MosJan Posted February 20, 2002 Report Share Posted February 20, 2002 THE GHOSTS OF ARMENIA There are ghosts in the office of state Controller Carl McCall --ghosts from another time and place that could wind up haunting the next gubernatorial campaign, the New York Daily News writes. “Like any good ghost story, this one begins long ago. Back before World War I, when Turkey was still the Ottoman Empire, enterprising agents of the New York Life Insurance Co. began peddling policies there. They signed up 8,000 clients, half of them Armenian merchants. The attraction was obvious. A lot of these Armenians had relatives in the United States, and some planned to move there themselves. Most of them never made it. In 1915, the Ottoman Turks began the first genocide of the 20th century. More than a million Armenians were murdered. Eventually, the empire itself collapsed and was replaced by a secular Turkish government. By 1922, the New York Life Insurance Co. was aware that most of its Armenian policyholders were dead. One of its executives dryly informed the U.S. State Department that they had been "prematurely terminated" by "massacre. "The new Turkish rulers cast an envious eye on the insurance money. They argued that the dead Armenian policyholders would have been Turkish citizens if they had survived. Since they hadn't, their estates should go to the government. New York Life rejected this macabre proposal. The company settled the individual claims it could verify and closed the books. Over the years, when other claimants came forward, the company had a simple demand: Show me the paper. Since the Ottomans hadn't given their victims death certificates, and the new Turkish government – its own claims denied -- refused to admit genocide had occurred, there was no way claims could be documented. The company considered this tough luck. One of the supposed beneficiaries was a woman named Yegsa Marootian. She began making inquiries about her brother's policy around 1920.Almost 80 years later, her son Martin was still asking. In 1999, by now an old man, Martin Marootian filed a class-action suit against the company in California. New York Life was forced to admit it held 2,200 unpaid Armenian policies. It offered to settle with Marootian and other claimants for 10 times face value, up to a total of $10 million. Marootian turned the offer down flat. His case is now in Federal Court in Los Angeles. It's unlikely he'll live to see a penny. Others may be more fortunate. In the course of the Marootian case, Armenian community leaders noticed something interesting: New York Life did not claim that it had turned the uncollected insurance money over to New York State, as required by law. New York Life says that it long ago turned over the Armenian policies to a French company, and that it owes nothing. But McCall evidently had his doubts. Last year, the controller's office informed an attorney for the Washington-based Armenian National Institute, Jacob Toumayan, that an audit of New York Life's Armenian accounts would begin in the late spring of 2002. Toumayan was recently told that it has been moved up and is in fact underway. Will the inquiry be completed by Election Day? The controller's office refuses to even discuss its audits, let alone their motivation and timing. This leaves the way open for cynics to speculate that the audit might have something to do with the fact that there are 75,000Armenian-Americans in New York State. Me, I'd rather believe that McCall simply wants to do the right thing and give a 90-year-old ghost story a happy ending. © Copyright AZG Quote Link to comment Share on other sites More sharing options...
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.