QUOTE(nairi @ Nov 4 2006, 05:49 AM)
Eve, have you heard of Louis Theroux's Weird Weekends? He too goes off to remote English speaking places (as himself) to expose the type of people who live outside of the mainstream. The idea behind it is: "Are we, Westerners, really as civilized as we like to believe we are?"
In the case of Borat and Ali G (and Bruno the Austrian), the joke started in England, and only after it became a hit was it moved to America. For Ali G, it was to expose the idiocy of the smartest people in England and America (professors, government officials, etc.) For Borat, it's to expose the other side of England and America; the quite shocking side we never get to see. In England, Borat started off going to upper class events, like horse-racing, fox-hunting, and tea time, just to expose these classes for what they really are. In America, he spent most of his time with your average Joe; the average Joe most of us never get to see. The main question with Borat, like Theroux, is: "What is civilization? And are we really as civilized as we believe we are?"
I do agree that sometimes he goes overboard (I felt the same with Ali G at times), but when he nails it, he nails it well.
I haven't seen the movie yet, but there are plenty of earlier clips on YouTube.
QUOTE
"Are we, Westerners, really as civilized as we like to believe we are?"
Absolutely, I did mention in my review that this is what I picked up from his delicate "lesson learned" points, Kazakhistan - one backwards world vs. US - another. But it wasn't done in a deliciously subtle yet poignant manner, it was done through extreme vulgarity as if he is counting on the viewer to be rather stupid that he needs to chew and spit it out. I don't need to see feces in a plastic bag at a dinner table to understand that some people are overly conservative. I loved Politically Correct and I did wish they would get raunchy but not derriere abusive raunchy.
And it's a little trite don't you think to always target the upper classes, it's been done so much over the years, politically, artistically and socially. How about criticizing those who continuously criticize the bourgeoisie, the leftist, the democrats, the union supporters, those who believe they must suffer in order to be creative. There are so many territories to explore, so many edgy, raunchy and delicious subjects that making your first motion picture about Muslims, evil and stupid Americans, ghettos and anti-Semites is very clichéd at this time.
As I've mentioned before it's the fact that it's popular to find this movie funny, because it means that you are liberal and open minded and not afraid to laugh or fart. And everyone jumps on the wagon, people love to think that they are cool and have a great sense of humor but very few actually get there. It's one thing if this was along the lines of "Airplane" or "naked gun" but his film is actually marketed as a political and offensive comedy. I found nothing offensive except for the homosexual scene, but only because my eyes just couldn't take it anymore. Otherwise it's pretty idiotic and I hate the fact that it's cool to say that this movie is so cool and you are so cool that you find it so cool so let's get together and be cool and just smell each others stinky shoes, because it's so raunchy and cool.