Well I made it explicit. Maybe you should have read my post in the firstplace.
I will not engage further into this debate. There is nothing new in your dissertation, you are just rehashing the same propaganda like an automaton. Having no valid counter-arguments you write a 3-page message (which is not a response to mine although it appears to be) in order to drown the reader into an ocean of sophisms.
If anarchy is intrinsic to human activity as has been claimed in an early post, then why spend so much time discussing it? If it is a fact, a tautology, it is not worth debating. Do we engage in endless discussions over the fact we have two legs instead of three?
The fact is you first state the obvious and then narrow the theory down and using the very "fungibility" of words, manage to substitute another reality for the one you first presented. This is precisely the way Mises proceeds. He first attempts to present his theory in the most
general framework so that one may not reject and then pharisaically modifies the semantics behind the words so as to push a specific agenda and
put forward specific beliefs.
Why is it that this one-size-fits-all category you call "the state" exists? why did it appear? what could prevent it from appearing ore reappearing if ever it is destroyed?
One might argue nothing is artificial. All proceeds from man's nature. Chaos as well as Order. The rise of "monopolies of authority and coercion" and their fall. One may say all of this is inexorable or cyclic.
I wonder whether your real intent is to promote "anarcho-capitalism" in the US (this system doesn't seem to have greatly benefited Russia over the last ten years or so, has it?) or rather to confuse people with "fungible" and nonsensical ideas.
The discussion from the onset was something that eluded you. From my original argument the premises and the conclusion laid, there would have been a discussion but in fact you made it a tautology, just as in the thread regarding Armenian nation. Here you simply chose to "discard" my argument, simply because you didn't like it, and then from that rallying point there was no point for you to be in this discussion, yet you lingered. So by discarding my argument, you ensured yourself some sort of moral high ground and no need to discuss aside from tautological statements.
Then when that wasn't enough, you simply assumed things and made things elastic, accusing me of the same thing, just like with regard to Armenian nationalism, and that Armenian nationalism must have been a fact before nationalism was itself a fact - a gross distortion of history may I add. So in both instances when things do not fit your preconceived views, it is ipso facto obvious that you do not wish to engage in a sincere discussion, since obviously ideology and bias has more to do with your thought process, than an actual point by point discussion. Then I'm accused of writing too much, simply because you cannot follow or address the points which you yourself chose to turn into a tautology, or simply because you don't know me nor that I write alot, or maybe I'm assuming you are interested in this discussion when you aren't ( if taken to its logical consequences your view would mean there is no need to discuss anything since everything at some point is a tautology ).
When that is all said and done, you "will no longer respond to this thread" like in the previous thread. Anarchy is simply a fact of life, and if you bothered to discuss, you would see that all our actions are anarchic, that our everyday actions revolve around something of our own volition, not because of State sanctioned laws or legislations.
Your "critique" of Mises is very abstract and in fact I am not even sure what you are critiquing him on, and such is either the attempts to present yourself either somehow familiar with Mises, or simply a misconception. If you haven't read human action, there is no point in you to raise this issue. Even the social contract myth which you repeated is clear to you to have been a misconception.
When presented with the argument that the State was not always so, and in fact it was precisely because of lack of regulation that the capitalist revolution took off, you ignore it, but then you seem to come back and linger on the idea that "the State as always existed". The "State" is a modern creation, coined first by Machiavelli. Entropy and thermodynamics which deal with chaos and order, are not from "man", i.e. his actions. Perhaps indirectly, but man is simply working within those laws. You further fail to accept since you very well know that the States life flows from ideologies such as nationalism, which you defended to the bitter end in the other thread, antihistorically may I add.
Mises laid out that there is either private ownership in society, or public ownership, of these only one accompanies choice, and the other uses coercion. Socialism and Communism use coercion to achieve their ends. Thus you are in essence arguing for control, and that the individual to himself is not an individual from the whole, a Marxist twist in essence. As far as Russia, when you have had Communism from 1917 until very recently, that is tantamount to almost a century of moving backwards. The problems in Russia are precisely a result of too much regulation and creating a big beaurocratic base thanks to the State.
I defined the "State" for you in my argument which you chose to "discard", yet you offered to other alternative definition. I delved into the theory of private production for security, you chose to not discuss that either, then you respond with tautology. Clearly you are incapable of any rational discussion here. So to start all over I will define the State in the hopes that you actually respond this time, and not "discard" it simply because it gives you a crack in your edifice of thought.
A State is defined as a territorial monopoly of force and ultimate decision making in the event of conflict (including conflicts involving itself) and implied in this power is its ability to tax ( you have no choice thus you have coercion )to determine unilaterally the price that those seeking justice must pay for its services. Now like I said, if you wish to provide a counter argument, you must show that somehow nothing will happen to you if you don't pay your tax. But even if you insist that you are happy with your paying taxes, what about those that don't want to or are not happy? The victims of the State have been 200 million people in the 20th century alone. You pretty much ignored this part. I'm afraid that discussing this with you would be a miracle. Adieu.