-
Posts
2,222 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Content Type
Profiles
Forums
Events
Gallery
Everything posted by Anonymouse
-
Since you're so desperate to get the last word in, you get it.
-
It will be down to Bush and Kerry, and both are members of the Skull and Bones. How much different is it? Well, Bush has republican governors and republican majority in most of the country, hell, the whole california recall was a desperate attempt to secure this position, as well as the soon to come electronic voting scam.
-
Oh by the way, I bet you're just waiting to hit the "Ban" button on me, eh?
-
Gee, moderator, I thought you guys were fair and balanced?
-
Let's dispense with social pleasantries. Face the monitor, and pay attention while I explain the 'Theory Of Why You Are Ignorant' to you. My response was not merely at your supposed "good faith" remark, but your overall condescending tone which you displayed as if you bear some validity because youre "older" and somehow youre humor is not "repugnant" and other jibes; that somehow you deserve some inkling of respect or that I should somehow give in to you because you are older, when plainly put, you're ignorant. It was you who desperately reshaped your position to somehow arise with an immutable argument, and you who constantly resorted to cherry picking to defend your case, and when you noticed your intellectual assets were not making up for it, you gradually started to resort to your antics of inanity, and the overall tone by those who disagreed here morphed into that as well, since no one likes uncomfortable topics that crack their prism, or prison of thought. Nor is it my fault that this escaped the comprehension of your gap filled cranium. Now you try to paintyourself as the "victim" of insults whereas it was your so called "maturity" that "comes with age" that sparked off this insecurity of yours. As for you following my posts and noting my presence, well I'm thankful for I have nothing to note you for aside from this desperate attempt at trying to come across has half intelligent and "wise" as you implied. If you don't like posts from "kids" like me, then stop reading them and using your pointy forehead to hit the keyboard and respond. Truly the behavior of a bark.
-
The male body is refrigerator shaped. We are the rectangle people!
-
He started it. I'm just finishin
-
Ahhh, now THAT is a voice of reason.
-
Actually my response was meant for angel which I mistakenly clicked on yours. But enlighten me.
-
Well, in that case, I really cannot pretend to know what would form of this lone ranger surviving on his own. If he has no contact with other humans are we to assume that he develops ideas of morality based on how humans relate to one another? I would think no.
-
So your assertion is tantamount to Armenians staying "pure" but that is untrue and inaccurate, since yes, even the population mixed. You cannot escape is, otherwise we wouldn't see the differences today. Indeed, there is, no one disputes this. But by and large, even the peoples who comprised the different groups of what were "Armenians" during that period of say, Tigran, were very different than the "Armenians" who we know them as now. It means there is a change in the make up of the people, whether they adopt Armenian culture or not, the people change. That is why more Turks nowadays look alike with Armenians and Greeks, because of all the mixing, rape, and forceful conversions. I hate to break it to you, but these people have not remained the same over 2000 years. We live on the same soil as the early natives of this continent, yet we aren't the same as them are we? Thus a Turk that lives around Van now is somehow, by your logic, living on the same soil. Your idea of history is a point in time, not a process. But reality says that peoples change. For example, when Arabs dominated Armenia, they eventually settled there, no different than other invaders that came later. When there is a relative time of peace, there is no "losing side", people fall in love, and marry, and interact, your assertion ignores everything and tries to make this solely "political"; meaning your assertion tries to make out there behavior into something they "ought'" to have done, as opposed to what they did. People interacted and mixed at all times, no different during the Cilician period. Aww, what's the matter, cannot fathom the crack in your edifice of thought? The truth is that you may not even relate back to the Artashesians but a totally different gene pool that may have found its way in Armenians throughout the centuries. Thus maybe you have more "Greek" or "Turkic" or "Arabic" in you than say anything remotely resemling the Armenians of the Artashesian period. Are you threatened by this? Before you come here and preach about your "age" and "wisdom" you should know that the two are mutually exclusive and your childish demeanor is evidence of this.
-
Well, since I pee outside anyway, this doesn't apply to me.
-
Thank you for your opinion. You can make a difference!
-
But Sip, science and reason are in a different realm than faith. Science is the study of how our natural world works and reacts, now what lies behind or beneath it. Thus science is very useful, but limited, just like human reason and intelligence, both useful yet limited. We are finite creatures. Thus we cannot know what lies beyond in the infinite. That all knowledge comes from carefully scrutinized observation, in other words what we call research, is just another metaphysical assumption. The scientific method simply cannot answer all questions, therefore cannot be possibly the only source of knowledge. Science has a very important job which I do not dispute. But why anything comes to be there at all, and whether there is anything behind the things science observes, that is not a scientific question. Whether or not an intelligence beyond our universe and comprehension exists, reason and the scientific method cannot answer. Anyone who attempts to answer that question, even scientists with their "big bang" are making a philosophical or metaphysical assumption, not a scientific statement. I don't wanna stray too off topic, but then this discussion would evolve further into God and morality, etc., etc.
-
Basically your tautological assertions aside, where is the "proof"? Fossil A, Fossil B, it is only assumed that Fossil A evolved to Fossil B. That is not proof, but an assumption.
-
Wow, now THAT is simply transcendental. Hyeren lezun iroq shat gexetsik lezu e yev na brnele ayt gexetskutsyun@.
-
Well, "morality" as we know it applies to humanity and its civilization. When man has civilizaion it has seperated itself from the animals. But when man is alone it is forced to survive, it is also forced to be an animal to compete with the animal, so thus I don't see this as a valid comparison.
-
I never retreated to that, that was my point the whole time, you just cherry picked certain parts of my posts. Well, if this isn't another one of your sad attempts to 'cling' to your idea that Armenians were flirting with nationalism and unity before they actually did, I don't know what it is. They were self-aware of being Armenian but the idea of the "nation" uniting high and low eluded them for that was not their primary concern. Not until Enlightenment influence of nationalism sparked that idea in them. You didn't need "political success" for people to assimilate into Armenian culture. This is what you do not understand, or don't want to. Throughout the centuries many peoples have come through that area, some have settled some have moved, and others intermarried. The fact that literally the Armenian nakharar is of Persian origin speaks volumes. People have always changed, no different than an Assyrian or an Arab emir intermarrying an Armenian. Yes, Armenians of today do not resemble nor bear the same culture as "Armenians" of say the Artashesian period. What part of that is so hard for you to grasp in that empty cranium? I can look at Armenians and see the spectrum of the light skinned to the tanned skinned and those that display Mongoloid or Asiatic features. This indicates alot of change from the people. Obviously the Armenians of the Artashesian period would not have any Mongoloid mixture because quite obivously the Mongols weren't around then. In any event, I suggest you approach things without ideological or nationalistic bias. Nothing you said makes any sense for me to register, for something to register it must be sensible not merely appeal to your own ignorance of what things ought to be. You can call this pride, I can call it ignorance, and it is nothing more than tautology. What it ultimately isn't for you is viewing this objectively, but rather with a bias. You should apply your message to yourself before you apply it to others. No need to be sorry here. What I started merely as just a discussion you turned it into a personal issue and thus resorted to negativity, which is the last refuge of the pointless. Adieu.
-
What I said, is indeed more than just nationalism is modern, which you were thoughtful enough to post. What I also said is that Armenians have changed and that region far from being homogenous has been diverse. Thus mixing has taken place along with cultural changes. Thus the idea of what it constitutes to be "Armenian" has changed over time and hence you cannot pin one fixed "nation" on it. That you cannot grasp this simple is beyond me. Apparently for you wisdom means resorting to personal attacks because you feel threatened oh "wise and grown up one" or that's simply where you got tired of thinking. This proves wisdom does not necessarily come with age.
-
Ayo. Arach shat baner eyi hishum, hima moratsa inchkan Angleren sovoretsi. Petkeh het gnam norits sksem vor hishoxutsyunus zartni norits.
-
You have grossly misconstrued my position on this, whether consciously or unconsciously. It is precisely youre ignorance and hang up with maintaining Armenian nationalism before the idea of nationalism itself that you cannot see, nor wish to. I have throughout my discussion highlighted that "self awareness" is not the same as nationalism. Apparently you haven't understood what differentiates the two and ultimately why you are confused by the issue must resort to personal attacks to compensate for your lack of understanding, or simply because you cannot deal with the fact that national history is not accurate history. Just because the ethnically based "nation-states" have been called "imagined communities" and that because communities have been called "imagined" should not be dismissed or triviliazed. The process by which nationalism emerged varies from region to region. In regions lacking political organization for example Armenians in the Ottoman Empire were spread out, nationalism provided an ideology to create and augment state power, the creation of a State. When nationalism was being created in France and Germany, governments and ideologues suppressed minority languages, cultural traditions and variant memories of the past in favor of a unified national history and homongenous language that could claim to project into the distant past. So in empires such as the Ottoman or the Hapsburgs, individuals identifying themselves as members of oppressed minorities used nationalism to claim the right to not only separate cultural existnece as well as political autonomy. During the middle ages prior to the rise of nationalism and nation-states, the nation along with religion, kindred, and lords provided the overlapping ways by which certain active elites identified themselves. A sense of belonging to a nation did not constitute the most important of these bonds. Nor was there any common national identity to unite the high and low, or lord and peasant. This is why Armenians in Ottoman Turkey lacked the unity as the development of nationalism was sparked off by the Armenians of Russian influence. This is why the conservative bourgeois Armenians in Ottoman society and the patriarch generally resisted change, whereas the peasant class and the revolutionaries were for change. There was no unity for "the nation" in the sense we come to understand it these days. So ultimatley when Armenians of today, look in hindsight and ask the question of "why were Armenians never united throughout history?" that is because of precisely what I just outlined, the concept of nationalism was alien to them. But then again, those of us who do not wish to get a crack in our edifice of thought will stop at no lengths to maintain and create history of what it 'ought' to be, as opposed to what it really was.
-
Yes, if you look really hard you can see a camel toe.
-
As well as showing what kind of empty shell women are out there eh? No the show is not indicative of real life, no show or movie is. It is precisely because they are shows or movies that they are not real, and in fact a dream world that is why we respond to them so greatly, they are illusions and away from reality. In fact, one can argue that these shows and movies and the "fads" of whats "hot" and whats "not" is actually set by television. Look at fashion and how people act or think what is cool. 20 years ago "roommates" or "live in partners" were not popular, now thanks to shows like friends, "roommates" are a popular concept. Those who control the information and the things we receive ultiamtely mold our minds in a way. Thus one shouldn't be too carried away into the dream world that is television. I only watch X Files reruns on Sci-Fi and Family Guy on Adult Swim on cartoon network. That's about the only tv time I put out.
-
Well "cultural relativism" and morality go hand in hand really. I don't see how you can seperate one from the other. I am more inclined to say that certain cultural behaviors may differ and in fact do differ from culture to culture but this has ultimately no bearing on a universal moral law. It is to be expected there are cultural differences and inequalities among cultures simply because of mans innate inequalities. The basic development of this idea can be traced to the egalitarianism that pervaded academia. It's sole purpose was to sort of make us not "judge" other cultures, but can we really do this? Humans are such that they all judge. Judging is part of the human character. We are exposed to information, we accept it, and we judge for good or bad. Well what cultural relativism ultimately implies is moral relativism and I do not agree with either. Basically I think this goes down to the morality, the crux of it, the sense of right and wrong. This ultimately goes into this question, is there a universal moral law or is there no such thing? I apologize for jumping ahead of the game regarding culture, but I see this as ultimately an issue of morality since culture is nothing but a set of beliefs and morals handed down to us. Now, from my perspective, since I believe in a universal moral law, I will argue against relativism. Simply put this universal law is not simply from the old or new testaments or any other religion, it is within us, in what we call conscience. C.S. Lewis says there's two sources of evidence for this, "One is the universe God has made...the other is that moral law which God has put into our minds." According to Lewis he goes on to say that the moral law is better evidence because, "..it is inside information...you find out more about God from the moral law than from the universe in general just as you find out more about a man by listening to his conversation than by looking at a house he has built." Basically this is Lewis' affirmation along the lines of Kant who pointed out the "moral law within" as the powerful witness to the greatness of God. Someone who would argue against this view would be Freud. According to him, God is simply a projection of parental authority. If we accept this then Lewis' and Kant's statement hold true and make sense. We associate parents with our creation and with teaching us right and wrong. Freud argues that our father is the person who gave us life and guarded us against perils and taught us the necessarily knowledge, and right and wrong, and to perform certain duties by a system of rewards and punishments, to paraphrase Freud. So the ultimate conclusion is that since different parents come from different cultures that ultimately there is relativism here and how you are raised by certain parents in a certain culture is how you will become. To Freud and other rational thinkers, a universal moral law is in conflict with reason. I would say that yes we learn tthe moral law in part from our parents, teachers, role models, and culture, and it helps develop our conscience. But this does not mean that the moral law is simply a "human invention" or "social construct". Our parents and culture did not simply make up the law any more than they made up the multiplication tables which they also teach us. Culture and customs change with time, morals and moral law hold firm. Anyway, I apologize for veering off into forbidden lands but ultimately this is what the conversation would evolve to.
-
My Mousey Sense tells me there is trouble ahead. Can we get some definition for "cultural relativism" for the purposes of a discussion so we will avoid confusion?
