the underlying reasoning for this mission is to fight terrorism and perserve U.S. interests. Sarcasm has no place in this reasoning. Resources are not sent to defend America b/c of "fighting evil" , press have made cliches. Resources are sent to defend American Interests here and abroad for now & future. that simple. you can't blame the U.S for doing this, every country looks & protects its interests.
I am trying to catch up on the reading given that there a lot to begin with.
I have made a few observations that I would like to point out...
-War is generally comprised of many factors/variables, so to say that we went to War for 1 reason is very niave. There an incredible amount of assessment/Evaluation & contingency plans being drawn for different scenarios as to how U.S. should confront/take action against a particular country or region. There is a huge repository of information collected upon a particular country or region that will take months to understand if you and I or general public were to try to make sense of it. consideration of regional conflicts, aliances, markets, dependencies and how they pertian to a particular course of action now & in the future to U.S. interests is indeed no small task to take up. So before one concludes that a certain action was meaningless, consider the fact that you dont have the resources nor the understanding of the circumstance. It's good to be critical of a given action, but please let us also try to come up with better solutions b/c it may be the case that that was the best course of action to take. this is the reason why I poised the ? to you (911) and u were surprised, it was b/c I wanted to hear your response as to what alternative there was and if indeed the alternative was better than the action we took.
this complexity is often not discussed in general public b/c
1. some of it's parts r confidential since knowledge may predict course of future action
2. the discussion will be obtused once it's publicized since there are too many facts that need to be taken into consideration.
3. media is in biz of making $, not wether or not general public understands all the facts to a scenario
I mean can the president really say "well we are going to open a battle front in Iraq b/c it's better for the terrorists to blow up in Iraq than here in the U.S."
or...
"the ability to buy Iraq's valuable oil reserves at a resonable price will surely maintain America's dominence against rising powers such as China & India"
but it is much easier to coin these things in a phrase such as "fighting evil", but you seem to mistake this as America wanting to get rid of evil. What is your defn of evil? America does whats in the best interest of America. that's it. If another country is incompitent not to be able to manage itself, then what does that have to do with U.S interests?
Look, the first thing a federal employee does is swear allegence to U.S. and NOT TO FIGHTING EVIL or to anything else. If our current president uses the word Evil, it represents the evil nature of these islamic fundemental terrorists and the actions they have chosen to take.
Similarily, the U.S. as any other country/organization including the one that signs your paycheck does/pursues things that are in it's interests. It would be very interesting to know which country you reside.
Saddam was not a desirable partner b/c he demonstrated the ability/intention to invade kuwait and other nieghboring regions. if U.S. were to buy from him after he invaded kuwait, then they would have simply empowered him to take on new conquests into Iraq & possibly Saudi Arabia. Its amazing how one can blame the U.S. when any 2nd grader in elementary school would agree given the course of events in the past that it was Saddam indeed that was the criminal/mass murderer and his actions were purely for the gratification of himself and not his nation. Saddam's henchmen were stealing/raping kuwait of its goods but this seems to have been forgotten.
first, innocent civilians were attacked in the U.S by terrorists, so this is a reaction to an event. Innocent civilians are NOT to be engaged, they are not soldiers.
second, you agreed that U.S. should have gone into another laundry list of countries, so perhaps you should ask the ? to yourself before asking me.
its not that simple. this type of thinking may have worked in primitive times(hundreds of years ago), but the institution of government and art of war have changed dramatically. it's more complicated now. in this global economy, no country can afford to exlude itself from the rest of the world but more importantnly why would it need to? well dictators often enjoy this b/c it helps them keep rule. foreign investments & trade are at the heart of regional/global alliances and often time one countries interests are dependent upon anothers. Most countries are willing to share/sell their resources with other & trying to create an envoirnment were this is possible is in the best interests of all.
another thing that i have noticed in your previous replies, is that you seem to use facts of war to justify the evilness of the U.S. War by definition is when two sides don't agree and decide to engage(kill/wound) each other. War is very destructive especially to the loosing side no matter if the U.S. is involved or not. It brings out the most efficient tools/methods of killing soldiers and u see it happen. Every country reserves the right to use or go to war to protect itself or its interests. I understand u feel sorry for ppl who have died, but how can u have a war without ppl dying, then no side will win? well then why have a war in the first place? well this is a product of human nature/scare resources and the institutions we have come up with. Please share your alternative if you think it's better and justify how/why you think this will be adopted and followed. In a few thousand yrs of civilization, why haven't we been able to come up with a peaceful soln?
b/c I think there exists an inherent conflict of interest between 2 or more entities to put it in short.