politics/63099.html Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.