-
Posts
32,837 -
Joined
-
Last visited
-
Days Won
333
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by MosJan
-
ՔՐԻՍՏՈՍ ՅԱՐԵԱՎ Ի ՄԵՌԵԼՈՑ
-
inchpes asum er HamaZasp@ - Qaraqakan gortsichner@ "poYnikner" en
-
The New York Times: Events of 1915 were not a “massacre”, it was genocide 07.04.2007 14:18 GMT+04:00 Print version Send to mail In Russian In Armenian /PanARMENIAN.Net/ By the decision of The New York Times’ editorial council in 2004, events of 1915 fall under the definition of “genocide” and when publishing articles over this subject the editorial staff will always use the word “genocide”. A headline on April 5 about a planned vote in Congress over the Armenian Genocide Resolution, the widespread killing of Armenians by the Ottoman Turkish government early in the 20th century incorrectly described the killings, in which 1.5 million Armenians died. The editorial of the Newspaper has made clear it was genocide, not a “massacre.” The same definition concerns a March 29 article titled “Armenian Genocide Resolution has infuriated Turkey”, where the Armenian Genocide of 1915 was described as “massacre”.
-
tarorinak@ gites incha ? - yerb Sevan t@gherq@ Ishxan xostatsan brnel vor yerekoyan Anush aneyinq - asetsy che et l@jum qani hata mnatsel or duk uzzum eq brneq menq el anush anenq - isk hima nstel ishxan utluts em xosum Tarorinak ~ Tarorinak MArd Ararats
-
http://www.newsbull.com/forum/topic.asp?TOPIC_ID=11256
-
Younes & Soraya Nazarian ? are also names that i have found that have gave donations left and right
-
also see http://www.jewishjournal.com/home/preview.php?id=17270 i don;t know if it's the same person but in many Blogs - Armenians and azeris are fighting over is Nazarian is or not Armenian - so take your time and search
-
Investor Sam Nazarian Contracts with Philippe Starck to Design Miami's Ritz Plaza Hotel By Douglas Hanks III, The Miami Herald Knight Ridder/Tribune Business News Dec. 10, 2004 - Celebrity designer Philippe Starck's surreal interiors still define the Delano, South Beach's most famous hotel. Nearly a decade later, Starck is returning to South Beach to design another hotel -- across the street from his original creation. The new owners of the Ritz Plaza hotel have signed Starck as their designer, his first South Florida hotel commission since the Delano, whose 1995 opening launched the minimalist aesthetic that remains the South Beach standard. Ritz Plaza's owners say Starck plans an updated version of his take on the style South Beach needs -- one that's warmer than the Delano's famed white-on-white look. "I don't think we're going to go for -- to use the pun -- as 'stark' a design," said Paul Makarechian, one of the developers. "It will have a little bit more of a connection with old Europe. It won't be as modern, I guess is a way of saying it." During a brief interview last week, Starck sniffed at the notion of comparing his new project to the Delano. But with the two oceanfront properties standing 20 paces apart at 17th Street and Collins Avenue, competition seems inevitable. And the new owners are seeking the same kind of hip star power that fuels the Delano. Their main investor, Sam Nazarian, is a 29-year nightclub owner and movie producer from Los Angeles who recently paid $12.5 million for Jennifer Lopez's Beverly Hills mansion. And he seems willing to take on Ian Schrager, the iconic hotelier who hired Starck for the Delano and a number of his other hotels. "You look at the Delano -- it was built 10 years ago and a penny hasn't been spent since," Nazarian said. Turning to another Ian Schrager hotel not designed by Starck, Nazarian added: "The Shore Club -- I'll let you be the judge of what that is." Schrager did not respond to an e-mail asking for comment on Starck's latest venture, and a publicist also declined to reply to an interview request this week. Starck, a 55-year-old French designer, has only been linked with one South Florida project since the Delano -- the Related Group's new South Beach condominium tower, Icon. In between, he has emerged as one of the country's most famous designers, largely for the line of household goods he created for Target. Schrager made Starck sign a noncompete contract that would have barred the designer from working in South Beach, but that agreement expired in recent years, according to Nazarian, who said he has hired Starck to design seven L.A. restaurants for him. At the Delano, Starck created a mix of whimsy (a giant purple settee couch sits on the far wall of the hotel's lobby) and sterility (the rooms have white walls, white floors, white beds, white chairs and white TVs). Its 1995 opening drew a six-page spread in Vanity Fair and prompted Herald writers to describe the hotel's look as both "urgent chic" and "chromatic cold turkey." At Icon's debut party Friday, Starck told The Herald that the Ritz Plaza will not resemble what he created at the Delano. "It will be completely different. Because it's 20 years later," he said, inadvertently aging the Delano by a decade. The new owners of the 1940 hotel have filed preliminary drawings with Miami Beach's Historic Preservation Board, and some bear the stamp of Starck's design firm. But they seem to offer only fleeting hints of what he might have in mind for his South Beach sequel. A pool deck features a three-story mirror towering over a teak deck, the patios draped in ivy. The lobby would have fireplaces and wood paneling and metal railings. A marble-topped table accents one room's entry way. But the drawings do not say whether these were Starck creations or just placeholders until he puts his stamp on the plans. The developers are coy about describing too much. "We want to surprise everybody," Nazarian said, before returning to the development group's refrain. "It's going to be a complete night-and-day difference with what he did with the Delano." The owners bought the 132-room 1940 hotel this summer from Ignacio Contreras and Starwood Hotels & Resorts Worldwide. Starwood hoped to build a W hotel there but was blocked by the Delano, which sued over the shadow the hotel's seven-story tower would cast. Makarechian's group plans a five-story "residence club" between the existing hotel building and the ocean, with 23 time-share units selling in three-month intervals. No prices have been announced, but the resort -- to be run by boutique-operator Kimpton Hotels, the new operator of Coconut Grove's Mayfair hotel -- would open in early 2006 after extensive renovations. It has been closed since the new owners bought it; Nazarian said the price was close to $30 million, with development costs expected to run about $70 million. Makarechian's development company, the Newport Beach, Calif.-based Makar Properties, also owns the St. Regis Monarch Beach Resort in California. Nazarian said his father, Younes, helped found Qualcomm, the $2 billion-a-year chip maker, launching his son on a successful real-estate career. The younger Nazarian's holding company owns 83 percent stake in the Ritz Plaza project, according to documents on file with Miami Beach. Nazarian said the Ritz Plaza planned to lead South Beach in luxury service -- including Rolls Royce pick-ups from the airport. But he said he wants the Ritz Plaza to come in with rates just below the Delano, where a peak-season room is running between $400 and $900 a night. During his brief interview amid the throngs of Icon guests wanting to meet him -- one middle-aged woman stared and said: You're so cool -- Starck said he did not have time to detail his plans for the Ritz Plaza. But he rejected the idea that the public would hold his new hotel up to his most famous one. "People can say what they want," he said. "But we don't need to compare
-
HOllywood Hills Entrepreneur Sam Nazarian Thursday, April 28, 2005 11:35 PM PDT Interview by Caroline Ryder Entrepreneur Sam Nazarian may be just 29, but his Midas touch is already more finely tuned than most. Since launching his first business aged just 20, Nazarian has created some of SoCal's trendiest hang-outs, including the clubs Shelter and Prey, Yu Restaurant & Lounge in Santa Monica, the Viceroy hotels in Santa Monica and Palm Springs. In a move that will "profoundly affect Southern California's social scene", Nazarian's SBE Entertainment Group recently announced an exclusive contract with acclaimed designer Philippe Starck to develop a host of new entertainment destinations in the area. But he isn't just about the bottom line n Nazarian believes in giving back too, and is a supporter of the newly formed Society of Young Philanthropists, which aims to inspire local youth to contribute to society. We met with Nazarian at his sumptuous home (formerly owned by J Lo) in the Hollywood Hills. How do you balance all your different interests? Good question! I work 16 hours a day, six or seven days a week. Every company I started has its own president COO, CFO and we've just got to manage their growth. I also have a great team around me. What's the most valuable lesson that you've learned about business? Having a good team. I think that it's important. And being authentic to every project that you do, as in understanding the marketing, the demographic and really picking a niche in every project, whether it's a new film, the location of a club, a hotel or real estate. Whatever it is, if you're making a movie or building a building, it's the same thing. You need a great foundation. And really having the infrastructure around you and team members who have 20/30 years experience in their field. Letting people flourish without hindering their ability to perform in their field. You're very young to have achieved this kind of success: have you found your youth has been a help or a hindrance as a businessman? It can be a hindrance when people first meet you. But I think pretty quick, they realize that we have a great vision. Youth can be a benefit, an added value, because many people want to be around a growing company, one where everything hasn't been set in stone. They can be part of something from the ground up. I started real young, so in many cases people don't believe my age. Ultimately when people get to know me, they realize that there is a lot more depth to me than is reflected by just my years. Were you always older than your years? Yes. Being youngest of four, I always wanted to be independent and I tended to put myself around a lot of older people. I was always in love with business when I was young. When I was 13 I used to lie to people and say I was 16 and 17. When it was spring break and winter vacation, I would work in delis. I just loved the thrill of working. That's what got me excited. When my friends were going off to summer camp, I was cleaning the floors of my father's factory. I loved it. I just loved getting the check. I always wanted to do it on my own so I never really got an allowance. I was always involved in some hustle. The nightclub scene is incredibly fickle n how do you stay ahead of the game? A city like New York lends itself to having a lot of clubs because it's geared towards a downtown. LA is different because it's a mixture of communities, from the beach to Hollywood and Downtown. The zoning means that every community has a center, surrounded by residential areas. So there isn't one driving area of force in Los Angeles, apart from maybe the Sunset Strip or Ocean Avenue. But LA doesn't have a Soho or meatpacking district or a Chelsea. A lot of people come here and have a concept they think will work, but they soon realize it doesn't. Things like the outdoors component, valet, and an understanding of the strict licensing laws are important. On Sunset Strip there are only two nightclubs that have dance licenses. The reason those licensing laws are so tough is because the homeowner communities here are very powerful compared to New York or London. For the most part, life in LA is not geared towards mixed use society. We pretty much control all of West Hollywood's and the Strip's dance licenses, most of which were grandfathered in. We've marked off that territory. So now, every new club or promoter has to go deep in to Hollywood. So we're living in a party-pooper kind of town? You'll have to ask the community about that. The dance license or liquor licenses mean there's going to be dancing and noise up until 2am. By controlling the number of licenses that are granted, the residents are controlling their sanity. For instance, we have the only liquor license on Montana. And there will never be another one. We are the only ones that can serve vodka. Is there a consortium of nightclub owners who are looking to have the 2am close abolished in LA? We have tried making some in roads, but have got a lot of resistance back. Nightclub owners are always perceived as not being very high on the rung, so they generally don't think they have any political influence. But when I think about how much more tax revenue the state would collect just by extending opening hours from 2 to 4am…And the young, the people who want the change, don't really get involved in actually fighting for these things. We met with Governor Schwarzenegger and he said he'll see…but that all he could say. Do you see the laws changing any time soon? I don't see any momentum in that right now. So what's your long-term vision? By the end of '06, and in early 07, our aim is to have re-landscaped LA. We're working with Philippe Starck, making new investments in creating nightclubs, nightclubs with a food component, very high end restaurants and hotels so we're pretty much hitting all angles of what people want to experience. The components of that vision are service, design, sophistication, world class chefs, customer tracking and follow up. The ability to track your habits when you go to our sushi place on Ocean versus our steak place on Sunset. Where you like to sit, and so on. Following your habits through an ID number, like what happens in Vegas. When you go to Vegas they know what you drink, how much you gamble, which room you like to stay in, what liquor you like…something that has never been done before here. Let's talk about the Young Philanthropists n you recently made a $10,000 donation to them. How long have you been involved with the charity? One of the Young Philanthropists' founders is a very good friend of mine. He came into my office a while back and told me his vision. What got me excited was that it's a way of getting our generation involved. He's trying to regenerate a movement within successful kids aged between 21 and 35 who are usually more focused on work, relationships and what they wear, rather than giving. They have a current message of "let's help, let's just give back, it's cool to give back… don't wait until you re 40, 50, 60 years old to do it!" I love being able to support that kind of movement as opposed to giving to just one cause. We figure if people are going to start giving when they are 40, 50 and so on, think what a difference it would make if they started giving 20 or 30 years earlier. For more information on The Society of Young Philanthropists visit the website: www.philanthropysociety.org.
-
1. Tulia (2008) (pre-production) (executive producer) 2. College (2007) (filming) (executive producer) 3. Last Resort (2007) (post-production) (executive producer) 4. Mr. Brooks (2007) (completed) (executive producer) 5. Pride (2007) (executive producer) 6. The Last Time (2006) (executive producer) 7. Five Fingers (2006) (executive producer) 8. Down in the Valley (2005) (executive producer) 9. Waiting... (2005) (executive producer) 10. Trespassing (2004) (executive producer) ... aka Evil Remains (USA) 11. The Beautiful Country (2004) (executive producer) 12. Home of Phobia (2004) (executive producer) ... aka Freshman Orientation (USA: new title) Self: 1. 20 Hippest Hot Spots (2005) (TV) .... Himself
-
Kcet - Lost Treasures Of Christianity: Ancient Monuments
MosJan replied to MosJan's topic in Events & Action Alerts
The Ombudsman Column Coming Soon to Viewers Like You: "The Armenian Genocide" By Michael Getler March 17, 2006 On Monday evening, April 17, many PBS-affiliated television stations across the country — including nine of the top 10 TV markets — will air an hour-long documentary on "The Armenian Genocide" produced by the independent, New York-based filmmaker Andrew Goldberg. The new documentary deals with an old, and very sore, subject: the deaths, mostly between 1915 and 1918, of anywhere from several hundred thousand to perhaps 1.5 million Armenian civilians living in the eastern Anatolia region of Turkey during the rule of the "Young Turks" of the Ottoman Empire as World War I engulfed Europe. The program will air a week before the annual "Armenian Remembrance Day" is marked in this country. PBS officials, in a statement, said they "accepted 'The Armenian Genocide' for the schedule based on its merits and because the information it presents is an important part of recent world history. Implicit in PBS's decision to accept" the film for distribution, the statement says, is PBS's "recognition that the overwhelming majority of historians have concluded that a genocide took place." Nevertheless, despite that recognition, PBS also went ahead and commissioned Oregon Public Broadcasting to produce a 25-minute panel discussion — which is already taped and scheduled to air immediately after the documentary — that includes two scholars who support the view implicit in the film's title, and two who question, among other things, the accuracy and use of the label "genocide." The panel discussion is called "The Armenian Genocide: Exploring the Issues." It is moderated by National Public Radio correspondent Scott Simon. The New York Times quoted Lea Sloan, PBS's vice president for media relations, as saying the network "acknowledges and accepts that there was a genocide." But it ordered the panel discussion, she told the Times, to explore more deeply the question of why the Turkish government and its supporters continue to reject the genocide label. A PBS statement later added that "the specific intent is to examine the question of how historians can come to such radically divergent conclusions about these events. An important part of the mission of public television is to engender responsible discussion and illuminate complex issues." Turkey has acknowledged that millions of people died — Muslims, Christians and Jews — in the waning years of the Ottoman Empire, which ended in the early 1920s when the Republic of Turkey was established. But it has also always vehemently denied that a planned, systematic extermination, or genocide, of the Christian Armenians took place. A few scholars, including some in the U.S., also hold this view. Turkey is an overwhelmingly Muslim country but, unlike most, it has a strong tradition of separation of church and state. Turkey is also perhaps this country's most important ally in the Muslim world, although its parliament, when the chips were down three years ago, did not allow the U.S. Army's 4th Infantry Division to use its ports to get to Iraq in time for the invasion. (That action, and the Pentagon's failure to secure Turkish agreement beforehand, remains, in my view, one of the bigger blunders of the war's planning.) If It's Genocide, What Is There to Discuss? The addition by PBS of a panel discussion in which people who are described, by their critics, as "genocide deniers" are given air time has provoked an outpouring of outrage from the Armenian-American community. They view it as "perverse," among other things, for PBS officials to acknowledge the historical view of the genocide and then have a panel including those who deny it. Current.org, the bi-weekly newspaper covering public television in the U.S., reported on March 6 that about 4,000 e-mails protesting the panel show (it's about 6,000 now, according to the latest PBS figures) and 2,000 supporting it had been received by PBS, and that an online petition to cancel the panel had some 16,000 names attached at the time. Pressure to cancel the panel also has come from two Democratic congressmen where there are large Armenian-American communities — Rep. Anthony Weiner from Brooklyn in New York City, and Rep. Adam. B. Schiff, whose California district includes Pasadena and Burbank, just outside Los Angeles. Several key PBS-affiliated stations have said they do not intend to show the panel discussion. Current.org also reported on March 6 that of PBS stations in the top 10 markets, only those in Chicago and Houston plan to air the follow-up panel. In New York, the broadcasting director of the high-profile WNET/Thirteen said it would air the documentary, which he described as having "a solid journalistic approach to the subject matter," but that it was decided to reject the panel after it was screened by senior staffers there. "The follow-up (panel) made no new points to the case outlined in the documentary, added nothing substantive and was, in general a weak program," he said. By the time of their decision, "public opinion and public display had accelerated among other people who had seen neither the documentary nor the follow-up. But we made a conscious decision to stick to our original editorial instincts, despite the pressure we were getting from outside sources both to carry and not to carry either the documentary or the follow-up." Goldberg, the filmmaker, told reporter Paul Farhi of The Washington Post that he didn't think the panel was necessary, "but I didn't fight it. It wasn't up to me and I had nothing to do with its production." He told Current.org, "I knew that for our film we had done our homework six ways from Sunday. Every fact was quadruple-checked and had been vetted by so many people — historians, journalists — that I knew there was no way that the after-show was an interpretation of our reporting." Earlier, the Los Angeles Times reported that residents of that city, which has the largest ethnic Armenian community outside Armenia, will not get to see either the documentary or the panel on KCET-TV. Rather, the station has decided to broadcast a new French-made documentary on the subject, "Le Genocide Armenien," a decision that Goldberg described as "bizarre." Farhi of The Post, who was perhaps the first to call attention to this brewing controversy over the panel, especially, reported that the $650,000 budget for the documentary was partly funded by Armenian-Americans. Writing, But Not Seeing In my role here as ombudsman, I've made it a rule to come at issues that are raised by viewers, and as a viewer. I don't write about programs until after they have aired. I watch them as you would. So in this case, I have not yet seen either the documentary or the panel, although both have been recorded for some time now. And with few exceptions, the people raising a fuss — and they are on both sides of this "genocide" issue — haven't seen the actual programs either. The battle is really over whether the panel should be aired at all. Yet I decided to write about it, in this preliminary stage, because the circumstances surrounding this matter, the decision-making by PBS and affiliated stations, the issues being raised and the pressures being applied by interest groups strike me as concerning free speech and the responsibilities that go with that freedom. They also remind me just slightly about the journalistic debate in this country a few weeks ago about whether to publish or show those offending cartoons depicting the Prophet Muhammad to newspaper readers or television reviewers here. This was months after they had been first published by a Danish newspaper and at a time when they had become the rationale for rioting and killing around the world by Muslim extremists and a very big news story. My feeling about the cartoons, as I wrote in an earlier column, was that readers and viewers who wanted to see them — rather than just have some editor describe them in words — and understand visually what this rioting was all about ought to be able to view them. I thought that those few U.S. newspapers and television networks that did find a way to do that, did so with context and with no disrespect for religion, while maintaining their respect for this country's news values. I thought newspaper Web sites, especially, offered a way to display one or two of the cartoons without putting them in the printed paper so that people who did not want to see them, or who would be offended, would not randomly come across them. I said I thought PBS had also handled the issue skillfully as a news story on the nightly "NewsHour with Jim Lehrer." The forthcoming presentation of "The Armenian Genocide" and the follow-up panel have not been accompanied by violence or threats. But it does involve some questions and background that seem worth noting and thinking about in advance. A Pretty Solid Judgment I am not an authority on this subject at all. But from what reading and research I've been able to do in anticipation of the program/panel, PBS seems clearly correct when it states that "the overwhelming majority of historians have concluded that a genocide took place." The Encyclopedia Britannica, for example, says that, "In what would later be known as the first genocide of the 20th century, hundreds of thousands of Armenians were driven from their homes, massacred, or marched until they died." The online encyclopedia, Wikipedia, says that, "Several facts in connection with the event are a matter of ongoing dispute between parts of the international community and Turkey. Although it is generally agreed that events said to comprise what is termed the Armenian Genocide did occur, the Turkish government rejects that it was genocide on the alleged basis that the deaths among the Armenians were not a result of a state-sponsored plan of mass extermination, but from the result of inter-ethnic strife, disease and famine during the turmoil of World War I. "Despite this thesis," it continues, "most Armenian, Western, and an increasing number of Turkish scholars believe that the massacres were a case of genocide. The event is also said to be the second-most studied case of genocide, and often draws comparison with the Holocaust" against the Jews in Nazi Germany. "To date 24 countries have officially recognized and accepted its authenticity as Genocide," the Wikipedia reports. There is also, the encyclopedia states: "a general agreement among Western historians that the Armenian Genocide did happen. The International Association of Genocide Scholars (the major body of scholars who study genocide in North America and Europe), for instance, formally recognize the event and consider it to be undeniable. Some consider denial to be a form of hate speech or/and historical revisionism. "However, this academic recognition has not always been followed by governments and media. Many governments, including the United States, the United Kingdom and Israel, do not officially use the word genocide to describe these events, due in part to their strong political and commercial ties with Turkey, although some individual government officials have used the term." In her widely acclaimed, Pulitzer Prize-winning book, "A Problem from Hell: America and the Age of Genocide," author Samantha Power lays out the evidence of the genocide against the Armenians at the time that was headline news in The New York Times, and the strenuous but unsuccessful efforts of the U.S. ambassador to the Ottoman Empire, Henry Morgenthau Sr., to get President Woodrow Wilson to intervene. In that book, Power writes that "America's nonresponse to the Turkish horrors established patterns that would be repeated." The modern American official approach remains strained. Although some 37 U.S. states have, by legislation or proclamation, recognized the Armenian genocide, and in 2000 a resolution made it through a key House of Representatives committee for the first time, a resolution has not made its way through the full House or the U.S. Senate. *See correction at the end of this column. In 1981, President Reagan was the last American president to use the term genocide referring to the Armenians in a remembrance proclamation. The first President Bush talked about the "terrible massacres" and President Clinton talked about "a great tragedy of the twentieth century: the deportations and massacres of roughly one and a half million Armenians," and the current President Bush talked about "annihilation, forced exile and murder." But they have stayed away officially from the G-word, although Paul Glastris, editor of the Washington Monthly, wrote in The Washington Post in 2001 that George W. Bush, as a candidate, wrote to Armenian-American groups about the earlier "genocidal campaign." Last June, Glenn Kessler of the Post reported that the American Foreign Service Association had honored the U.S. Ambassador to Armenia, John M. Evans, for publicly characterizing the mass killings as genocide but then withdrew the honor. Evans' comments stirred such a diplomatic tempest, Kessler reported, that the diplomat had to retract his remarks and later even clarify the retraction. But Was It Genocide? The American scholar most associated with questioning the genocide is Justin A. McCarthy, a history professor at the University of Louisville in Kentucky. He, along with a Turkish scholar, will be one of the two panelists challenging the genocide designation. McCarthy does not appear in the documentary. He recently told Farhi of The Post that the history of that period is complex and does not lend itself to simple judgments and labels and that calling the documentary "The Armenian Genocide" is "a false description of a complicated history." He said he could not find evidence of 1.5 million Armenian deaths and also said three million Turks died during that same period. "If saying both sides killed each other makes me a genocide denier, then I'm a denier." My apologies for the length of this column, but it's nothing compared to what's been written about this. And, at the risk of exhausting your patience, what follows is a list of questions I submitted to top PBS officials and their answers. In some cases the answers are slightly abbreviated, with permission. Q — One assumes that a documentary by a skilled producer will produce the fullest exploration and informed judgment on an issue, that it would be PBS's statement on this long-running, hot-button issue. So why, exactly, did PBS feel the need to do a panel? What was the reasoning behind it? That assumption is faulty. No one-hour documentary, no matter how skillfully produced, can be said to represent the fullest exploration of such a topic. This is why PBS's editorial standards have long included the goal to seek a diversity of perspectives on controversial subjects in the national schedule over time. In this case, we judged THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE to be a credible documentary on a significant and little-covered event. We worked with the producer through his final editing to ensure that the program met our standards. We, through Oregon Public Broadcasting, vetted its content with a historian and journalist unconnected with the show. While we were satisfied that it was fair and accurate, because the fact of genocide is still contested in terms the documentary could only mention in brief, we commissioned a panel discussion that could explore the issues in greater nuance and detail. Q — Whose idea was it to have a panel; what was the process that led to this decision, who was involved in the decision and who made the decision? There was immediate consensus among the Senior Programming Team that a follow up panel was a good idea. The decision to commission the additional program was made as Andrew Goldberg was finishing the program and as we were in contact with him requesting script revisions. The acceptance of the documentary and the decision to do a follow up was essentially one process. The follow-up program had a carefully articulated goal — not to provide a platform for those interests who deny the genocide, but to explore how serious historians do their work, and how they can look at events and evidence and reach such different conclusions. PBS's chief programmers, John Wilson and Jacoba Atlas, are responsible for the ultimate decision in this case. Q — Did politics enter into the decision, or pressure from the Turks or from anywhere inside or outside PBS? Did it intrude in any way? Turkey is obviously an important ally, is trying to enter the European Union, is a Muslim country. No, the documentary was completed and PBS had commissioned the follow-up long before we were contacted by anyone about the program. We obviously knew of the international controversy surrounding the subject and the attention being focused on Turkey's position and internal laws, and the fact that the U.S. stance on the use of the term "genocide" differs from that of many other nations. It is true that this larger present day status of the issues that stem from the history presented in the documentary provided a compelling rationale in our minds for providing the public with more information on the subject. Q — How common is it for PBS to schedule, in advance, a panel to air immediately after a program? Perhaps you could tell me some other instances and when they took place. There have been several examples in recent years. The P.O.V. presentation of "Two Towns of Jasper" (about the dragging death of a black man in a predominantly white town) was followed by a Ted Koppel-anchored town meeting, which allowed the further exploration of differing and passionate viewpoints engendered by the killing. Each evening's presentation of AVOIDING ARMAGEDDON (a series we ran over four nights) that looked at the dangers of nuclear proliferation) was followed up by a panel discussion led by Frank Sesno allowing the airing of viewpoints not emphasized in the films. TRADE SECRETS, a Bill Moyers investigation of the chemical industry's knowledge of threats to public and workplace safety, was followed up by a discussion with an industry spokesman. Q — Jacoba Atlas has been widely quoted as saying that this is "settled history." By having a panel, does this not suggest that PBS is leaving room for doubt? That a question is generally considered "settled" does not mean that it does not warrant discussion. The fact is there are individuals, organizations and countries (including the United States) that do not see the Armenian Genocide as settled. The panel discussion recognizes that fact and provides, in our opinion, information that should be useful to the public understanding of the issue. Q — Who funded the documentary and the panel? The documentary was fully funded from outside sources — individuals, foundations and corporations. A list is provided at the end of this document. They are credited on screen per our normal disclosure requirements. As is the case with all PBS underwriters, none of these had access to program materials or influence over the production. PBS (the National Programming Service budget) funded the panel. Q — Several news articles have reported, according to Colgate professor Peter Balakian, who was also an adviser on the documentary, that PBS threatened to pull the documentary if he and another genocide scholar declined to participate in the panel discussion. True? **See clarification at the end of the column. This is absolutely not true. If Balakian declined, we would have sought out other historians to speak as experts in Armenian history. Q — Officials at WNET in New York say they made the decision not to air the panel because after reviewing it they felt it made no new points beyond the documentary. What was the PBS assessment of the panel that went into your decision to distribute it? Did PBS consider it to be a worthwhile, substantive addition to the documentary — and if so, in what aspect — or was it automatically linked to the documentary and a commitment to distribute it included in the original programming decision however it came out? We do feel the panel is a worthwhile addition to the documentary — if only because it provided the rare, perhaps unprecedented, occasion for experts holding differing views to be in the same room, let alone a TV studio, participating in a discussion about such sensitively held convictions. Scott Simon did a wonderful job of keeping the discussion on track and asking tough questions of all panelists. And the panelists did provide significant detail beyond that mentioned in the documentary in support of their perspectives. Neither the documentary nor the panel program was designated for common carriage. We respect local stations' decisions to carry both, or one, or neither. There was no automatic imperative to proceed with distributing the panel discussion no matter how it turned out. The programming content team screened the panel program shortly after the taping and felt it did the job we had envisioned. Additional executive staff screened the show, and concurred. Finally, we never believed that this documentary or its follow-up would be the last word on this subject, or bring an end to the generations-old dispute. But, as one of the only institutions in America using media to serve the public, we believe we have to take on tough subjects, even if it means taking heat from both (or all) sides of a given issue. The easier approach — one that most of America's commercial media have employed — is to steer clear of the subject altogether. While easier, we do not believe that approach is in the public's best interest. Underwriters: THE ARMENIAN GENOCIDE ABNOUS, SUZANNE M. AND RAZMIK; ASLANIAN, RICH; AVANESSIANS FAMILY FOUNDATION; BABIKIAN, JEFFREY C.; BALIAN FAMILY FOUNDATION, INC.; BEDROSIAN, MR. JOHN C. & JUDITH D.; CALIFORNIA COMMERCE CLUB; DEMIRJIAN, YERVANT; FALCON MANAGEMENT CORPORATION; GRS MANAGEMENT; HAGOPIAN FAMILY FOUNDATION; HAMPAR, ARMEN AND NORA; HAMPARIAN FAMILY FOUNDATION; KABLANIAN, ADAM; KAZANJIAN BROS.; KECHEJIAN FOUNDATION; KECHEJIAN, SARKIS; KEVORKIAN FOUNDATION, GRGE & ALICE; KHEDERIAN, ROBERT P. AND LORA M.; KOUYOUMDJIAN, HAGOP AND ERANICA; KULHANJIAN STRAUCH FAMILY FDN; LINCY FOUNDATION, THE; MANOOGIAN SIMONE FOUNDATION; MARDIGIAN FOUNDATION; MEKHJIAN, DR. HAROUTUNE & SHAKE FDN; MULLER USA, FRANCK; SIRAN & ANOUSH MATHEVOSIAN CTBL FDN; SOBEL/DUNN FDN, JONATHAN & MARCIA; ST. GREGORY/ ILLUM ARMENIAN CHURCH; UNITED ARMENIAN CHARITIES; VARIOUS; VARIOUS INDIVIDUALS; VARIOUS PRIVATE FOUNDATIONS; WAGNER, JEANETTE S. AND PAUL A. So . . . . . . where does this preliminary back and forth about the still unseen documentary and panel discussion leave me? More illuminated but still uneasy about a couple of things, given the intense pressures exerted by both sides. One is the participation of Armenian-Americans in the funding of the documentary; not because I fear they had any influence or because I don't trust PBS and the producer to prevent any influence, but because it would just be better to not have it. I know money is tight and I don't know how this would get funded otherwise, but there it is; a factor in my head. Another involves the different assessment of the panel's value by WNET in New York. The panel was funded by PBS and PBS officials offer worthy explanations of why they felt the need for it. My presumption is that the one-hour documentary does explore, at least in some fashion, the case against the genocide label. The officials at WNET, who reviewed the panel discussion, said they didn't think it made any new points to the case outlined in the documentary and added nothing substantive. The producer, Andrew Goldberg, said he didn't see any need for a panel. So the documentary, that the Armenians don't seem to object to going in, is funded partly by the Armenians. Then the panel, which they clearly don't want, is funded by PBS. So one could argue, as PBS does, that the public is best served by the combination. But if the documentary does indeed explore the other side, and the panel doesn't add anything, as WNET suggests, that would raise anew questions about why the panel was felt to be necessary. My instincts, without having seen anything, are with PBS's desire to have the fullest airing possible of this historic event. But let's wait and see. _____________________________________________________________________________________________ * Harut Sassounian, publisher of The California Courier, serving the Armenian-American community, wrote to say that, "Both in 1975 and 1984 the full House adopted resolutions to observe "a day of remembrance for all the victims of genocide, especially the 1.5 million people of Armenian ancestry who were the victims of the genocide perpetrated in Turkey between 1915 and 1923." ** I would like to correct the misrepresentation of my involvement with the Armenian Genocide documentary in your Ombudsman column of 3/11. In a question you posed to PBS officials you said: "Q — Several news articles have reported, according to Colgate professor Peter Balakian, who was also an adviser on the documentary, that PBS threatened to pull the documentary if he and another genocide scholar declined to participate in the panel discussion. True?" That is a false description. What I have told several journalists in the past month is the following: I was told (in fact three times) by Oregon PBS producer David Davis that PBS would not run the documentary if a post-show panel with deniers were not made. Mr. Davis made it clear that this was the direct word from Jacoba Atlas at national headquarters. (I had sent her a letter in November appealing to her to drop the idea of a post-show on ethical and historical grounds.) I never said nor implied that the documentary would not air if I personally were not on the panel. That would be, of course, absurd. Naturally, PBS would find someone else to take my place. After all my efforts to convince PBS to not produce a post-show failed I decided to go forward with the "debate" because I have experience in discussing this subject on TV and radio and felt I could help shape the conversation in an ethical way and perhaps a way that would expose Turkish denial more fully for what it is . . . Sincerely, Peter Balakian Donald M. and Constance H. Rebar Professor of the Humanities Colgate University Correction and clarification posted March 22, 2006 -
i'm gonna order some and have my shop painted it's annoying wan you say haw can i help you and you customer is Yapping on the phone & chewing gum at the same time
-
Yervant@ jisht e !!! Zartonq Gonyag@ chiMornas
-
etpes chi lin barekam inchpes xoses Ishxani masin yerb iyn arjevt che iy yerb 1 hat Ishxan beres amen mekis - bes seghanin Xorrovats arats - et jamanak el k@xosenq te che ari yev hishi te ishxan@ vor mekn er inch er eti dzuka ? chem hishum
-
NIce Nire he is just use to taking cheep shuts at Armenians
-
NAKHIJEVAN AS A PART OF ARMENIA - A MISTAKE OR...? * On the front cover of an audio CD with the national anthems of Turkish republics, published by the Ministry of Culture and Tourism of Turkey, Nakhijevan, Nagorno-Karabakh and the security area are drawn as a part of the Republic of Armenia. Azerbaijani mass media report that the first to notice the mistake was the Turkish Embassy in Azerbaijan. "Such a rough mistake can cause serious diplomatic misunderstanding," says the Embassy's message. The Culture Ministry of Turkey replied that it is a mere misprint and promised to correct it.
-
IMPOSSIBLE TO CONVINCE US CONGRESS THAT ARMENIAN ALLEGATIONS OF GENOCIDE ARE GROUNDLESS * On February 22 "Azg" reported that Ankara had an intention to send 3 Meclis delegations to Washington in order to start lobbying activity against the Resolution on the Armenian Genocide. The first two delegations paid their visits on February 25-March 4 and March 11-18. The visit of the second delegation is appointed on April 14-21. very little was reported in the Turkish press about the mission of the two delegations. On April 2 "Turkiye" newspaper published an article about the third delegation's mission, based upon the information received from the Armenian Studies Institute, Ankara. Seemingly the most important of the three Turkish parliamentary delegations is the last one, which is to be lead by the head of Foreign Relations Commission Dulger. The delegation is to take with it a large number of materials on the Armenian issue - the video recording of the Akhtamar's Surb Khach church inauguration ceremony, audio CDs with the works of Greek, Armenian and Jewish composers, general Mayevsky's notes and the following books: "The Armenian Folder" by Kyamuran Gurun, "The Armenian Question in 1000 Documents" by Mehmed Perincek and "The Armenian Question" by Bilal Simsir. "Turkiye" says that the materials are to be presented to the Congressmen with the words "If we hated the Armenians so much we wouldn't spend 3 millions of our taxpayers' money top restore Akdamar church. The Turkish Music Fund issued one audio CD with works of Jewish and another of Greek composers, and two CDs with the works of the Armenian ones. Our music has much in common. So, it was impossible to commit genocide against the Armenians". What will all this avail in persuading the US Congressmen that the Armenian Genocide is a fiction, none can say yet. Nevertheless Ilter Turkmen, former Foreign Minister of Turkey, whose diplomatic skills were highly estimated in the West, is obviously rather pessimistic on this point. Turkmen in an article published on April 2 in "Huriet" says, "Now its impossible to be sure that the Representatives' Chamber will adopt the Armenian Resolution before April 24. Nonetheless, in case the Resolution is voted on a plenary session of the Chamber, surely it shall gain the majority of votes. Although the White House and the office of the Secretary of State are doing the best to fail the Resolution, even in case the voting is postponed due to pressure of President Bush's board, it will be considered again next year. The annual speech of the US President on April 24 is also not to be neglected. Although the word 'genocide' is never used in the speech, extremely exaggerated statements are made, which are not acceptable for us." Taner Akcam, professor of the Minnesota University, indirectly affirmed Ilter Turkmen's words. Inan inerview to "Zaman" newspaper, published on March 31, he said "I'm not strongly interested in eth Resolution itself. I wish the Congress pass it. This torture must end. Turkey has been doubting for long years, whether it shall be adopted or no. The same has doubted Armenia. Let it pass and let us get rid of it. The resolution will give considerable moral advantage to the Armenians. They will be very excited that one more state has accepted the Genocide. There is no one in the Congress to say that Turkey's actions weren't genocide. They are just unwilling to disappoint Turkey. The matter is not about 1915, but about Incirlik. In case the Resolution is adopted, Turkey shall close the Incirlik military base for the United States. " Akcam also commented on Prime Minister Erdogan's recent initiatives on the Armenian issue. "I hope the Government will be more intended in this question. As for now it is not intended enough. Turkey's problems with Armenia will be settled only after getting rid of such politicians as Yusuf Halacoglu, Gunduz Aktan, Sukru Elektag, who at present determine the governmental policy." * By H. Chaqrian
-
“In Iran, they do what they can to restore them. In Azerbaijan and Georgia, they do what they can to destroy them.” http://hetq.am/eng/culture/0703-skarapetyan.html Interview with Samvel Karapetyan, director of the Yerevan office of the NGO Research on Armenian Architecture (RAA) [[March 12, 2007] How many Armenian architectural monuments are there in the liberated territories adjacent to Nagorno Karabakh? I began working on investigating and documenting Armenian architectural monuments in 1993, following the liberation of the territories. We visited these areas in 1986 and 1987, too, but didn't study them thoroughly until 1993 to 1998. When I visited in 1993 and1994, there was no one there and I documented only what I had discovered myself or seen with my own eyes. It's one thing to work without any assistance from local residents, and another thing when a person knows the area well. I intend to continue the census to complete the project. Most likely we'll do that in two years. As of today, in seven liberated regions we have registered 1,600 monuments, and that's not the final figure, or rather it is very far from being considered as such. What condition are these monuments in? There are, of course, monuments that have been deliberately destroyed – such as the monastery of Getamej, whose stones were used to build a school after it was demolished. Of four churches in the village of Tsar (Turkish: Char) in the Karvatchar (Kelbajar) region only two are left – the other two were completely destroyed and their were stones used for construction work. Cemeteries were destroyed as well, but this was not a universal phenomenon. In some important settlements, everything Armenian was destroyed. Generally, the monuments are half-destroyed or dilapidated. Church of St. Gabriel A totally different situation exists in Northern Artsakh – in the Gandzak region, which has not been liberated. Every day Armenian monuments are being savagely destroyed. These cases only come to light by chance. For example, former residents of Northern Artsakh, most of whom emigrated to Russia, send us letters saying that the churches in their native villages have been destroyed. Since they miss their homes, they pay to have Azerbaijanis take pictures of the villages. When they get the pictures they see that the homes are intact but the churches are missing. That's how they learn about the destruction. Most recently we found out that the seventh-century Church of St. Gabriel in the village of Mirzik village the Church of St. Jacob in Voskanapat village in the Khanlar region had been destroyed. In its structure and proportions, St. Jacob was unique church among the churches of Artsakh. Tsitsernavank The most famous Armenian monument in the liberated areas, Dadivank, is being renovated. Are there other monuments that have been restored? Yes there are. For example, Tsitsernavank in the Kashatagh (Lachin) region was renovated and consecrated a few years ago. Our organization has been working on the restoration of the Dadivank monastic complex since 1997. The complex consists of 25 different buildings, including ten religious structures – churches and chapels—and fifteen secular buildings of various purposes. The main buildings have already been restored and will be consecrated this year. Azerbaijanis complain that Armenians are destroying their monuments in NKR and the controlled territories… Whatever facts there are there, that's the reality. Azerbaijanis are telling lies more and more. The fact is that the Aghdam mosque is in the same condition as it was before. The Shushi mosques are standing erect – one of them was restored by the Shen Company, the other by the prelate of the Artshakh diocese, Archbishop Pargev himself. In other words, we have the opposite picture of what the Azerbaijanis are doing. Their mausoleums or “cumbazes” as they call them are in the same condition as when I saw them in Soviet times. The fact is that the Aghdam cumbazes , the Khojaly cemeteries, the Fizuli mosques, the monuments in the villages, are all intact. A tide of protest has risen in Armenia because of the destruction of monuments in Old Jugha, Nakhichevan. However, UNESCO didn't seem to react in the way that was expected in Armenia. I don't think there was a large tide of protest in Armenia. In December of 2005 the Azerbaijani Army smashed to smithereens the remnants of the Armenian khatchkars that had toppled in 2002. Virtually no state agency or political party remembered last December 14 and 15 that it was the first anniversary of the annihilation of the world-famous cemetery. They didn't even take the opportunity to raise the issue. Only our NGO organized a preview of the documentary film Jugha at the Union of Writers, and even though we had sent out invitations only a quarter of seats in the hall were taken. In other words, we have never raised a clamor and today Armenians, who are so isolated from Armenian culture, can't even protest loudly against the destruction of their monuments. Monuments in Old Jugha, 1978 Monuments in Old Jugha, 2005 Monuments in Old Jugha, 2006 Azerbaijan has presented its arguments. For example, Azerbaijani Ambassador to the US Hafiz *****yev has rebutted a letter of protest by US congressman Frank Pallone. He stated that nothing had happened at the Jugha cemetery. According to him, the origins of the site were not known and it was not clear who the people were who had worked with these cubic stones. Does Georgia mistreat Armenian monuments like Azerbaijan? Arminian khachkar, 1681 and 1997 Georgia has a different attitude. Azerbaijan cannot appropriate an Armenian church or a khachkar in any way. And they have to destroy them. As for Georgia, under the pretext of restoring the churches they get rid of the Armenian signs - scrape off lithographic inscriptions and frescoes, and demolish the features that their churches don't have – such as elevated stages, fonts, etc. In other words, they make the signs asserting their Armenian origins disappear; they even change the crosses, since they have a different appearance, and consecrate them as if they were Georgian churches, turning them into Georgian churches. So the buildings remain, but all the Armenian features disappear. For example, I've seen khachkars with Armenian inscriptions scraped off. But being Christians they don't scrape off the crosses. And I've seen khachkars in Azerbaijan with the engraved framings intact but with the crosses scraped off. You can see such things at the Museum of History of Karvatchar. What can be done to fight this? In general, a lot can be done, if the desire exists. But we are not the bearers of our culture today. We don't realize that these monuments belong to us, and we don't work hard enough to solve these problems. We are not the masters of what we have and what our adversaries destroy. Today every trace of us is being wiped out of our home – whether is it in Nakhichevan or in Georgia. We are very carefree. It is the type of Armenian that has developed over the centuries who adheres to alien values that is to blame. Every nation is formed within the framework of its faith, its ideology. In other words, when cherished values are professed, the national type, character takes shape. Our type is anti-national. For us the letters of St. Mesrop Mashtots mean nothing. Just walk along the avenue named after the same Mesrop Mashtots. Whatever is written in Armenian, there is five times as much is in English or Russian. And, in general, what condition are Armenian monuments in Armenia in? Holy Cross Church in Aghtamar In Iran, they do what they can to restore them. In Azerbaijan and Georgia, they do what they can to destroy them. The situation in Turkey is a bit different. In the 1960s and 1970s, Turkey was doing what Azerbaijan is doing today. Now the situation has changed. First in the 1960s and 1970s, a huge number of very important monuments were destroyed – they were blown up or used as targets during military manoeuvres. There was the Red Church in the village of Hindzk (Ghumlu) in Erzerum. When we asked the Turks to show it to us, we were told that there was no church there. Then they accompanied us and we got to a hill completely covered in meadows. The guide told us that the Red Church used to be there. We looked around and saw nothing but meadows – no structures or even stones. This was the case in the 1960s and 1970s. Today the restoration of the Holy Cross Church in Aghtamar has both political and economic significance for Turkey. Political since Turkey aspires to becoming a member of the European Union and they have to prove that they are not the Turks they used to be. At the same time they have a great economic interest. Every tourist who visits Van is sure to go to Aghtamar. Boats go there every thirty or even fifteen minutes carrying some thirty or forty tourists. Khtskonk Church The mayor of Tekor (Digor) wants to restore the Khtskonk Church, which was blown up in 1964. Not because he values the Armenian monuments, but because there is an interest. St. Karapet Church The St. Karapet Church of Mush doesn't exist anymore. The Kurdish village of Changly is there now. The village has sprung up right where the church used to be. And the church has disintegrated in the village – over the decades the church stones have been used to build new Kurdish houses. The Mayor of Changly says, “I feel very sorry. What fools our fathers were to destroy this church. If the church were still standing our villagers would make their living selling tan to tourists. If you can give us old pictures and drawings of the church we could rebuild it even partly to attract tourists to the village.” The Varagavank, partly destroyed, has become a very important source of profit for the Kurdish village. They sell needlework in the chapel. The church has turned into a kind of art gallery. As for the Armenian monuments in Armenia, they are not in a particularly brilliant condition. We have left them to the mercy of fate. In any case, they are standing for our masters build them skillfully, and it doesn't look like there are many fortune hunters in Armenia to cause great damage. But if we had some national dignity and didn't stand on the brink of a precipice vis-à-vis our culture, the situation would be much better, of course. And the Mayor of Haghpat, for example, wouldn't dare to build a restaurant leaning against the wall of a church that is on the list of monuments being preserved by UNESCO. And, similarly, there would not be a café next to Noravank and the UNESCO team visiting the church would not have to turn back after seeing the café. It attests to us being faceless, dishonorable. Interview by Vahe Sarukhanyan (The full text of the interview can be accessed at http://hetq.am/arm/culture/0702-skarapetyan.html
-
Khojaly: The Moment of Truth - 4 [March 26, 2007] See also: Khojaly: The Moment of Truth, Khojaly: The Moment of Truth - 2, Khojaly: The Moment of Truth - 3 http://hetq.am/eng/politics/0703-khojaly-3.html The greatest human tragedy in the days of the Karabakh war was undoubtedly Khojaly. During no other military operation did so many civilians, including women and children, suffer as in Khojaly. The actual number of the people killed is still debated today—differing figures are put forth and official Baku continues to use the Khojaly tragedy for its own political ends. How many people were killed in Khojaly? Different numbers have been put forward at different times – from 200 to more than 600. Thomas de Vaal considers the number made public following the investigation conducted by the Azerbaijani parliament, 485 people, to be most realistic. This number includes all the people killed during the Khojaly operation, including those who froze to death during the escape. A member of the parliamentary commission, Namik Aliyev, told the visiting Helsinki Watch team in April 1992 that 213 residents of Khojaly had been buried in Aghdam. Another official, Aydin Rasulov, assured the same team members that the number of civilians killed exceeded 300 - not counting those who had frozen to death on the way to Aghdam. On February 27, 1992 the imam of the Aghdam mosque showed American journalist Thomas Goltz a list of 477 names of people killed. The same year Azerbaijani newspaper Ordu printed a list of 636 people killed in Khojaly. On March 4, 1992 the Nagorno Karabakh parliament made the following statement: “The neutralization of weapon installations of the Azerbaijani armed units and the unblocking of Nagorno Karabakh's only airport near the village of Khojaly…have prompted wide reaction from Azerbaijani and foreign mass media. The armed units of the National Army of Azerbaijan stationed in Khojaly had completely blocked the roads connecting the Askeran region of NKR with the capital of the republic, and had periodically bombarded Stepanakert and other Armenian settlements with heavy artillery. It was possible to overcome the famine that had originated as a result of the blockade only by putting the airport into operation. Although the NKR self-defense forces had left a corridor for the residents of Khojaly to leave the zone of military operations, a portion of the civilian population of the village didn't avail itself of this opportunity. All of them – some 200 people - by their own wish and without any precondition were accompanied to the other side of the border. The Presidium of the Supreme Council of NKR once again declares its readiness to settle all the problems between Nagorno Karabakh and Azerbaijan exclusively by peaceful means, at a negotiating table.” What Chingiz Mustafayev filmed Azerbaijani cameraman Chingiz Mustafayev shot footage in the vicinity of Aghdam first on February 29 th and then on March 2 nd . It was his footage that was shown at the extraordinary session of the Azerbaijani parliament. The locality where Mustafayev had filmed the corpses was under Azerbaijani control, or more precisely, under the control of armed units of the Popular Front – this can be clearly seen from the footage. It is a fact that the corpses had been mutilated before the second time Mustafayev filmed on March 2 nd . Mustafayev informed Mutalibov of this. It was President Mutalibov, incidentally, who had sent him to film the scene. According to certain information, Mutalibov warned: “Chingiz, don't say a word to anyone that something is wrong, or they will kill you.” The area where the corpses were mutilated was at a distance of a few hundred meters from the positions of the Popular Front and was easily controlled by snipers. Mustafayev simply would not have been able to film in those areas if they had they been under the control of the Karabakh forces. A few months later Mustafayev was killed while doing routine filming inside a sector of military operations controlled by the military units of the Popular Front. Why he was killed is still debated. The Karabakh side insists that Mustafayev was a victim of Khojaly. Both Mutalibov and Mustafayev firmly believed that the Popular Front had tried to come to power by taking advantage of the Khojaly tragedy. This is what happened immediately after Khojaly, and what is more, it was Mustafayev's footage that was used to accuse Mutalibov. Tens of thousands of protesters gathered in front of the Azerbaijani parliament building to demand Ayaz Mutalibov's resignation. During the March 5, 1992 extraordinary session of the Supreme Council of Azerbaijan, Elmira Kafarova submitted her resignation and the Dean of the Medical Department at Baku University, Yaghub Mamedov, was elected speaker of parliament. The demonstrators kept the parliament building under siege, holding parliament members inside. Mutalibov called the unfolding events a “coup d'etat”. On March 6 th he resigned and Mamedov became the acting president until the presidential election was held. This is how Mutalibov commented on these events: “My resignation was forced. I had no intention of leaving but when I realized that everything had been scrupulously planned and the left and the right had united against the president I decided not to provoke confrontation.” The retired president believed that following his resignation the Karabakh issue would be speculated on within the internal political struggle and the further spread of war would become irreversible. “The Popular Front blamed us for not being able to solve the Karabakh problem. And now they have to give the people assurances that they are able to solve it. There are two ways: either more resolute actions, since I was blamed for indecision, or a compromise… Suppose, they succeed in uniting all our forces. In that case all this could turn into a large-scale war without any clarity regarding who is going to win, though no one in Azerbaijan wants to fight anymore.” Tatul Hakobyan
-
Qeri jan Urax tesnelu et lava or lava antsnum qez hamar !!! bari jamants / Aramin el barevi ( chnayats chem janachum ) bayst te ov im qeru @enkerna mer @enkernela Edward muys angam http://hyeforum.com/lofiversion/index.php es mi linkov mty forum aveli arag klini qez hamar qez lav nayi
-
IRAN MILITARY CONCENTRATE AT AZERI BORDER * Iranian armed forces’ defense equipment and sub-divisions are concentrated along the Iranian-Azerbaijani border. Military sources said in the past days these forces concentrated along the land border. Military experts claim that the troops advanced to protect the territory from possible attack. The same sources reported that the Iranian side did not inform Baku officials about the movement of its troops. This demonstrates Tehran’s deep concern and distrust toward Azerbaijan. At the same time activity of Iranian naval forces on the Caspian Sea has noticeably weakened recently. Experts say that Tehran fears the delivery of mobile diversion groups from Azerbaijan. With regard to reports about the closure of border and customs, businessmen said that transportation of goods to Azerbaijan via Iran has become severely limited. At present a considerable part of cargos are stuck on the Iranian side. The beginning of information war is also evident. One intelligence expert said that the recent reports that Iran has made a list of objects for bombardment in Azerbaijan in the event of a U.S. attack is a bright example of this. This information has been most likely disseminated by Iranian special services to exert psychological pressure on Baku. Its goal is to prevent Azerbaijan from supporting Washington in the military conflict with Tehran. With regard to Iranian missile specialists’ ability to hit targets in Azerbaijan, Shakhab missiles are not high-precision weapon able to hit concrete targets. This means that they could miss U.S. objects in Azerbaijan and hit other objects. This insane step by Tehran would destabilize the situation in South Azerbaijan, causing its separation from the remaining part of Iran. A missile attack on Baku will inevitably lead to the deployment of U.S. and NATO anti-missile and anti-aircraft defense units in Azerbaijan, but this is what Iran is strongly opposed to, PanARMENIAN.Net reported, citing Turan news agency
